How much is "taught" vs "organic"?

Posted By Message

randella
Love my little man

Member since 8/05

16290 total posts

Name:
Randi

How much is "taught" vs "organic"?

As Sasha gets older, and I realize that I can't "go with the flow" anymore and I have to really start teaching her skills, I can't help but wonder how much happens naturally, or how much I really need to teach her.

I guess I am beating myself up a little, feeling I didn't do enough with teaching her to crawl, and now with pulling up.

Anyway-- what does everyone else do in terms of "lessons"?

eta-- I have successfully gotten her on the straw sippy, now am working on spoon feeding. Looking for other things I should be doing, and/or suggestions for fun teaching activities for cognitive skills, etc.

Message edited 2010-02-18 09:56:18.330000.

Posted 2/18/10 9:46 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

beachgirl
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

7967 total posts

Name:
sara

Re: How much is "taught" vs "organic"?

I believe they teach themselves mostly...I do pull DS up and down on my lap but thats more of a play thing than a teaching thing..I never officially taught my DD anything and she was pulling herself up on the coffee table at 10 1/2 months....

So dont beat yourself up ..there are plenty of other guilt trips you can takeChat Icon I was like this with my first, always stressing about whether I was doing enough for her etc but this time around with #2 I dont stress or worry half as much.


Chat Icon

Posted 2/18/10 9:56 AM
 

EricaAlt
LIF Adult

Member since 7/08

22665 total posts

Name:
Erica

Re: How much is "taught" vs "organic"?

I feel like the first year it's all "organic," besides us kind of encouraging and supporting them. Clapping for new things they learned and all. Mason is only 8.5 months old now so I'm not there. I don't think if a child is a late walker it's b/c their parents never worked with them on doing it. Now, if it's a case where parents are holding the child all the time that's a whole other thing. I say keep with what you're doing. Letting her learn things on her own and just reward and encourage her. Chat Icon

I remember when I worked at a daycare there was a boy about 17 or 18 months who still wouldn't walk b/c his parents carried him all the time. That's really the only case I can think of where parents held their child back from learning more.

Posted 2/18/10 9:57 AM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: How much is "taught" vs "organic"?

I think that DC learn from everything, they are such sponges at early ages. I have never gone out of my way to "teach" DS ANYTHING.

I feel like they will learn to do everything at their own pace honestly. Somethings are mastered faster and sooner than others....

Posted 2/18/10 9:59 AM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: How much is "taught" vs "organic"?

Posted by KateDevine

I think that DC learn from everything, they are such sponges at early ages. I have never gone out of my way to "teach" DS ANYTHING.

I feel like they will learn to do everything at their own pace honestly. Somethings are mastered faster and sooner than others....



I agree, although in the past few weeks I have realized they have started catching on to things really quickly. For example - I bought them those snack cup things the other day and when I first gave it to them, they didn't know what to do with it. I am sure they would have figured it out on their own, but all I had to do was show them once, and they got it.

Posted 2/18/10 10:02 AM
 

computergirl
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3118 total posts

Name:

Re: How much is "taught" vs "organic"?

Honestly, I don't even think clapping (or waving) is taught. I think I read somewhere someone was saying their kid learned it at daycare, but I'm a SAHM and I honestly really never made any effort to "teach" my kids these particular things, and it still happened right on schedule anyway, lol. Kids just clap instinctively, I think... once they have the coordination to put their hands together with an open palm. Maybe they observe us doing it every time they do something good. Waving just happens from observation and imitation. I think these are just natural developmental milestones that occur between 6 to 9 months.

I agree that not too many skills are realy "taught" for the first year or so. Even drinking from a sippy cup.... how do you really "teach" it? You just keep handing the baby the cup and one day they get it.

Posted 2/18/10 10:04 AM
 

shapla79
Where Does The Time Go?

Member since 11/07

4619 total posts

Name:

Re: How much is "taught" vs "organic"?

I don't know if I necessarily "taught" DS anything in the first year and a half, but I kept giving him opportunities to try new things until it clicked with him. Now that he's closer to 2, I'm finding that he's wanting to learn and imitate me more.

Posted 2/18/10 10:05 AM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: How much is "taught" vs "organic"?

Putting aside the fact that I am a special educator, I work with MANY behaviorists. I asked one of our HIGHLY TRAINED behavioral consultants how much of who our children are is "organic" versus "environmental" (or taught). Her answer:

100% organic
100% environmental

and to be honest, I agree.

There will be battles of genetics versus home/day care/school/work environments for the entirety of our children's lives. We can be as influential as we want to be but we cannot always expect to change (or reverse) any organic predispositions. The best thing we can do is provide a CONSISTENT environment for our children full of love and life experiences that will complement what has already been pre-determined for them. Many may disagree with me, but this is how I feel based on personal and MANY years of professional experience.

ETA - I was tangential - sorry.

Message edited 2010-02-18 10:08:06.893000.

Posted 2/18/10 10:07 AM
 

mrsgafforio
LIF Adult

Member since 3/07

3929 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: How much is "taught" vs "organic"?

Posted by KateDevine

I think that DC learn from everything, they are such sponges at early ages. I have never gone out of my way to "teach" DS ANYTHING.

I feel like they will learn to do everything at their own pace honestly. Somethings are mastered faster and sooner than others....



I totally agree!!

Posted 2/18/10 10:13 AM
 

randella
Love my little man

Member since 8/05

16290 total posts

Name:
Randi

Re: How much is "taught" vs "organic"?

ok-- this makes me feel a little better. While I do look at everything as a "teaching moment", I have really felt that she'd always do things at her own pace. But I can't help if I should be doing MORE...

I think as she gets older, can respond more to classes and other children, it will be a whole different experience.

Posted 2/18/10 10:22 AM
 

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Re: How much is "taught" vs "organic"?

Posted by Goldi0218

Putting aside the fact that I am a special educator, I work with MANY behaviorists. I asked one of our HIGHLY TRAINED behavioral consultants how much of who our children are is "organic" versus "environmental" (or taught). Her answer:

100% organic
100% environmental

and to be honest, I agree.




moi aussi.

Posted 2/18/10 10:34 AM