Help me decide on an RE
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
Help me decide on an RE I'm in CT so I don't expect that anyone has specific feedback (but if you do, please share), but I need help deciding which RE to work with based on pros/cons. I don't know anyone personally who used either. I'm 37, 38 in July. Message edited 2015-03-18 08:55:51.567000. |
|
Posted 3/17/15 10:30 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Help me decide on an RE I'm not sure if this info is available for either practice, but I would look at whether or not you'll be seen by and monitored by a doctor vs. a technician each time. |
|
Posted 3/17/15 11:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: Help me decide on an RE Posted by LIRascal I'm not sure if this info is available for either practice, but I would look at whether or not you'll be seen by and monitored by a doctor vs. a technician each time. Also important: do you have to go to a lab for blood work, semen analysis and other procedures like hsg? Or are they on site? Whatever you choose, best of luck! ![]() Good questions! Thanks...I'll call tomorrow. |
|
Posted 3/17/15 11:40 PM
|
|
|
Re: Help me decide on an RE Looking at the SART stats, the number of patients who are being done in the two groups are small (versus the large city practices). The stats are hard to compare with that in mind (one patient one way or other could make a difference). The numbers, to me, look very similar for the big things (percent transfers that result in live births & percent of cycles that result in live births). |
|
Posted 3/18/15 8:53 AM
|
|
|
Re: Help me decide on an RE Posted by nycgirl Looking at the SART stats, the number of patients who are being done in the two groups are small (versus the large city practices). The stats are hard to compare with that in mind (one patient one way or other could make a difference). The numbers, to me, look very similar for the big things (percent transfers that result in live births & percent of cycles that result in live births). I used RMA, but had my IVF in Manhattan. I was happy with them. I do know someone who used the Greenwich group. She was happy with them. Personal reviews are tough to manage because a LOT of happiness depends on whether it worked for that person. My OB does not recommend my RE & visa versa (but this is more due to the referral pattern of the doctors & could be due to personality in many cases). Location is important (but not a sole factor). My RE office was 15 minutes from home, 1 hour from work (at the time I'd be commuting). Still chose them because the place closer to work had much worse stats. "Money driven" is true of any practice. It's not volunteer work. Actually, when I paid cash for most of my cycle (before insurances covered what they sometimes now do), I think my "service" was better (?better staff maybe?) than now. I always liked my own doctor personally: but that may just be a personality thing & the fact that he explained things very well to me (and like to use email, my preferred method of communication). So, conclusion, you could chose either group. Personally, I'd chose RMA, but I'm biased in that I had a good experience with them and it worked for me. Thanks for your feedback!! Did you see the same dr at RMA every time? I heard that you see different drs at each appt. What was that like? I was leaning toward RMA but my husband is leaning toward Greenwich because he knows that feeling taken care of and the personal service is a big thing for me so he feels I would be happier at Greenwich...so now I don't know what to do.
|
|
Posted 3/18/15 8:59 AM
|
|
|
Re: Help me decide on an RE Posted by jodi714 Posted by nycgirl Looking at the SART stats, the number of patients who are being done in the two groups are small (versus the large city practices). The stats are hard to compare with that in mind (one patient one way or other could make a difference). The numbers, to me, look very similar for the big things (percent transfers that result in live births & percent of cycles that result in live births). I used RMA, but had my IVF in Manhattan. I was happy with them. I do know someone who used the Greenwich group. She was happy with them. Personal reviews are tough to manage because a LOT of happiness depends on whether it worked for that person. My OB does not recommend my RE & visa versa (but this is more due to the referral pattern of the doctors & could be due to personality in many cases). Location is important (but not a sole factor). My RE office was 15 minutes from home, 1 hour from work (at the time I'd be commuting). Still chose them because the place closer to work had much worse stats. "Money driven" is true of any practice. It's not volunteer work. Actually, when I paid cash for most of my cycle (before insurances covered what they sometimes now do), I think my "service" was better (?better staff maybe?) than now. I always liked my own doctor personally: but that may just be a personality thing & the fact that he explained things very well to me (and like to use email, my preferred method of communication). So, conclusion, you could chose either group. Personally, I'd chose RMA, but I'm biased in that I had a good experience with them and it worked for me. Thanks for your feedback!! Did you see the same dr at RMA every time? I heard that you see different drs at each appt. What was that like? I was leaning toward RMA but my husband is leaning toward Greenwich because he knows that feeling taken care of and the personal service is a big thing for me so he feels I would be happier at Greenwich...so now I don't know what to do. I did see the same Dr at RMA each time (I went to the Westchester satellite office, but I'm pretty sure people in the city tend to "stick" with one Dr too). I did have different people when it came time to IVF though (IUI was done in office by my Dr). For IVF, by chance, my Dr did one (very successful) retrieval & one (not successful) transfer. Communication was very good the other times (they knew my request to have only one transfer the second time around & had it in my chart). With a smaller practice, the only thing that I get nervous of is the quality of the lab (how your embryos grow & fertilize is out of your hands). By stats, Greenwich looks ok. Don't worry: there is no "wrong" choice. |
|
Posted 3/18/15 9:35 AM
|
|
|
Re: Help me decide on an RE I just posted this on the person asking about RMA in Garden City. This is just my experience and my opinions: |
|
Posted 3/19/15 8:06 PM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Work - did you go back and decide to leave? | KAS | 8/2/06 | 6 | Parenting |
| Another carseat Dilema...I can't decide on a pattern.... | Dani00518 | 7/12/06 | 12 | Parenting |
| Photo Album versus Scrapbook...how do you decide where the photos go??? | suvenR | 6/10/06 | 6 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Help me decide on a digital camera- GOT ONE! (UPDATED 6/10/06) | Bri | 5/29/06 | 11 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| How do you decide on what kind of take home outfit to bring with you? | preciouslove | 5/1/06 | 15 | Pregnancy |
| Pls. help decide on nursery.. | KittyCat | 4/24/06 | 9 | Pregnancy |






