Insurance Question Please Help...
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
Insurance Question Please Help... Im going to try and make this as short and sweet as possible... |
|
Posted 5/26/10 6:10 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Insurance Question Please Help... It is called fraud in reality! Message edited 2010-05-26 18:22:26.310000. |
|
Posted 5/26/10 6:19 PM
|
|
|
Re: Insurance Question Please Help... Posted by Phyl It is called fraud in reality! My XH cashed my Ins. reimbursement checks that came after I had surgery. It was in excess of 25,000! I left him a couple months later and got told that if I didn't pay the Doctor's 100% of the orig. bill they would get me for fraud! Had he not taken the checks behind my back the doctor's involved said they would have accepted the amount the insurance paid. It was a horrible time, but I paid every one of those Doctor's bills off by myself, while suppport my kids without his help! A short term solution can create a long term nightmare! The insurance company reimbursed the doctor in full b/c it was an emergency type of situation. So the Out of Network amount isnt really at issue here. Nor is she not going to pay the doctor at all. But rather pay them back a little bit at a time at his interest rate. I dont know if they can get you for fraud when you are paying them... I had a similar issue happen to me that was a mistake on both the doctors part as well as my own. (Very long story) I paid them every month until the bill was paid. She knew my back story so I think that's why she asked me... Im trying to find something online but cant... I feel so bad for them. They are the greatest people. I wish I had the money to loan them.... |
|
Posted 5/26/10 6:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: Insurance Question Please Help... If the checks are made out to her and she cashes them, how can that be fraud? |
|
Posted 5/26/10 6:34 PM
|
|
|
Re: Insurance Question Please Help... Posted by Mssissy If the checks are made out to her and she cashes them, how can that be fraud? I had surgery in Dec. The dr was out of network and the checks came to me, payable to me. I was tempted to cash the checks and pay the dr with my AMEX card. Just to get the points but they didn't accept AMEX![]() So I just signed them over. I know my paperwork states: Since this provider is not a participating provider, we are making payment for these services to you. You are responsible to pay the provider. Nowhere does it say I must sign these checks over to them. Did really answer your question. Just thought I would share my experience. And I'm curious to know if it would be considered fraud. Exactly... I wish I could find something online that would explain this... Under any other circumstances I would say that it's wrong. But I can definitely see where it would be tempting. Im my case ..... The insurance company wasnt paying the doctor so I set up payment arrangements with the him. When I got reimbursement check I cashed it and just continued to pay him the agreed upon amount...How is this different? |
|
Posted 5/26/10 6:55 PM
|
|
|
Re: Insurance Question Please Help... Posted by Mssissy If the checks are made out to her and she cashes them, how can that be fraud? I had surgery in Dec. The dr was out of network and the checks came to me, payable to me. I was tempted to cash the checks and pay the dr with my AMEX card. Just to get the points but they didn't accept AMEX![]() So I just signed them over. I know my paperwork states: Since this provider is not a participating provider, we are making payment for these services to you. You are responsible to pay the provider. Nowhere does it say I must sign these checks over to them. Did really answer your question. Just thought I would share my experience. And I'm curious to know if it would be considered fraud. Well it definately scared the crap out of me when I found out! At this time period , when insurance was 80/20 I was told that once the check is cashed and not signed over to pay for services I was liable for 100% of the orig. bills and not just what the ins. paid! Yes, fraud threats were heavily dumped on me!! I had my divorce lawyer help me deal with the whole fiasco! I never wanted to get into that slippery slope with taking money and not being able to pay it back. I had no choice but to take care of it as my X had spent the money on...... So it really happened to me. Just thought I would share what I went thru! Heather maybe see if your neighbor can read the fine print from the Ins. Company about cashing checks. It could be that Insurance has changed so much it's an entirely different situation now. I still wish them the best.
Message edited 2010-05-26 19:34:04.997000. |
|
Posted 5/26/10 7:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: Insurance Question Please Help... Posted by Phyl Posted by Mssissy If the checks are made out to her and she cashes them, how can that be fraud? I had surgery in Dec. The dr was out of network and the checks came to me, payable to me. I was tempted to cash the checks and pay the dr with my AMEX card. Just to get the points but they didn't accept AMEX![]() So I just signed them over. I know my paperwork states: Since this provider is not a participating provider, we are making payment for these services to you. You are responsible to pay the provider. Nowhere does it say I must sign these checks over to them. Did really answer your question. Just thought I would share my experience. And I'm curious to know if it would be considered fraud. Well it definately scared the crap out of me when I found out! At this time period , when insurance was 80/20 I was told that once the check is cashed and not signed over to pay for services I was liable for 100% of the orig. bills and not just what the ins. paid! Yes, fraud threats were heavily dumped on me!! I had my divorce lawyer help me deal with the whole fiasco! I never wanted to get into that slippery slope with taking money and not being able to pay it back. I had no choice but to take care of it as my X had spent the money on...... So it really happened to me. Just thought I would share what I went thru! Im wondering though if things would be different from NY to CA? I know insurance laws can differ from state to state....
|
|
Posted 5/26/10 7:34 PM
|
|
|
Re: Insurance Question Please Help... Posted by hbugal Posted by Phyl Posted by Mssissy If the checks are made out to her and she cashes them, how can that be fraud? I had surgery in Dec. The dr was out of network and the checks came to me, payable to me. I was tempted to cash the checks and pay the dr with my AMEX card. Just to get the points but they didn't accept AMEX![]() So I just signed them over. I know my paperwork states: Since this provider is not a participating provider, we are making payment for these services to you. You are responsible to pay the provider. Nowhere does it say I must sign these checks over to them. Did really answer your question. Just thought I would share my experience. And I'm curious to know if it would be considered fraud. Well it definately scared the crap out of me when I found out! At this time period , when insurance was 80/20 I was told that once the check is cashed and not signed over to pay for services I was liable for 100% of the orig. bills and not just what the ins. paid! Yes, fraud threats were heavily dumped on me!! I had my divorce lawyer help me deal with the whole fiasco! I never wanted to get into that slippery slope with taking money and not being able to pay it back. I had no choice but to take care of it as my X had spent the money on...... So it really happened to me. Just thought I would share what I went thru! Im wondering though if things would be different from NY to CA? I know insurance laws can differ from state to state.... Read what I added to my above post. I had Blue Cross/Blu Shield at that time. |
|
Posted 5/26/10 7:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: Insurance Question Please Help... I wonder if they talk to the doctor and explain the situation - will the doctor let them go on a payment plan. |
|
Posted 5/27/10 12:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: Insurance Question Please Help... Tell her to cash it. She can then get a final bill from said doctor and set up a payment plan. |
|
Posted 5/27/10 12:25 PM
|
|
|
Re: Insurance Question Please Help... The provider would have to agree to receive payments, and make sure the agreement is in writing. They do not have to accept partial payments or payment plans. Message edited 2010-05-27 12:51:55.300000. |
|
Posted 5/27/10 12:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: Insurance Question Please Help... Posted by tarabelle99 The provider would have to agree to receive payments, and make sure the agreement is in writing. They do not have to accept partial payments or payment plans. The provider may find out the insurance paid the entire amount and turn around and sue for the full amount. Yes, the insurance company will tell them the policy holder was sent a check for X amount. Other alternatives include sending it to a collection agency who may add fees/interest, screw up their credit by placing the account as a collection on a credit report and possibly sue, resulting in a judgment and all the headaches that go with it. Very interesting.... I actually called my insurance company to ask for her... The insurance company said that they couldnt give any of that information to the provider b/c the provider is not participating and not entitled to the information. They can see the status of the claim and whether or not it was paid or not but not the amount. |
|
Posted 5/27/10 1:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: Insurance Question Please Help... Posted by hbugal Posted by tarabelle99 The provider would have to agree to receive payments, and make sure the agreement is in writing. They do not have to accept partial payments or payment plans. The provider may find out the insurance paid the entire amount and turn around and sue for the full amount. Yes, the insurance company will tell them the policy holder was sent a check for X amount. Other alternatives include sending it to a collection agency who may add fees/interest, screw up their credit by placing the account as a collection on a credit report and possibly sue, resulting in a judgment and all the headaches that go with it. Very interesting.... I actually called my insurance company to ask for her... The insurance company said that they couldnt give any of that information to the provider b/c the provider is not participating and not entitled to the information. They can see the status of the claim and whether or not it was paid or not but not the amount. That's a new one on me. In over 15 years doing medical billing, I've never had an insurance company's provider relations not give me information about a claim, whether we were participating or not. One of the things you sign at a Dr's office is for authorization to bill/release of information. Smaller, union type insurers may give a hassle (though I've never experienced this..), but most will tell the provider it's been paid or not. .. I'd still be proactive and get a payment agreement in writing from the provider. JMVHO |
|
Posted 5/27/10 8:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: Insurance Question Please Help... Posted by Mssissy If the checks are made out to her and she cashes them, how can that be fraud? I had surgery in Dec. The dr was out of network and the checks came to me, payable to me. I was tempted to cash the checks and pay the dr with my AMEX card. Just to get the points but they didn't accept AMEX![]() So I just signed them over. I know my paperwork states: Since this provider is not a participating provider, we are making payment for these services to you. You are responsible to pay the provider. Nowhere does it say I must sign these checks over to them. Did really answer your question. Just thought I would share my experience. And I'm curious to know if it would be considered fraud. This is definitely true! Those checks are made payable to YOU! They can't get you on fraud at all, and I'm in the medical industry and know this! As long as you make some sort of payment every month, they can't put you in collections either, it's against the law. Only if you don't make any payment can they do that! They have to accept even $5 a month, KWIM??? |
|
Posted 5/27/10 8:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: Insurance Question Please Help... Posted by GottaHaveFaith This is definitely true! Those checks are made payable to YOU! They can't get you on fraud at all, and I'm in the medical industry and know this! As long as you make some sort of payment every month, they can't put you in collections either, it's against the law. Only if you don't make any payment can they do that! They have to accept even $5 a month, KWIM??? I agree on the fraud part, I don't know how they could call it fraud. Maybe as theft of services? I don't know.. I'm sure they could find a way if they really wanted to, but I've never had to go that route before. It is a myth that a provider has to accept partial payments or payment plans. They have every right to demand payment in full and not less, unless they are bound by a contract with an insurer to accept less than their billed amount. Of course another exception is if you and the provider agreed to this. It is also a myth that they can't send you to collections. Many hospitals and larger providers use automatic dunning systems which send all bills within a certain bucket (like, every bill over 90 days) over to a collection agency automatically, regardless of whether or not payments are being made. Unless you have an agreement in writing. And, sending in tiny "nuisance" payments on a large bill (like $5 a month on a 10K bill) can be regarded as not making a serious attempt to pay or as not having the intent to pay and can actually backfire, landing you in a courtroom being sued for the amount due PLUS additional collection and legal fees and in some cases, interest. Judgments can be particularly nasty as they mar not only your credit report, but are also a matter of public record. They also can lead to wage garnishment or liens on property which can be embarrassing and messy to clear up. Like I said, if you are proactive you can usually stop it from going to collections or from being sued. But always ALWAYS get the agreement in writing!!!!!! I've seen it backfire on people who've been told by person A that it's OK to send 150/month only to have it go to collections/court later on because they didn't get the agreement in writing. |
|
Posted 5/27/10 8:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: Insurance Question Please Help... It's not fraud to cash those checks or deposit them if they are made payable to you. |
|
Posted 5/27/10 9:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: Insurance Question Please Help... When I had my DS, my anesthiologist was out of network but agreed to accept what my insurance would pay. I received a letter from them that as long as I signed the check over to them or send them a check along with the explaination of beneifts from my insurance company that they would accept that as payment in full. Otherwise, I could be responsible for paying what THEIR typical fee was. I do not believe it is fraud. On a seperate occassion when I was treated in the emercency room, I was sent a check directly for an out of network doctor. It was not clear who the doctor was and I probably could have figured it out with some leg work but I was pregnant and couldnt be bothered. I instead deposited the check into my money market and collected interest on it until the doctor sent me a bill three months later. then I just wrote him a check. Message edited 2010-05-28 04:53:15.500000. |
|
Posted 5/28/10 4:49 AM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Question about insurance | casey31 | 10/25/05 | 4 | TTC |
| Open Enrollment and Insurance Question | AnnBrunoXO | 10/14/05 | 4 | Pregnancy |
| health insurance question. | CJC25 | 9/13/05 | 3 | Pregnancy |
| Insurance Question | Marcie | 8/25/05 | 4 | TTC |
| insurance & escrow question | raken40 | 8/4/05 | 6 | Home |
| Medical Insurance question | BigB | 7/1/05 | 13 | Families Helping Families ™ |






but they didn't accept AMEX




