Illegal Alien Sues for having ICE called on him - Thoughts?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
Illegal Alien Sues for having ICE called on him - Thoughts? Alien Sues, Saying NYPD Called in Feds Message edited 2008-04-01 12:34:20.750000. |
|
Posted 4/1/08 11:42 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Illegal Alien Sues for having ICE called on him - Thoughts? Just from that amount of info, it sounds like the cops were wrong and didn't listen to the Mayor. I don't know if there is an over-riding law that makes it ok though. |
|
Posted 4/1/08 11:43 AM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal Alien Sues for having ICE called on him - Thoughts? but he is an UNLICENSED cab driver who got into an argument over another parking spot with another cabbie. That is why he was involved with the police. (I saw the story on TV). |
|
Posted 4/1/08 11:47 AM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal Alien Sues for having ICE called on him - Thoughts? There seems to be more to this story but from what's stated it would seem like the cop was not following the "rule" set forth by the mayor. |
|
Posted 4/1/08 11:49 AM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal Alien Sues for having ICE called on him - Thoughts? Based on your first post, I was going to agree with JenniferEver. Now that you elaborated, I don't think he has a caese. If he's breaking the law, then he loses amnesty from the police dept. |
|
Posted 4/1/08 11:50 AM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal Alien Sues for having ICE called on him - Thoughts? Posted by KPtoys but he is an UNLICENSED cab driver who got into an argument over another parking spot with another cabbie. That is why he was involved with the police. (I saw the story on TV). Didn't see this post... Did the cop know the cabbie was unlicensed? If not, I would still think the cop was still technically wrong. No? |
|
Posted 4/1/08 11:51 AM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal Alien Sues for having ICE called on him - Thoughts? Posted by KPtoys but he is an UNLICENSED cab driver who got into an argument over another parking spot with another cabbie. That is why he was involved with the police. (I saw the story on TV). Ok..for some reason when I read unlicensed I was just thinking it meant he was illegal. I glazed over it. I guess it depends. If he was having an altercation and police were involved and found out he had no license, I would consider that breaking the law. |
|
Posted 4/1/08 11:51 AM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal Alien Sues for having ICE called on him - Thoughts? I think that based on what's posted, the police have a right to get involved since he was operating a vehicle without a license and was transporting people. |
|
Posted 4/1/08 11:54 AM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal Alien Sues for having ICE called on him - Thoughts? well the key here is that the mayor says the cops won't alert ICE about those who "obey the law" Message edited 2008-04-01 11:58:37.090000. |
|
Posted 4/1/08 11:57 AM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal Alien Sues for having ICE called on him - Thoughts? Doesn't federal law supercede local laws or "promises"? |
|
Posted 4/1/08 11:57 AM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal Alien Sues for having ICE called on him - Thoughts? Posted by MrsPJB2007 well the key here is that the mayor says the cops won't alert ICE about those who "obey the law" if he is an unlicensed operator of a vehicle---he is breaking the law. therefore that voids the mayor's statement. But how did the cop find out he was unlicensed? I'm asking, was it dumb luck that this cabbie was unlicensed or did something happen where the cop found this out and then called ICE. KWIM? Which came first? If the cop found out he was unlicensed and then called ICE, I say he was within the mayor's rule. If her didn't know this before hand, then I say he was wrong. |
|
Posted 4/1/08 12:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal Alien Sues for having ICE called on him - Thoughts? Posted by Jennie0898 Posted by MrsPJB2007 well the key here is that the mayor says the cops won't alert ICE about those who "obey the law" if he is an unlicensed operator of a vehicle---he is breaking the law. therefore that voids the mayor's statement. But how did the cop find out he was unlicensed? I'm asking, was it dumb luck that this cabbie was unlicensed or did something happen where the cop found this out and then called ICE. KWIM? Which came first? If the cop found out he was unlicensed and then called ICE, I say he was within the mayor's rule. If her didn't know this before hand, then I say he was wrong. I agree. |
|
Posted 4/1/08 12:12 PM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal Alien Sues for having ICE called on him - Thoughts? Posted by KPtoys Illegal Alien Sues, Saying NYPD Called in Feds New York Sun, by JOSEPH GOLDSTEIN Mayor Bloomberg's pledge that the city won't alert immigration authorities to illegal aliens who otherwise obey the law. This is if you OBEY the law...if not, then of course they have the right to report you. Or at least they should! |
|
Posted 4/1/08 12:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal Alien Sues for having ICE called on him - Thoughts? Posted by MST9106 Posted by KPtoys Illegal Alien Sues, Saying NYPD Called in Feds New York Sun, by JOSEPH GOLDSTEIN Mayor Bloomberg's pledge that the city won't alert immigration authorities to illegal aliens who otherwise obey the law. This is if you OBEY the law...if not, then of course they have the right to report you. Or at least they should! I agree, but in this case I think there's more to the story... |
|
Posted 4/1/08 12:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal Alien Sues for having ICE called on him - Thoughts? Posted by Jennie0898 Posted by MST9106 Posted by KPtoys Illegal Alien Sues, Saying NYPD Called in Feds New York Sun, by JOSEPH GOLDSTEIN Mayor Bloomberg's pledge that the city won't alert immigration authorities to illegal aliens who otherwise obey the law. This is if you OBEY the law...if not, then of course they have the right to report you. Or at least they should! I agree, but in this case I think there's more to the story... Definitely...I mean the cab drives must have been caught breaking the law or something... |
|
Posted 4/1/08 12:19 PM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal Alien Sues for having ICE called on him - Thoughts? Posted by MST9106 Posted by Jennie0898 Posted by MST9106 Posted by KPtoys Illegal Alien Sues, Saying NYPD Called in Feds New York Sun, by JOSEPH GOLDSTEIN Mayor Bloomberg's pledge that the city won't alert immigration authorities to illegal aliens who otherwise obey the law. This is if you OBEY the law...if not, then of course they have the right to report you. Or at least they should! I agree, but in this case I think there's more to the story... Definitely...I mean the cab drives must have been caught breaking the law or something... That's what I'd like to know. If the cabbie broke the law, then by ALL MEANS he deserves whatever he gets. But if nothing happened and the cop just assumed he was illegal, then I don't think the cop was right. |
|
Posted 4/1/08 12:20 PM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal Alien Sues for having ICE called on him - Thoughts? Posted by Jennie0898 Posted by MrsPJB2007 well the key here is that the mayor says the cops won't alert ICE about those who "obey the law" if he is an unlicensed operator of a vehicle---he is breaking the law. therefore that voids the mayor's statement. But how did the cop find out he was unlicensed? I'm asking, was it dumb luck that this cabbie was unlicensed or did something happen where the cop found this out and then called ICE. KWIM? Which came first? If the cop found out he was unlicensed and then called ICE, I say he was within the mayor's rule. If her didn't know this before hand, then I say he was wrong. i would assume that maybe if there was some type of altercation and the cop asked for his license for identification purposes---and the cabbie didn't have any type of id....perhaps the cabbie admitted he didn't have a license or id? obviously there is so much more to this story than just the snippet that was posted. |
|
Posted 4/1/08 12:23 PM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal Alien Sues for having ICE called on him - Thoughts? Posted by MrsPJB2007 obviously there is so much more to this story than just the snippet that was posted. Yes, I agree. I don't think a fair opinion can be formed without having all the facts. Though I have to admit, I'm glad it came out he's unlicensed b/c it's scary to think there are cab drivers out there operating w/o a license!!
|
|
Posted 4/1/08 12:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal Alien Sues for having ICE called on him - Thoughts? I found the whole article |
|
Posted 4/1/08 12:39 PM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal Alien Sues for having ICE called on him - Thoughts? Well certainly from the article, it sounds to me like he fits the "trouble maker" description. He's had a few altercations, therefore I think the police were well within their rights to call ICE. |
|
Posted 4/1/08 12:43 PM
|
|
|
Re: Illegal Alien Sues for having ICE called on him - Thoughts? Posted by Jennie0898 Well certainly from the article, it sounds to me like he fits the "trouble maker" description. He's had a few altercations, therefore I think the police were well within their rights to call ICE. yeah i hate to say it---but that guy seemed like he was always into something and getting into it with people that the cops had to be called. not for nothing but i know he may not have "directly" been doing something at the time the cops tipped off ICE---but with his track record...i can see why they did it. |
|
Posted 4/1/08 12:53 PM
|
|










