Good Sam vs. Southside

Forum Opinion Poll
Good Sam 12 70.59%
Southside 3 17.65%
Both are great 1 5.88%
Niether one 1 5.88%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Good Sam Vs. Southside

Posted By Message

bella321
Blessed!

Member since 3/09

1952 total posts

Name:
Kristy

Good Sam Vs. Southside

My OB is affiliated with both Good Sam and Southside. I'm not sure if I will have the option to choose but I'm wondering if I can tour both and then decide. Is that normally a choice? Also, does anyone have any info about the maternity experience at either place? I've heard that Good Sam has a great neonatal dept but that the rooms are small and dirty? Please help clear this confusion! TIA

Posted 9/18/09 7:37 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

DeniseMarie
<3

Member since 8/07

10682 total posts

Name:

Re: Good Sam Vs. Southside

I delivered at good sam. I am sure you can tour both.

I loved, loved, loved good sam. Yeah - I guess the rooms are small but it didnt really bother me. The nurses were GREAT. I cant say enough about them. I had some issues when I delivered and I was really upset the first couple of days (I had a hard time getting over the fact that I was asleep for the delivery for medical reasons and I was team Chat Icon ) + my hormones were out of control. The nurses would sit and talk to me and reassure me. They were EXCELLENT. I was out of it the first day so the nurses showed DH how to change her diaper , swaddle, etc. They were just wonderful.

And they allowed pretty much anyone to come and visit me and anytime during the day. I had a ton of people in my room ( i didnt havr a roomate) and they never complained. Security did ask everyone to leave by 8pm, but thats understandable. (except DH, he stayed as long as he wanted)

the rooms were DEF not dirty.

HTH

Posted 9/18/09 7:46 PM
 

Coley
LIF Adolescent

Member since 6/09

546 total posts

Name:
N

Re: Good Sam Vs. Southside

Posted by bella321

My OB is affiliated with both Good Sam and Southside. I'm not sure if I will have the option to choose but I'm wondering if I can tour both and then decide. Is that normally a choice? Also, does anyone have any info about the maternity experience at either place? I've heard that Good Sam has a great neonatal dept but that the rooms are small and dirty? Please help clear this confusion! TIA



I work on the Maternity unit at Southside as an RN - rotate between the nursery and on the floor with the mommies - I can't give my opinion because obviously I am biased Chat Icon

Posted 9/18/09 7:47 PM
 

Domino
Always My Miracle

Member since 9/05

9924 total posts

Name:

Re: Good Sam Vs. Southside

I have the same situation with a twist. Next week we are movin 25 minutes east of where we are now. I am now going to be very close to St. Brook with their new big private rooms and bathrooms and showers...but my doctor is here. I just had my first experience at Good Sam L&D rooms. They are not private, they are SMALL, but dirty? Not that I saw. The other problem is the bathroom. Shared by your roomate AND THE adjouning room so four patients share the bathroom....and no shower...you have to use the community shower.Chat Icon Southside does not have a neonatal should this be an issue for you. I am high risk so it is for me. One thing that I can say from being there today is that the nurses at Good Sam were EXCELLENT. i enjoyed them all. I still dont know what I am going to do. The bathroom facilities bothered me more than the shared cramped shobox room.Chat Icon

Posted 9/18/09 8:51 PM
 

Alex110879
craziness

Member since 8/06

3762 total posts

Name:
Alexandria

Re: Good Sam Vs. Southside

Good sam does have private ldr's... if you are under observation and not in active labor or they are very full then you are put in a two person room aka labor room... the regular ldr rooms are beautiful.... I had such a wonderful experience at good sam with ds both when i was there from preterm labor (which was when i was in a sharing room) and when i actually had ds (in a private room).... As for the bathrooms... when you are in the ldr rooms you have a private bath and shower.. no sharing whatsoever... you only share if you are in a labor only room...

Message edited 2009-09-18 20:57:31.177000.

Posted 9/18/09 8:56 PM
 

Purplegirl77
i love my kids!

Member since 1/09

1963 total posts

Name:
Debbie

Re: Good Sam Vs. Southside

MY OB is affiliated w/ both Good Sam and Southside...we are delivering @ Good Sam...I don't think it is up to the patient, I believe the OB.. anyway DH and I went for a tour recently of Good Sam. We could not see the labor and delivery floor b/c the rooms were all taken, lol, but we saw the maternity floor...the rooms like like a decent size compared to other hospitals I have seen and also it looked very clean. The Nurses all seemed very nice. The shower/bathroom thing will probably skeeve me out b/c I get very skeeved to begin w/ with a public bathroom, lol but oh well hopefully it is 2 days and it is what it is ya know!!

Posted 9/18/09 9:01 PM
 

twinkletoes807
Mommy's Girls! &hearts;

Member since 11/07

10116 total posts

Name:
Gabi

Re: Good Sam Vs. Southside

I delivered at Good Sam last October and will deliver there again this December. I did not see the labor rooms that the PP described with a shared bathroom/shower. I was in a Labor and Delivery Room from 9am until 10pm by myself. My family was allowed to hang out in the room as long as I wanted them to be there. My hubby watched a flat screen TV while relaxing in a reclining chair. The L&D nurses were FANTASTIC! My nurse was Jackie and she was the best thing since sliced bread. Chat Icon

I was brought to the maternity floor after delivering my DD and was put in a double room. I would have shared the bathroom and shower with a roommate, had one been assigned but I had the entire double room to myself for my 2 day stay. It was wonderful. The shower was on the tiny size, but I am a chubby girl so it was to be expected. The room was spotless and I received new linens and a freshly made bed every morning and if I need them sooner. Everyone on staff was wonderful, attentive and caring.

As far as having a choice as to which hospital to choose, IMO there is no choice. From what I understand, Good Sam has a higher level NICU than Southside. That is what makes all the difference. I can surely survive in a small dirty room sharing a toilet and shower with 10 other ladies for 2-4 days (if it were necessary) but I'd rather get the absolute highest level of care possible for my newborn. I never thought I would need it, but my DD was in the NICU at Good Sam for 8 long days. I am forever thankful for the nurses and doctors who helped her to get well enough to come home. Chat Icon

Posted 9/18/09 9:38 PM
 

Purplegirl77
i love my kids!

Member since 1/09

1963 total posts

Name:
Debbie

Re: Good Sam Vs. Southside

Posted by twinkletoes807

I delivered at Good Sam last October and will deliver there again this December. I did not see the labor rooms that the PP described with a shared bathroom/shower. I was in a Labor and Delivery Room from 9am until 10pm by myself. My family was allowed to hang out in the room as long as I wanted them to be there. My hubby watched a flat screen TV while relaxing in a reclining chair. The L&D nurses were FANTASTIC! My nurse was Jackie and she was the best thing since sliced bread. Chat Icon

I was brought to the maternity floor after delivering my DD and was put in a double room. I would have shared the bathroom and shower with a roommate, had one been assigned but I had the entire double room to myself for my 2 day stay. It was wonderful. The shower was on the tiny size, but I am a chubby girl so it was to be expected. The room was spotless and I received new linens and a freshly made bed every morning and if I need them sooner. Everyone on staff was wonderful, attentive and caring.

As far as having a choice as to which hospital to choose, IMO there is no choice. From what I understand, Good Sam has a higher level NICU than Southside. That is what makes all the difference. I can surely survive in a small dirty room sharing a toilet and shower with 10 other ladies for 2-4 days (if it were necessary) but I'd rather get the absolute highest level of care possible for my newborn. I never thought I would need it, but my DD was in the NICU at Good Sam for 8 long days. I am forever thankful for the nurses and doctors who helped her to get well enough to come home. Chat Icon



Thank you for sharing, I am being induced 9/29 so good to hear!! By the way your daughter is adorable and good luck to you.

Posted 9/18/09 9:53 PM
 

MaMaSaP
LIF Toddler

Member since 2/09

391 total posts

Name:

Re: Good Sam Vs. Southside

I am delivering at Southside and many of my friends have too. It is newly rennovated and I have met the staff a few times and they are amazing! They do have private rooms.

I almost switched my OB b/c I heard of all these rumors of the NICU only being a level I NICU. When I spoke to my doc and went on the tour both stated that it is a level III NICU. Good Sam is level IV. Since Southside is affiliated with LIJ, if there are major complications or the baby needs to have a long stay(like a month or two), they do transfer the baby to schnieders children's hospital (one of the BEST children's hospitals). I asked how often that occurs and the nurse said rarely.

IMO: I hate hospitals and both have their ups and downs.

I have heard negatives about both hopsitals (I don't want to bath Good Sam or Southside).

Go on a tour and go with your gut. I loved southside and stayed with my OB b/c I felt very confident about it!

Posted 9/19/09 9:08 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Good Sam in West Islip or Southside in Bay Shore NancyD 5/4/09 9 Pregnancy
Good Sam or Southside IrishMom77 11/28/07 9 Pregnancy
Good Sam vs. Southside Blondie805 7/24/07 17 TTC
Good Sam or Southside IrishMom77 5/14/07 15 Pregnancy
Pregnancy question--Good Sam/Southside want2beamom 1/8/07 13 Parenting
Good Sam or Southside Jacquie 3/31/06 28 Pregnancy