Grammar question #3005

Posted By Message

klingklang77
kraftwerk!

Member since 7/06

11489 total posts

Name:
Völlig losgelöst

Grammar question #3005

Which do you think is correct?

Brilliant careers have ended in cases of personal failure and psychological trauma for many athletes.

or

Brilliant careers have ended in cases of personal failures and psychological traumas for many athletes.

or

Brilliant careers have ended in cases of personal failures and psychological trauma for many athletes.

And why?

I think the first, but I don't know how to explain it. Parallel structure?

I'm teaching a test course at the moment and they throw in some really hard to explain examples at times. All I can think of is it just sounds right, but that isn't a good enough answer. There has to be a rule.

Thanks!

Posted 6/12/13 11:11 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

evrythng4areason
And then there were 4

Member since 1/10

5224 total posts

Name:
Kayla

Grammar question #3005

I would think the first also, but I'm not sure why other than it sounds right, and I haven't really heard of "psychological traumas"

Posted 6/13/13 8:56 AM
 

Pumpkin1
LIF Adult

Member since 12/05

3715 total posts

Name:

Re: Grammar question #3005

I don't believe that you can pluralize "trauma." However, all of these sentences are in the passive voice, so while gramatically correct, I prefer the active voice "Many atheletes have ended their careers with personal failures and physical trauma."

Posted 6/13/13 9:02 AM
 

SusiBee
. . . . .

Member since 3/09

8268 total posts

Name:
S

Re: Grammar question #3005

I am inclined to choose number one, only because "cases" is already plural.
If failures and traumas is pluralized, it would seem redundant.

Posted 6/13/13 9:03 AM
 

BriBri2u
L'amore vince sempre

Member since 5/05

9320 total posts

Name:
Mrs. B

Re: Grammar question #3005

Posted by SusiBee

I am inclined to choose number one, only because "cases" is already plural.
If failures and traumas is pluralized, it would seem redundant.



Same

Posted 6/13/13 9:05 AM
 

klingklang77
kraftwerk!

Member since 7/06

11489 total posts

Name:
Völlig losgelöst

Re: Grammar question #3005

Posted by Pumpkin1

I don't believe that you can pluralize "trauma." However, all of these sentences are in the passive voice, so while gramatically correct, I prefer the active voice "Many atheletes have ended their careers with personal failures and physical trauma."



I see what you mean, but they get a text and they have to fill in the correct word form like this:

Brilliant careers have ended in cases of personal _________ (fail) and ___________ (psychology) trauma.


Susibee I see what you are saying about redundancy, but then what about kinds of, like there were all kinds of cookies at the party.

I agree trauma can't really be plural, but failure can, can't it?

Thanks for the responses!

Posted 6/13/13 9:08 AM
 

evrythng4areason
And then there were 4

Member since 1/10

5224 total posts

Name:
Kayla

Grammar question #3005

failures can be plural, but i would think for the structure you would keep things consistent

Posted 6/13/13 9:18 AM
 

halfbaked
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6937 total posts

Name:

Re: Grammar question #3005

Posted by evrythng4areason

failures can be plural, but i would think for the structure you would keep things consistent



I agree- it would be the first.

Posted 6/13/13 9:54 AM
 

sunnyflies
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1757 total posts

Name:

Grammar question #3005

The first is correct because although "cases" is plural the word is actually referring to multiple instances of individual failures and traumas, not multiple cases of individuals failing and being traumatized several times, so failure and trauma would be singular. IMHO

Posted 6/13/13 3:49 PM
 

klingklang77
kraftwerk!

Member since 7/06

11489 total posts

Name:
Völlig losgelöst

Grammar question #3005

Thanks everyone! Luckily, I didn't get too many questions about that particular question-- phew!

Posted 6/13/13 9:02 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Grammar Question DRMom 10/15/07 4 Families Helping Families ™
Grammar people-I have a question! LuckySV 7/3/07 7 Families Helping Families ™
Question for you grammar experts.... lipglossjunky73 6/15/07 11 Families Helping Families ™
Grammar pros - I have a quick question.... Anniegrl 5/22/07 13 Families Helping Families ™
grammar police - seasons greetings question... anon 11/24/06 19 Families Helping Families ™
GrammAr Question!! KPtoys 10/17/06 10 Families Helping Families ™