I really need help from teachers on these boards!

Posted By Message

WhatNow
Say Cheese!

Member since 1/06

8033 total posts

Name:
A (formerly WhatNow?)

I really need help from teachers on these boards!

Question for teachers on this board, specifically upper elementary teachers: what would be your strategy for a situation described below?
One of your students consistently doesn't produce work during writing periods in your classroom. A topic is given, plenty of books are made available for research on the said topic. Student in question is bright and well read. However, he continues to either read up on the topic without ever moving on to the writing, sits and stares at the blank sheet of paper, deep in his own thoughts, or writes a maximum of 1 or 2 sentences in the 45 to 60 minute period allotted for the writing activity, while the rest of the students fill up to 5 pages. This is not a single incident, it has been happening continuously for months.
What is your course of action?

Posted 2/11/15 11:54 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Meme729
LIF Adolescent

Member since 2/11

547 total posts

Name:
M

Re: I really need help from teachers on these boards!

Try setting short term goals for him. Put an x 5 lines down on the paper. His goal for that day is to write at least 5 lines. The next day, make it 6 and so on. Give him a certain amount of time to research the topic and then he must start writing. You could even try a timer.

Posted 2/11/15 12:26 PM
 

Meme729
LIF Adolescent

Member since 2/11

547 total posts

Name:
M

Re: I really need help from teachers on these boards!

Also, try speaking to him about it. Ask him why he is having difficulty and what you can do to help.

Posted 2/11/15 12:27 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: I really need help from teachers on these boards!

Not a teacher here but I have a son that is very similar to what you've described. It was the idea of committing the information to paper.

When he has an assignment to do, it was easier for him to dictate what he wanted to say & for me to write it down EXACTLY as he said. Then he edited it.

I don't know how to combat it other than using the computer helped him because he knew he could edit it.

Posted 2/11/15 12:40 PM
 

WhatNow
Say Cheese!

Member since 1/06

8033 total posts

Name:
A (formerly WhatNow?)

Re: I really need help from teachers on these boards!

Thank you, Meme729 and Nrthshgrl! I really appreciate the feedback!

It was the idea of committing the information to paper.



Exactly! Same issue here! He will tell you a beautiful story and will speak none stop for a really long time. He is so eloquent that completel strangers in public places ask me how old he is because they can't believe that a little boy would speak like that! But when the time comes to put it down on paper.... it's like someone hits a break pedal in his head! Chat Icon

ADD has been mentioned, but I think that's just something that is very fashionable to throw out there these days...

I have already tried some of the tricks you guys mentioned, but I will keep on pushing and hopefully things will get better!

We did get a writing tutor and she seems to be helping... But things are still tough in the classroom.

Posted 2/11/15 12:56 PM
 

AllyMally
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/13

881 total posts

Name:
Alyson

I really need help from teachers on these boards!

Not a teacher but I had this problem in school. It took a long time and very proactive english teachers and tutors to fix it. I knew what I wanted to say and could say it but to put it on paper was to hard. I couldn't write fast enough and when I did I would make mistakes and get confused with my thoughts or my spelling would suffer. It was very frustrating. It took time and a lot of help.

Posted 2/11/15 1:06 PM
 

LIMomma
LIF Adolescent

Member since 6/12

523 total posts

Name:
Momma

I really need help from teachers on these boards!

Not a teacher but my DD was like this when she was younger. She was tested in the top 1% in the nation for reading comprehension and is in the gifted program in the school and a couple programs outside of school. I could not get her to the writing peice for anything - nothing the teachers did to encourage her (and boy did they try) worked. What helped us was her gifted teacher - She told us and my DD, that she should write what she was thinking and we could organize it into the report after. (she said there was too much going on her her head which was good because she was interested but she told her it was "getting stuck" -- just let it all out -- doesn't matter if it makes sense just get it down on paper). IT WORKED!! I owe that teacher my sanity. As DD got older she changed to taking notes on sticky's as she read, she then organizes them into how she wants to "tell the story" and then she writes (well now types) it all out. She still to this day HATES with a passion, writing assignments. - but gets them done.

Message edited 2015-02-11 13:19:13.667000.

Posted 2/11/15 1:13 PM
 

WhatNow
Say Cheese!

Member since 1/06

8033 total posts

Name:
A (formerly WhatNow?)

Re: I really need help from teachers on these boards!

Posted by LIMomma

Not a teacher but my DD was like this when she was younger. She was tested in the top 1% in the nation for reading comprehension and is in the gifted program in the school and a couple programs outside of school. I could not get her to the writing peice for anything - nothing the teachers did to encourage her (and boy did they try) worked. What helped us was her gifted teacher - She told us and my DD to write was she was thinking and we could organize it into the report after. (she said there was too much going on her her head which was good because she was interested but she told her it was "getting stuck" -- just let it all out -- doesn't matter if it makes sense just get it down on paper). IT WORKED!! I owe that teacher my sanity. As DD got older she changed to taking notes on sticky's as she read, she then organizes them into how she wants to "tell the story" and then she writes (well now types) it all out. She still to this day HATES with a passion, writing
assignments. - but gets them done.



Same with my son: G &T class, always read several levels above his grade, reads all the time. Writing is a no go!

I will try the method you described! Thank you so much for taking the time to answer!!

Posted 2/11/15 1:17 PM
 

WhatNow
Say Cheese!

Member since 1/06

8033 total posts

Name:
A (formerly WhatNow?)

Re: I really need help from teachers on these boards!

Posted by AllyMally

Not a teacher but I had this problem in school. It took a long time and very proactive english teachers and tutors to fix it. I knew what I wanted to say and could say it but to put it on paper was to hard. I couldn't write fast enough and when I did I would make mistakes and get confused with my thoughts or my spelling would suffer. It was very frustrating. It took time and a lot of help.



Thank you so much for sharing your story! I really appreciate it!

So there point is, it can be helped and that's so good to hear right now!Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/11/15 1:18 PM
 

MrsT809
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

12167 total posts

Name:

I really need help from teachers on these boards!

It's totally understandable to feel like he has too much to say to get it on paper effectively. I would encourage him to spend no more than maybe 10 minutes researching and then jot down a few main ideas he wants to discuss. Not complete sentences or anything, just enough to remember his main points. Then start elaborating from those ideas into longer, complete paragraphs. Sounds like something he can probably handle if he is advanced and it may help him feel less overwhelmed by everything he wants to say.

Posted 2/11/15 1:25 PM
 

kgs11
LIF Adult

Member since 2/07

1424 total posts

Name:
Kim

Re: I really need help from teachers on these boards!

Honestly I would let them type, or publish in another tech app or program as incentive after they successfully (and I am timely manner)'filled in a graphic organizer

Posted 2/11/15 5:46 PM
 

MissJones
I need a nap!

Member since 5/05

22153 total posts

Name:

I really need help from teachers on these boards!

For some kids, it's just so hard to start. Their minds move faster than their hands.

I always have my kids start with a graphic organizer and I tell them just write the 'spark words'. Those are just the reminder words that when you go back and are going to draft, the thoughts come back to you because they spark your memory. Even my most stubborn writers write better starting with an organizer.

But I have also had a kid use a tape recorder to record the paper and then go back and re-write.

Also, some kids need a visual timer to see how much time is left. There is a great battery operated timer that shows the time left in red. There is also an online timer that does the same.

Message edited 2015-02-11 17:52:50.010000.

Posted 2/11/15 5:51 PM
 

tourist

Member since 5/05

10425 total posts

Name:

Re: I really need help from teachers on these boards!

Not a teacher, but I have this problem myself. I can't write one sentence at a time.
I have to "write" the whole thing in my head first to make sure it is in the correct order.

Computers to make it easier b/c I blurt things out & rearrange & make it sound pretty later.

Can he be allowed to write on index cards?

That was actually the suggested method when I was in college & it made things much easier to start that way. I always liked it better than the outline method, or at least I needed cards first, and then could create an outline from that.
I know these are for larger scale projects but the cards or post- its as someone else stated, can help get the ideas out.

Posted 2/11/15 7:23 PM
 

MsSissy
xoxoxo

Member since 3/07

39159 total posts

Name:

Re: I really need help from teachers on these boards!

Posted by MissJones
But I have also had a kid use a tape recorder to record the paper and then go back and re-write.



This is what I was going to suggest. That way he gets it all out and can go back and write at his own pace.

Posted 2/11/15 7:42 PM
 

cets1290
LIF Adult

Member since 6/14

1051 total posts

Name:

I really need help from teachers on these boards!

I'm middle school, but I have very bright students in my math class who are just like this. I coteach, so I am able to take these students out of the room to do the task in a quieter location, and this almost always is the solution. If you have a big class, it could be the distractibility that causes an issue.

If that doesn't fix the problem, I would try sitting with the student during the writing activity and keeping him/her on task. Maybe they just have trouble jotting their thoughts onto paper in an organized way, and need more one-on-one direction to figure it out.

If that doesn't work, call the parents. Maybe there is similar behavior at home, and the parents can shed a little light on the situation. I've had many parents who knew exactly what I was talking about, and had a suggestion for what to do!

Posted 2/11/15 8:17 PM
 

evrythng4areason
And then there were 4

Member since 1/10

5224 total posts

Name:
Kayla

Re: I really need help from teachers on these boards!

Posted by MsSissy

Posted by MissJones
But I have also had a kid use a tape recorder to record the paper and then go back and re-write.



This is what I was going to suggest. That way he gets it all out and can go back and write at his own pace.



This is one of the tools I use

Posted 2/11/15 8:25 PM
 

MissJones
I need a nap!

Member since 5/05

22153 total posts

Name:

Re: I really need help from teachers on these boards!

Posted by evrythng4areason

Posted by MsSissy

Posted by MissJones
But I have also had a kid use a tape recorder to record the paper and then go back and re-write.



This is what I was going to suggest. That way he gets it all out and can go back and write at his own pace.



This is one of the tools I use




Just saw this app on pinterest:

http://appshopper.com/utilities/easy-record

Posted 2/13/15 6:05 AM
 

jend572
LIF Infant

Member since 8/09

125 total posts

Name:

I really need help from teachers on these boards!

I'd work with him one on one to try to find out exactly what's holding him back. Is it the physical act of writing? A need for perfection? Lack of focus? Then set super specif goals. Walk away and come back to check in. Big praise for meeting goal.

If it's research he needs to collect, provide him with a graphic organizer with prompts for the exact

Posted 2/21/15 12:50 AM
 

jend572
LIF Infant

Member since 8/09

125 total posts

Name:

I really need help from teachers on these boards!

I'd be interested to see how he works with a partner -especially when the topic is student driven.

Posted 2/21/15 12:54 AM
 

DaisyGirl
LIF Adult

Member since 2/08

1650 total posts

Name:

Re: I really need help from teachers on these boards!

I would talk to him and try to find out what the problem is.
Give him graphic organizers to help plan his writing before he starts. It's often easier for kids to get their ideas down on a graphic organizer and then start writing. This is especially helpful if the issue is that he has too many ideas in his head.
Give him short term goals and tell him not to worry about spelling or grammar. He should just try to get his ideas down on paper. Once he's done, he can go back and check for errors.
Good luck! Writing can be overwhelming for many kids because it involves using multiple skills simultaneously- generating ideas, spelling, grammar, handwriting and so on. The trick is to try to remove some of those stressors.

Posted 2/21/15 10:51 AM
 

pharmcat2000
Mom of 2 + 1

Member since 10/05

7395 total posts

Name:
Catherine

Re: I really need help from teachers on these boards!

My dtr is the same way. She is bright, and can come up with great ideas and stories, but when faced with the pressure of writing for an assignment, she shuts down. She does have ADD, so I don't know if that is part of it, but even with homework, when I know she is paying attention, she just shuts down when I ask her to put thought to paper.

Posted 2/21/15 3:20 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
teachers/bullitan boards AnthonysWife 9/11/06 3 Families Helping Families ™
Question for teachers MamaNDaddyof3 5/17/05 9 Families Helping Families ™
For the teachers ... Miro127 5/13/05 1 Families Helping Families ™
no offense to any school teachers BUT TAD 5/13/05 28 Families Helping Families ™
City Teachers TAD 5/12/05 5 Families Helping Families ™
Teachers- Am I the only one... MrsProfessor 5/10/05 7 Families Helping Families ™