Good Start Gentle vs. Good Start Protect

Posted By Message

teaforthree
My Handsome Boy!

Member since 12/10

2549 total posts

Name:

Good Start Gentle vs. Good Start Protect

Is "Protect" just "Gentle", but with probiotics for the immune system?

That's what I assumed, so I've been going with "Protect" figuring it's the best.

But, if my DS has a lot of gas and a seemingly sensitive belly, should I try "Gentle"?

Also, is there a difference in the powder mix formula and RTF regarding effects on the baby? Do you think RTF will keep him full longer since it's thicker? Do I have to do a gradual transition if I switch to RTF?

They don't make Protect in RTF... should I ADD probiotic if I try Gentle?

Lots of questions... thanks for your input!

Posted 10/18/11 10:38 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

LINewbie
Tigger the the Rescue!

Member since 8/08

5647 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Good Start Gentle vs. Good Start Protect

IDK the difference and all, but I found DS does best on the Gentle (vs. other brands, never tried Protect). It helps his get the gas out and makes him less fussy. (The first few days we use it he toots like crazy then he settles into it).

I found no difference in RTF vs formula in fullness. But DS was hungry every 2 hours for many months, no matter what, so that just might have been him.

I wouldn't add anything to anything lol

I would only use the protect, really, if he was a very sick baby or needed to strengthen his immune system for some reason.

Posted 10/19/11 11:50 AM
 

teaforthree
My Handsome Boy!

Member since 12/10

2549 total posts

Name:

Re: Good Start Gentle vs. Good Start Protect

Posted by LINewbie

IDK the difference and all, but I found DS does best on the Gentle (vs. other brands, never tried Protect). It helps his get the gas out and makes him less fussy. (The first few days we use it he toots like crazy then he settles into it).

I found no difference in RTF vs formula in fullness. But DS was hungry every 2 hours for many months, no matter what, so that just might have been him.

I wouldn't add anything to anything lol

I would only use the protect, really, if he was a very sick baby or needed to strengthen his immune system for some reason.



Thank you!

I'm wondering if I can give him RTF to try if he's only been on formula all this time? I'm hoping that it might keep him more full longer since my pediatrician really wants to get him to go 4 hours between feedings.

Posted 10/19/11 1:03 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Spinoff to my own post...Nestle Good Start v. Good Start Gentle Plus missrock 5/1/09 0 Parenting
Good Start Gentle Plus - can it be almost too easy to digest? TaraHutch 1/18/10 0 Parenting
rtf Similac Sensitive (RS) & powder Gerber Good Start Gentle Plus to give away summerBaby10 11/29/10 1 Parenting
Giving away a new 30.8oz can of Gerber Good Start Gentle Plus summerBaby10 11/8/10 2 Parenting
Good Start Protect Plus? LittleBlueBug 3/3/10 5 Parenting
Nestle Good Start Gentle Plus? LoveMySMT09 10/7/09 2 Parenting