Is certain behavior taught or "genetic disposition?"

Posted By Message

Charly
LOVE!

Member since 5/05

12578 total posts

Name:

Is certain behavior taught or "genetic disposition?"

OK so we spend ALOT of time with another couple. Their DS is 4 months older than Hannah. The kids go to daycare together, we spend almost every Saturday together, go on vacations together, etc.

Our children are (expectedly so) very different, however the one thing that drives me crazy is the "sharing" thing. He will NOT share. He will hold every single toy in his hands and scream mine and not let Hannah play with anything (even if they are HER toys.)

When his parents intervene and give Hannah 1 toy of many he cries and cries until Hannah gives it back, which she always does. Hannah on the other hand shares everything with anyone. She brings him toys and doesn't seem bothered when he forcefully takes things away from her.


Now I'm not comparing our children and I know this "mine" thing is typical for the age, but he's always been like that. So my question is - is behavior, such as sharing, something that is learned or just part of a childs disposition? See I don't think I ever "taught" Hannah to share, she just seems to enjoy it and his parents are always trying to teach him but he doesn't improve at all.

ETA: he's like this with all kids, not just my DD. Daycare has a hard time with this as well.

Message edited 2008-04-05 21:56:37.860000.

Posted 4/5/08 9:10 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Elizabeth
Mom of Three

Member since 9/05

7900 total posts

Name:
"MOMMY!!!"

Re: Is certain behavior taught or "genetic disposition?"

I'd say some kids are more strong willed and some are more easygoing but something like that is a learned behavior. I mean, as he gets older, he can easily be taught to share. But it depends on many things, ie, if the child is very spirited and has a fit when someone tries to make him share, do the parents just give in to him or do they try to help him learn? I think that will be the difference. There might always be aspects of his personality that are very demanding but that doesn't mean he can't be taught. JMO.

Posted 4/5/08 9:53 PM
 

2BEANS
wow time is going fast.

Member since 9/07

16106 total posts

Name:
Tina

Re: Is certain behavior taught or "genetic disposition?"

I think it can be both. But i think if you start teaching the child at a very young age, even a few months old, that sharing is fun, then they will be more inclined in doing so.

eta: worlds longest run on sorry.

Message edited 2008-04-05 22:10:10.573000.

Posted 4/5/08 10:09 PM
 

Stacey1403
Where it all began....

Member since 5/05

24065 total posts

Name:

Re: Is certain behavior taught or "genetic disposition?"

At his age not sharing is completely normal. They really don't even play with other children at his age. They will parallel play with each other. As he gets older and has more of an understanding he should grow out of it, hopefullyChat Icon

Posted 4/5/08 10:36 PM
 

aja
my princess

Member since 10/05

2936 total posts

Name:

Re: Is certain behavior taught or "genetic disposition?"

Posted by Stacey1403

At his age not sharing is completely normal. They really don't even play with other children at his age. They will parallel play with each other. As he gets older and has more of an understanding he should grow out of it, hopefullyChat Icon



not sharing and playing alone is normal at this age...as other posted some children are just more easy going and don't mind when others touch their stuff...just like adults

my son sounds like the boy you described....I noticed he is more likely to share with older children (who are femaleChat Icon )than with children his age

i try to practice with him ...but sharing for him means he gives it to me for 5 seconds and then he says "my turn" and takes it back

Posted 4/5/08 10:42 PM
 

CunningOne
***

Member since 5/05

26975 total posts

Name:

Re: Is certain behavior taught or "genetic disposition?"

OMG, both my kids are like the boy you described... They don't share at all and throw super hissy fits if someone touches one of their toys Chat Icon Chat Icon I just think its their nature because I know I have tried my hardest, and even got a second chance at it with my DD, and still no luck. What kills me is that all the playdates we have, all the other kids are so laid back and go with the flow, and then there is my two Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 4/5/08 10:45 PM
 

stickydust
Now a mommy of 2!!!

Member since 4/06

3164 total posts

Name:

Re: Is certain behavior taught or "genetic disposition?"

My DD sounds like your DD very laid back in that way an always shares everything. It always has just been her nature.









Posted 4/5/08 11:35 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Is certain behavior taught or "genetic disposition?"

I feel that it is both - but I think that the way you raise a child will govern the majority of his/her behavior.... I am a behaviorist, so I will always lean towards that, but I truly believe it. Yes, someone can genetically be predisposed to be a certain way, but if it is not reinforced, then it just has no way of manifesting....

Posted 4/5/08 11:37 PM