Inter-faith marriages

Posted By Message

kspags
LIF Adult

Member since 6/08

1228 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Inter-faith marriages

My SIL is dating a Jewish guy and the conversation of religion and children came up. My in-laws are not very religious, but they were raised Catholic, celebrate holidays and received sacraments, etc., but no church. She is not sure how "religious" he really is. However, he stated that he would like his sons to have a bris and bar mitzvah (sp?) and she can do whatever with the girls. She deosn't feel its fair and would just like to do holidays and let the kids decide on their own. Does anyone have this situation? How do you handle it? I feel if religion is not important to her, then she shouldn't lose him over it. She feels she would be left out of a part of her child's life. Thoughts?

Posted 11/16/10 6:52 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Nshoregrl
LIF Toddler

Member since 8/09

406 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: Inter-faith marriages

My family is jewish and my sister just married a catholic.

The subject of religion was of course brought up before the marriage. They agreed to raise the children jewish. They will have a bar/bat mitzvah and a bris if appropriate.

If the guy your SIL is dating wants to have a bris and a bar mitzvah, then the religion is probably somewhat important to him. IMO-I presonally don't think I would want a boy to be raised jewish or partake in these jewish ceremonies, but then not do something equal for the girls. What if there were twins, one would have a bar mitzvah and the other wouldn't?
Personally..it just doesn't make sense to me.
Whatever they decide, I believe you have to pick one way or the other to raise the kids, and if you are going to "let them decide" then they shouldn't have any of the traditional religious "right of passage" type ceremonies.

Hope it works out

PS-My sister and her now husband went to like an Interfaith Pre-cana sort of class before they got married, to discuess these sorts of issues. It might be helpful.

Posted 11/16/10 7:22 PM
 

twicethefun
Loving life

Member since 7/06

4088 total posts

Name:

Re: Inter-faith marriages

We are interfaith and have a rabbi and priest working together to guide us in the right direction. Both my children received a Hebrew name when they were christened. We do all holidays

Posted 11/16/10 8:10 PM