Is it too early to get rid of the bottles?

Forum Opinion Poll
yes 13 36.11%
no 23 63.89%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

is it too early?

Posted By Message

Meggo613
im a big girl!

Member since 2/07

4536 total posts

Name:
Megan

is it too early?

to get rid of the bottle?

abby is doing fantastic with her sippy cup will take water or formula in it no problems. she is very independant and wants to do it herself so i got her 2 avent bottles with handles thoes are the only bottles she uses. with the 1 and only exception of when she takes her last bottle of the night ive been holding her since she was born snuggle and feed her. i really dont want to give up with time with her but i think i need to. her sleeping habits are getting out of control we have done CIO with her but i think the hwole snuggle feeding her before bed is really thowing her off i feel maybe if i just gave her her last bottle in her sippy in her bed she would be able to fall asleep easier.

so am i crazy to take away her bottles? she seems to be doing fine with out. WWYD?

by the way abby is a little over 8 months old

Posted 3/9/10 12:14 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: is it too early?

IMO, yes

She still needs her formula and will for a few more months.

But, if it works for you, then do it. I would just be concerned about how many oz's she gets a day b/c even with the markings on the sides of the cups, its hard to tell what they get.

Posted 3/9/10 12:15 PM
 

MrsDrMatt
Live and RUN like a Ninja!

Member since 5/06

3104 total posts

Name:
MrsDrMatt

Re: is it too early?

I am completely for getting rid of bottles as soon as it is reasonable to do so but in my opinion 8 months is too early

Posted 3/9/10 12:17 PM
 

Meggo613
im a big girl!

Member since 2/07

4536 total posts

Name:
Megan

Re: is it too early?

Posted by KateDevine

IMO, yes

She still needs her formula and will for a few more months.

But, if it works for you, then do it. I would just be concerned about how many oz's she gets a day b/c even with the markings on the sides of the cups, its hard to tell what they get.



her formula intake hasnt changed i actually make her formula in a bottle so i can measure acurately and then i put it into a sippy cup

Posted 3/9/10 12:17 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: is it too early?

Posted by Meggo613

Posted by KateDevine

IMO, yes

She still needs her formula and will for a few more months.

But, if it works for you, then do it. I would just be concerned about how many oz's she gets a day b/c even with the markings on the sides of the cups, its hard to tell what they get.



her formula intake hasnt changed i actually make her formula in a bottle so i can measure acurately and then i put it into a sippy cup



That's not what I mean, I meant that she may "nurse" a cup more than a bottle. Formula is still her main source of nutrition for at least another 3 months...

I just think its too early, but if you want to do it, go for itChat Icon

Posted 3/9/10 12:19 PM
 

Meggo613
im a big girl!

Member since 2/07

4536 total posts

Name:
Megan

Re: is it too early?

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by Meggo613

Posted by KateDevine

IMO, yes

She still needs her formula and will for a few more months.

But, if it works for you, then do it. I would just be concerned about how many oz's she gets a day b/c even with the markings on the sides of the cups, its hard to tell what they get.



her formula intake hasnt changed i actually make her formula in a bottle so i can measure acurately and then i put it into a sippy cup



That's not what I mean, I meant that she may "nurse" a cup more than a bottle. Formula is still her main source of nutrition for at least another 3 months...

I just think its too early, but if you want to do it, go for itChat Icon



thanks for your opinion i really appreciate it.. this is my first go round with everything and i was shocked she took so well to a cup this early on so i didnt know when it was approptiate. i have some family memebers whos 3 year olds are still taking a bottle and to me thats pushing it

Posted 3/9/10 12:23 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: is it too early?

As long as she is drinking the same amount of formula in a cup as she would in a bottle, I don't see why not!

Posted 3/9/10 12:27 PM
 

shapla79
Where Does The Time Go?

Member since 11/07

4619 total posts

Name:

Re: is it too early?

I don't see why not if she's doing great with the sippies. DS was off the bottle at 8 months and it made my life so much easier! He still got his BM/formula in his sippy cup and his intake never changed. It was one less transition to worry about.

Posted 3/9/10 12:33 PM
 

carolyns4cupcakes
C ♥'s F

Member since 2/07

6456 total posts

Name:

Re: is it too early?

Posted by SweetTooth

As long as she is drinking the same amount of formula in a cup as she would in a bottle, I don't see why not!



If she likes formula in a cup than go for it.

My DD's are 10 months apart. At 10 months she was only taking a bottle at night and at 11 months she was off it completely. I never had the 2 of them on bottles. It worked for me. Do what works for you!

Posted 3/9/10 12:34 PM
 

Meggo613
im a big girl!

Member since 2/07

4536 total posts

Name:
Megan

Re: is it too early?

thanks so much for all the replies i really appreciate all the input

Posted 3/9/10 12:37 PM
 

BeachMom
Love my 4 kiddos!

Member since 11/08

8346 total posts

Name:
Kristie

Re: is it too early?

Posted by SweetTooth

As long as she is drinking the same amount of formula in a cup as she would in a bottle, I don't see why not!



ITA... I woulnd't go throwing the bottles out incase you need them, but if she's drinking the same amount out of the sippy cup then go for it.

Posted 3/9/10 12:44 PM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: is it too early?

If she's drinking all of her formula reliably in a cup I see no reason not to take her off the bottle.

I had no chance of taking my DD off the bottle that young, or even a year later without her refusing all milk/formula so it was never an option for me.

Posted 3/9/10 12:55 PM
 

jellybean78
:)

Member since 8/06

13103 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: is it too early?

Posted by SweetTooth

As long as she is drinking the same amount of formula in a cup as she would in a bottle, I don't see why not!



ITA. DD is 27 months and will only drink her milk in a bottle. Everything else from a sippy or regular cup but milk only in the bottle. I would think the habit is a lot harder to break the older they get. Honestly I don't push her too much to give it up because I'm not a stickler when it comes to that stuff but that said, if you can do it now and she's still getting the same amount of formula go for it.

Message edited 2010-03-09 13:30:51.810000.

Posted 3/9/10 1:30 PM
 

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: is it too early?

IF she's taking in the same amount in the sippy as what she was taking in bottles, then go for it.

I think you mentioned giving her a sippy to finish in bed? BAD idea as your asking for bottle rot. It's what happens when babies are allowed to fall asleep with bottles/sippies. The formula/milk is allowed to pool in the mouth and will cause tooth decay.

Better to not let her get used to taking anything into bed other than a water sippy.

Posted 3/9/10 1:36 PM
 

Meggo613
im a big girl!

Member since 2/07

4536 total posts

Name:
Megan

Re: is it too early?

Posted by Porrruss

IF she's taking in the same amount in the sippy as what she was taking in bottles, then go for it.

I think you mentioned giving her a sippy to finish in bed? BAD idea as your asking for bottle rot. It's what happens when babies are allowed to fall asleep with bottles/sippies. The formula/milk is allowed to pool in the mouth and will cause tooth decay.

Better to not let her get used to taking anything into bed other than a water sippy.



thank you so much for that i didnt know about the tooth decay! i tried it all day today only giving her the sippy and she did great everything that she normally takes in her bottles i put into her sippys and she sucked them dry! Chat Icon i did give her one bottle because its what i had clean and she actually drank better from the cups Thank you all again for your input! Chat Icon

Posted 3/9/10 7:45 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
good morning early birds! what are we doing up so early? who is awake? hunnybunnyxoxo 9/20/08 25 Pregnancy
why do stores sell next seasons clothes sooo early? dm24angel 7/17/05 4 Families Helping Families ™
a day early but: HAPPY BIRTHDAY JAIME AKA MRS. BOOP!! ggt08 7/14/05 22 Families Helping Families ™
Did anyone ever get a BFP with an early test? LIMOMx2 6/29/05 8 Pregnancy
Is it too early to say this or not... preciouslove 6/23/05 11 Sports
did any of you ladies use an early pregnancy test? Dee 6/14/05 5 Pregnancy