Honda pilot vs compact SUV?

Posted By Message

LiveItUp
Love my babies!

Member since 8/11

4096 total posts

Name:

Honda pilot vs compact SUV?

Dh and I need to get a 2nd car. We have a sedan and our 4wd SUV just died, so we're looking for a replacement SUV. We had started out looking at the compact SUVs, like the Nissan rogue, Honda cr-v, Mazda cx5, etc... Because they are more in our price range and with just one child (possibly 2 in the future but most likely no more than 2) the size of a compact SUV would suit us just fine. We mostly just need the trunk space for our dog once in a while and trips to costco, and want something that can drive in the snow.

Well dh found a 2011 Honda pilot with low miles (20,000) for about the same price that we would spend on a brand new compact SUV, and he fell in love with it. I have to say I do really like the look of it, but I feel like it might be a waste for us to have the third row of seats and such a huge trunk. I think in the long run we might regret paying more for gas just to haul around such a large trunk that we don't really need.
Also, I'm nervous it would be hard to back up in and park. It's a good amount bigger than our SUV that died (2door ford explorer sport).

So can anyone who has a Honda pilot or has driven one, can you tell me what you love and/or don't love about it? How is it to drive and park, and how is the gas mileage? I've read some reviews that say it gets lower mileage than Honda claims it does.

And for anyone with a compact SUV, are you happy with it? Do you feel like it has enough trunk space and a good amount of room for 2 children? And do you feel confident driving it in the snow? Feel free to recommend one you really love.
Specifically, can anyone tell me about the Rogue? We're also strongly considering a 2011 rogue, as well as the 2014.

TIA!!

Posted 2/26/14 11:44 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MrsO
Big Brothers to Be

Member since 1/07

4521 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Honda pilot vs compact SUV?

We had a pilot and loved it. When we were expecting #3 we moved to the minivan. I nver had an issue parking it or managing in tight spaces. Would easily parallel park in nyc.

The advantage might be if you do have 2 dc's what ifyou want to bring another adult along for the ride. In a compact suv (cr-v) there is no room anywhere for additional people.

Posted 2/26/14 11:47 AM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Honda pilot vs compact SUV?

We have a 2014 Pilot, a 2012 VW Tiguan (compact SUV) and just got rid of a 2011 Nissan Rogue (for the Pilot).

Let me start off by saying I've never driven the Pilot. DH loves it. It's "his" car whereas mine is the Tiguan.

As far as the compact SUV and 2 kids, I'm sure plenty of people do it. We didn't see it working for us so we opted for a larger car instead of another small SUV. The tiguan, IMO, definitely wouldn't work with 2 kids. the trunk is SMALL. I think it's smaller than my Jetta was. But other than that, I looooove it. The Rogue was fine. Just fine, not amazing and not bad. The trunk was definitely bigger than the Tiguan but i don't think it was enough space to say, take a road trip with 2 kids for an extended weekend. Although again, i'm sure plenty of people do it.

Factor in your dog... I'd go larger.

Hope this helps a little!

Posted 2/26/14 11:52 AM
 

LiveItUp
Love my babies!

Member since 8/11

4096 total posts

Name:

Re: Honda pilot vs compact SUV?

Posted by MrsO


The advantage might be if you do have 2 dc's what ifyou want to bring another adult along for the ride. In a compact suv (cr-v) there is no room anywhere for additional people.



Good point!

Posted 2/26/14 11:55 AM
 

LiveItUp
Love my babies!

Member since 8/11

4096 total posts

Name:

Re: Honda pilot vs compact SUV?

Posted by Bearcat

We have a 2014 Pilot, a 2012 VW Tiguan (compact SUV) and just got rid of a 2011 Nissan Rogue (for the Pilot).

Let me start off by saying I've never driven the Pilot. DH loves it. It's "his" car whereas mine is the Tiguan.

As far as the compact SUV and 2 kids, I'm sure plenty of people do it. We didn't see it working for us so we opted for a larger car instead of another small SUV. The tiguan, IMO, definitely wouldn't work with 2 kids. the trunk is SMALL. I think it's smaller than my Jetta was. But other than that, I looooove it. The Rogue was fine. Just fine, not amazing and not bad. The trunk was definitely bigger than the Tiguan but i don't think it was enough space to say, take a road trip with 2 kids for an extended weekend. Although again, i'm sure plenty of people do it.

Factor in your dog... I'd go larger.

Hope this helps a little!







Thanks, very helpful!

Posted 2/26/14 11:56 AM
 

FTM427
LIF Adult

Member since 1/12

1261 total posts

Name:

Honda pilot vs compact SUV?

We have a Pilot and I love driving it. It is big, but I like having the space in the trunk, and its very more comfortable to ride in. Its easy to drive, and parking isnt horrible. We have a 2011 and it has a backup camera as well as parking sensors if you get too close to something. Its very easy to get DD in and out of carseat.

Posted 2/26/14 12:10 PM
 

ISpoilHim
I think I got this

Member since 11/10

1523 total posts

Name:
K

Honda pilot vs compact SUV?

I have a Saturn Vue and 1 DS. DH and I are both tall. It is tight for us to be in the car, which is the only reason I am getting rid of it. Passenger seat can not go all the back with the car seat behind it. It was an even tighter fit when we had the infant car seat. But like I said we are both over 6 foot tall. The Vue is slightly larger than the Rogue - my mom had one and it was definately smaller.

Message edited 2014-02-26 12:33:32.113000.

Posted 2/26/14 12:33 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Anyone have the Britax Advocate in a Honda Pilot? evenedan 8/7/13 4 Parenting
Anyone have a Honda Pilot? Love it or hate? specrn 3/14/12 15 Parenting
What other cars should i consider if I am interested in the Honda Pilot? MrsKellyBride 12/12/11 11 Families Helping Families ™
Tell me about the gas milage on your Honda Pilot please! MommyCorinne 3/21/11 4 Parenting
Anyone have these SUVs: Buick Enclave, GMC Acadia, Honda Pilot? What are their pros and cons? beautyq115 4/25/10 1 Families Helping Families ™
Does Anyone Have a Honda Pilot Who Can Give Me Advice On Installing The Graco Infant Snug Ride Car Seat? BabyLove08 8/23/08 6 Parenting