How do you control the whining...

Posted By Message

Tina1117
LIF Adult

Member since 11/07

1447 total posts

Name:
Tina

How do you control the whining...

DS is 3yrs and the whining is uncontrollable not to mention so annoying.

He whines about everything...even when he doesn't know he's whining he's whining. Do I do time outs for everytime he whines? I feel like that will be a whole day of time outs Chat Icon I've tried ignoring him and that doesn't work it at all. I'm at a lose I'd love any advice I can get.

TIA!

Posted 1/22/12 8:13 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

FranM
And so it goes....

Member since 9/05

2217 total posts

Name:

Re: How do you control the whining...

When DS was in that stage I would whine back at him in a "whiney bird" voice so he heard what it sounded like. Then I would model a big boy voice and ask him to repeat what he said in his big boy voice. Lots of praise and response for the big boy voice.

Once he started to get it I would remind him when the "whiney bird" came back that the whiney bird had to fly away and ask where my big boy was.

Posted 1/22/12 8:22 AM
 

Tina1117
LIF Adult

Member since 11/07

1447 total posts

Name:
Tina

Re: How do you control the whining...

Posted by FranM

When DS was in that stage I would whine back at him in a "whiney bird" voice so he heard what it sounded like. Then I would model a big boy voice and ask him to repeat what he said in his big boy voice. Lots of praise and response for the big boy voice.

Once he started to get it I would remind him when the "whiney bird" came back that the whiney bird had to fly away and ask where my big boy was.




I'll try anything. How long was your sons whining stage? This has been about 2months now. It was all of a sudden around the time he turned 3.

Like right now, he's whining and saying "hold, hold". It's like he's acting like he's 1 again.

Posted 1/22/12 8:33 AM
 

Lillykat
going along for the ride...

Member since 5/05

16253 total posts

Name:

Re: How do you control the whining...

DD#2 (2.5) has been doing this for a few months and it drives me crazy. It isn't like she can't ask for things - but she whines and cries as she says mommy can I have some apple juice please. I do a few things. 1st time I say I'm sorry I can't understand you when you whine if you want something you need to ask for it without the whine. Sometimes that works (I might have to say it 2x). If that doesn't work - I have tried one of two other things. Either I whine back and talk to her in the same whinny voice - which she usually stops and looks at me and then I ask if she likes that and she says no - and stops. OR I say okay we don't whine - when you are finished I'm happy to help you - I will be in x room when you are ready to ask like a big girl.

Posted 1/22/12 9:34 AM
 

Tina1117
LIF Adult

Member since 11/07

1447 total posts

Name:
Tina

Re: How do you control the whining...

Posted by Lillykat

DD#2 (2.5) has been doing this for a few months and it drives me crazy. It isn't like she can't ask for things - but she whines and cries as she says mommy can I have some apple juice please. I do a few things. 1st time I say I'm sorry I can't understand you when you whine if you want something you need to ask for it without the whine. Sometimes that works (I might have to say it 2x). If that doesn't work - I have tried one of two other things. Either I whine back and talk to her in the same whinny voice - which she usually stops and looks at me and then I ask if she likes that and she says no - and stops. OR I say okay we don't whine - when you are finished I'm happy to help you - I will be in x room when you are ready to ask like a big girl.



I've tried all this. It works for that instant but not in the long run. I wish there was an immediate fix...wishful thinking.

Posted 1/22/12 9:43 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Crying out of control & the whining is killing me! jmo 9/30/09 3 Parenting
Taking Maddie to Dr. tomorrow...the whining is out of control.... johnsae 2/5/08 20 Parenting
Repost... cuz I feel like whining about it... VirginiaDeb 6/22/08 1 Families Helping Families ™
Really bad whining at 7 months...is this a "stage" or am I in for it? johnsae 2/2/08 8 Parenting
crying and whining when a lot of people are around??? LoveBeingMrsT 12/9/07 11 Parenting
So Ava's been whining and bending over all day and... BaroqueMama 8/31/06 28 Parenting