How would you handle this?

Posted By Message

mikeswife06
Drama Momma

Member since 9/06

9947 total posts

Name:
Anne

How would you handle this?

Mother: "OK, give me your hand we're in the parking lot now."

DC: Pulls hands in so Mom can't hold them.

Mom: Picks child up.

DC: Pulls mother's hair and smacks her in face.

I was Chat Icon Chat Icon blown away.

She is 28 months and I KNOW her last 2 molars are coming in and it was close to nap time but STILL...unacceptable!

She has hit me like 2-3 times in the past, at home, not as violently and went right into time out but I have heard you shouldn't do time outs in public because children shouldn't be made to be showcased and embarassed or ashamed in public. So I had no clue what to do!

I kneeled down to eye level and said, "NO! That hurt Mommy. You use words, not hands when you're upset. Now say you are sorry."

She just burst into tears and didn't apologize. Silently I put her in the car seat and we talked about it when she calmed down. She repeated, "Use words, not hands," and promised not to hit anyone anymore.

How would you have handled that? I was really at a loss. Chat Icon

Posted 1/10/11 3:30 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

LJSMommy
Love him!

Member since 10/07

3189 total posts

Name:

Re: How would you handle this?

Very much the way you did is how I would have handled it.

I probably would have put DS in his carseat for a timeout before heading into the store. He is super verbal at 2 1/2 so we are very successful at him understanding WHY & WHEN he gets a time out.

Posted 1/10/11 3:45 PM
 

mikeswife06
Drama Momma

Member since 9/06

9947 total posts

Name:
Anne

Re: How would you handle this?

Posted by LJSMommy

Very much the way you did is how I would have handled it.

I probably would have put DS in his carseat for a timeout before heading into the store. He is super verbal at 2 1/2 so we are very successful at him understanding WHY & WHEN he gets a time out.



We were leaving but had it been on arrival that's a good idea. I just didn't know if that was "enough".

Posted 1/10/11 3:48 PM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: How would you handle this?

You did exactly what I would have done.

I don't think her lashing out has anything to do with teeth or being close to naptime. I think at this age they just can't express what they are really feeling (completely) and lash out. She's still testing the waters too.

Keep doing what you're doing!! Chat Icon

Posted 1/10/11 3:55 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: How would you handle this?

Sorry to butt in but..


Posted by mikeswife06
She has hit me like 2-3 times in the past, at home, not as violently and went right into time out but I have heard you shouldn't do time outs in public because children shouldn't be made to be showcased and embarassed or ashamed in public. So I had no clue what to do!



B. S.!!! AJ is the same age and she has no clue of embrassment. She gets time out in public. A lot more before but I think if you teach them WHAT time out is, then they will learn not to want it. If you show them early on, no where and no time is a 'freebie' out of it, then they will respect it more.

You hit me, then its "no hitting" stern voice and look. Hit me again "TIME OUT" end of story.

But given what you believe and what happened and of course 'in the moment' I think you did just what needed to be done. There was a reaction to her actions and I think that is key.

Oddly enough, AJ pulls the SAME act. Every day out of daycare she wants to walk on her own, etc. I say "No, cars, hand for mommy" and she says no, and pulls her hand into her chest. I grab it firmly, point to the moving cars on the street past the parking lot and say "See, cars? Hands, thank you" if I'm holding her hand. If she resist I ask she wants up, if she says no (Which happens) its a choice... hand or Up. If she still whines then its Hand or Time Out. She usually does hand. I'm talking less than 15ft to walk too! Its a battle but one I refuse to lose.


ETA: public time outs: its not like she's 5 and understands embarassment or feels shame. She is 2 she lives in her own world and frankly AJ thinks she IS the world. So I don't understand how 'they' think she would feel shamed or embarassed (im talking of AJ of course) to each their own I guess. I figure I'm setting a habit. She has honestly been less unruly in public since she knows she's not immune to time out. I haven't put her in public time out in over a month.

Message edited 2011-01-10 16:56:25.223000.

Posted 1/10/11 4:51 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: How would you handle this?

Truthfully, I would've put her in a time out right then and there. I don't care where we are or who is around........if Emerson misbehaves she's going into a time out.

As for public time outs, everything I've read said that children need to be put into a time out as soon as they act inappropriately and I have no problem with it. I don't think you are shaming them or embarrassing them. I think you're making the point to them right then and there that their behavior is unacceptable. I'm not really a fan of dealing with it later, especially with a toddler who will have moved on from what happened 10 seconds later.

I think it's really important to handle inappropriate behavior when it occurs. Chat Icon

Posted 1/10/11 5:24 PM
 

JandJ1224

Member since 6/06

5911 total posts

Name:
Jannette

Re: How would you handle this?

This reminds me of the time we were out at a restuarant and my DD was being bad, we put her in a time out and turned her away from the table and she was smiling telling the waitstaff she was in time out! Chat Icon

It must be the age, makes me feel better about when my DD acts out though! Thanks for sharing. I think your reaction was fine. Its embarassing as a parent esp. in public when your child is so fresh.

Posted 1/10/11 5:52 PM
 

BargainMama
LIF Adult

Member since 5/09

15660 total posts

Name:

Re: How would you handle this?

Posted by Hofstra26

Truthfully, I would've put her in a time out right then and there. I don't care where we are or who is around........if Emerson misbehaves she's going into a time out.

As for public time outs, everything I've read said that children need to be put into a time out as soon as they act inappropriately and I have no problem with it. I don't think you are shaming them or embarrassing them. I think you're making the point to them right then and there that their behavior is unacceptable. I'm not really a fan of dealing with it later, especially with a toddler who will have moved on from what happened 10 seconds later.

I think it's really important to handle inappropriate behavior when it occurs. Chat Icon



Where do you put your child in time out at when you are in public?

Posted 1/10/11 6:08 PM
 

1stimemom
Love my boys

Member since 2/08

8766 total posts

Name:
Mrs Dee

Re: How would you handle this?

Posted by BargainMama

Posted by Hofstra26

Truthfully, I would've put her in a time out right then and there. I don't care where we are or who is around........if Emerson misbehaves she's going into a time out.

As for public time outs, everything I've read said that children need to be put into a time out as soon as they act inappropriately and I have no problem with it. I don't think you are shaming them or embarrassing them. I think you're making the point to them right then and there that their behavior is unacceptable. I'm not really a fan of dealing with it later, especially with a toddler who will have moved on from what happened 10 seconds later.

I think it's really important to handle inappropriate behavior when it occurs. Chat Icon



Where do you put your child in time out at when you are in public?



WHEREVER!! Time out, IMO, is more of a state of mind than a location. Ds can be at home in the same room we always play in, but when we put him in time out he knows not to move from the chair.

Sorry, i also don't agree with the "don't embarrass them" thing. #1 at 2 they really dont "get" embarrassment, and # 2 how embarrassed were you for being hit? What if she did it in front of people? Embarassment is out the window, discipline is key. No warnings with hitting. JMHOChat Icon

ETA - I think you did well being in unfamiliar territory and givien the circumstances. It is easy to say what we all would do given the time to think about it. You reacted great in the moment, so kudos to you ( i probably would have either started to cry or smacked his butt, honestly, on a spur of the moment reaction)

Message edited 2011-01-10 18:29:28.363000.

Posted 1/10/11 6:26 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: How would you handle this?

I think what you did is fine. I haven't done TO's yet with my DD, but when I do, I will do them in public too (so I may have done that here).

Posted 1/10/11 6:28 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: How would you handle this?

Posted by BargainMama

Where do you put your child in time out at when you are in public?



Anywhere and everywhere

In costco I sat her on a chair close by, in the mall I sat her on the floor, at Outback I sat her facing the wall in the booth, at Olive Garden I turned her highchair to a blank boring space, in the car she gets all toys and towel taken away and has to sit in her car seat, in the house its a corner or room, at the classmate's bday party it was the corner in the room where cake was being served (while it was being served no less), there's ALWAYS time and space for time out!

Posted 1/10/11 6:36 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: How would you handle this?

Posted by BargainMama

Posted by Hofstra26

Truthfully, I would've put her in a time out right then and there. I don't care where we are or who is around........if Emerson misbehaves she's going into a time out.

As for public time outs, everything I've read said that children need to be put into a time out as soon as they act inappropriately and I have no problem with it. I don't think you are shaming them or embarrassing them. I think you're making the point to them right then and there that their behavior is unacceptable. I'm not really a fan of dealing with it later, especially with a toddler who will have moved on from what happened 10 seconds later.

I think it's really important to handle inappropriate behavior when it occurs. Chat Icon



Where do you put your child in time out at when you are in public?



Anywhere. Wherever she can sit works just fine. I do the same at home too. I don't put her in the same "naughty spot" because I want her to understand that it doesn't matter where we are or where she sits the consequence is the same. She doesn't need a special spot to understand she did something wrong which is why I can put her anywhere in public and she gets that she's in trouble.

I don't play any games with my DD. I fully expect her to behave a certain way when we're out (and at home) and if she doesn't she goes into time out right away. Waiting until later isn't productive with a toddler. She needs the consequence right away for it to be effective.

Truth be told, my DD is VERRRRRY well behaved for 2 but that's because DH and I have always been consistent in teaching her how to behave and correcting her when she misbehaves. She's very rarely in time out but when it happens she totally knows why she's there and it ends the bad behavior asap. Chat Icon

Message edited 2011-01-10 18:56:40.140000.

Posted 1/10/11 6:56 PM
 

carlowlou
loving my babies!

Member since 4/08

4594 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: How would you handle this?

I think you handled it well especially since she seems to understand based on her repeating "words not hands." Good job Mama!

Posted 1/10/11 7:01 PM
 

pickles16
Real Estate Professional

Member since 11/07

17227 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: How would you handle this?

I would have done the same...If there was a safe place to do it I would have done a time out but obviously I don't think there was in a parking lot..

Posted 1/10/11 7:39 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
"Road Rage" type situations - how do you handle them? greenfreak 11/3/06 42 Families Helping Families ™
We are trying to find a specific kind of door "handle" for a sliding bathroom door...(PIC) AndreaLMT 8/18/06 4 Home
Can anyone offer advice on how to handle MIL smoking in her house? btrflygrl 7/6/06 16 Parenting
For moms that dont have family by them, how did you handle it when your baby was born JerseyMamaOf3 3/7/06 1 Parenting
How do you handle it when your friends disagree? baghag 3/1/06 5 Families Helping Families ™