infant crying - how long do you wait?

Posted By Message

SweetPeaMomma
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/07

806 total posts

Name:
jen

infant crying - how long do you wait?

my DH and i have differing opinions about how long you can let your infant (DS is 7 weeks old) cry before you pick them up to comfort them. maybe i'm too quick to do so, but i run and get him the moment i hear him crying. if i'm out of the room and DH is watching him, i'll hear DS cry for several minutes, and i usually have to stop what i'm doing to go in and ask DH to pick him up. it's causing tension between DH and me...he gets annoyed that i'm constantly getting on his case about him waiting to soothe the baby.

so i'm wondering, am i wrong for thinking the baby needs to be picked up immediately when crying? and if not, how long is too long to wait to pick up a young infant when they are crying?

TIA!

Posted 3/3/12 3:38 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: infant crying - how long do you wait?

An infant I didn't wait long at all. They do not manipulate at that age, they cry because they need something (food, changing, comfort, etc.). If your DH is letting it go for a minute or so, I don't think harm is done, but generally babies do not settle down or comfort themselves at that age.

Around 6 months you can start crying it out, but you will never spoil an infant.

Posted 3/3/12 3:42 PM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: infant crying - how long do you wait?

I think it's fine to let a newborn fuss for a few minutes - there's nothing wrong with fussing and every baby needs to learn to soothe themselves eventually. I'd never let a newborn actually cry for more than a few seconds though if I could get them - I mean if I'm in the bathroom or something they will have to wait but I'd get them as soon as I was done. I believe that they will learn to soothe themselves faster if they know that they can trust someone to soothe them if they really need it - and some babies really need that closeness they used to feel in the womb, moreso than others.

Posted 3/3/12 3:56 PM
 

aliwnec10
mom of 3 boys

Member since 4/06

11426 total posts

Name:
Ali

Re: infant crying - how long do you wait?

I have a 6 week old. I'll let him fuss, but i won't let him cry. Fussing is fine. Full on cry... not so much IMO. I don't run the second i hear him cry, but after a minute at most, i'll get him. Depends on his cry. Chat Icon

Posted 3/3/12 4:22 PM
 

TheDivineMrsM
2 girls 4 me!

Member since 8/08

7878 total posts

Name:
Mama mama mama....

Re: infant crying - how long do you wait?

Depended on the age. As a nb, I'd run if she cried. At 15 months, I give her 15-20 minutes depending on the scenario.

Posted 3/3/12 5:11 PM
 

cheryl28
LIF Adult

Member since 2/10

4657 total posts

Name:

Re: infant crying - how long do you wait?

I never jumped the sec heard dd no matter the age. I always let her fuss. I knew her limit and she needed to learn to soothe herself (not talking newborn as in 1 week old but def as the the weeks went on). I was/am never on top of her.

I think it's fine to let them fuss.

Posted 3/3/12 5:57 PM
 

MrsPJB2007
MBA at your service!

Member since 7/06

12020 total posts

Name:
MJ

Re: infant crying - how long do you wait?

I feel like sometimes men are just less inclined to pick up boys to soothe them as girls, because they have some weird hang-up like you're "babying" them and creating a mama's boy or some wimpy son. It's insane because it's a BABY and that young they are crying for a reason. I saw it with my brother sometimes. When his DD was born he would pick her up quick to soothe her but when his DS was born he was not so quick to do so and would seem to want to toughen the kid up or something.

Letting the baby fuss a little bit is not a big deal to me, but if the baby is actually crying I would go and get them. I mean you don't have to run across the house to get them asap like your life depends on it. If they cry a minute or two I don't think that's the end of the world. Your DH needs to understand that a baby that young is not crying just to cry..it's for a reason.

Posted 3/3/12 6:03 PM
 

SummerMom
Now a mom of 2!

Member since 6/07

4970 total posts

Name:

Re: infant crying - how long do you wait?

I think it's okay that you and your DH have two different approaches. You're going to approach a lot of things differently while you're parenting. You can't spoil a 7w baby so if you want to pick her up right away, that's okay. It's also okay to wait a couple of minutes (I wouldn't wait more than 4 or 5 minutes, ever, with a 7w baby though).

Posted 3/3/12 7:13 PM
 

My2Girlz11
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

785 total posts

Name:
Corrie

Re: infant crying - how long do you wait?

I have issue at all with letting babies cry. I let my two daughters cry, but they were 5-6 months old. However, a 7 week year old baby I would not let them cry. As other posters have said, they need something and are not trying to manipulate. So, if I was getting dressed and they needed something I would let them cry and quickly get dressed. HOwever, if I wasn't doing anything and they were crying at that age I would quickly pick them up or try to figure out why they were crying.

Posted 3/3/12 7:22 PM
 

noworlater
LIF Adult

Member since 2/11

1528 total posts

Name:
Now!

Re: infant crying - how long do you wait?

Like others said, they cry for a reason at that age. Sometimes though they cry when sleepy and trying to get out some energy before falling asleep- it took me a while to know the difference...its usually over in a few seconds and not as loud as 'need something cry' and then they are sleeping.. if you pick them up then, it may re-stimulate them and it'll be harder for them to get to sleep. but like others said no more than a few minutes crying at that age

Posted 3/3/12 8:19 PM
 

SweetPeaMomma
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/07

806 total posts

Name:
jen

Re: infant crying - how long do you wait?

i appreciate the responses. i think i can cool it a little bit w DH. he doesn't let him cry for more than a few minutes before picking him up. i know he wouldn't just let the baby cry it out for a long period of time. i think the fact that i already feel the motherly instinct so strongly makes me have the urge to go pick him up myself the instant i hear his cries. but often it's not a full-on cry, just fussing...i'll try to learn to give DH more time before i intervene. i don't want him to think i doubt him as a father.

Posted 3/3/12 8:24 PM
 

maybemommy10
Big Brothers to Be !

Member since 2/10

3868 total posts

Name:

Re: infant crying - how long do you wait?

Posted by MrsPJB2007

I feel like sometimes n are just less inclined to pick up boys to soothe them as girls, because they have some weird hang-up like you're "babying" them and creating a mama's boy or some wimpy son. It's insane because it's a BABY and that young they are crying for a reason.



I agree with this. I have two boys and when they were 7/8 weeks old, I would get them ASAP and DH would always make a comment that I'm spoiling them or trying to turn them "soft" um helllloooo they shit their pants and suck a paci! newsflash they ARE soft they are also INFANTS!!!Chat Icon Chat Icon Around 4 months or so is when i started letting them cry for a minute or two in order to get something done. Make a bed, do laundry etc.

Posted 3/3/12 10:02 PM
 

jax1
Love my baby girl!!!

Member since 3/09

3405 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: infant crying - how long do you wait?

Posted by cjik

An infant I didn't wait long at all. They do not manipulate at that age, they cry because they need something (food, changing, comfort, etc.). If your DH is letting it go for a minute or so, I don't think harm is done, but generally babies do not settle down or comfort themselves at that age.

Around 6 months you can start crying it out, but you will never spoil an infant.



ITA

Under 3 months, I would go to her whenever she cried because she needed something and crying was her way of expressing it. She either needed to eat, be changed, burped, tired, or just wanted to be held by mommy/daddy.

She's 5 months and really only cries when she is hungry so I go to her right away because she needs to eat. I EBF on demand.

You can not spoil a baby when they are that little.

Posted 3/4/12 12:47 AM
 

WenRC
Happiness is...

Member since 4/11

1253 total posts

Name:
Wendy

Re: infant crying - how long do you wait?

Ds isi 7 weeks as well. If he cries as im making his bottle i let him for10 secs then run and give him paci so I can finish. He also cries in his sleep so i wait 10sec and look to see if hes ok but dont pick him up.
babies communicate by crying and depend on you so not good to let him cry it out this early.

Message edited 2012-03-04 01:57:55.747000.

Posted 3/4/12 1:54 AM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: infant crying - how long do you wait?

I wouldn't let a newborn cry. It's ok to let a baby fuss for a little bit, but if the baby is actually crying, I would tend to DC as quickly as possible.

Posted 3/4/12 8:33 AM
 

blustar214
So in love with my little girl

Member since 1/10

2471 total posts

Name:

Re: infant crying - how long do you wait?

At that age I didn't wait at all, I went straight to DD if she was crying.

Posted 3/4/12 10:40 AM
 

carlowlou
loving my babies!

Member since 4/08

4594 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: infant crying - how long do you wait?

a newborn, I would pick up within moments. but getting into the infant stage..3,4,5 months old, I dont think its a bad thing if they fuss a bit before getting them. My DH also has a higher tolerance to DS crying than I do. I always want to get him and DH is slower to respond. not to say that he doesnt respond because he does, but he wont be as quick about it as I am.

Posted 3/4/12 10:57 AM
 

maybesoon
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

5981 total posts

Name:

Re: infant crying - how long do you wait?

We usually tend to them right away unless we are sleep training

Posted 3/4/12 11:37 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Infant Constipation - How long do you wait? LadyBug1209 3/30/11 9 Parenting
Interesting Article about Infant/Child Crying mommyIam 3/15/11 1 Parenting
What is your "tolerance" for infant crying? ChilisWife 9/30/10 41 Parenting
crying grunting and general infant noise making mommyIam 5/6/10 1 Parenting
do/did u put your infant into sitting position or did you wait till they able to get into that position on there own. LoveBeingMrsT 10/20/09 7 Parenting
I can't wait for Greys anatomy! june262004 5/22/05 29 Families Helping Families ™