is it on or in

Posted By Message

Jessica
I'm a mommy :)

Member since 1/06

7322 total posts

Name:
~Jess~

is it on or in

our wedding is on Long Island,NY...

i was asked where my wedding was and i stumbled if it was on or inChat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/17/07 11:30 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: is it on or in

I think either is technically correct, because you are physically ON an island, but if you're referring to a geographic area, "in" is usually correct.

For example, you'd never say "The Empire State Building is ON New York City"

but I suppose you would technically be correct in saying it is ON Manhattan Island

Posted 3/17/07 11:32 PM
 

nyteacher13
Three Under Four!!! :-)

Member since 8/06

6405 total posts

Name:
~ THERESA ~

Re: is it on or in

I say "ON".

"I live on Long Island."

If NYC were my home,
I'd say, "I live IN NYC."

Not sure the technical reason why, but this is the way it should be said. Chat Icon My certification tells me so. heheheheh

Seriously though, I'm not sure why.

Chat Icon

Posted 3/17/07 11:43 PM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: is it on or in

Posted by nyteacher13

I say "ON".

"I live on Long Island."

If NYC were my home,
I'd say, "I live IN NYC."

Not sure the technical reason why, but this is the way it should be said. Chat Icon My certification tells me so. heheheheh

Seriously though, I'm not sure why.

Chat Icon



I think it's the ON the physical island, vs IN a specific county, area, etc.

Posted 3/17/07 11:51 PM
 

nyteacher13
Three Under Four!!! :-)

Member since 8/06

6405 total posts

Name:
~ THERESA ~

Re: is it on or in

Posted by JenniferEver

Posted by nyteacher13

I say "ON".

"I live on Long Island."

If NYC were my home,
I'd say, "I live IN NYC."

Not sure the technical reason why, but this is the way it should be said. Chat Icon My certification tells me so. heheheheh

Seriously though, I'm not sure why.

Chat Icon



I think it's the ON the physical island, vs IN a specific county, area, etc.



sounds good to me!!! It's funny when non-LI people say it the other way. Just a little quirky thing I guess. Chat Icon

Posted 3/17/07 11:54 PM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: is it on or in

Posted by nyteacher13

Posted by JenniferEver

Posted by nyteacher13

I say "ON".

"I live on Long Island."

If NYC were my home,
I'd say, "I live IN NYC."

Not sure the technical reason why, but this is the way it should be said. Chat Icon My certification tells me so. heheheheh

Seriously though, I'm not sure why.

Chat Icon



I think it's the ON the physical island, vs IN a specific county, area, etc.



sounds good to me!!! It's funny when non-LI people say it the other way. Just a little quirky thing I guess. Chat Icon


I think I usually say "It's IN Long Island"

Posted 3/17/07 11:55 PM
 

LiPo
:(

Member since 9/06

1864 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: is it on or in

I always say "on" Long Island.

Posted 3/18/07 5:58 AM
 

lilqtny
-Crossfit & pitbull addict

Member since 7/06

2830 total posts

Name:
Tracy

Re: is it on or in

I am an English teacher and this is something that always drives me nuts.

I constantly hear people say they live IN Long Island, that is not correct.

To say where you live it is :

I live ON long island, you do not live IN the island.

You live IN a certain town (within the boundaries of that town) .

So I live on Long Island and IN West Islip.

Your wedding is ON Long Island and IN a certain town or hall.


Posted 3/18/07 8:01 AM
 

MarathonKnitter
HAPPY

Member since 2/07

17374 total posts

Name:
EMBRACING CHANGE

Re: is it on or in

Posted by lilqtny

I am an English teacher and this is something that always drives me nuts.

I constantly hear people say they live IN Long Island, that is not correct.

To say where you live it is :

I live ON long island, you do not live IN the island.

You live IN a certain town (within the boundaries of that town) .

So I live on Long Island and IN West Islip.

Your wedding is ON Long Island and IN a certain town or hall.





ditto... except for the part about being a teacher Chat Icon

Posted 3/18/07 9:08 AM