Is this normal behavoir for a 3 year old??

Posted By Message

bettybcafe
Big brother in the making

Member since 7/07

8611 total posts

Name:
M

Is this normal behavoir for a 3 year old??

I was taking care of my 3 year old niece yesterday from 2-11pm. From 2-5 we were out shopping, eating and went to the pet store, she was well behaved. As soon as we got home around 5pm all hell broke lose. Literally, from 5-11pm(when her mom picked her up) this girl was out of control. Now, I have two dogs and was also dog sitting my brothers 6mth old puppy. She keep taunting the puppy with his toy and when he scratched her she got upset and started crying. I put the puppy in the crate and he calmed down but then she walked up to his crate and started banging the ball on the cage to bother him. She then opened the crate door and when he started to come out she slammed the door in his face. Then, my toy poodle was under the sofa and his head was kind of sticking out from under the sofa, she started stomping his head with her feet. I told her in a stern voice that she cannot do this because thats mean and will hurt him. She then proceeded to continue to do this. She keep demanded to eat (even after she ate) didnt let me talk while I was on the phone with my mother and was constantly disobeying me. She was playing with rocks and I told her she cannot throw the rocks on the floor because the puppy will eat it and can get sick. She proceeded to continue to do it and looked at me like she was trying to push my buttons. Is this normal 3 year old behavior? This is really terrifying to me being that I am now pregnant and Im very afraid that this is what a 3 year acts like. I do want to add that she comes from a very disorganized family were there is constant yelling and she is very spoiled and always gets her way.

Posted 8/21/11 6:46 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

LJSMommy
Love him!

Member since 10/07

3189 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this normal behavoir for a 3 year old??

3 year old will test your limits for sureChat Icon I have one!!

As for taunting the animals....I have no answer.

But as for disobeying you, she was likely trying to keep your attention is part of my guess. You were on the phone...she did not want you to be. Lots of yelling at home.....well probably means some amount of her having to fight for attention.

Posted 8/21/11 7:00 PM
 

bettybcafe
Big brother in the making

Member since 7/07

8611 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Is this normal behavoir for a 3 year old??

Posted by LJSMommy

3 year old will test your limits for sureChat Icon I have one!!

As for taunting the animals....I have no answer.

But as for disobeying you, she was likely trying to keep your attention is part of my guess. You were on the phone...she did not want you to be. Lots of yelling at home.....well probably means some amount of her having to fight for attention.



Thanks for responding! Yea, I figured the testing me was normal but the taunting of my dogs...that just doesnt seem right to me. Like, arent kids usually affectionate towards animals. They dont normally want to hurt them, its just so strange to me. I do blame a lot of her behavoir on what happens at home. Do you have any suggestions on how to deal with her tantrums and need for constant attention?

Posted 8/21/11 7:06 PM
 

nov04libride
big brother <3

Member since 5/05

14672 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Is this normal behavoir for a 3 year old??

Posted by bettybcafe

Posted by LJSMommy

3 year old will test your limits for sureChat Icon I have one!!

As for taunting the animals....I have no answer.

But as for disobeying you, she was likely trying to keep your attention is part of my guess. You were on the phone...she did not want you to be. Lots of yelling at home.....well probably means some amount of her having to fight for attention.



Thanks for responding! Yea, I figured the testing me was normal but the taunting of my dogs...that just doesnt seem right to me. Like, arent kids usually affectionate towards animals. They dont normally want to hurt them, its just so strange to me. I do blame a lot of her behavoir on what happens at home. Do you have any suggestions on how to deal with her tantrums and need for constant attention?



It can go either way with the animals. When a baby arrives, the dogs can get jealous since they aren't getting the attention that they are used to, and even when babies are playing, they are rough and grab tails, etc. I can't even count the number of threads of people having to get rid of their dogs because they couldn't give them the attention that they need/the animals are not gentle with the kids.

IMO, there isn't much that you can do to change her behavior if it is based on what happens in her own home.

Posted 8/21/11 7:14 PM
 

Lillykat
going along for the ride...

Member since 5/05

16253 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this normal behavoir for a 3 year old??

I don't know I don't think that they being cruel and taunting the dog is what I would say is normal. I know my girls wouldn't do that they like animals even if they are a bit afraid of dogs they certainly wouldn't taunt them. Maybe that is something she learned at home? As far as the wanting to eat after eating, being upset you were on the phone etc. A lot of it sounds like 3 year old behavior in one way or another.

Not to say the behavior is acceptable but:

It isn't unusual for a 3 year old to want attention while you are on the phone. Where you on the phone for a minute or for a while - she might have felt like you were ignoring her.

My girls will eat dinner than say 30 mins later I'm hungry. I think that is pretty normal. They can eat all day one day then barely eat for a few.

The throwing rocks then looking at you sounds exactly like she was testing you to see what she could get away with and what you wouldn't let her do. I think most kids that age do things to test adults to see what limits they can push. If you let her get away with it she will only continue.

If there is a lot of yelling at home - that might be how she is used to being disciplined or it could be she doesn't get much attention and hoped to get it from you - remember for some kids negative attention is still attention.

Posted 8/21/11 7:22 PM
 

Lillykat
going along for the ride...

Member since 5/05

16253 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this normal behavoir for a 3 year old??

Posted by bettybcafe

Posted by LJSMommy

3 year old will test your limits for sureChat Icon I have one!!

As for taunting the animals....I have no answer.

But as for disobeying you, she was likely trying to keep your attention is part of my guess. You were on the phone...she did not want you to be. Lots of yelling at home.....well probably means some amount of her having to fight for attention.



Thanks for responding! Yea, I figured the testing me was normal but the taunting of my dogs...that just doesnt seem right to me. Like, arent kids usually affectionate towards animals. They dont normally want to hurt them, its just so strange to me. I do blame a lot of her behavoir on what happens at home. Do you have any suggestions on how to deal with her tantrums and need for constant attention?



I would limit the phone calls and keep them short- and if you do need to tell her that you must make a call and that if she can wait nicely you would be more than happy to play x game or x toy with her when you are finished. I would keep the dogs away from her - maybe put them in another room where she is not allowed if you have to watch her at your home. Are you allowed to do time out with her? By taking away the attention she might learn she has to behave to GET attention. Do you give her positive reinforcement when she does something good like waiting quietly? Make a big fuss over her when she is behaving nicely that might help.

Posted 8/21/11 7:26 PM
 

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: Is this normal behavoir for a 3 year old??

There's a reason my kids are down by 7:30pm. 5pm until bedtime is usually a disaster around here.

What you described is pretty typical 3 year old behavior- especially the phone. At the first sign that she couldn't handle being around the dogs without bothering them, the dogs should have been completely removed from the situation. She should have never had any access to the crate.

Posted 8/21/11 8:55 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Is this normal behavoir for a 3 year old??

Posted by Porrruss

There's a reason my kids are down by 7:30pm. 5pm until bedtime is usually a disaster around here.

What you described is pretty typical 3 year old behavior- especially the phone. At the first sign that she couldn't handle being around the dogs without bothering them, the dogs should have been completely removed from the situation. She should have never had any access to the crate.



ITA!

Once 5pm hits over here all helll breaks loose, literally. That is also ALOT of activity for a 3 year old in a short period of time. My kids were with me and my mother shopping today for a half hour and they were done. I couldn't imagine three hours.

Posted 8/21/11 9:06 PM
 

jlk51496
Mom of 3 - YIKES! =)

Member since 10/09

6758 total posts

Name:
Katie

Re: Is this normal behavoir for a 3 year old??

Def testing you..they need a lot of distractions or redirections at that age...get excited about an activity and make her forget about the dogs for a while..that usually is the only thing that works... sometimes reasoning or just telling my DS "don't do that" means nothing to them!

Unfortunately evening are witching hours and if dinner didnt calm her then she just needed redirection!

Sorry dont let that one day scare you..but I am sure you will have days like that with yours..now you will know better when it is coming and how to stop it! HAHA!

Good luck!

Posted 8/21/11 9:14 PM
 

LadyH
April Baby Girl is Here!

Member since 12/07

1077 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this normal behavoir for a 3 year old??

Yikes - she was really testing you.

My DC is usually more reasonable with other people than he is with me. He knows I let him get away with more. I put him in the corner if his behavior gets out of control (like hurting the dogs)

Posted 8/21/11 10:41 PM
 

gck0708
She is love!

Member since 11/08

1863 total posts

Name:
Grace

Re: Is this normal behavoir for a 3 year old??

Not that I have a 3 year old - my DD is almost 2 - but I'm sure that she was testing you and all that but my first reaction was probably that after the 5PM witching hour (that I have heard lasts well into toddler-dom - if I am late giving my DD dinner and she's hungry, that's it for the rest of the night until bedtime-terrible!). But I truly feel that she was probably exhausted. A child that age should be in bed hours before 11PM - I know her Mom couldn't pick her up until then, but I'd say that over-triedness was the culprit for her bad behavior, especially as the day went on.

Maybe - if there's a next time - you could put her to bed and just have her Mom get her up to put her in th car to go home. It's not fair for you to have to put up with an over-tired, badly behaved child, and it's not fair for her, either.

Posted 8/22/11 3:36 AM
 

gck0708
She is love!

Member since 11/08

1863 total posts

Name:
Grace

Re: Is this normal behavoir for a 3 year old??

Posted by gck0708

Not that I have a 3 year old - my DD is almost 2 - but I'm sure that she was testing you and all that but my first reaction was probably that after the 5PM witching hour (that I have heard lasts well into toddler-dom - if I am late giving my DD dinner and she's hungry, that's it for the rest of the night until bedtime-terrible!). But I truly feel that she was probably exhausted. A child that age should be in bed hours before 11PM - I know her Mom couldn't pick her up until then, but I'd say that over-triedness was the culprit for her bad behavior, especially as the day went on.

Maybe - if there's a next time - you could put her to bed and just have her Mom get her up to put her in th car to go home. It's not fair for you to have to put up with an over-tired, badly behaved child, and it's not fair for her, either.



I just wanted to reiterate that I am SURE she was testing you - I am not trying to excuse her behavior by saying that she was overtired. I simply meant (and believe) that her over-tiredness would not have helped anything. DD acts out often - the terrible 2s are here early, I know - but when she is tired it's 100x worse.

Posted 8/22/11 3:43 AM
 

Chai77
Brighter days ahead

Member since 4/07

7364 total posts

Name:

Re: Is this normal behavoir for a 3 year old??

Sounds to me like an overtired kid who was testing the limits and trying to get your attention. Not entirely atypical for a three year old IMO.

Posted 8/22/11 7:52 AM
 

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Re: Is this normal behavoir for a 3 year old??

Overtired and pushing limits.

That's probably why she kept asking to eat too, when DD1 is tired she says she is hungry. Eating will give them a little more energy.

Even the taunting is pushing limits. You're telling her no, she wants to see how far she can go before you really snap.

Put her into time out next time, lay her down to sleep at a normal hour too. It's a lot to ask a 3yo to be up til 11pm, even with a nap.

Posted 8/22/11 9:41 AM
 

memi7206
LIF Adult

Member since 3/11

2355 total posts

Name:
Due Dec 29th!!!!!

Re: Is this normal behavoir for a 3 year old??

sounds like a witching hour to me......

Posted 8/22/11 10:10 AM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: Is this normal behavoir for a 3 year old??

sounds like typical behavior of a girl....

I know, I have one!



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 8/22/11 10:13 AM
 

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Is this normal behavoir for a 3 year old??

Posted by Porrruss

There's a reason my kids are down by 7:30pm. 5pm until bedtime is usually a disaster around here.

What you described is pretty typical 3 year old behavior- especially the phone. At the first sign that she couldn't handle being around the dogs without bothering them, the dogs should have been completely removed from the situation. She should have never had any access to the crate.



YES to THIS..

Posted 8/22/11 5:06 PM
 

bettybcafe
Big brother in the making

Member since 7/07

8611 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Is this normal behavoir for a 3 year old??

Thanks for all the responses ladies!! I REALLY wanted to put this child to sleep but her mother told me if I did and didnt wake her up in an hour or so that she wouldnt pick her up because then she wouldnt go to sleep once she got home but honestly, this child doesnt go to sleep until 11pm anyway. I know this because her mother tells me. I sometimes speak to the mom on the phone at 10-11pm and I hear the child in the background. I know she was tired...and it really makes sense now that she was acting this way..

Posted 8/22/11 6:12 PM
 

bettybcafe
Big brother in the making

Member since 7/07

8611 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Is this normal behavoir for a 3 year old??

Posted by tarabelle99

Overtired and pushing limits.

That's probably why she kept asking to eat too, when DD1 is tired she says she is hungry. Eating will give them a little more energy.

Even the taunting is pushing limits. You're telling her no, she wants to see how far she can go before you really snap.

Put her into time out next time, lay her down to sleep at a normal hour too. It's a lot to ask a 3yo to be up til 11pm, even with a nap.



How do I enforce a time out for a 3 year old? I wanted her to nap but it was 5pm when we got home and the mom said if I let her sleep past 6pm that she wont pick her up because then she wont go to bed later and of course the baby didnt want to go to sleep at 5pm. This child has been up since 10am-11:45pm(when she got picked up) and didnt even have a nap!

Posted 8/22/11 6:14 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
What is a normal meal for your one year old waterspout4 9/8/08 9 Parenting
Normal for a one year old?? OffWithHerHead23 3/1/07 3 Parenting
is it normal for a one year old to be really fussy for extended periods of time? mamabear 2/25/11 6 Parenting
It it normal to have bedtime battles with a 2 year old? rileysmama 1/8/10 6 Parenting
is this normal for a 2 year old to do/know? 04bride 9/3/08 8 Parenting
What is normal blood pressure for a 65 year old woman? johnsae 6/8/07 8 Families Helping Families ™