Grammar question

Posted By Message

klingklang77
kraftwerk!

Member since 7/06

11489 total posts

Name:
Völlig losgelöst

Grammar question

Which is correct?

There is a sofa, a TV, and a table in my living room.

There are a sofa, a TV, and a table in my living room.

I know the sentence isn't the best sentence, but which one do you think is correct? And why? Chat Icon

Posted 10/25/11 6:58 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

peanutbutter2
Carpe diem!

Member since 11/10

5287 total posts

Name:

Re: Grammar question

There is

The word should agree with the first noun.

Message edited 2011-10-25 19:04:18.903000.

Posted 10/25/11 7:03 PM
 

jlk51496
Mom of 3 - YIKES! =)

Member since 10/09

6758 total posts

Name:
Katie

Re: Grammar question

Posted by JAAMS

There is

The word should agree with the first noun.



agreed..if you had more than one sofa
then it would be:

"There are sofas, a chair..." etc

Posted 10/25/11 7:10 PM
 

klingklang77
kraftwerk!

Member since 7/06

11489 total posts

Name:
Völlig losgelöst

Re: Grammar question

Posted by JAAMS

There is

The word should agree with the first noun.



I think there is sounds correct, but the subject is the sofa, the TV, and the table. So wouldn't it be there are? For example:

A sofa, a TV, and a table are in my living room.

You wouldn't use is, KWIM?

This is where I'm scratching my head. There is just sounds correct being that all the nouns are singular, but the rules say there are.

Posted 10/25/11 7:11 PM
 

peanutbutter2
Carpe diem!

Member since 11/10

5287 total posts

Name:

Re: Grammar question

Posted by klingklang77

Posted by JAAMS

There is

The word should agree with the first noun.



I think there is sounds correct, but the subject is the sofa, the TV, and the table. So wouldn't it be there are? For example:

A sofa, a TV, and a table are in my living room.

You wouldn't use is, KWIM?

This is where I'm scratching my head. There is just sounds correct being that all the nouns are singular, but the rules say there are.



I totally get what you're saying. I'm pretty sure it's because of the construction of the sentence.
Passive constructions generally change the verb (The ball was thrown by the boy...not The boy threw the ball), so I think that's why.

I think it's just better to say "A sofa, a tv, and a table are in my living room" since it's active and avoids all confusion Chat Icon

Posted 10/25/11 7:18 PM
 

klingklang77
kraftwerk!

Member since 7/06

11489 total posts

Name:
Völlig losgelöst

Re: Grammar question

Posted by JAAMS

Posted by klingklang77

Posted by JAAMS

There is

The word should agree with the first noun.



I think there is sounds correct, but the subject is the sofa, the TV, and the table. So wouldn't it be there are? For example:

A sofa, a TV, and a table are in my living room.

You wouldn't use is, KWIM?

This is where I'm scratching my head. There is just sounds correct being that all the nouns are singular, but the rules say there are.



I totally get what you're saying. I'm pretty sure it's because of the construction of the sentence.
Passive constructions generally change the verb (The ball was thrown by the boy...not The boy threw the ball), so I think that's why.

I think it's just better to say "A sofa, a tv, and a table are in my living room" since it's active and avoids all confusion Chat Icon



Yeah, I get what you are saying. I've googled it and haven't found anything clear about it. I'm just marking my beginner, senior, ESL students writing and I'm trying to think of a way to keep it really, really simple. I, personally, would not say that, but I just want them to get the concept.

Posted 10/25/11 7:21 PM
 

emilylives
biking

Member since 12/09

2163 total posts

Name:
Emily

Re: Grammar question

According to this, and I really have no reason to trust it and it sounds off, "there are" would technically be correct, but "there is" is used casually by native speakers.

According to this, again, no reason to trust, the British say "there are" if referring to multiple objects and Americans say "there is," referring to the first object.

Posted 10/25/11 8:58 PM
 

bookworm
Two Little Rosebuds

Member since 8/09

2106 total posts

Name:

Re: Grammar question

"There" is the subject, not the series of objects. The subject determines the conjugation of the verb.

In general, the grammar rules for English are often backwards and nonsensical (ever since the 1600's when they tried to align a Germanic dialect with the grammar rules of formal Latin to "elevate" the language). Therefore, I go with what's less awkward. Over the years we have habitually broken some of the more annoying rules and thus officially accepted grammar use that's technically incorrect.

Consider: Ending a sentence in a preposition is something up with which I will not put!

It's just not good sentence construction even though it's correct. So we end a sentence in a preposition even though it's wrong for the purpose of avoiding awkwardness and stating our point clearly.

There are three things in my living room: a sofa, a TV, and a table. (technically correct)

There is a sofa, a TV, and a table in my living room. (technically incorrect but less awkward than using "are")

Message edited 2011-10-26 05:58:51.477000.

Posted 10/26/11 5:45 AM
 

klingklang77
kraftwerk!

Member since 7/06

11489 total posts

Name:
Völlig losgelöst

Re: Grammar question

Posted by bookworm

"There" is the subject, not the series of objects. The subject determines the conjugation of the verb.




Thanks for your response. Maybe I'm definitely over thinking this, as I often do, but isn't the "real" subject what follows the 'be' verb? I mean that's the one that is doing the action. I see that 'there' is the subject, but is it really? KWIM?

I've been teaching grammar for years, and I've done many linguistics courses, but for some reason I'm stuck on this. Chat Icon Teaching absolute beginners will do that to you. Chat Icon My class tonight consists of older Germans who just love their rules...

Posted 10/26/11 7:52 AM
 

peanutbutter2
Carpe diem!

Member since 11/10

5287 total posts

Name:

Re: Grammar question

Posted by klingklang77

Posted by bookworm

"There" is the subject, not the series of objects. The subject determines the conjugation of the verb.




Thanks for your response. Maybe I'm definitely over thinking this, as I often do, but isn't the "real" subject what follows the 'be' verb? I mean that's the one that is doing the action. I see that 'there' is the subject, but is it really? KWIM?

I've been teaching grammar for years, and I've done many linguistics courses, but for some reason I'm stuck on this. Chat Icon Teaching absolute beginners will do that to you. Chat Icon My class tonight consists of older Germans who just love their rules...



I'm almost positive that "there" is not the subject.

Purdue Online Writing Lab

This thread has me so intrigued/confused. Chat Icon

Posted 10/26/11 9:12 AM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Grammar question

There is. The trick here is to take each noun individually. "There are a sofa in the living room." doesn't make any sense.

Same thing goes for groups. A lot of people think that because a group is more than one person/place/thing you need to use a plural verb, but that's not the case if you are talking about the group as one collective thing.

ETA: In this case, I honestly do not believe google. I am 110% positive that this is the way I was taught in school and that according to those standards, "There is" is the only correct way.

Message edited 2011-10-26 09:59:58.347000.

Posted 10/26/11 9:57 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Grammar question

Posted by bookworm

"There" is the subject, not the series of objects. The subject determines the conjugation of the verb.



This was my reasoning too. (Not a grammar expert though)

Posted 10/26/11 10:16 AM
 

tourist

Member since 5/05

10425 total posts

Name:

Re: Grammar question

Posted by jilliibabii

There is. The trick here is to take each noun individually. "There are a sofa in the living room." doesn't make any sense.

Same thing goes for groups. A lot of people think that because a group is more than one person/place/thing you need to use a plural verb, but that's not the case if you are talking about the group as one collective thing.


This is correct. If the items were plural, it would be "are".
There are sofas, tvs, and tables in my living room.

This is for American English. I am not 100% postive on Britsh English, but I do know that in British English, as posted above, groups are treated as pural; for example:
U2 are a rock band vs. U2 is a rock band.

Message edited 2011-10-26 10:19:48.587000.

Posted 10/26/11 10:19 AM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Grammar question

Posted by tourist

Posted by jilliibabii

There is. The trick here is to take each noun individually. "There are a sofa in the living room." doesn't make any sense.

Same thing goes for groups. A lot of people think that because a group is more than one person/place/thing you need to use a plural verb, but that's not the case if you are talking about the group as one collective thing.


This is correct. If the items were plural, it would be "are".
There are sofas, tvs, and tables in my living room.

This is for American English. I am not 100% postive on Britsh English, but I do know that in British English, as posted above, groups are treated as pural; for example:
U2 are a rock band vs. U2 is a rock band.



Who cares if they wrote the language, that sounds dumb. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/26/11 10:30 AM
 

HoneyBadger
YourWorstNightmare.

Member since 10/06

15979 total posts

Name:
BahBahBlackJeep

Re: Grammar question

Is

Posted 10/26/11 10:31 AM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Grammar question

I think this is one of the cases where "are" is technically correct since it is multiple singular nouns connected by "and", but "is" is the more common usage and "sounds better".

Sometimes when I get into something tricky and technical like this, depending on the audience, I will go with the one that sounds better, even if it is not technically correct.

Singular subjects connected by "and" = plural noun.

Posted 10/26/11 11:11 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Grammar experts... I have a question for you... JP826 7/9/09 5 Families Helping Families ™
ok grammar experts.... a question for you... wannabemom 5/20/09 6 Families Helping Families ™
grammar question... me or i? MarathonKnitter 10/8/08 23 Families Helping Families ™
Grammar pros - I have a quick question.... Anniegrl 5/22/07 13 Families Helping Families ™
grammar police - seasons greetings question... anon 11/24/06 19 Families Helping Families ™
GrammAr Question!! KPtoys 10/17/06 10 Families Helping Families ™