Hypothetical
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
Hypothetical Try to follow Message edited 2008-08-16 19:12:26.107000. |
|
Posted 8/16/08 7:07 PM
|
|
|
Prudential Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| Long Island Weddings
| |
|
Re: Hypothetical The landlord can only be on top of repairs if they are notified about the need for them. And from what you wrote, that would mean they would have to move in with these two guys since they won't even be honest when asked a direct question. |
|
Posted 8/16/08 7:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: Hypothetical The renters definitly need to say something. Mold is a serious issue if it isn't handled properly and in a timely matter. It kinda sounds like they were waiting until it got really bad and then were going to try and throw the blame on the landlord. |
|
Posted 8/16/08 7:47 PM
|
|
|
Re: Hypothetical I think the renters need to speak up more, but if I was the LL I think I would have called the electrician or the tenants to make sure that problem had been fixed. Did the electrician bill the LL without ever fixing the problem? Wouldn't the LL know it wasn't fixed if he didn't get a bill? |
|
Posted 8/16/08 7:47 PM
|
|
|
Re: Hypothetical Posted by ready2ttc I think the renters need to speak up more, but if I was the LL I think I would have called the electrician or the tenants to make sure that problem had been fixed. Did the electrician bill the LL without ever fixing the problem? Wouldn't the LL know it wasn't fixed if he didn't get a bill? My mom rents, and it's so hard because she hates to complain. She usually waits until a few things are wrong/broken before she makes the call so she wont seem like a whiner. The landlord had her sons friend who is an electrician come. The landlord went away the day the electrican came to repair it. The friend's significant other spoke to the renters 2-3 times that week before the friend asked if the electric was repaired. Only after being asked did they say it was still broken. I understand about not complaining. They are two young men who don't exactly keep the cleanest house. They work and play. They were just living with 1/2 a house that has power... just waiting for it to be fixed without complaining
|
|
Posted 8/16/08 8:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: Hypothetical IMO, in this case, the "friend" is wrong, but only because they have obviously tried multiple times to get thru to these two 21 yr olds that they need to report stuff to the landlord, and its obvious they don't care. at that point, the friend really should have backed off and let the landlord deal with it. these are not boys, they are men, and need to learn to grow up sooner or later. they don't need a mother/father telling them what to do - it was fine the first time or two to let them know that they had to speak up, and then they should have dropped it, because it's really not their business. |
|
Posted 8/16/08 8:09 PM
|
|
|
Re: Hypothetical Posted by headoverheels IMO, in this case, the "friend" is wrong, but only because they have obviously tried multiple times to get thru to these two 21 yr olds that they need to report stuff to the landlord, and its obvious they don't care. at that point, the friend really should have backed off and let the landlord deal with it. these are not boys, they are men, and need to learn to grow up sooner or later. they don't need a mother/father telling them what to do - it was fine the first time or two to let them know that they had to speak up, and then they should have dropped it, because it's really not their business. it's also the job of the landlord to stay on top of the repairs, knowing that there is an issue, and knowing that it's not likely that these renters are going to report a new/continuing problem. if the landlord feels the need to, he/she can terminate the lease or take the cost of repairs out of the security deposit, especially if the problem was made worse by the renters failing to report the issues. It was only told to the renters 2x to speak up. 1st when the friend found out there was mold growing and 2nd when the electrician didn't return a week 1/2 later. Yes, it is the landlords job but the landlord asked every month when they delivered the rent if everything was ok. The lease is up in October. Message edited 2008-08-16 20:20:13.453000. |
|
Posted 8/16/08 8:20 PM
|
|
|
Re: Hypothetical Posted by KPtoys The landlord had her sons friend who is an electrician come. The landlord went away the day the electrican came to repair it. The friend's significant other spoke to the renters 2-3 times that week before the friend asked if the electric was repaired. Only after being asked did they say it was still broken. I understand about not complaining. They are two young men who don't exactly keep the cleanest house. They work and play. They were just living with 1/2 a house that has power... just waiting for it to be fixed without complaining I don't know...the men are obviously wrong for not complaining, but I think the LL shouldn't have relied on a friend of the son who wasn't responsible enough to follow up and actually make the repair. Maybe the LL in this particular case needed to actually hire an actual electrician instead of using a friend. They might have even felt uncomfortable complaining if they knew that the worker was a friend of the LL. Or, maybe the electrician said "I have to order/get a part," and they just assumed it was taking longer. I don't think the original 3 days to complain is that unusual--we've had major problems in our house but due to work schedules didn't call anyone for a few days. We didn't use the oven and dishwasher for weeks when they broke. It does sound like this friend of the LL is acting as a go-between when the renters don't want him tattling on everything they say. I'd tell the friend of LL to butt out--if the things bother the renters enough, they'll speak up. But as LL I would be on top of the repairmen checking to make sure they did the job, especially if it was a friend and not a professional. Message edited 2008-08-16 20:56:02.690000. |
|
Posted 8/16/08 8:51 PM
|
|
|
Re: Hypothetical Posted by ready2ttc Posted by KPtoys The landlord had her sons friend who is an electrician come. The landlord went away the day the electrican came to repair it. The friend's significant other spoke to the renters 2-3 times that week before the friend asked if the electric was repaired. Only after being asked did they say it was still broken. I understand about not complaining. They are two young men who don't exactly keep the cleanest house. They work and play. They were just living with 1/2 a house that has power... just waiting for it to be fixed without complaining I don't know...the men are obviously wrong for not complaining, but I think the LL shouldn't have relied on a friend of the son who wasn't responsible enough to follow up and actually make the repair. Maybe the LL in this particular case needed to actually hire an actual electrician instead of using a friend. They might have even felt uncomfortable complaining if they knew that the worker was a friend of the LL. Or, maybe the electrician said "I have to order/get a part," and they just assumed it was taking longer. I don't think the original 3 days to complain is that unusual--we've had major problems in our house but due to work schedules didn't call anyone for a few days. We didn't use the oven and dishwasher for weeks when they broke. in the electricians defense the wall needed to be cut open to access a wire. I don't know if he wanted to do that, not being a carpenter and all. They also live across the street from the Landlord. And it's electric... not just a dishwasher KWIM Message edited 2008-08-16 20:58:26.250000. |
|
Posted 8/16/08 8:55 PM
|
|
|
Re: Hypothetical Posted by KPtoys in the electricians defense the wall needed to be cut open to access a wire. I don't know if he wanted to do that, not being a carpenter and all. but how did he leave it then? the renters were supposed to call the LL and ask the LL to call a carpenter? or the electrician said he would come back with a carpenter? i don't know why he would say he would come back the next day if it was something he couldn't do. i dont know, was it a friend of the LL who repaired the bathroom and in doing so broke the electric? Message edited 2008-08-16 20:59:14.360000. |
|
Posted 8/16/08 8:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: Hypothetical Posted by ready2ttc Posted by KPtoys in the electricians defense the wall needed to be cut open to access a wire. I don't know if he wanted to do that, not being a carpenter and all. but how did he leave it then? the renters were supposed to call the LL and ask the LL to call a carpenter? or the electrician said he would come back with a carpenter? i don't know why he would say he would come back the next day if it was something he couldn't do. i dont know, was it a friend of the LL who repaired the bathroom and in doing so broke the electric? All I know is the electrician said he would return the next day and didn't. The carpenter was there the day after he found out it wasn't an easy electrical fix removing nails/screws trying to find the problem. He will be there on Monday with the electrician. |
|
Posted 8/16/08 9:12 PM
|
|
|
Re: Hypothetical I would think the landlord would be on top of it if HE FRIGGEN KNEW ABOUT IT. |
|
Posted 8/16/08 10:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: Hypothetical Uh, at 21, if you're not willing to tell your landlord that you have mold in your bathroom or your electric isn't working, then you need to grow up. Why in the world wouldn't you tell your landlord? |
|
Posted 8/17/08 12:11 AM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hypothetical Single Mother Question | nrthshgrl | 6/27/06 | 30 | Parenting |
| Bizarre Dream & Hypothetical Question | nrthshgrl | 6/13/06 | 9 | Parenting |
| Another Hypothetical Question.... | LadyMaravilla | 5/15/06 | 17 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| A hypothetical... | nov04libride | 5/15/06 | 19 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Hypothetical question...spinoff of my other thread.. | NS1976 | 10/18/05 | 3 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Lost Hypothetical | Redhead | 9/21/05 | 56 | Families Helping Families ™ |







