I need to vent (long RE: EI)

Posted By Message

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

I need to vent (long RE: EI)

My son has been receiving EI for speech and PT since about 14 months old (he is 20 months now). PT has gone very well, he is all caught up and being phased out.

With speech, he has made little to no progress, he has the same 3 words he had when we started. Our therapist is chronically late (one time she was an hour late!), she never calls when she is late and our sessions end up being 30 minutes because of her tardiness. She doesn't do much during the session, just repeats consonants (b-b-bubble, etc.) . I really feel like there should be more going on.

She has been telling me all along that she thinks DS has sensory issues because he giggles or pulls back when she touches his face and because he doesn't like ice cream or freeze pops. NO ONE else sees this, the PT has been testing him because of the ST concerns and sees nothing and our PED sees nothing. They feel he is ticklish and just doesn't like ice cream or freeze pops.

Today we were going over DSs progress because his 6 month meeting is next week and I mention that I feel he needs a different approach because we aren't seeing any progress. She wants to up him to 3 days a week from 2 - which I am OK with, but had she come on time and done full sessions that would be the equivalent of 3 days with her!

She then starts telling me she thinks DS may be on the Spectrum and we should go to a Developmental PED. Her reasons:
1. DS spends too much time on one task, doing the same thing repeatedly (like building with blocks)he doesn't get bored and move on as quickly as he should for his age.
2. He is interested in the details of his toys (he likes to figure out how things work)
3. If she tries to get him to change activities and he doesn't want to he'll either ignore her or take his toy and walk away.

My DSS is PDD-NOS and DSs "characteristics" are nothing like DSS. DSS with do things over and over again, for example he will make identical paper airplanes until he runs out of paper, he never plays with the planes just makes them. DS just seems to have a good attention span.

I was really upset after our meeting because I feel like she just has this checklist of signs to look for and 1. doesn't really understand them and 2. feels like there HAS to be something. In my gut I don't feel like anything is wrong with DS, he is just delayed verbally. He is social, playful and receptive, but then I worry maybe I am just in denial because I am his Mom and don't want anything to be "wrong".

I called our PED to get her opinion, and she basically said the therapist is crazy, that DS will talk at 2.5 (which apparently isn't uncommon for boys), she said he is very bright, he has a stubborn streak and is mechanical by nature. He isn't interested in speaking yet because he is observing and figuring things out. She said to find a new therapist if we want but she doesn't really think DS needs the therapy we just need to be patient.

We are going to find a new therapist, because I don't think it will hurt, but I am just so frustrated from the conversation this morning.

If you got this far, thank you, I really needed to vent.

Does anyone else have a young toddler in Speech? What kinds of activities does your therapist do? and are they constantly looking for a "reason" for the delay?

Thanks!

Posted 8/25/10 3:58 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Little-J-Mommy
I'm a Big Brother

Member since 5/06

8041 total posts

Name:
D

Re: I need to vent (long RE: EI)

I don't have answers to all your questions but get a new ST now!! her attendance issues alone warrant it. call your service coordinator and get this switched asap. there are a ton of people out there...no need to stick with someone ineffectiveChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 8/25/10 4:09 PM
 

carolyns4cupcakes
C ♥'s F

Member since 2/07

6456 total posts

Name:

Re: I need to vent (long RE: EI)

Sorry no advice other than get a new therapist. Her attendance and tardiness doesn't make her very credible IMO.

good luck to you!

Posted 8/25/10 4:11 PM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: I need to vent (long RE: EI)

My DS started speech and PT at around 16-17 months. We had a similar experience, that we saw improvements with PT almost immediately, but it took much longer with speech.

We had our first speech therapist for 6 months. I decided at our 6 month meeting that we would replace her. My DH wanted to do it sooner, and I was on the fence. She was professional and my issue wasn't about the amount of time she was spending, but I did have concerns that perhaps she was not the right fit for our situation.

My county service provider said it was no problem to change and that if we had doubts, that she would find someone else for us. We started with someone new and I am serious when I say I learned more about DS's speech, delays, muscle tone in his face, and other things in the first session of speech with the 2nd therapist than I did in 6 months with the first one.

I guess my point is that the speech will take longer in coming, but that if you have doubts about the therapist (and given what you have said here, I would too), request that they find someone else for your DS.

Personally, I love my peds, but I don't think they see enough of my DS to determine what his delays are. They definitely noticed the speech, but it was his PT who recommended we get a special ed eval after she noticed other issues. If you are concerned at all about PDD-NOS, you can request a special ed eval and find out if he qualifies for services other than what he is getting now.
Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-08-25 16:13:12.197000.

Posted 8/25/10 4:12 PM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: I need to vent (long RE: EI)

Thank you Chat Icon We are getting a new therapist. I told the therapist today and she started to cry. I felt awful because I know she genuinely cares about DS, but I just don't think they are a good fit.

Right now I'm not concerned about PDD-NOS. I honestly think DS is fine, the difference between him and DSS is night and day. I am just frustrated that the ST feels there has to be a reason for his delay and it started to make me question myself and wonder if I am in denial. None of the other therapists we have had, have felt that DS has any other issues though, so I go back to feeling like the ST just needs to find a reason.

Thanks everyone for the thoughts ans hugs, I think I am just really frustrated and feel like we have wasted 6 months.

Chat Icon

Posted 8/25/10 4:18 PM
 

BMonster
:)

Member since 2/06

2959 total posts

Name:
Denise

Re: I need to vent (long RE: EI)

I'm so sorry about your experience with this STChat Icon Have you spoken to her about her lateness or shortened sessions? We lucked out with our ST, but we did have another therapist we didn't like, so we called our service coordinator & switched (she "broke up" with her for us). Don't feel bad about it. You need someone who will help your DS and also give you full sessions. After 6 months with no progress, looks like it's time to move on.

Our ST has done so many different things with DS (to see what would work) and for someone who wasn't "supposed to" do much, he's doing so much now. I'd recommend our ST, but I believe she has a full schedule at this point.

GL!Chat Icon

Posted 8/25/10 4:22 PM
 

organichic
LIF Adult

Member since 9/08

2223 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: I need to vent (long RE: EI)

I dont have much advice, but wanted to offer Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 8/25/10 4:23 PM
 

Bridex100
Two Under Two Mommy

Member since 3/08

10420 total posts

Name:
Momx100

Re: I need to vent (long RE: EI)

Sorry, no advice but to get a new speech therapist. She sounds unprofessional being constantly tardy. I can't stand unpunctual people!

Posted 8/25/10 4:28 PM
 

MrsNicolaxoxo
<3

Member since 6/09

3403 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: I need to vent (long RE: EI)

I don't have experience with speech but I think your therapist is completely out of line to say that your son is on the spectrum based on the things you described. Also, mommy's instincts are usually dead on. IF I were you I would def get another therapist and try not to let today's meeting get the best of you. You DC sounds like a typical little boy that wants to do what he wants to do when he wants to do it! I'm have a feeling that he will catch upin no timeChat Icon Chat Icon It also sounds to me like you will have a Mr. "fix" LOL

I also have to add that it sounds to me like she is trying to blame your sons lack of progress on her sucky therapy..her fault not his! Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-08-25 16:50:45.313000.

Posted 8/25/10 4:49 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: I need to vent (long RE: EI)

My son has been receiving speech services since he was 19 months old.
I have a few things to say:

1. Get rid of the therapist ASAP. My son had a therapist for 8 mnths. He learned NOTHING from her. Nada. I felt bad. I thought it was him. I thought he was stubborn. I asked her to try a different approach. I asked her to bring new toys. Nothing changed. We got a new therapist and he flourished (could be bc of his age, but I know for sure the old therapist was not helping at all)

2. I do think that 20 mnths is still young to see a ton of progress in a young boy. It's so hard, but be patient - the words will come.

As for her diagnosis, it sounds to me like she is making excuses as to why he's not learning as much bc she doesn't want it to fall on her.

FM me with any questions at allChat Icon

Posted 8/25/10 5:03 PM
 

lvdolphins
My Loves!

Member since 5/05

46292 total posts

Name:

Re: I need to vent (long RE: EI)

Oh Dear, sounds like you are explaining my DS' first therapist!
We changed because DS started school.
His school therapist was good, but, when it got changed again to another school therapist (schedule conflicts) theres even MORE of a change.
SO happy with the one we have now.
Our first one, was a very nice lady, but, I felt nothing got done.

Call your coordinator and ask about a change!

Posted 8/25/10 5:11 PM
 

Jacksmommy
My love muffin!

Member since 1/07

5819 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: I need to vent (long RE: EI)

Posted by NinaLemon

My son has been receiving EI for speech and PT since about 14 months old (he is 20 months now). PT has gone very well, he is all caught up and being phased out.

With speech, he has made little to no progress, he has the same 3 words he had when we started. Our therapist is chronically late (one time she was an hour late!), she never calls when she is late and our sessions end up being 30 minutes because of her tardiness. She doesn't do much during the session, just repeats consonants (b-b-bubble, etc.) . I really feel like there should be more going on.

She has been telling me all along that she thinks DS has sensory issues because he giggles or pulls back when she touches his face and because he doesn't like ice cream or freeze pops. NO ONE else sees this, the PT has been testing him because of the ST concerns and sees nothing and our PED sees nothing. They feel he is ticklish and just doesn't like ice cream or freeze pops.

Today we were going over DSs progress because his 6 month meeting is next week and I mention that I feel he needs a different approach because we aren't seeing any progress. She wants to up him to 3 days a week from 2 - which I am OK with, but had she come on time and done full sessions that would be the equivalent of 3 days with her!

She then starts telling me she thinks DS may be on the Spectrum and we should go to a Developmental PED. Her reasons:
1. DS spends too much time on one task, doing the same thing repeatedly (like building with blocks)he doesn't get bored and move on as quickly as he should for his age.
2. He is interested in the details of his toys (he likes to figure out how things work)
3. If she tries to get him to change activities and he doesn't want to he'll either ignore her or take his toy and walk away.

My DSS is PDD-NOS and DSs "characteristics" are nothing like DSS. DSS with do things over and over again, for example he will make identical paper airplanes until he runs out of paper, he never plays with the planes just makes them. DS just seems to have a good attention span.

I was really upset after our meeting because I feel like she just has this checklist of signs to look for and 1. doesn't really understand them and 2. feels like there HAS to be something. In my gut I don't feel like anything is wrong with DS, he is just delayed verbally. He is social, playful and receptive, but then I worry maybe I am just in denial because I am his Mom and don't want anything to be "wrong".

I called our PED to get her opinion, and she basically said the therapist is crazy, that DS will talk at 2.5 (which apparently isn't uncommon for boys), she said he is very bright, he has a stubborn streak and is mechanical by nature. He isn't interested in speaking yet because he is observing and figuring things out. She said to find a new therapist if we want but she doesn't really think DS needs the therapy we just need to be patient.

We are going to find a new therapist, because I don't think it will hurt, but I am just so frustrated from the conversation this morning.

If you got this far, thank you, I really needed to vent.

Does anyone else have a young toddler in Speech? What kinds of activities does your therapist do? and are they constantly looking for a "reason" for the delay?

Thanks!



I am an EI teacher (Special Instruction) and am seriously concerned with your speech therapist. Under NO circumstances should any therapist suggest that your child has PDD-NOS. if she has concerns, she should have recommended a psychological evaluation because of xy and z concerns. She should NEVER suggest that he has ANY type of disability. . . That is not her job. I have been working with children with autism for many years and can usually point out who has autism and who does not . . . but I NEVER say it to a parent. I am not a psychologist. Also . . . if your therapist is not providing her scheduled sessions . . . you do not have to sign the papers. If she is billing for an hour but only sees your child for 1/2 an hour that is technically fraud.

Posted 8/25/10 6:21 PM
 

Jackie24
~We Did it~

Member since 7/06

6718 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: I need to vent (long RE: EI)

Sorry to crash.....EI therapist here.

Under no circumstances should your ST being suggesting that your child

is on the spectrum. The only person who can diagnose this is a Developmental neurologist or a psychologist. So even if this was the case she is way out of line.

Personally it sounds like she is not a good match for your DS and you should find a new therapist. Try not to get down!

You live upstate right? FM me I may be able to make a recc.

Posted 8/25/10 6:31 PM
 

A3CM
Avatar Title

Member since 9/08

3762 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: I need to vent (long RE: EI)

DS started ST at 15 months old and he is now 3 and i would say at about 2 1/2 his speech just TOOK off.

get a new ST right away, her suggesting he is on the spectrum is unethical and she is not trained to diagnose.

her tardiness should be noted and you should not sign her sheets if she leaves early.

as a mother with a child on the spectrum, and i say this in the kindest way.. but pediatricians are idiots.

most pediatricians will always never see a problem.

i had concerns when AJ was 6 months old and finally at 14-15 months i put my foot down and took it into my own hands, but his ped is fantastic.

every child is different when it comes to being on the spectrum bc it is sooo broad.

it wouldnt hurt to have him seen by a psychologist (at least that is how i see it)

good luck and get a new ST

Posted 8/25/10 6:40 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: I need to vent (long RE: EI)

Call your EI coordinator and get a new therapist ASAP. You should have done it a long time ago.

If a child does not clique with the therapist they will not progress. She sounds like a flake in general and can't imagine she is doing a good job with him.

I bet if you get a new therapist, one that is on time and devotes the time correctly with your DS you will see results right away.

As for the autism stuff...she's not an expert. It's not her call. He's a boy. My DS liked to evaluated his toys and he was evaluated for autism and is not on the spectrum. Honestly after she brought all this up which is NOT in her area of expertise I would have asked her to leave and not come back.

Posted 8/25/10 7:44 PM
 

adeline27
LIF Adult

Member since 5/06

3121 total posts

Name:
Angela

Re: I need to vent (long RE: EI)

Sorry you had to go through all that but you did the right thing and acted quickly on it. It's all about your DC best interest no one else's feelings. I feel so bad when I come on here and read how people got some very unhelpful therapists. You think all that time that was wasted. You know in your gut when its right and when it's wrong. For anyone to even diagnose a child should only be a doctor. Your little guy is so young too, he will get there with the right people Chat Icon I know about EI went through it with older son so I know how you're feeling.

Posted 8/25/10 8:00 PM
 

adeline27
LIF Adult

Member since 5/06

3121 total posts

Name:
Angela

Re: I need to vent (long RE: EI)

Posted by adeline27

Sorry you had to go through all that but you did the right thing and acted quickly on it. It's all about your DC best interest no one else's feelings. I feel so bad when I come on here and read how people got some very unhelpful therapists. You think all that time that was wasted. You know in your gut when its right and when it's wrong. For anyone to even diagnose a child should only be a doctor. Your little guy is so young too, he will get there with the right people Chat Icon I know about EI went through it with older son so I know how you're feeling.



ALso just so you know if you feel weird about the agency and not get a good feel on the new therapist go with a different agency. Your schoold district can recommend a great one too.

Posted 8/25/10 8:01 PM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: I need to vent (long RE: EI)

Thank you everyone for sharing your experiences. It is very helpful, I have been struggling with for a few months now wondering if I was expecting too much. I knew to expect quicker gains in PT than speech, but I also expected to see SOMETHING in speech.

Knowing my son, I just don't see him being on the spectrum and I don't want to venture down until I feel there is a reason. We have been to soooo many specialists with my DSS and each Dr. has a different diagnosis. I know this isn't a black and white syndrome, but with DSS (who has had very obvious "symptoms" since infancy) the diagnosis have varied from delayed to mentally retarded to PDD-NOS, I just feel that sometimes specialist are looking for a diagnosis when there may be nothing at all.

We have decided to give it 6 more months (with a new therapist) and if the new therapist sees reason to have him evaluated by a developmental PED then we will go from there.

Thank you again for sharing your experiences they have helped me to feel more secure in my feeling that this just wasn't a good fit and that DS is still young so we need some patience.Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 8/25/10 8:04 PM
 

MDF
.

Member since 5/05

2313 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: I need to vent (long RE: EI)

I agree with calling your service coordinator. I believe that at the 6 month mark you can also request another speech eval. I had concerns with my ds. His teachers where great but he wasn't progressing. In our case we saw some other issues. They re evaluated him and added a phych eval.
If you have any other questions feel free to fm me.

Posted 8/25/10 8:08 PM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: I need to vent (long RE: EI)

I would drop this therapist, if for no other reason because of her chronic tardiness and lack of phone calls. Plus she doesn't make up the time! DS had ST for 9 months, and I think his therapist had to come late a couple times, but she always called in advance (usually she had something she had to do with her own kids) and she never cut us short on time--if we couldn't hold a later session, she made it up another day. It also sounds as if she isn't working well with DC. Do they play when she comes over? Ours brought different games and toys, they varied quite a bit. They would play and while playing she used words with him, and encouraged him to speak himself, or sign for things he wanted.

We started at 21 months. DS really started to pick up lots of words around 26 months, though he did pick up a few before that. But at 26 months his speech really started to explode, and not long after that he started to put sentences together.

Call and ask for a new therapist, and if you are concerned about PDD, ask for another evaluation. But it sounds as if the therapist spoke out of turn.

Posted 8/25/10 8:24 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: I need to vent (long RE: EI)

you seriously just described my boy.

speech from 24 mos 36 mos
very slow to talk. just did not want to. they never got him to say anything new.

turns out, he just picks and chooses situations where he wants to speak and who he wants to speak to.

1. he literally can spend 3 hours straight upstairs in his "train" room setting up tracks, trucks, building legos around it. I tell people this and they think i am nutty. I put his cd player in there, he listens to his music and builds. by himself.

2. if i leave a screwdriver in my junk drawer, something will be taken apart that day. before he turned 3, we had gone from our remotes, to universal ones...atleast 2. takes them apart. I was once in a coffee shop with my moms group...my little nugget unscrewed the door hinges! a screw was loose and he sat there and took it apart.

3. ignored and walked away. if he wanted something to drink, i was told to tell him milk or juice? making him actually say it. he did not want to say it...never a tantrum...just ignore me and walk away.

8 mos later, he is so well rounded, polite, nice...I can't even tell you the wonderful brother he is. so gentle and attentive.
i took a break from alphabet and sounds...he was driving me crazy. we picked up math books at the dollar store. he caught onto math so quickly!! i guess adding and subtracting make so much more sense to him then the sound of the letter k.

Posted 8/25/10 8:46 PM
 

twinkletoes807
Mommy's Girls! &hearts;

Member since 11/07

10116 total posts

Name:
Gabi

Re: I need to vent (long RE: EI)

Nina, I am so pisssed off for you right now! Chat Icon Chat Icon Tardiness once, maybe twice over 6 months is barely acceptable but chronically late? No effing way! To be honest, I would not really take her opinion to be authoritative considering the fact that she continues to repeat consonants which apparently is not helping Wilson! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon I would immediately speak to her supervisor and demand a new therapist. I would go so far as to say that I would not allow her continue with whatever therapy sessions she has left.

Follow your mommy instincts. If Wilson is nothing like your stepson and the ped agrees that he is fine and just a late talker, I would not sweat the conversation that you had with her earlier today. Sounds to me like the therapist is lacking in skills anyway. Like you, I would also continue with speech since he only has 3 words right now, because in my mind- it can only help him right?

Hang in there honey. I would have been fuming and probably would have cursed the therapist out for insinuating that my DS was worse off than he is especially due to the lackadaisical manner in which she has handled Wilson's case. Chat Icon Call her supervisor and get a new therapist. Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 8/25/10 9:16 PM
 

MsMBV
:P

Member since 5/05

28602 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: I need to vent (long RE: EI)

Posted by Jacksmommy

I am an EI teacher (Special Instruction) and am seriously concerned with your speech therapist. Under NO circumstances should any therapist suggest that your child has PDD-NOS. if she has concerns, she should have recommended a psychological evaluation because of xy and z concerns. She should NEVER suggest that he has ANY type of disability. . . That is not her job.

I am sorry that you did not see the results, or get the attention that you were expecting., I am not an EI teacher, but this was my first reaction too. This is not her area of expertise, and making a recommendation to the proper person/Dr. should have been her first course of action, IMO, not rendering her version of a *diagnosis* for your LO.

As for the continual tardiness; I know I would get fired if I were a 1/2 hour late every day...

I hope the new therapist is a better fit.Chat Icon

Posted 8/25/10 10:44 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Can I vent? Can I? Huh? Please. Right, I am going to vent. Now. Here. Yes. Now. yankinmanc 11/29/07 11 Parenting
LONG VENT - Does anyone else have a MIL who is totally self-absorbed? Jax430 6/15/05 10 Families Helping Families ™
I have to vent or I am going to STRANGLE my MIL!!!! REALLY long!!! AJsMommy122 6/10/05 4 Parenting
Guess it's my turn to vent about my doctor! MrsJ 6/3/05 14 TTC
long vent about doctor! I need advice! NS1976 5/28/05 10 Families Helping Families ™
I hate the whole healthcare system! (need to vent please!) Disneygirl 5/23/05 5 Families Helping Families ™