Manual Pumps?

Posted By Message

4PsInaPod
My Loves <3

Member since 7/07

10079 total posts

Name:
D

Manual Pumps?

Did you like them better?

A few friends said they liked the manual ones better? I would think that would be worse, but clearly I have no idea.

wondering if I should purchase one for #2

Posted 8/22/11 11:43 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MissJones
I need a nap!

Member since 5/05

22152 total posts

Name:

Re: Manual Pumps?

i have the medela harmony. it was great to help when my milk came in. i didnt want to use the electric bc i wasnt sure if bfing would work. now i use the manual when im staying at my inlaws or on long trips. i like my electric one but the manual has pluses. sorry for typos.

Posted 8/22/11 11:52 AM
 

MissJones
I need a nap!

Member since 5/05

22152 total posts

Name:

Re: Manual Pumps?

i think if you are staying home and dont need to express milk for lots of feedings, its perfect.

Posted 8/22/11 11:53 AM
 

Erica
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

11767 total posts

Name:

Re: Manual Pumps?

I have the avent manual pump. I brought it to the hospital with me with #2, but the electric is so much better.

Posted 8/22/11 12:28 PM
 

imyself

Member since 10/06

2938 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Manual Pumps?

I could not use the electric. i tried with ds but it hurt too bad and really just ripped up my nipples. I also did not get very much milk at all using it. I switched to the Avent manual and loved it. It didn't hurt and was actually quite fast. i used the manual to pump for dd too.

Posted 8/22/11 12:29 PM
 

Wendy
Wheeee!

Member since 5/05

13736 total posts

Name:

Re: Manual Pumps?

Posted by MissJones

i have the medela harmony. it was great to help when my milk came in. i didnt want to use the electric bc i wasnt sure if bfing would work. now i use the manual when im staying at my inlaws or on long trips. i like my electric one but the manual has pluses. sorry for typos.



I think this is what I got for the reason stated ...

BTW, if you want, you can have mine - I'm about to toss all things pump/pump related! Chat Icon

Posted 8/22/11 12:42 PM
 

tannahhh
LIF Zygote

Member since 5/10

40 total posts

Name:
tana

Re: Manual Pumps?

I pumped at work 3-4x a day with both my DS's. With my first I used an electric one from lansinoh (sp?) and it worked fine. I wanted a medela double electric but just couldn't justify spending that much at the time. When my second came along my electric one broke 3days after my milk came in (go figure) so I needed something fast to replace it. Ran out and picked up the medela harmony manual pump and can i just say that I got more milk out of that manual pump than i ever did with my old electric one in less time too. I ended up just buying a second harmony pump so i could double pump at work. haha. SO for me hands down the manual pump was better. Plus i had more control using a manual pump.

Posted 8/22/11 7:28 PM
 

2boys4me
He's coming soon!

Member since 4/10

4260 total posts

Name:

Re: Manual Pumps?

My MIL got me the Avent uno electric pump but you can use as an electric or manual. My mother ended up getting me the Medela PIS. I liked both for different reasons. I EP'd for the first 2 months and being attached to the pump for all hours of the day the Medela came in handy BUT a lot of times I would use the Avent after the Medela 1/2 hr was up and get a whole other bottles worth that just wasn't coming out with the Medela. The suction was better with the Avent and with the manual I could control things better, if that makes sense and I also took it with me when I went out if we were going to be out for a long time because it was less bulky to carry than the Medela, it fit right in the diaper bag.

Posted 8/22/11 7:34 PM
 

DBJ808
LIF Adult

Member since 6/09

1039 total posts

Name:
Dana

Re: Manual Pumps?

The subject of this post should be retitled "want your hand to fall off?" Definitely do not recommend it! I didn't bring my pump with me to the hospital because I didn't want to use it until I knew for sure BF was right for me. SO I used a manual pump that they gave me in the hospital. It takes FOREVER and my hand felt like it was going to fall off! Plus, it isn't nearly as strong as the automatic. For someone that had supply issues, I think you would benefit from that automatic, which is still not as strong as natural BF but the closest to it. You don't want to lose your supply from pumping manually! You will have Joey to run around with and time is precious so you want something that gets the job done quick! The Medela Pump In Style is a DREAM...I was attached to it 24/7! Also- if you decide at the end to exclusively pump...manual definitely is not a good option unless you want your hand to fall off!

Posted 8/22/11 9:58 PM
 

4PsInaPod
My Loves <3

Member since 7/07

10079 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Manual Pumps?

Posted by DBJ808

The subject of this post should be retitled "want your hand to fall off?" Definitely do not recommend it! I didn't bring my pump with me to the hospital because I didn't want to use it until I knew for sure BF was right for me. SO I used a manual pump that they gave me in the hospital. It takes FOREVER and my hand felt like it was going to fall off! Plus, it isn't nearly as strong as the automatic. For someone that had supply issues, I think you would benefit from that automatic, which is still not as strong as natural BF but the closest to it. You don't want to lose your supply from pumping manually! You will have Joey to run around with and time is precious so you want something that gets the job done quick! The Medela Pump In Style is a DREAM...I was attached to it 24/7! Also- if you decide at the end to exclusively pump...manual definitely is not a good option unless you want your hand to fall off!



lol! Got it! Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 8/22/11 10:29 PM
 

BnBdreamin
Gonna be a BIG Bro in April!

Member since 10/06

5913 total posts

Name:
Denise

Re: Manual Pumps?

You know, I think it's an "everyone is different" kind of thing. I loved my Medela Harmony manual pump. I had an electric too. Not for me. I got way more milk in way less time with the manual than the electric. And... my hand did not fall off! Chat Icon Not in the least. A lot less parts to wash and replace and store. It was way more convenient for traveling and on the go. I'd keep the very small parts washed and in a zip-loc in my diaper bag so it was ready to go. I pumped under my nursing cover in the car on long trips, on the plane, even under my cape at the hairdresser while under the dryer (in hindsight not necessary but it was my first time being away from DS for a feeding! Chat Icon )

I'd like to see you get up and address something with Joey while you're hooked up to an electric pump. With the manual, I was able to walk around, let the dog in and out, grab the phone or a magazine that I forgot to get before I sat down. I could get comfy anywhere and did not have to sit within 3 feet of an outlet. I filled our freezer with a great supply.

I would stick with my manual over an electric anytime, [not fallen off] hands down!

Posted 8/23/11 1:43 AM
 

Kelly9904
Mommy to 2 amazing little boys

Member since 5/05

9306 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Manual Pumps?

I can't say either way. I bought a manual with DS#1, but never really gave BF a try. With DS#2 I wanted to BF and got an electric pump.

If you want a manual I am selling my Harmony (probably used 3x)...you can have it for $15....

Posted 8/23/11 7:20 AM
 

4PsInaPod
My Loves <3

Member since 7/07

10079 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Manual Pumps?

Posted by BnBdreamin

I'd like to see you get up and address something with Joey while you're hooked up to an electric pump. With the manual, I was able to walk around, let the dog in and out, grab the phone or a magazine that I forgot to get before I sat down. I could get comfy anywhere and did not have to sit within 3 feet of an outlet. I filled our freezer with a great supply.



I have to tell you, this is why I was thinking about it. I was like HOW in gods name, could I be hooked up to a pump and chase Joey around. My friend swears by her manual. Wendy is nice enough to give me hers, so I'm going to give it a whirl, if my hand falls off, I'll stop Chat Icon

Posted 8/23/11 9:25 AM
 

VikingChick
LIF Adult

Member since 5/11

1024 total posts

Name:
Anna

Re: Manual Pumps?

I had both a medela pump in style and the manual harmony. I loved both. (well, not loved, but they both worked well)
I used the PIS at work, and the harmony at home/on the road. The PIS was too bulky to carry around with me, and the harmony was perfect if I needed to pump in the car, or a quick pump at home.

Posted 8/23/11 9:40 AM
 

LadyBug1209
Mommy to FOUR little men!

Member since 8/08

9655 total posts

Name:

Re: Manual Pumps?

I never used one but it seems like a lot of work... pumping was my relaxing time LOL. I would just let the machine do the work! Chat Icon

I have the Medela In-style Advanced pump and love it. If you want to just buy the accessories, you can DEF use mine until you see if it's worth the investment! Chat Icon

Posted 8/23/11 9:59 AM
 

DBJ808
LIF Adult

Member since 6/09

1039 total posts

Name:
Dana

Re: Manual Pumps?

The PIS comes with a battery charger and you can buy a hands free bra... so you are wire free and hands free :)

Posted 8/26/11 10:56 AM
 

snowflake09
LIF Adult

Member since 4/10

1076 total posts

Name:
Jillian (Bean08)

Re: Manual Pumps?

Posted by DBJ808

The PIS comes with a battery charger and you can buy a hands free bra... so you are wire free and hands free :)



This...and, you can look oh-so stylish!!

External Image


Chat Icon

Posted 8/26/11 11:09 AM
 

NextStopBabytown
TTC #2

Member since 11/08

3141 total posts

Name:
Lindsey

Re: Manual Pumps?

Posted by snowflake09

Posted by DBJ808

The PIS comes with a battery charger and you can buy a hands free bra... so you are wire free and hands free :)



This...and, you can look oh-so stylish!!

External Image


Chat Icon



Oh my gosh!!!!! Chat Icon

I'm sure my boss would love that! Chat Icon

Posted 8/26/11 11:17 AM
 

snowflake09
LIF Adult

Member since 4/10

1076 total posts

Name:
Jillian (Bean08)

Re: Manual Pumps?

Posted by NextStopBabytown


Oh my gosh!!!!! Chat Icon

I'm sure my boss would love that! Chat Icon



It's the epitome of the American Dream - taking care of your career AND your family at the same time! Chat Icon

Posted 8/26/11 11:20 AM
 

Cpt2007
A new love!

Member since 1/08

5946 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: Manual Pumps?

I have a harmony as a backup that i keep in my electric pump bag. it's not as strong as the big pump (love my ameda), but it's great for when i don't have the ability to use the big one (in the car) or, heaven forbid, I forgot the ac plug for the big one. $35 well spent.

Posted 8/26/11 12:27 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Pls recommend your manual pumps! wingsofsong 5/7/10 8 Parenting
Manual Pumps bella321 4/20/10 0 Parenting
Nasal Clear - battery powered nasal aspirator vs. manual bulb MrsKellyBride 2/11/10 8 Parenting
canon rebel users I need help and I left my manual at home!!!! AnthonysWife 1/16/10 2 Parenting
manual vs. electronic aspirator? (poll) LoveBeingMrsT 1/3/08 4 Parenting
spin-off to manual transmission - Can you drive a motorcycle? TheWhiteRabbit 10/26/07 14 Families Helping Families ™