How much would you offer?

Posted By Message

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

How much would you offer?

I found a house on homeaway.com that I would love to rent for Labor Day weekend. It's in the exact neighborhood where we usually rent, but our normal house is already rented for Labor Day. This new house is way nicer, but it's also more then double the cost. They are asking for $250 a night. Our regular lady only charges me $100 a night. I reached out and sent a message asking that if they are not able to rent it, would they be willing to go down in price. She just replied saying if we're still interested to call her. What would be a reasonable amount to try to get her down to?

Posted 8/20/14 6:43 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

ourhappysurprise2012
LIF Adult

Member since 9/12

901 total posts

Name:
Lori

How much would you offer?

Maybe $175...somewhat in the middle...

Posted 8/20/14 6:50 PM
 

JME78
LIF Adult

Member since 11/09

3672 total posts

Name:

Re: How much would you offer?

175 seems reasonable since the holiday is so close!

Posted 8/20/14 7:37 PM
 

WhatNow
Say Cheese!

Member since 1/06

8033 total posts

Name:
A (formerly WhatNow?)

Re: How much would you offer?

I would tell her that you pay $100 a night for your regular house and ask what she would be willing to accept if she is not able to rent out for her price.

Posted 8/20/14 7:40 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: How much would you offer?

Posted by WhatNow

I would tell her that you pay $100 a night for your regular house and ask what she would be willing to accept if she is not able to rent out for her price.



This.

Posted 8/20/14 7:52 PM
 

BBD322x0
LIF Adolescent

Member since 3/14

703 total posts

Name:
Brittany

How much would you offer?

I rented a house off that site last August for a bachelorette party and paid $200/night. If she said to call her it definitely seems like she's willing to work with you - $150 sounds like a reasonable start that way you can work your way up to $175 if you have to.

Posted 8/21/14 11:17 AM
 

RainaK
LIF Adult

Member since 4/14

904 total posts

Name:
R

How much would you offer?

For me, the way I am, I wouldn't expect/try to get her below $200. You said it's a much better house so it should be more. I wouldn't want to pay less than what it's worth. I wouldn't feel right about it. This is just me. I am saying this in a nice, non snarky way. :)

Posted 8/21/14 2:30 PM
 

MarathonKnitter
HAPPY

Member since 2/07

17374 total posts

Name:
EMBRACING CHANGE

Re: How much would you offer?

Posted by BBD322x0

I rented a house off that site last August for a bachelorette party and paid $200/night. If she said to call her it definitely seems like she's willing to work with you - $150 sounds like a reasonable start that way you can work your way up to $175 if you have to.



this is what i was thinking. start at $150 and work up to $175. give yourself a little wiggle room

Posted 8/21/14 2:36 PM
 

Christine Braun - Signature Premier Properties
LIFamilies Business

Member since 2/11

3992 total posts

Name:

Re: How much would you offer?

Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee

Posted by WhatNow

I would tell her that you pay $100 a night for your regular house and ask what she would be willing to accept if she is not able to rent out for her price.



This.



Honestly, I think this strategy can be tricky, because you are basically asking her to negotiate against herself.

Although I am mainly a sales agent, I occasionally take rental listings, and I HATE when other agents or prospective tenants say "are you negotiable" or "how much less would you take?" Most of my clients would rather have a specific offer to work with. If they say, "I'll take x" off the bat, perhaps, they will miss out on the chance that the renter would offer more.

In my view, the asking price is the landlord's initial offer, and if a potential renter doesn't want to pay it, then they should make a counteroffer. Maybe the landlord will accept it, but if not, maybe she'll counter again. There's a back and forth. So by making an offer in response to her asking price, you've put the ball back in her court, rather than asking her to just throw out another number that is different from her original ask price. I think the onus should be on the person who wants to rent it to throw a number out first if the list price is not acceptable. Jmo!

Also, sometimes whether or not a landlord is negotiable depends on who is making the offer (how desirable the renter and their terms are). So the landlord may respond better to a specific offer versus a general "are you negotiable?" type question. This definitely applies to longer-term rentals, but I think it could be relevant for a short-term vacation rental, too.

Posted 8/21/14 8:42 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Received offer on co-op! need advise... Suezboss 4/20/06 7 Home
does anyone ever get the gevalia offer and then cancel? raken40 3/20/06 10 Families Helping Families ™
Boys Clothing For Sale... Best Offer... KangaMom 1/12/06 2 Parenting
from start (making an offer) to finish (closing) how long did it take? raken40 7/14/05 14 Home
China Cabinet For Sale-MAKE ME AN OFFER!! PLEASE~~ meganNbobby 7/11/05 1 Home
China Cabinet For Sale-MAKE ME AN OFFER!! PLEASE~~ meganNbobby 7/9/05 8 Families Helping Families ™