Help me understand Romney and birth control

Posted By Message

DeniseMarie
<3

Member since 8/07

10682 total posts

Name:

Help me understand Romney and birth control

The other thread got me thinking and researching. I am still an undecided voter and I want to know everything I can about Romney and women's issues.

Does he plan on restriting access to birth control? And if so, what exactly does that mean? Who will it impact?

Posted 10/19/12 9:54 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Help me understand Romney and birth control


Go to http://www.plannedparenthoodaction.org/

This also has some good info:
http://www.factcheck.org/2012/09/day-2-more-convention-canards/
Coverage for Birth Control

Cecile Richards, president of Planned Parenthood, was wrong when she said Romney and Ryan “are committed to ending insurance coverage for birth control.” That’s not what the Romney-Ryan campaign has said at all. Instead, both men have spoken against a government mandate requiring most employers and insurance companies to cover birth control at no cost to employees.

Romney first came out against the Obama administration’s requirement that most employers, including religious-affiliated groups including Catholic hospitals, provide birth control coverage with no copays. Romney said in early February that the Obama rule “tramples on religious freedom, taking particular aim at Roman Catholics. The Obama administration is forcing religious institutions to choose between violating their conscience or dropping health care coverage for their employees, effectively destroying their ability to carry on their work.”

Ryan, too, lambasted the mandate on religious grounds.

The Obama administration later modified its rule to say religious-affiliated organizations wouldn’t have to provide such coverage. However, in those cases, insurance companies would have to provide birth control coverage for free.

Romney said he also supported an amendment from Missouri Sen. Roy Blunt (which was subsequently defeated) that would have given any employer the ability to opt out of the birth control mandate on religious grounds. Employers also could opt out of any requirement in the Affordable Care Act. That’s what Richards was referring to when she said Romney and Ryan “would turn women’s health care decisions over to our bosses.”

Romney’s campaign said he would eliminate the birth control mandate altogether. So, under a Romney presidency, employers wouldn’t be required to offer coverage that included contraception with no copay. But many employers already offered contraception coverage without such a mandate. A 2010 survey from the Kaiser Family Foundation found that 85 percent of large firms offered coverage of birth control — though copays among the plans likely varied. And 28 states had already required insurance carriers to cover contraceptives, with exemptions.

There’s a big difference between ending a mandate that all employers and insurers provide free coverage of contraception and “ending insurance coverage for birth control” altogether, as Richards claimed.

Posted 10/19/12 10:05 AM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Help me understand Romney and birth control

Chat Icon
Such a solid response... nicely done!

Posted 10/19/12 10:30 AM
 

VikingChick
LIF Adult

Member since 5/11

1024 total posts

Name:
Anna

Re: Help me understand Romney and birth control

Re the Blunt bill- it would have allowed any employer the right to deny health insurance coverage for any benefit based on a moral conviction- Romney supported this. Do we really want our employers deciding which medical procedures are "moral"? Birth control, infertility treatments, abortions, the list goes on and on...
He would also defund planned parenthood, which provides cancer screenings, well-woman exams, and birth control (in addition to abortions, which are not federally funded).
He also backs legislation like the personhood amendment, which seeks to define life at conception (could have the effect of banning common forms of birth control and in some cases, in vitro fertilization in addition to abortion).
He has also said that states should have the right to ban contraception-- he said that Griswold v. Connecticut was decided incorrectly-- in this case the Supreme Court ruled that a law that banned the sale of contraceptives (even to married couples) was unconstitutional.
While you can read Romney's record a number of ways, since he has changed positions several times, all the above are things he has actually said, and these positions frighten me- A LOT.

Posted 10/19/12 11:46 AM
 

BeachGrl
LIF Adult

Member since 10/11

2140 total posts

Name:
Kristy

Help me understand Romney and birth control

Birth control has NEVER been covered for me the past 12 years, I always paid out of pocket for it, under both obama and bush it was never covered, so to me it doesn't make a difference either way.

I did see a clip of a woman asking him "why are you against birth control?" and he said "I'm not, I believe life begins at conception, birth control prevents that from even happening, so I have zero problem with birth control" And then he went on to say how he would never take it away, etc

Posted 10/19/12 12:24 PM
 

DeniseMarie
<3

Member since 8/07

10682 total posts

Name:

Re: Help me understand Romney and birth control

Posted by nrthshgrl


Go to http://www.plannedparenthoodaction.org/

This also has some good info:
http://www.factcheck.org/2012/09/day-2-more-convention-canards/
Coverage for Birth Control

Cecile Richards, president of Planned Parenthood, was wrong when she said Romney and Ryan “are committed to ending insurance coverage for birth control.” That’s not what the Romney-Ryan campaign has said at all. Instead, both men have spoken against a government mandate requiring most employers and insurance companies to cover birth control at no cost to employees.

Romney first came out against the Obama administration’s requirement that most employers, including religious-affiliated groups including Catholic hospitals, provide birth control coverage with no copays. Romney said in early February that the Obama rule “tramples on religious freedom, taking particular aim at Roman Catholics. The Obama administration is forcing religious institutions to choose between violating their conscience or dropping health care coverage for their employees, effectively destroying their ability to carry on their work.”

Ryan, too, lambasted the mandate on religious grounds.

The Obama administration later modified its rule to say religious-affiliated organizations wouldn’t have to provide such coverage. However, in those cases, insurance companies would have to provide birth control coverage for free.

Romney said he also supported an amendment from Missouri Sen. Roy Blunt (which was subsequently defeated) that would have given any employer the ability to opt out of the birth control mandate on religious grounds. Employers also could opt out of any requirement in the Affordable Care Act. That’s what Richards was referring to when she said Romney and Ryan “would turn women’s health care decisions over to our bosses.”

Romney’s campaign said he would eliminate the birth control mandate altogether. So, under a Romney presidency, employers wouldn’t be required to offer coverage that included contraception with no copay. But many employers already offered contraception coverage without such a mandate. A 2010 survey from the Kaiser Family Foundation found that 85 percent of large firms offered coverage of birth control — though copays among the plans likely varied. And 28 states had already required insurance carriers to cover contraceptives, with exemptions.

There’s a big difference between ending a mandate that all employers and insurers provide free coverage of contraception and “ending insurance coverage for birth control” altogether, as Richards claimed.



thank you!!!

Posted 10/19/12 3:56 PM
 

VikingChick
LIF Adult

Member since 5/11

1024 total posts

Name:
Anna

Re: Help me understand Romney and birth control

Posted by BeachGrl

Birth control has NEVER been covered for me the past 12 years, I always paid out of pocket for it, under both obama and bush it was never covered, so to me it doesn't make a difference either way.

I did see a clip of a woman asking him "why are you against birth control?" and he said "I'm not, I believe life begins at conception, birth control prevents that from even happening, so I have zero problem with birth control" And then he went on to say how he would never take it away, etc



Unless you work for a church or similar, birth control should begin to be covered by your insurance plan soon. Most plans, unless they were "grandfathered", have to start providing coverage for it.

Posted 10/19/12 4:00 PM
 

BeachGrl
LIF Adult

Member since 10/11

2140 total posts

Name:
Kristy

Re: Help me understand Romney and birth control

Posted by anskiv

Posted by BeachGrl

Birth control has NEVER been covered for me the past 12 years, I always paid out of pocket for it, under both obama and bush it was never covered, so to me it doesn't make a difference either way.

I did see a clip of a woman asking him "why are you against birth control?" and he said "I'm not, I believe life begins at conception, birth control prevents that from even happening, so I have zero problem with birth control" And then he went on to say how he would never take it away, etc



Unless you work for a church or similar, birth control should begin to be covered by your insurance plan soon. Most plans, unless they were "grandfathered", have to start providing coverage for it.



Good to know, thanks!

Posted 10/19/12 6:03 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Birth Control Question (not pill) Jesaroo 9/19/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
Birth Control Question?? NoStressMom 9/13/05 3 Families Helping Families ™
birth control and preganancy GenLCSW 9/12/05 15 Pregnancy
Post Partum Birth Control BabyAvocado 7/31/05 16 Parenting
weight gain after stopping birth control pills? Laura1976 6/23/05 16 TTC
Female Question regarding Birth Control.... monkadoo 5/31/05 20 Families Helping Families ™