interfaith kids

Posted By Message

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

interfaith kids

I was raised Jewish (though not very religious0 and DH was raised Catholica (religious schooling, alter boy, mom still goes to church.) DH and I are on board that Ds will not be raised in either faith but will be taught about them both and celebrates holidays with both families. Neither of our parents have ever had a real issue with this- though other family members have commented. Chat Icon
So anyway, now that DS is getting older, we are realizing that MIL is teaching/talking about religious things to him. DH just told me the other night, he tried not to tell me at all since this happened 2 weeks ago, that DS had kissed out friends cross (necklace) and said Jesus. That really pizzes me off. DH said something to his mom about DS technically being jewish since I am and how that's really disprectful for her to go behind our backs like that. I will not say anything to MIL, at this point anyway, but I'm wondering how you would feel about this...

Posted 1/20/09 2:17 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

RMA9728
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/08

863 total posts

Name:

Re: interfaith kids

My dh and I are doing the same thing. When my MIL started telling things to my girls and I found out, I "kindly" told her that it was not her place for her to teach our kids this. I have also told my dd's who are old enough to understand that if they have a question about this to ask my dh or I.

Posted 1/20/09 3:42 PM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: interfaith kids

i would be pretty upset about that too. it's one thing to teach your child about her faith, but to teach him to kiss the cross seems a little extreme to me (unless it's just something he saw her doing and decided to copy it, in which case i'd be more understanding).

i think it's totally reasonable for your DH to say something to her nicely, that you don't mind celebrating all the holidays with her, but when it comes to his religious education, that is best left to you and your DH Chat Icon

ETF: spelling

Message edited 2009-01-20 15:48:31.743000.

Posted 1/20/09 3:47 PM
 

Summersalwaysinseason
I'm finally able to write here

Member since 1/06

2044 total posts

Name:

Re: interfaith kids

Interfaith here...I'm Jewish and DH is Protestant. We are doing the same exact things you are doing...celebrating all holidays, teaching both sides, teaching about G-d, teaching our kids to be kind to others, etc.

This would really, really bother me...and I would probably not say anything either, but my poor DH would get an ear full!!!!

Posted 1/20/09 3:51 PM
 

imyself

Member since 10/06

2938 total posts

Name:
me

Re: interfaith kids

I was raised Catholic and dh was raised Jewish. We are raising our kids the same way you are. Other people will not understand and you have every right to be upset. I actually had some one ask me if they could secretly christen my ds. Like it was my husbands fault I won't do it Chat Icon . I told him NO HE MAY NOT CHRISTEN MY CHILD! My own mother threatened to christen my ds. She said "well you know antone can do it" I was afraid to leave her alone with ds. We didn't have a bris so he was not being christened. We had a baby naming that incorporated both religions.
So long story short, you have every right to be upset and dh should have a chat with her.

Posted 1/20/09 4:37 PM
 

mtnmama

Member since 5/06

4794 total posts

Name:

Message edited 2010-01-08 13:07:03.950000.

Posted 1/20/09 9:25 PM
 

bayla
Love my two kiddos :)

Member since 8/06

7178 total posts

Name:

Re: interfaith kids

Posted by cpanyc

But you said that you will be teaching your DS about both faiths. So why would it upset you that your MIL is talking to him about Christianity? Is it that only you and your DH can talk to him about religion and no one else?



i'm sorry I dont agree with you..it is up to her and her DH to decide what their child learns and what to teach them about their religions. I am Jewish and my DH is catholic and we are raising my DS jewish. However we will celebrate all holidays and my DH will teach my DS whatever HE chooses about Jesus. If is not up to my SIL or my MIL , (both are very religious) to teach him. and if i ever found out someone taught my kid something, without checking with me or my DH i woudl be floored. Here's an ex: My DH deosnt accept the host when he goes to church b/c he hasn't gone to confession in years, what if someone told my DS that you have to do it, or your not a true catholic. It is not up to them to tell him that, esp b/c my DH is catholic, believes in Jesus, but practices as he sees fit to
Esp regarding religion if its an interfaith one. Families need to tread carefully and respect the requests of the parents

Message edited 2009-01-20 21:37:22.743000.

Posted 1/20/09 9:34 PM
 

mtnmama

Member since 5/06

4794 total posts

Name:

Message edited 2010-01-08 13:08:14.260000.

Posted 1/20/09 9:54 PM
 

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: interfaith kids

When I say that both faiths will be taught I guess I mean that in a superficial way. DS will be told what the holidays stand for and what we are celebrating, but I think having him kiss a cross, or if she taught hoim to make the sign of the cross over himself, is taking it too far.
And as much as he will be told about both religions, he was technically born to a Jewish mother- which makes him Jewish. It makes me uncomfortable that she's doing more than "teaching" him, she is most definitely trying to push him in her religious direction.

Posted 1/20/09 10:21 PM
 

ddunne2
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

4189 total posts

Name:
Doreen

Re: interfaith kids

I think everyone has different ideas of what is appropriate to do and act upon when dealing with religion. I personally, do not think that anyone outside of my DH and I should push reigious teachings on my children. Both my DH and I were raised Catholic, went to Catholic school and will raise our children Catholic. I'm not very religious...I fully admit to being a go through the motions Catholic. I just don't get much out of religion. My DH is much more devout than I am.

My SIL is obsessive catholic and is constantly giving my kids religious gifts. If the event is a reliigious one..communion, etc...sure, religious gifts are fine. But outside of that I think it is very inappropriate to give my kids religious gifts (prayer CD's etc, ) and influence the relgious traditions we have or don't have in our home. To me that is no different than a Jehovahs witness ringing my door bell. I just think it is not her place. So I agree, that family should back off when it comes to religion.

Posted 1/20/09 10:44 PM
 

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: interfaith kids

Posted by cpanyc

But you said that you will be teaching your DS about both faiths. So why would it upset you that your MIL is talking to him about Christianity? Is it that only you and your DH can talk to him about religion and no one else?



I don't know if you realize my DS's age, but he's only 2. She's not "talking" to him per say, she is "showing" him religious rituals which are not his faith. My DS doesn't know enough about religion one way or another to discuss anything at this point, but yes, I would prefer DS come to DH or myself to discuss religion or ask questions.
Would you want someone else to discuss where babies come from with your child? I just think there are certain things that shoud be left to the parents.

Posted 1/20/09 10:53 PM
 

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: interfaith kids

Bumping for more thoughts...

Posted 1/21/09 9:34 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Spinoff to kids & age appropriateness PiyoPika566 3/21/06 45 Families Helping Families ™
Xpost: Families that have kids and adopted a puppy...? JennChris 3/20/06 0 Parenting
Families that have kids and adopted a puppy... JennChris 3/20/06 0 Pets
Moms who keep busy during the day with their kids... monkeybride 3/20/06 10 Parenting
Which breeds of dogs are good with kids? cloddy 3/20/06 39 Pets
Spinoff to Kids MrsS2005 3/13/06 20 Families Helping Families ™