Intelligence and right and wrong...

Posted By Message

mommy2bella
Where does time go?

Member since 12/05

9747 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Intelligence and right and wrong...

***changed the title**

I know we all like to talk about what our children are doiung and how wonderfully smart they are. Counting, singing, learning to walk, smiling...all milestones I have cherished when they came along.

I have a concern though and I don't want this to come off like it may...but I am so past knowing what to do at this point.

Every book and person I ask says a child does not know right or wrong and consequence until 3...

I am afraid of having an almost too smart child on my hands. And as you roll your eyes, let me say I know...
But beyond the obvious things that I love to be like wow about, I am afraid she is intelligent to a point of manipulation...

She will open her mouth and pretend to go and bite me when she doesn't get what she want, but knows that biting will warrant a bigger punishment...she will tell you EXACTLY why she is being timed out.

She rolls her eyes, holds her hand out with something like she is about to throw it on the floor while looking at us for reaction, looks at me before doing something she remembers I have warned her about...when I tell her I am going to count to 3 or she gets a timeout, she'll count for me! There is more than I can remember right now.

I hate to sound ungrateful for a smart,spirited child...but I know those girls from school and how they smartly worked people to get what they want at the expense of others feelings...and she really is a sweet, amazing, and incredibly loving little girl. She does listen a lot, help clean up, and tries to have these conversations with me...

I just see how she almost puts on a "show" in front of others and then DH and I seem like fools when we talk about our difficulties...and she won't be two until freakin' September.

Am I just being silly? And what the heck can I do to teach her differently?

Message edited 2007-07-25 14:04:16.403000.

Posted 7/25/07 1:55 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

sunny
Life is good!

Member since 5/05

8369 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Intelligence...

I could have written this myself.......although mine can be kind of bratty in front of others too, sometimes I get embarrassed she is so "spirited".

I have to tell you, I think that a child does not know right or wrong and consequence until 3 is BS, I know that she does and she shows me that she does.

I don't have any answers for you because I am in the same boat. She is sweet and lovey and mushy a lot of the time, but definitely manipulates very well to try and get her way.

Posted 7/25/07 2:03 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Intelligence...

My niece started her "smart" phase at around 7-8 months. Throwing things to see what my sister and BIL would do or say. She would knock bottles of water on the floor to "test" them. Then hug them and smile...when she was 1 year old. By 1.5-2 years old, she would do something "bad" and say " Camille... bad, no tv". She would play her cutie/girlie look.

You see the pattern. She started very early. She is very "advanced" for her age.

While her early milestones were "comical", it took my sister and BIL to correcting what she was doing, a lot of "NOs" and both of them on the same page.

She just turned 3 and is still "VERY FAST" but she does know NOT to push it too far.

So yes, kids know what they do before 3.

Message edited 2007-07-25 14:08:54.090000.

Posted 7/25/07 2:07 PM
 

Calla
My girls

Member since 7/05

4303 total posts

Name:

Re: Intelligence and right and wrong...

I think that they are saying there is no sense of morality. They know what will get you mad or get them in trouble but they have no concept of social responsibility yet. What you describe with Bella is simple experimentation in cause and effect. She is testing you for reactions, just the same as she'd do a little dance to get you to clap and smile.

Posted 7/25/07 2:08 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: Intelligence and right and wrong...

I think the difference is not that they do not know right or wrong or consequence...Its that they learn MANIPULATION at a very early age ( as early as 4 months old)....And that manipulation can come in many forms and probably what she is showing....

The thing is their brain cannot formulate the thought and understanding required, BUT repetition teaches them it. So they really are not understanding there is a consequence to their actions as much as remembering that the last few times " I did this" ...that "happened" or they are reacting to body launguage, your voice etc when they show they understand WHY they did something and why its wrong. They just know its wrong b/c you get mad.

I think the thing is to get the manipulation under control with children who are very active and spirited so when they ARE 3 and 4 they dont become MASTER manipulators and intelligent children will do that.

Posted 7/25/07 2:12 PM
 

Marybeth222
My Girls!

Member since 5/05

2688 total posts

Name:
Marybeth

Re: Intelligence and right and wrong...

I think they know EXACTLY what they are doing. Peyton, my 17 month old knows when I'm at my limit.

I'll start counting and when I get to two she smiles and knows when I get to three she runs.

Children are alot smarter than we think. They know who and how to manipulate. I'm with you it's very frustrating.

Posted 7/25/07 2:13 PM
 

mommy2bella
Where does time go?

Member since 12/05

9747 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Intelligence and right and wrong...

See I think she knows. She knows biting is NOT tolerated and will get her in major hot water, a timeout, and raised voices...so she pantomime's biting you...just to show that she is mad enough to do so. And it sound ridiculous to say that a not-quite-two-year old can even do this...but you have to see it...DH didn't believe me until she did it to him yesterday.

I know what you mean by cause and effect. She's been doing that for a looooong time. She'll watch me while doing something for a reaction...I get that...and she didn't really understand timeout until about 2-3 months ago, thought it was a joke...now she KNOWS that that is what happens when she does something wrong...so at least I have that.

Should I be stimulating her more? Is it an emotional or a mental thing? She counts to ten, knows her ABCs, "reads" me books based on pictures, speaks in sentences, etc...what else can I do to excercise that muscle... we don't have a ped appointment unril she turns two and I think making an appointment because she is "manipulating me" is not an ailment
Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/25/07 2:23 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Intelligence and right and wrong...

Posted by Calla

I think that they are saying there is no sense of morality. They know what will get you mad or get them in trouble but they have no concept of social responsibility yet. What you describe with Bella is simple experimentation in cause and effect. She is testing you for reactions, just the same as she'd do a little dance to get you to clap and smile.



I completely agree with this. I mean, Ava does things like that too. She'll get my attention, then go and yank to yank the cats tail, stop and yell, NO NO NO and run away. So I really do think it's a cause and effect, as well as a testing phase.Chat Icon

Posted 7/25/07 2:31 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Intelligence and right and wrong...

Kelly -

I was in the same boat & know what you mean. Joseph would pretend to hit & look to make sure we were watching him. Then there were times when he would actually hit.

I pooh-poohed a lot of people telling me to ignore it & reward the good behavior for a long time. I'm only now seeing the difference in behavior by doing that.

As for stimulating her more, you could try that. She's obviously looking for your attention. Maybe give her attention for other things.

Posted 7/25/07 3:08 PM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Intelligence and right and wrong...

Well, you know our situation with Alex, so you know we fall on virtually the same spectrum with regard to behaviour. Most of what you describe is what we go through with Alex on almost a daily basis - I've managed to keep a good sense of humor about it Chat Icon

In all honesty, I attribute half of it to her intelligence, and half of it to her temperment - combine the intelligence factor with the strong-willed and devilish nature, and oh my, what a result you have Chat Icon I see it as my single most important role to direct that intellectual, strong-willed, devilish energy to GOOD as opposed to bad, which means that we utilize quite a bit of discipline in our household, and because Alex DOES understand, I reason with her - and yes, by god, it works (I've actually been able to reason with her that sharing with her friends is the nice thing to do, and if we don't share, our friends won't want to play with us).

The other factor is what you said - stimulate her. They have SO much undirected energy and so much curiosity, that if we don't provide a healthy outlet, that's when the behaviour issues start running amuck. Honestly, this is something that our pediatrician has discussed with us several times. From day one he told us that Alex is very alert, very curious, very precocious, and that it is extraordinarily important for us, as her parents, to direct her energy by stimulating her in good ways.

Do I always succeed? No. But, I try, I really do. I have to admit, DH is much better in that regard than I am. But, I have found that the more we engage her, one on one, with things that interest her and peak her curiousity, the better she has become.

Good luck. God knows, we need it Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/25/07 4:22 PM
 

luvsun27
Check out my cool glasses

Member since 5/05

8135 total posts

Name:
Kim

Re: Intelligence and right and wrong...

I have an 11 year old step-daughter...and she does this also. She has only lived with us since she was 7...so I attribute some of the bad behavoir to her bad environment as a toddler...however, now that she has been with us for almost 4 years, you would think she would "get it" by now.

For example...doing chores, or homework, etc. She gives an attitude about everything (I know partly because she's 11 Chat Icon Chat Icon ). But..she knows when she's pushed the line...because she will say, "I don't care if you take my gameboy away", "I don't care if I can't watch TV", "I don't care if I can't play on the computer", etc.

So...I have no advice, other than to say, Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon I'm with ya Chat Icon

Posted 7/25/07 4:37 PM
 

-Laurie-
Hi!

Member since 5/05

2536 total posts

Name:

Re: Intelligence and right and wrong...

Ds is a master of manipulation. He works the shy card and makes people work for a smile with both dimples then when they get it he works his magic on them.
He totally knows right from wrong when doing certain things.

Posted 7/25/07 5:06 PM
 

CkGm
They get so big, so fast :(

Member since 5/05

13848 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: Intelligence and right and wrong...

Posted by Calla

I think that they are saying there is no sense of morality. They know what will get you mad or get them in trouble but they have no concept of social responsibility yet. What you describe with Bella is simple experimentation in cause and effect. She is testing you for reactions, just the same as she'd do a little dance to get you to clap and smile.



exactly what I was going to say and what I understand from the zillion developmental classes I have taken. They do know if they do something you will be react a certain way- ie. punishment but they don't understand fully why this occurs.

Posted 7/25/07 5:33 PM
 

mommy2bella
Where does time go?

Member since 12/05

9747 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Intelligence and right and wrong...

Thanks everyone for the thoughtful answers...I appreciate it so much.

I am also seeing a huge difference in her attitude when she sleeps less than two hours a day in daycare...she is crabby, clingy, etc when she doesn't get enough sleep. At home when she only sleeps an hour in the morning, she has to have another nap around 4 pm or it's demon city...I see her dark side then...

I don't know how to fix that one.

Posted 7/26/07 11:58 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
How Smart Are You? Intelligence Test. joenick 4/3/07 67 Families Helping Families ™
Can you IMPROVE your child's intelligence? lovelyday2005 11/3/05 3 Parenting