help with formula - Enfamil or Good Start?

Posted By Message

smp123
Praying for the LOs!

Member since 1/09

1630 total posts

Name:

help with formula - Enfamil or Good Start?

My pediatrician has recommended either Enfamil premium newborn or Gerber Good Start (orange or green can)

which one does everyone like the best? I am nursing now but am going to switch to formula soon

thank you!

Posted 11/11/10 8:20 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

spooks
So in love!

Member since 6/06

4378 total posts

Name:
Sarah

Re: help with formula - Enfamil or Good Start?

After the Similac thing, we went to Enfamil - I wasn;'t crazy about it - didn't mix well for me and something about it - we switched to Good Start Gentle Ease and I'm happier - still doesn't mix as good as Similac but DS seems happier on it.

Posted 11/11/10 8:24 PM
 

sunnygirl
loving life

Member since 1/07

5413 total posts

Name:
D

Re: help with formula - Enfamil or Good Start?

i used enfamil and good start protect plus, my dds are doing great with the good start

Posted 11/11/10 8:26 PM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: help with formula - Enfamil or Good Start?

The thing is, formula is different on different babies, some need more sensitive formulas. So you might just try both and see if she has any adverse reaction.

I really liked Good Start, because the first ingredient is whey protein and not a sugar. Both Protect Plus and Gentle are similar in that way.

I know many physicians, nurses and other health care pros, that feed their babies enfamil lipil and think its the best. But I always wonder if it has something to do with their marketing. Because no one could explain to me, what really is better about it that has been proven to be better.

I ended up actually with Similac Organic, once DS grew out of his gassy/fussy phase (around 3m) and could take "regular" formula. He was on Good Start Gentle prior to that and did very well on it.

Posted 11/11/10 8:58 PM
 

Lucky09
2017!

Member since 1/06

7539 total posts

Name:
DW

Re: help with formula - Enfamil or Good Start?

I am still nursing, but very occasionally will supplement with formula.

I was having the same debate and found this online that led me to lean towards the Enfamil. Also, the hospital where DS was born used Enfamil premium.
_________
Carnation Good Start's "comfort protein" is really an ingredient adjustment. Breastmilk has a certain whey:casein (protein) ratio. Similac and Enfamil products try to mimic that ratio (which they really can't, since it changes over time) and Carnation has decided to go 100% whey. Whey is theoretically easier to digest...hence "comfort" protein. I don't know what happens when you remove casein from your diet. I would guess it's in breastmilk for a reason. Carnation has less lactose, an adjustment needed to accommodate all the whey. Lactose is important in kids...see below.

source: http://www.drjen4kids.com/myths/mythformula.htm

Message edited 2010-11-11 21:21:34.417000.

Posted 11/11/10 9:21 PM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: help with formula - Enfamil or Good Start?

we used gerber goodstart gentle (orange) from birth to 4 months and we LOVED it Chat Icon

turns out DS has a milk allergy so we switched but it was great

Posted 11/11/10 9:33 PM
 

mig
LIF Adolescent

Member since 11/10

888 total posts

Name:

Re: help with formula - Enfamil or Good Start?

I have been through 6 different formula's with my DD. I loved Gerber Good Start Gentle Ease (orange can). She did very well on it! Unfortunately had to switch to a thicker rice starch formula due to reflux. It's always a hard decision, as all babies are different. Good luck with whichever you choose.

Posted 11/11/10 9:39 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: help with formula - Enfamil or Good Start?

Enfamil

Posted 11/11/10 9:46 PM
 

smp123
Praying for the LOs!

Member since 1/09

1630 total posts

Name:

Re: help with formula - Enfamil or Good Start?

thank you so much everyone!

i tried the good start RTF last night and my little guy kept spitting up - i think i am going to try the powder today and see how he does.

the post regarding the casein and the Enfamil is really interesting also - so maybe i'll end up switching to that so the boys can get some casein instead of 100% whey

this is so frustrating and it's making me feel so badly - i wish i could exclusively pump for them, but i have mastitis and the constant pumping really takes so much time away from them.

i never knew feeding the babies would give me this much stress!!

thank you all for your help!

Posted 11/12/10 9:01 AM
 

BeachMom
Love my 4 kiddos!

Member since 11/08

8346 total posts

Name:
Kristie

Re: help with formula - Enfamil or Good Start?

We're using Enfamil this time around.

We have used GoodStart and Similac in the past but found the least reaction in my DD from the ENfamil and she digests it better.

Overall it's going to be how your LO takes to the formula that will probably be the ultimate deciding factor in which one to use.

With my last DD we used the Similac sensitive(even though it had less DHA) because it didn't constipate our DD like the Enfamil did.

Pick one, try it and see how they do and go from there, because what may look good on paper as the best nutritional wise isn't always what works best for your baby.

Posted 11/12/10 9:06 AM
 

smp123
Praying for the LOs!

Member since 1/09

1630 total posts

Name:

Re: help with formula - Enfamil or Good Start?

Posted by BeachMom

We're using Enfamil this time around.

We have used GoodStart and Similac in the past but found the least reaction in my DD from the ENfamil and she digests it better.

Overall it's going to be how your LO takes to the formula that will probably be the ultimate deciding factor in which one to use.

With my last DD we used the Similac sensitive(even though it had less DHA) because it didn't constipate our DD like the Enfamil did.

Pick one, try it and see how they do and go from there, because what may look good on paper as the best nutritional wise isn't always what works best for your baby.



how long did you give your DD on each formula until you decided to switch?

i was giving the boys good start probiotic for a few days and the past two days have been miserable - i think the probiotics really upset their stomachs. so i switched and they are still fussy, and i'm not sure if it's the new formula or leftovers from the last one!

thanks!

Posted 11/12/10 9:10 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
BTDT moms - Which formula did you use?? Similac Sensitive, Enfamil Gentlease or Good Start.... missrock 2/20/09 25 Parenting
Enfamil and Good Start formula checks...up for grabs! TAKEN MrsRivera 1/17/09 0 Parenting
Enfamil & Good Start Formula coupons to trade Reese32 12/5/09 1 Parenting
Nestle Good start and enfamil formula up for grabs Jacksmommy 3/16/09 1 Parenting
is this a good prioce for formula? 04bride 9/12/06 2 Parenting
Nestle Good Start Formula Coupons greek627 8/30/06 0 Parenting