How would you handle this?

Posted By Message

JenMarie
One day at a time

Member since 11/07

7397 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

How would you handle this?

MIL watches DD (4 months old) FT. DDs ears stick out a little bit, but nothing crazy. They are her fathers exact ears. She taped DHs ears back when he was a baby and she keeps saying she's going to tape DDs back. Everytime I tell her she will do no such thing and today she says to DD "you won't tell on Nana, will you? We can keep a secret from Mommy." She then said "no daughter of mine will have cauliflower ears." And she has referred to herself as mommy a couple of times to DD (so 2 separate issues I have right there). I made a comment about being her mother and making the decisions and her ears will not be taped.

And another issue was we were talking about my 2 year old niece who is a little wild child. Typical behavior for a 2 year old - doesn't sit still. MIL made a comment about it and I said just that - she's a typical 2 year old. She says no, it's about teaching her to sit still. That she shouldn't be running around while eating and it's just about the parenting. I told her to wait until DD is 2 and running around her house and she says oh no DD won't if she has anything to do with it. And she said DH never acted like that when he was 2. Can you please show me a 2 year old who sits perfectly still?

I feel like I need to make clear that DD is OUR daughter and WE make the parenting decisions. MIL may or may not agree with them, but she needs to deal with that. I'm worried that as DD grows up she will intervene when she shouldn't and not follow through with the decisions we make. Am I wrong to feel this way? Am I overreacting? I want to discuss it with her tomorrow, but MIL is WAY dramatic and this will turn into a huge thing, which I obviously don't want. She takes great care of DD and I have no complaints about that, but I want to make sure she doesn't lose sight of that fact that she is not the parent, even if she does spend more time with DD than we do.

Posted 11/10/11 8:53 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Ever-After
Goals w/o plans r just wishes

Member since 6/09

2585 total posts

Name:
C

Re: How would you handle this?

I don't want to sound dramatic, but making that statement to your DD "We can keep a secret from Mommy" is a SERIOUS no-no! I don't care if she was joking, that would freak me the he11 out! We're supposed to teach our children that there are NO secrets from you parents. God forbid something happens or somebody tries to abuse a child somehow (a classmate, adult, relative, babysitter), they need to know that they can always tell their parents things and that secrets are not okay. So her saying something like that is giving a dangerously WRONG lesson and I would put a stop to that right away.

The whole taping the ears back is ridiculous and insulting. Is she trying to say that any 'imperfection' must be fixed? A friend of mine growing up had a father who used to hate left-handed people (weird). When SHE ended up being left-handed he was so angry that he would tie her left hand behind her back so that she would learn to only use the right. That seriously messed her up. Gave her a major complex well into her teens and to me that was definitely abuse (maybe more psyhological than physical). Her grandma taping back her ears could have the same affect - making her selfconscious about something that she shouldn't be (not to mention it would be uncomfortable & mean). If I were you I would seriously put my damn foot down and not put up with it. She is YOUR daughter, your MIL has no right whatsoever making ANY decisions (esp things you disagree on) let alone calling herself MOM to her. W.T.F is that?!?!

I'm sorry, I'm getting heated over this. The whole thing is just ridiculous. Honestly, I would just want to take my child out of her care and find somebody else because it would scare me. But if that's not an option for you then I think you need to be upfront about it. It can't be just a roll of the eyes side comment when you're dropping off or picking up DD. It needs to be a real serious conversation between just the three of you (you, her, & DH) about what is and isn't ok. It doesn't have to be in an icky way that would make her angry, just honest.

I don't know. That's MY input anyway. Take from it what you will. I hope it works out.

Posted 11/10/11 9:18 PM
 

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: How would you handle this?

I think I would probably have DH have a talk with her. Have him be the one to tell her that you both find her comments unacceptable. Make sure he stresses how much you two appreciate everything she does for your DC, but that doesn't mean she gets to make the decisions. And whether or not she agrees with how you two choose to parent, she needs to respect it and follow by your guidelines.

Posted 11/10/11 9:30 PM
 

spa118
LIF Adult

Member since 3/09

2157 total posts

Name:
Shari

Re: How would you handle this?

I honestly would have a very hard time with this situation. I would not want her calling herself "mommy", and I honestly might look into finding someone else to watch her. I'm not saying cut MIL altogether - I get that it is helpful financially and she does take good care of DD, but I wouldn't be comfortable with her watching DD full time between the "mommy" and taping ears back business. I think boundaries are being crossed. I think I'd look into maybe day care 2-3 x a week, and MIL 2-3 x a week.

Posted 11/10/11 9:35 PM
 

hotsauce345
my love, my life, my son

Member since 1/09

4169 total posts

Name:
Melody

Re: How would you handle this?

Posted by Ever-After

I don't want to sound dramatic, but making that statement to your DD "We can keep a secret from Mommy" is a SERIOUS no-no! I don't care if she was joking, that would freak me the he11 out! We're supposed to teach our children that there are NO secrets from you parents. God forbid something happens or somebody tries to abuse a child somehow (a classmate, adult, relative, babysitter), they need to know that they can always tell their parents things and that secrets are not okay. So her saying something like that is giving a dangerously WRONG lesson and I would put a stop to that right away.

The whole taping the ears back is ridiculous and insulting. Is she trying to say that any 'imperfection' must be fixed? A friend of mine growing up had a father who used to hate left-handed people (weird). When SHE ended up being left-handed he was so angry that he would tie her left hand behind her back so that she would learn to only use the right. That seriously messed her up. Gave her a major complex well into her teens and to me that was definitely abuse (maybe more psyhological than physical). Her grandma taping back her ears could have the same affect - making her selfconscious about something that she shouldn't be (not to mention it would be uncomfortable & mean). If I were you I would seriously put my damn foot down and not put up with it. She is YOUR daughter, your MIL has no right whatsoever making ANY decisions (esp things you disagree on) let alone calling herself MOM to her. W.T.F is that?!?!

I'm sorry, I'm getting heated over this. The whole thing is just ridiculous. Honestly, I would just want to take my child out of her care and find somebody else because it would scare me. But if that's not an option for you then I think you need to be upfront about it. It can't be just a roll of the eyes side comment when you're dropping off or picking up DD. It needs to be a real serious conversation between just the three of you (you, her, & DH) about what is and isn't ok. It doesn't have to be in an icky way that would make her angry, just honest.

I don't know. That's MY input anyway. Take from it what you will. I hope it works out.



agree completely on all accounts. I esp. don't like secrets part for the reason stated above.

Posted 11/10/11 9:42 PM
 

MommaBear
Very much in love!

Member since 6/10

2864 total posts

Name:
Angela

Re: How would you handle this?

Aww as a mommy of another sweet sweet girl with ears that stick out, I can totally relate. I think DD's ears are one of her most adorable qualities ever! How mean of your MIL to say that! Lots of people have commented about taping my DD's ears. Bunch of jerks!

Posted 11/10/11 9:49 PM
 

JenMarie
One day at a time

Member since 11/07

7397 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: How would you handle this?

Thanks ladies. I have a bad habit of overreacting so I didn't want to say anything today. It's been on my mind since this afternoon and I wanted the opinions of outsiders so I could see if my feelings are validated. I honestly didn't think of the secret issue like one of you mentioned, so I'm glad I posted now.

Posted 11/10/11 10:11 PM
 

TheDivineMrsM
2 girls 4 me!

Member since 8/08

7878 total posts

Name:
Mama mama mama....

Re: How would you handle this?

Posted by nferrandi

I think I would probably have DH have a talk with her. Have him be the one to tell her that you both find her comments unacceptable. Make sure he stresses how much you two appreciate everything she does for your DC, but that doesn't mean she gets to make the decisions. And whether or not she agrees with how you two choose to parent, she needs to respect it and follow by your guidelines.



ITA, though I'd sit in on the discussion with MIL. She needs to see the two of you as a united front. She can get as dramatic as she wants, as long as she listens to your parenting decisions. If she doesn't... well, caring for your daughter is a privilege, not a right.

Posted 11/10/11 10:13 PM
 

missus-hbradio
Twin mommy

Member since 5/05

15857 total posts

Name:

Re: How would you handle this?

Posted by TheDivineMrsM

Posted by nferrandi

I think I would probably have DH have a talk with her. Have him be the one to tell her that you both find her comments unacceptable. Make sure he stresses how much you two appreciate everything she does for your DC, but that doesn't mean she gets to make the decisions. And whether or not she agrees with how you two choose to parent, she needs to respect it and follow by your guidelines.



ITA, though I'd sit in on the discussion with MIL. She needs to see the two of you as a united front. She can get as dramatic as she wants, as long as she listens to your parenting decisions. If she doesn't... well, caring for your daughter is a privilege, not a right.



Exactly. I would make DH handle this.

Posted 11/10/11 10:15 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
"Road Rage" type situations - how do you handle them? greenfreak 11/3/06 42 Families Helping Families ™
We are trying to find a specific kind of door "handle" for a sliding bathroom door...(PIC) AndreaLMT 8/18/06 4 Home
Can anyone offer advice on how to handle MIL smoking in her house? btrflygrl 7/6/06 16 Parenting
For moms that dont have family by them, how did you handle it when your baby was born JerseyMamaOf3 3/7/06 1 Parenting
How do you handle it when your friends disagree? baghag 3/1/06 5 Families Helping Families ™