How long should a drunk driver be in jail?

Posted By Message

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

How long should a drunk driver be in jail?

I read this & thought..really? only a year? No one was hurt but he was driving a school bus, which I think should hold him to a higher standard & a longer punishment.

Crime Nearby: Drunk Bus Driver Gets 1 Year

A bus driver who was drunk at the wheel when he crashed into a Syosset home will serve one year in prison, according to the Nassau District Attorney's office.

Frederick Flowers, 67, of Massapequa Park, pleaded guilty to charges and was sentenced Monday to one year in prison, said the DA's office. Flowers admitted to Leandra's Law violations, DWI, reckless endangerment in the second degree, and endangering the welfare of a child.

External Image

Posted 4/30/13 12:19 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Kitten1929
LIF Adult

Member since 1/13

6040 total posts

Name:

How long should a drunk driver be in jail?

Although I don't know much about DUI/DWI laws, I do think 1 year in prison seems a bit lax. Especially when fatalities occur, it seems the punishment never fits the crime.

Posted 4/30/13 12:23 PM
 

mommy2B3
2 boys 2 girls!!!!

Member since 7/08

3324 total posts

Name:
M

Re: How long should a drunk driver be in jail?

I find this insane! 1 yr for drunk driving into not only a home, but driving a bus! Was any kids involved? If any kids were involved, this is just sick, and shows how lax our justice system really is..

Posted 4/30/13 12:35 PM
 

2boys4me
He's coming soon!

Member since 4/10

4260 total posts

Name:

Re: How long should a drunk driver be in jail?

I'm really disgusted by drunk drivers and as obvious as that statement sounds, I feel like a lot of people don't agree with me and I'm not sure why. There have been plenty of people I know of that have been busted and all their close friends shove it under the rug, no one thinks less of the person and I've even known of people to try and cover it up for not only their friends and family but for people they don't know in their town because "we don't want people to think about our town" or " that's so and so's kid so let us sweep it under the rug". Even sports players and celebrities are given the okay when this happens, I mean do they have any less fans, get any less jobs?

I saw this special on 20/20 about texting and driving a few months ago and they said that most people are AGAINST Strict punishments for texting and driving because they could put themselves in the drivers position or engage in the activity themselves and wouldn't want to be punished so they said a large majority of Americans are against strict punishments for these people who could murder others just by engaging in this act. I feel like this thought process, of putting yourself in the shoes of the drunk/buzzed driver is the reason so many people aren't completely shocked regarding this behavior. I really don't see people get upset about this unless someone is killed or their actions affect children. Other than that, no one really cares. I think people who drink/get high and drive are disgusting. I don't are who you are, who you are related to or where you live, I don't care that it is "just weed" or want to hear " oh the cops just keep letting me go because I live here or I'm related to xyz" or the worst I've heard..."I'm a cop, they let me go" (said for the 20+ time).

Maybe the drunk driving will stop when we give harsher punishments out, when society views this as disgusting but I don't think that will ever happen. To me, getting in a car drunk or high is no worse then going to the mall, closing your eyes, and start shooting a gun. You have a potential to kill all of those around you and those who don't get hit are lucky. Why don't people understand how dangerous this is!? I don't get it. I enjoy a drink every now and then but we either have one or two at home every once in a blue moon or if we are out one of us has ONE at the beginning of the meal and then STOPS so that person can drive home in an 1.5-2 hrs or we walk to the local restaurant. I don't think it's fair that we can be as responsible as can be but that will not protect us when we get in the car with our two little boys and have to worry if that person swerving a tad ahead of us is drunk and may careen into us or if someone could just come out of nowhere going the wrong way and crash into us killing my babies or my husband. This could happen, you could kill others anytime you get in the car drunk so WHY would you do this or why would you think it's not a big deal for someone your friends with to do this? It's attempted murder in my book.

Posted 4/30/13 1:00 PM
 

DaniJude
You're My Home <3

Member since 11/06

14815 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: How long should a drunk driver be in jail?

Ugh this is my daily nightmare - the horrible consequences of someone else's selfish and completely avoidable CHOICE and then the pathetic sentences that go along with it. And the idea of "well, this time no one was hurt" so then they don't sentence them as harshly - it is the idea that only by the grace of GOD did someone not get hurt or killed. Could you imagine, to hit a HOME, how obliterated this guy must have been? People that try and put themselves in the offender's shoes, like "oh that could have been me" don't usually realize HOW drunk these people are - they relate them having a glass of wine at dinner and then driving to the level that this person was operating that bus. Or, in Ken's case, the guy that hit him had drank a BOTTLE AND A HALF of Bacardi rum. Umm, I would be dead if I drank that. So, that's what people need to realize - stop relating to the offender, start trying to put yourselves in the victim's shoes because you are MUCH more likely to end up a victim one day than to be the offender, statistically.

So much has been done to increase the penalties, which is great, but it is still not enough - we still need to focus on the loopholes that exist in Leandra's Law as well as punishments for those severely injured. Also, and this is so important, we need to focus on raising the MINIMUM penalty levels - many times, the penalties can be AS MUCH AS seven to ten years in prison but as little as one year. How can that be?? So, you get some devil's advocate Judge who gives them the minimum... recently, we had a woman who was driving drunk, REALLY high BAC level, at 10am - not even at night, she was "running errands" according to her statement - injured a mother and her two children in the car - by the grace of God, the mother sat the kids in their car seats on the right side of the minivan, one behind each other, rather than next to each other otherwise one of the babies would likely have been killed. The Judge? Gave her probation - said he felt bad for the offender. It's insane. These people who were injured live every single day with the ramifications of what that woman did to them. So, the minimum issue needs to be addressed as well. In Ken's case, the man that hit him could have been sentenced to, at the least, one year also!!! But, thankfully, the Judge realized he needed a harsh punishment and gave him the maximum - which is only seven years but thank God we got that. What if he gave him the minimum? It could have happened very easily - I could name five Judges off the top of my head that would have done that. I can name only two that would have given the max...

Many who are injured, like my brother, are not having their offenders sentenced harshly because they lived - yet the injury that they now have to live the rest of their lives with is not always being considered. There is a big difference between alive and dead - it is not that black and white. He didn't lose his life but he lost the functionality, on many levels, of his life. Some people are living with life-long, life-altering, and crippling injuries. So, those are three areas where we need to beef it up - I keep fighting the good fight, year after year, in both Albany and DC at Legislation Days/Lobby Days.

But, it is an up-hill battle against a society that wants to feel this is ACCEPTABLE. We lose over 10,000 people in this country each year to this -- imagine if we lost 10,000 people each year to bombings like we saw in Boston, or to shootings like we saw in Connecticut, or even a plane crash - something completely unavoidable like a plane crash. The FAA would launch the biggest investigation in this country's history into WHY and WHAT happened to cause all of these plane crashes that add up to over 10,000 people a year -- and they would make sure that they would fix whatever the issue was. People would storm DC to demand that something be done to avoid this - yet, drunk driving, we accept. Why is that? An accident is something that is unavoidable - it happens without negligence, it just occurs. This is a crime. This is avoidable, this is a person's DECISION to do this.

Three areas: loopholes in Leandra's Law, minimum sentences being raised on huge sentence ranges like 1 year to 12 years... ridiculous to have that kind of a separation, and the punishments being harsher for those severely injured.

Specifically about Leandra's Law and the school bus epidemic, just FYI for anyone who wants to be involved: Senator Fuschillo (thank God for him or we'd have no Leandra's Law at all and this bus driver would be picking up garbage for a few weeks as his sentence)... but Senator Fuschillo is having a public hearing examining REQUIRING ignition interlock devices for all school buses to protect our children in light of recent events involving several intoxicated school bus drivers.

The public hearing, which will be held by the New York State Senate Standing Committee on Transportation, will take place on Thursday May 2nd at 10am at Farmingdale State College (Campus Center, Ballroom, 2350 Broad Hollow Road Farmingdale, NY 11735).

Discussion at the hearing will include, but will not be limited to: crashes caused by intoxicated bus drivers; whether New York State's current pupil transportation laws should be strengthened to further protect children from drunk drivers; and recent legislation that would require the installation of ignition interlock devices in school buses.

If you would like to testify at this public hearing, please contact Melissa Kehoe at Senator Fuschillo's office: 518.455.3341 or at MKEHOE@NYSENATE.GOV

Changes can only occur if we do something about it - if we stand up and raise our voices to demand something be done. It could potentially save your child's life - or the countless lives of other innocent children just trying to get to school.

Posted 4/30/13 1:33 PM
 

Pray4Baby2010
<3 Cutest Giants Fan

Member since 10/09

5796 total posts

Name:
MB

Re: How long should a drunk driver be in jail?

I'm tired of the everyone makes a mistake line here- he is responsible for kids and I would love to see him go away for a LONG LONG time and also never be able to drive again.

Maybe if they made the punishments stronger, people would really think twice

Posted 4/30/13 1:36 PM
 

AllyMally
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/13

881 total posts

Name:
Alyson

Re: How long should a drunk driver be in jail?

Posted by Pray4Baby2010

I'm tired of the everyone makes a mistake line here- he is responsible for kids and I would love to see him go away for a LONG LONG time and also never be able to drive again.

Maybe if they made the punishments stronger, people would really think twice



I agree with you, but in a world where they see people like Lindsey Lohan getting slaps on the wrist what can you do? Sadly the celebrities are setting an example of either favoritism or lax laws.

As for me I think 1 year in jail is fine IF they have their license revoked for at least 1-3 years and only re-instated after doing community service with teenagers to discuss the consequences of DUI. For me it's not so much the jail time, but about the license being gone.

Posted 4/30/13 1:52 PM
 

DaniJude
You're My Home <3

Member since 11/06

14815 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: How long should a drunk driver be in jail?

Posted by AllyMally

As for me I think 1 year in jail is fine IF they have their license revoked for at least 1-3 years and only re-instated after doing community service with teenagers to discuss the consequences of DUI. For me it's not so much the jail time, but about the license being gone.



That's such a nice idea, in theory.

Sadly, in over 63% of the fatal crashes that occur - the offender who caused the crash did not have a license at the time of the crash. They were either driving with it revoked, suspended, out of restriction, etc. Taking a license away in NO means, sadly, stops the driver from driving. The only thing that actually stops them from driving is high-tech advances to installing interlock-type devices in cars. The more we focus on that and the modifications of that technology, the more we'll actually see a reduction in deaths, crashes, injuries, etc.

Just to reference: the person my brother initially pulled over for drunk driving had no license and no insurance. The person that then hit my brother, also drunk, also had no license (hadn't had a valid license in over eight years), and also no insurance. In fact, Mr. Griffin had his license taken away in New York -it was suspended over 27 times. He then went to New Jersey and changed the spelling in his name to ILLEGALLY obtain another license in that state, beating the 'system'. Then, that was revoked over 20 times, different violations, etc. Then, the gentleman that hit my brother decided to go to Georgia and do the same thing. That was suspended over 18 times. They actually had to bring in an eight foot long graph to court to demonstrate the amount of times his license was taken away to the Jury. The person who killed Police Officer Glen Ciano, a 22 year veteran, was driving OUT of restriction on a conditional license stemming from an arrest only one month, to the date, earlier where he was arrested for drunk driving in Nassau County. So, they took his license away - said, only drive to work, and he was out driving at almost 2am thirty days later drunk and hit and killed PO Ciano. Oh God, sadly, I could go on and on with examples of people hit and killed -- all of whom were hit by people with no license.

Message edited 2013-04-30 14:07:52.580000.

Posted 4/30/13 2:06 PM
 

Tulips915
................

Member since 8/08

6851 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: How long should a drunk driver be in jail?

Posted by Pray4Baby2010

I'm tired of the everyone makes a mistake line here- he is responsible for kids and I would love to see him go away for a LONG LONG time and also never be able to drive again.

Maybe if they made the punishments stronger, people would really think twice


Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 4/30/13 2:06 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

How long should a drunk driver be in jail?

I really do not think I know a single drunk driver who did any time at all.
I think 7 days in jail would have a ton of people calling cabs.
In nc, it is all about fines. You have to have a breathalyzer installed in your car...it will not start if you have alcohol in your system...so you just get a friend to breathe in it for you.
If it was a mandatory 7 days in jail, I swear you would see a difference.
I am fine with a much longer sentence

Posted 4/30/13 6:37 PM
 

JustBrowsing
LIF Infant

Member since 3/13

68 total posts

Name:
OnlyTheShadowKnows

Re: How long should a drunk driver be in jail?

Forever.

Posted 4/30/13 6:41 PM
 

missfabulous
#mommyneedswine

Member since 6/09

10031 total posts

Name:
<font color=purple><b>Colleen</b>

Re: How long should a drunk driver be in jail?

Sadly, anyone I know who drove drunk was in jail for no more than 48 hours.

The minimum penalties should definitely be raised. Driving scares me so much for this reason.

Posted 4/30/13 7:30 PM
 

apb17
My guys

Member since 5/06

2173 total posts

Name:
Alli

Re: How long should a drunk driver be in jail?

My family (me, DH and 2 sons) were hit from behind by a drunk driver. He was 19, took his brother's license, was running from police, had a .14 BAC, was high and was on his way home from partying in Pt. Jeff. His plan was to drive all the way home to Commack. He hit us while WE were at a red light and HE was running from the police (after an officer was trying to wake him up from being passed out at the traffic light before the one we are at). He refused to get out of the car and needed to have all of his windows bashed in so that the police could physically drag him out of the passenger window (as my boys witnessed the whole thing).

Long story short, he cut a deal to do 200+ hours of community service. After lengthy letters to the DA and the judge, I was able to convince them to put him in jail. He got 2 weeks with other conditions that will last for many more years.

Two weeks...that's it. He seemed to get off easy...I was hurt and my boys were traumatized. My truck needed some work while his PARENTS' truck was totaled. Seems like he got off real easy...



Posted 4/30/13 7:38 PM
 

Dani922
Here's to new beginnings

Member since 10/07

7260 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: How long should a drunk driver be in jail?

Posted by DaniRella


That's such a nice idea, in theory.

Sadly, in over 63% of the fatal crashes that occur - the offender who caused the crash did not have a license at the time of the crash. They were either driving with it revoked, suspended, out of restriction, etc. Taking a license away in NO means, sadly, stops the driver from driving. The only thing that actually stops them from driving is high-tech advances to installing interlock-type devices in cars. The more we focus on that and the modifications of that technology, the more we'll actually see a reduction in deaths, crashes, injuries,




A high school friend was killed by a drunk driver a few years ago & the driver had no license. It had been taken away after a prior DWI.

I work in insurance claims. Several times I've discovered DWI from looking through the hospital records... nothin on the policr report because there was no arrest. I've seen 4x the legal limit with no arrest. Why?!

Message edited 2013-04-30 20:23:55.853000.

Posted 4/30/13 8:23 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: How long should a drunk driver be in jail?

I don't get it either.

A few months ago I was in the parking lot where Ciao Baby is in Massapequa and there was a big group of guys standing around bragging about how often the drive drunk, and how they've gotten off before.

I gave them a look to kill.

With that said, NOT saying that I condone it but I could understand someone making a mistake one night and getting behind the wheel of a car (especially a young kid), but it seems like all you hear about are the people with a history going back years and a major drug/alcohol problem.

Sadly I do know that these days, kids too can have a history going back years and years.

Posted 4/30/13 8:31 PM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

How long should a drunk driver be in jail?

I will never ever understand 1. why people continue to get into a vehicle and drive while drunk, buzzed, high, or some other form of intoxication and 2. why the punishment is not even close to as severe as it should be. It's disgusting and extremely scary.

Posted 4/30/13 8:43 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Drunk driver pleads guilty in the crash that killed my son's father. AudioLoveStory 7/13/11 31 Families Helping Families ™
Victims to blame for being hit by drunk driver. REALLY!??! Shorty 11/10/10 17 Families Helping Families ™
A Drunk Driver Crashed through my sister's HOUSE last night! DaniJude 9/1/07 28 Families Helping Families ™
Report: Diana's Driver Was Drunk MrsQ 12/11/06 0 Celebrities & Entertainment
Defense lawyers for defendant who killed little girl/limo driver while driving drunk Ambersmom 4/6/06 34 Families Helping Families ™
Drunk Driver asked Cops for directions Smileyd17 4/5/06 6 Families Helping Families ™