Im struggling...(Long sorry)

Posted By Message

hbugal
Lesigh

Member since 2/07

15928 total posts

Name:

Im struggling...(Long sorry)

I watch 2 of my daughters friends after school every day. The girls are in 5th grade so it's not really "sitting" more like responsible adulting...

The major issue is one of the girls. We'll call her "M".She doesnt have the ability to be friends with more than 1 girl at a time. Lots of mini fights etc..typical preteen BS...

Now, please understand, my daughters, are by no means angels...nor is the 3rd girl We'll call her "J". But I can honestly say that it's the one kid who is the bad egg.

A week and a half ago something happened at school that caused my daughter to not want "M" to come to the house any more. I heard the story from several other girls..all the same story..so I know my daughter was telling the truth. I asked if my daughter could "stick it out" for the 50 some odd days left of school and she said OK. (I really like the mom)

Last week there was obviously some tention. But both my daughter and "J" made it through OK. I guess "M" didnt like the under current b/c the week culminated in "M" telling "J" that my daughter didnt want to be her friend any more (totally untrue). I was standing 10 feet away and heard the whole conversation. (My daughters were at their dads and not even home) "J" just blew it off and said that she would have to speak to my daughter about it the following day.

"M" went home that night and told her mom that "J" threatened to beat her up and make her life miserable for no reason. (This didnt happen I was standing right there). The mom calls me the following day and we discuss the situation and I told her what happened etc. She said she would talk to her daughter.

Now that you've made it through all of that here is my struggle...My daughter and "J" are purposely ignoring "M" essentially doing to her what she has done to one or the other since school started. Im sitting here in my room and I know what they are doing. They are giving her a piece of her own medicine. It's a long story but this girl can never be wrong and they are essentially being like her too her. Well she isnt liking it one bit and, Im sure, go home and tell her mother some version other than the full truth...

What would you do? Would you let them be mean to the other girl or would you jump in?

Posted 4/19/10 5:37 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

mrsmcd
Olivia & Grace...my girls!

Member since 12/07

1705 total posts

Name:
Andrea

Re: Im struggling...(Long sorry)

UGH! I teach 5th grade and this is the time of year when the girls start all this DRAMA!

I patiently sit them down together for "girl talk" and tell them that if they have DRAMA now and problems with friends NOW, 6th grade's going to be VERY tough. I try to "scare" them into being friends. I tell them that they don't have to "like" each other but they have to "respect" each other while they are in my classroom. The majority of the time, it stops. Good luck!Chat Icon

Posted 4/19/10 5:41 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Im struggling...(Long sorry)

Well, are they being MEAN or just ignoring her (which I know is mean, but you know what I mean...)

What do you think? In your gut, do you think that they should be nice to her to "make nice" or no?

Posted 4/19/10 5:46 PM
 

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: Im struggling...(Long sorry)

While I would like to sit back and let her get a taste of her own medicine, I would go in and use the opportunity to talk to all 3 of them. Maybe this is a chance to point out to "M" that she treats people like this and it isn't very nice to be on the receiving end. At the same time, you can remind your dd and "J" how they felt when they were treated the way they are treating "M" and ask if they can think of a better way of being with each other.

I don't have much experience with this age group so my suggestion may be way out there.

Posted 4/19/10 5:48 PM
 

hbugal
Lesigh

Member since 2/07

15928 total posts

Name:

Re: Im struggling...(Long sorry)

Posted by KateDevine

Well, are they being MEAN or just ignoring her (which I know is mean, but you know what I mean...)

What do you think? In your gut, do you think that they should be nice to her to "make nice" or no?



That..there in...lies my dilema...I have tried so hard to like this child. So my gut tells me she needs to be given a taste of her own medicine. But I have not raised my kids to be mean to people. The mommy in me tells me to go out there and give them a good talking to. Give the 3 of them (my one daughter isnt really involved in any of this) my lecture on being kind to others and how we dont have to be everyones friend but that doesnt give us the right to be mean blah blah blah.. HOWEVER, my daughter, and "J" have been following my rules since September and nothing has changed. Maybe it's time I just let them handle things their way...KWIM?

See my struggle?

Posted 4/19/10 6:08 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Im struggling...(Long sorry)

Posted by hbugal

Posted by KateDevine

Well, are they being MEAN or just ignoring her (which I know is mean, but you know what I mean...)

What do you think? In your gut, do you think that they should be nice to her to "make nice" or no?



That..there in...lies my dilema...I have tried so hard to like this child. So my gut tells me she needs to be given a taste of her own medicine. But I have not raised my kids to be mean to people. The mommy in me tells me to go out there and give them a good talking to. Give the 3 of them (my one daughter isnt really involved in any of this) my lecture on being kind to others and how we dont have to be everyones friend but that doesnt give us the right to be mean blah blah blah.. HOWEVER, my daughter, and "J" have been following my rules since September and nothing has changed. Maybe it's time I just let them handle things their way...KWIM?

See my struggle?



I do...

I don't know, maybe this is the wrong answer (b/c I know nothing....) but maybe giving her a taste of her own medicine might not be the worst thing...

As long as you can handle the mother complaining (bc honestly, this girl is going to make a stink with her mother no matter what iMO) and they aren't being CRUEL then maybe just turn a deaf ear?

But what do I know?

Posted 4/19/10 6:12 PM
 

Kerie-is-so-very
versatile!

Member since 5/05

13535 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Im struggling...(Long sorry)

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by hbugal

Posted by KateDevine

Well, are they being MEAN or just ignoring her (which I know is mean, but you know what I mean...)

What do you think? In your gut, do you think that they should be nice to her to "make nice" or no?



That..there in...lies my dilema...I have tried so hard to like this child. So my gut tells me she needs to be given a taste of her own medicine. But I have not raised my kids to be mean to people. The mommy in me tells me to go out there and give them a good talking to. Give the 3 of them (my one daughter isnt really involved in any of this) my lecture on being kind to others and how we dont have to be everyones friend but that doesnt give us the right to be mean blah blah blah.. HOWEVER, my daughter, and "J" have been following my rules since September and nothing has changed. Maybe it's time I just let them handle things their way...KWIM?

See my struggle?



I do...

I don't know, maybe this is the wrong answer (b/c I know nothing....) but maybe giving her a taste of her own medicine might not be the worst thing...

As long as you can handle the mother complaining (bc honestly, this girl is going to make a stink with her mother no matter what iMO) and they aren't being CRUEL then maybe just turn a deaf ear?

But what do I know?



Think of it as letting them not accept treatment that they do not want to accept.

Posted 4/19/10 6:15 PM
 

hbugal
Lesigh

Member since 2/07

15928 total posts

Name:

Re: Im struggling...(Long sorry)

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by hbugal

Posted by KateDevine

Well, are they being MEAN or just ignoring her (which I know is mean, but you know what I mean...)

What do you think? In your gut, do you think that they should be nice to her to "make nice" or no?



That..there in...lies my dilema...I have tried so hard to like this child. So my gut tells me she needs to be given a taste of her own medicine. But I have not raised my kids to be mean to people. The mommy in me tells me to go out there and give them a good talking to. Give the 3 of them (my one daughter isnt really involved in any of this) my lecture on being kind to others and how we dont have to be everyones friend but that doesnt give us the right to be mean blah blah blah.. HOWEVER, my daughter, and "J" have been following my rules since September and nothing has changed. Maybe it's time I just let them handle things their way...KWIM?

See my struggle?



I do...

I don't know, maybe this is the wrong answer (b/c I know nothing....) but maybe giving her a taste of her own medicine might not be the worst thing...

As long as you can handle the mother complaining (bc honestly, this girl is going to make a stink with her mother no matter what iMO) and they aren't being CRUEL then maybe just turn a deaf ear?

But what do I know?



My DH, who is a Middle School teacher, says to let them handle it on their own at this point. But I question his judgement b/c he finds her really annoying....Chat Icon

Posted 4/19/10 6:23 PM
 

JandJ1224

Member since 6/06

5911 total posts

Name:
Jannette

Re: Im struggling...(Long sorry)

I would not let them be mean, I thiink I would try to teach my daughter to be nice to people even if they are not always nice to her. I think you need to step in because this is not just happening at school but at your house when you are responsible for these girls.

Posted 4/19/10 6:26 PM
 

LoriH
There's no place like home

Member since 8/07

4110 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Im struggling...(Long sorry)

I would step in and see it as an opportunity to talk to all of them.

Posted 4/19/10 6:31 PM
 

ChrisDee
My Girls

Member since 11/06

9543 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: Im struggling...(Long sorry)

Time for a pow wow with ALL of them together. Put it all out on the table in front of you as well.

Posted 4/19/10 6:50 PM
 

Stacey1403
Where it all began....

Member since 5/05

24065 total posts

Name:

Re: Im struggling...(Long sorry)

Is there a way you can talk to all three with their mothers?

Posted 4/19/10 7:30 PM
 

ChrisDee
My Girls

Member since 11/06

9543 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: Im struggling...(Long sorry)

I just want to share some insight as the mom of a 9 year old girl who struggles with the skill of getting along in groupsChat Icon She is a great kid. She is a very very Loyal kid. She is however VERY insecure, which leads to her struggling in a group of 3. She will always feel like odd man out, even when she isn't. She tends to think the other kids are being mean to her, when I KNOW they are not. It is all in her head. It is very hard on her and on me. She does not ever mean any harm and will beat herself up. Sometimes she just needs some extra reassurance from her friends. Just something to keep in mind.

Posted 4/19/10 7:37 PM
 

hbugal
Lesigh

Member since 2/07

15928 total posts

Name:

Re: Im struggling...(Long sorry)

Posted by ChrisDee

I just want to share some insight as the mom of a 9 year old girl who struggles with the skill of getting along in groupsChat Icon She is a great kid. She is a very very Loyal kid. She is however VERY insecure, which leads to her struggling in a group of 3. She will always feel like odd man out, even when she isn't. She tends to think the other kids are being mean to her, when I KNOW they are not. It is all in her head. It is very hard on her and on me. She does not ever mean any harm and will beat herself up. Sometimes she just needs some extra reassurance from her friends. Just something to keep in mind.



I totally hear what you are saying. 100%...I have always taught my girls to be nice to everyone. My eldest daughter is disabled so Im very sensitive to these types of situations.

We have had a ton of issues with this girl since almost day 1. There isnt room enough for me to get into all the things that have gone on. Both me and "J's" mom have told our children a million different ways to get along. (Our girls get a long fantastically of course they have tiffs but nothing like this)..

If I speak to mom she will definitely try to make matters better. I actually spoke to her last Friday and she acknowledged the fact that her daughter was lying.

It's just that at some point we have to allow our children to fight their own battles. At what point do we just take a step back and let them take care of things on their own? Sometimes I wonder if Ive done them a disservice by teaching them to be nice to everyone and not teaching them how to stick up for themselves...KWIM?

Hence the reason why I was struggling with my decision...

Posted 4/19/10 7:59 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: Im struggling...(Long sorry)

Posted by ChrisDee

Time for a pow wow with ALL of them together. Put it all out on the table in front of you as well.



Ditto!

Posted 4/19/10 8:09 PM
 

2girlsforme
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

3071 total posts

Name:
XXXXXXXXX

Re: Im struggling...(Long sorry)

As the mother of 7 and 12 year old daughters, I'm inclined to let them work it out themselves. It sounds like your daughter is just reacting to the other child's behavior. Is that really a bad thing?

I've come to believe that first and foremost my job is to teach my kids how to get along in the world. While ideally it would be wonderful if everyone was kind and considerate, this isn't the case and after seeing enough of these kids, I would want my kid to be able to respond in kind or as another poster put it chose not to take the behavior. Frankly, that is a valuable life lesson.

Posted 4/19/10 8:19 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Ive been struggling with posting this....Long sorry hbugal 10/17/08 34 Parenting
Opps...sorry tania Redhead 5/18/05 1 Families Helping Families ™
saying sorry Redhead 5/16/05 36 Families Helping Families ™
question.. sorry if TMI 04bride 5/15/05 1 TTC
Sorry - kinda TMI, but....discharge jcndd 5/14/05 11 Pregnancy
(sorry if wrong forum)some good printable toys r us coupons pschica 5/13/05 14 Families Helping Families ™