How would you handle this....

Posted By Message

hbugal
Lesigh

Member since 2/07

15928 total posts

Name:

How would you handle this....

My DH purchased my engagement ring almost 5 years ago at Macys. Before the ring was a year old we had to replace, on 2 separate occassions, 2 of the begets. Both times the ring was brought back to Macys who did the repairs. (Obviously they send it to someone they use and dont do the repairs in house)...

Fast forward to today. I brought my rings in to be resized. (Very reputable jeweler who my family has been doing business with for years) I discussed with the jeweler possibly resetting my engagement ring...etc

Well...the 2 begets that have been replaced are of such poor quality that it doesnt warrant using them if I chose to reset the ring. Which essentially makes their "matching" stones useless as well b/c I dont have a quality pair...(I hope that makes sense).

The ring itself was very poorly designed which is the reason why I lost the begets in the first place...HOWEVER...as per the jeweler...the original stones are very good quality.

What would you do?

Posted 10/20/10 9:56 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

dawnygirl25
Growing up soo fast..

Member since 1/06

14917 total posts

Name:
Dawn

Re: How would you handle this....

I would probably ask DH what he suggests and what hes comfortable with. If hes OK it...truthfully..Id probably take the main stone and have it put into a new setting by the reputable jeweler you know.Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon sorry your having such trouble with the setting..

Posted 10/20/10 10:26 PM
 

DancinBarefoot
06ers Rock!!

Member since 1/07

9537 total posts

Name:
The One My Mother Gave Me ;-)

Re: How would you handle this....

Hmmm, did you have the original ring with the original stones appraised and insured?

Do you have records of the repairs made by Macys?

If so, I would have this jeweler write a comparison between the original and what the ring is now, and take it back to Macy's and complain.

Posted 10/20/10 10:40 PM
 

dawnygirl25
Growing up soo fast..

Member since 1/06

14917 total posts

Name:
Dawn

Re: How would you handle this....

Posted by DancinBarefoot

Hmmm, did you have the original ring with the original stones appraised and insured?

Do you have records of the repairs made by Macys?

If so, I would have this jeweler write a comparison between the original and what the ring is now, and take it back to Macy's and complain.



interesting idea...do youhave all of the origional paper work?

Posted 10/20/10 10:42 PM
 

hbugal
Lesigh

Member since 2/07

15928 total posts

Name:

Re: How would you handle this....

Posted by dawnygirl25

Posted by DancinBarefoot

Hmmm, did you have the original ring with the original stones appraised and insured?

Do you have records of the repairs made by Macys?

If so, I would have this jeweler write a comparison between the original and what the ring is now, and take it back to Macy's and complain.



interesting idea...do youhave all of the origional paper work?



Im sure I do....

I know that Macy's will have record of it. We put up quite a fight with them to fix it the second time.

I may or may not have copies of the paper work...

I think I still have the original emails...

I do have the original appraisal. But the jeweler today said that they probably didnt look closely at the begets b/c in comparison to the center stone it was negligible.

Posted 10/20/10 10:49 PM
 

DancinBarefoot
06ers Rock!!

Member since 1/07

9537 total posts

Name:
The One My Mother Gave Me ;-)

Re: How would you handle this....

Posted by hbugal

Posted by dawnygirl25

Posted by DancinBarefoot

Hmmm, did you have the original ring with the original stones appraised and insured?

Do you have records of the repairs made by Macys?

If so, I would have this jeweler write a comparison between the original and what the ring is now, and take it back to Macy's and complain.



interesting idea...do youhave all of the origional paper work?



Im sure I do....

I know that Macy's will have record of it. We put up quite a fight with them to fix it the second time.

I may or may not have copies of the paper work...

I think I still have the original emails...

I do have the original appraisal. But the jeweler today said that they probably didnt look closely at the begets b/c in comparison to the center stone it was negligible.



It's worth it to at least look at the original paperwork and see what it says. A proper appraisal would say at the very least what the clarity of the stones are/were, and the total carat weight has to be on it as well.

Posted 10/20/10 10:55 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
"Road Rage" type situations - how do you handle them? greenfreak 11/3/06 42 Families Helping Families ™
We are trying to find a specific kind of door "handle" for a sliding bathroom door...(PIC) AndreaLMT 8/18/06 4 Home
Can anyone offer advice on how to handle MIL smoking in her house? btrflygrl 7/6/06 16 Parenting
For moms that dont have family by them, how did you handle it when your baby was born JerseyMamaOf3 3/7/06 1 Parenting
How do you handle it when your friends disagree? baghag 3/1/06 5 Families Helping Families ™