Did you do gradual extinction or total?

Forum Opinion Poll
Gradual (time interval check-in) 7 25.00%
Total (don't go in at all) 21 75.00%
Other (please explain) 0 0.00%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

If you did CIO

Posted By Message

WishingforBaby
LIF Adult

Member since 10/09

1110 total posts

Name:

If you did CIO

Also, if you can elaborate...

1) How old was your DC when you did CIO?

2) How long did it take to be effective?

3) If you could've done something differently, what would you have done? Basically...any advice???

TIA!

ETA: Did you start with naps, bedtime or both at the same time?

Message edited 2011-10-04 09:42:48.283000.

Posted 10/3/11 8:58 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: If you did CIO

DD was 13 months, it took three nights and I just wish I had done it earlier and I could get back that month of sleep I lost walking back and forth trying to get her to sleep!

Did not go in at all.

Posted 10/3/11 9:00 PM
 

TheDivineMrsM
2 girls 4 me!

Member since 8/08

7878 total posts

Name:
Mama mama mama....

Re: If you did CIO

1) How old was your DC when you did CIO?

Almost 5 months, we used the Ferber Method (interval check-ins)

2) How long did it take to be effective?

Two nights.

3) If you could've done something differently, what would you have done? Basically...any advice???

Do what feels right for you and your family. People are going to try and push you in either direction... but YOU know your baby best.

Posted 10/3/11 9:17 PM
 

LadyBug1209
Mommy to FOUR little men!

Member since 8/08

9655 total posts

Name:

Re: If you did CIO

1) How old was your DC when you did CIO?

About 4.5mo.

2) How long did it take to be effective?

We used the Ferber Method as well.
He was STTN (11-12hours) by night 3.

3) If you could've done something differently, what would you have done? Basically...any advice???

Nothing! Full-blown CIO was not something that I felt comfortable doing. The Ferber Method worked for us bc it was less stressful for both of us!

Good Luck!! Chat Icon

Posted 10/4/11 7:35 AM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: If you did CIO

They were both 6 months.
It took 3 nights for both boys.
I do remember that my second son cried for 2.5 hours the first night. 1.5 hrs the second night. 5 minutes the third night.

Message edited 2011-10-04 07:39:05.197000.

Posted 10/4/11 7:38 AM
 

Torts
LIF Toddler

Member since 9/10

494 total posts

Name:
me

Re: If you did CIO

Luckily I did not have to do CIO until recently. DD is 22mos. We just moved her bedroom (along with ours and the nursery) upstairs in preparation for Chat Icon arrival. The transition was/is really hard on her.

I took 3-4 nights and since she is older I did not go in at all. DH caved once and I nearly killed him, so if you count that slip up, it was more like 6 days. We also did CIO for naps at the same time and thankfully it is working.

She went from 40mins of screaming/yelling/hyperventilating to now 5 minutes of light crying/whimpering.


Good luck!

ETA: also, I gave DD my husband's pillow to sleep with. I felt safe doing so since she's a toddler. I really think it helped to have something that 'smelled' safe and familiar. At night, I say "Do you want to go night-night with Daddy's pillow?" and that usually prepares her for bedtime and helps ease her anxiety.

Message edited 2011-10-04 08:24:31.363000.

Posted 10/4/11 8:22 AM
 

WishingforBaby
LIF Adult

Member since 10/09

1110 total posts

Name:

Re: If you did CIO

Bump to add edited question in original post.

Posted 10/4/11 9:43 AM
 

LoveyQ
Stalkers, get a life.

Member since 11/07

12820 total posts

Name:

Re: If you did CIO

1) How old was your DC when you did CIO?

He was exactly 6 months old.


2) How long did it take to be effective?

1 night. The second night he woke up and cried I think 5 minutes before going back to sleep on his own. Third night STTN. Fourth night woke up once and cried for about 5-10 minutes and went back to sleep. After that, he STTN without waking up.


3) If you could've done something differently, what would you have done? Basically...any advice???

I had a preemie (born 2 months premature) and I felt strongly with what the experts said that before 6 months we as parents should tend to them when they cry because they need something when they cry (food, diaper change, basic comfort, etc). My mother and many others told me I was spoiling him, that I'd regret it, that he would always want to be picked up when he cried, etc. I stuck to it because I figured the experts knew better
Chat Icon Maybe I just got lucky, but after we did CIO at 6 months (and to be honest, if he wasn't a preemie, I may have done it at 5 months), he wasn't spoiled at all. I think (and I could be wrong of course, but just what I think) that he had 6 full months of mommy and daddy being there when he needed us that he felt comforted and ok to not just cry to cry, or cry just to be held KWIM? I'm not sure if I'm making sense.

Point is, I'd do CIO at 6 months again. Trust me, I did NOT SLEEP for the first 3 months of his life. I took 30-60 minute catnaps once or twice a day. I was a zombie. Then from 3 months to 6 months, I slept in 2-3 hour segments with a 1-2 hour wake up attending to DS in between. It was HARD. And I'm still happy I didn't do it earlier or that I didn't wait longer. It was the right time.

ETA: we did bedtime first. Then about a week later we did naps. Naps were WAY harder! And took longer.

Message edited 2011-10-04 09:50:28.380000.

Posted 10/4/11 9:49 AM
 

JRsMaMa
LIF Adult

Member since 11/07

2044 total posts

Name:
Jake's Mama

Re: If you did CIO

5 months. I went in if he cried for more than 1/2 hr and it took 3 nights. Only the 2nd night did I have to go in. He is now almost fully awake when I put him in his crib at 10 months.

Posted 10/4/11 10:20 AM
 

jam11308

Member since 11/07

7273 total posts

Name:

Re: If you did CIO

1) How old was your DC when you did CIO?
13 months

2) How long did it take to be effective?
3 nights (we did the interval method)

3) If you could've done something differently, what would you have done? Basically...any advice???
I would have done it much, MUCH sooner!! 13m of no sleep was way too long Chat Icon

4) Did you start with naps, bedtime or both at the same time?
We just did bedtime at first. He had been a great napper up until that point, so when that changed we opted to do CIO. Once we got the nights in order, I realized that he had really just been dropping his 2nd nap which is why we were struggling so much. Once we dropped it we had to do CIO once or twice for his nap time before he was well adjusted to it.

Posted 10/4/11 10:50 AM
 

aliwnec10
mom of 3 boys

Member since 4/06

11426 total posts

Name:
Ali

Re: If you did CIO

started with naps at 6 months. The first day he cried for 40 minutes. 2nd day for 5 minutes.

night time (he was waking up 5 times a night) a week later. 1st night cried on and off for 2 hours. 2nd night nothing.

Would we change anything... yeah would have done it sooner. Chat Icon and also not go in everytime he cried (meaning even when he was younger, we should have let him stir a bit longer before going in).

*we did cio at night to reduce the wakings from 5 times a night to 1. He didn't start consistently STTN until 17 months. We did CIO many times, but every time he started STTN, he got sick and messed it all up.

Message edited 2011-10-04 18:56:41.727000.

Posted 10/4/11 6:53 PM
 

sunflowerjesss
Mommy to 3!

Member since 10/05

20369 total posts

Name:
Jesss, duh.

Re: If you did CIO

For DS we did it at 7.5 months. He coslept (in our bed) until then. We started at bedtime. We didn't go in at all. First night he cried about 45 minutes but STTN (first in his life). Second night he cried about 30 minutes. STTN. Third night he didn't cry at all and STTN.

Once we achieved success at night I did it for naps. It was less easier because he knew what was expected.

For the girls I did it at 4 months. The whined for about 20 minutes the first night. J STTN K woke up at 3am and I fed her. Then went back to sleep until 6:30. For about a month (4-5 months) they would whine/complain for about 5 minutes before going to sleep. K dropped that 3 am feeding herself about 3 weeks ago.

They still complain when we put them down (they will be 6 months tomorrow) but STTN. But it isn't for more than a minute or two.

ETA - I really don't think I'd change anything I did for CIO either time. I think the most important thing is consistency and routine. DS always had dinner, bath immediately following, nurse, bed. I think the routine/schedule really allowed an easy transition.

Message edited 2011-10-04 19:00:05.330000.

Posted 10/4/11 6:58 PM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: If you did CIO


1) How old was your DC when you did CIO?
6.5m

2) How long did it take to be effective?
night 1: 15m
night 2: ~10m
night 3: less than 5 min
When we have to redo it, it takes about 10 min.

3) If you could've done something differently, what would you have done? Basically...any advice???

I really believe we had a much easier time with CIO than expected, because we sleep trained early. Is like he had all the pieces of the puzzle, except something new was bothering him.

At 3m, we sleep trained using this method: pick up put down method

eta: I'm a nazi when it comes to routine, I sincerely believe its makes a huge difference for DS.

Message edited 2011-10-04 20:33:55.020000.

Posted 10/4/11 8:31 PM
 

WishingforBaby
LIF Adult

Member since 10/09

1110 total posts

Name:

Re: If you did CIO

DS is almost 4 and a half months and I plan on doing this next week. The reason I want to do CIO is because he relies too heavily on me/pacifier to fall asleep. Sometimes he will be crying for a few minutes, I'll go in and put the pacifier in and he turns his head and falls asleep immediately. Other times, I have to pick him up and rock him for a short time (less than a minute) and he's out. He is a cat napper and sometimes it takes longer for me to get him down and make sure he's out than the amount of time he actually sleeps! Chat Icon

Posted 10/4/11 9:11 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Terrible two's and getting abused by my daughter...AND I MADE HER CIO FOR THE FIRST TIME-EVER! aliasPook 2/24/07 7 Parenting
I give you CIO moms a lot of credit! CookiePuss 2/12/07 5 Parenting
So, Ava is currently CIO in her crib and.... BaroqueMama 12/26/06 6 Parenting
CIO Ladies, I have a few quick questions...not so much a long post, more a rambling post yankinmanc 7/22/06 7 Parenting
has anyone been successsful with CIO after age one? antoinette 7/15/06 4 Parenting
CIO...30 minutes of Screaming! But Now What do i do???? dree 3/1/06 13 Parenting