Godparents

Posted By Message

JoJo2010
Happy Family

Member since 8/09

6266 total posts

Name:
JO

Godparents

I am just wondering the Catholic rules with godparents. I am not catholic I am Lutheran, I got married catholic and we are raising our children catholic. Now I want my sister to be the godmother and she is not catholic. Is that allowed? i mean I know all churches are different, but wanted to see what everyone else experienced.

Also did you ask the godparents before the baby was born or after?

Posted 12/17/09 2:53 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: Godparents

I know that every church is different but I think only ONE godparent has to be Catholic. Also, I have been a godparent twice and I never had to sign something or declare that I was Catholic in any way.

We are waiting until after the baby is born to ask the godparents but it is pretty obvious who it will be ( my sister and his brother ).

Posted 12/17/09 2:54 PM
 

JoJo2010
Happy Family

Member since 8/09

6266 total posts

Name:
JO

Re: Godparents

Posted by Tilde

I know that every church is different but I think only ONE godparent has to be Catholic. Also, I have been a godparent twice and I never had to sign something or declare that I was Catholic in any way.

We are waiting until after the baby is born to ask the godparents but it is pretty obvious who it will be ( my sister and his brother ).



yea my sister and his brother as well..His brother is catholic..and I heard the same thing..So i am hoping this is how it goes!

Thanks!

Posted 12/17/09 2:55 PM
 

Deeluvsvinny
DONE

Member since 10/08

4952 total posts

Name:
Whatever

Re: Godparents

I beleive that only godparent has to be catholic (made confirmation).

I would wait to ask. My sister knows she is the godmother. DH's BF knows he is the godfather, since they discussed prior to us even getting a BFP.

Posted 12/17/09 2:56 PM
 

Deeluvsvinny
DONE

Member since 10/08

4952 total posts

Name:
Whatever

Re: Godparents

Posted by Tilde

I know that every church is different but I think only ONE godparent has to be Catholic. Also, I have been a godparent twice and I never had to sign something or declare that I was Catholic in any way.

We are waiting until after the baby is born to ask the godparents but it is pretty obvious who it will be ( my sister and his brother ).



Really? When I was a Godmother, I had to get a letter from my church that I was a practiving member.

Posted 12/17/09 2:56 PM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: Godparents

Posted by Deeluvsvinny

Posted by Tilde

I know that every church is different but I think only ONE godparent has to be Catholic. Also, I have been a godparent twice and I never had to sign something or declare that I was Catholic in any way.

We are waiting until after the baby is born to ask the godparents but it is pretty obvious who it will be ( my sister and his brother ).



Really? When I was a Godmother, I had to get a letter from my church that I was a practiving member.



Yeah every church is different. One baptism was at my parish so I guess they knew, but my goddaughter was baptised at a different parish and they never asked.

Posted 12/17/09 2:58 PM
 

Deeluvsvinny
DONE

Member since 10/08

4952 total posts

Name:
Whatever

Re: Godparents

Posted by Tilde

Posted by Deeluvsvinny

Posted by Tilde

I know that every church is different but I think only ONE godparent has to be Catholic. Also, I have been a godparent twice and I never had to sign something or declare that I was Catholic in any way.

We are waiting until after the baby is born to ask the godparents but it is pretty obvious who it will be ( my sister and his brother ).



Really? When I was a Godmother, I had to get a letter from my church that I was a practiving member.



Yeah every church is different. One baptism was at my parish so I guess they knew, but my goddaughter was baptised at a different parish and they never asked.



Yea, and I just remember, I baptized my godson in Pennsylvannia, so I guess things are different out of state.

Posted 12/17/09 3:00 PM
 

mtnmama

Member since 5/06

4794 total posts

Name:

Re: Godparents

In general, at least one Godparent has to be a practicing Catholic and the other can be a Christian witness.

We waited until after the baby was born to ask.

Posted 12/17/09 3:05 PM
 

BellaRock
I am all the Me I will ever Be

Member since 5/06

9746 total posts

Name:
She who shall remain nameless

Re: Godparents

When I had my DS baptized the Godparents had to get a letter from their parish saying they were practicing Catholics.

When I baptized my 2 nieces, at a different church, I was never asked to provide any proof that we were practicing Catholics.

We did have to go to a baptism preparation class for both my DS and for my nieces.

Eta: We asked the godparents after the baby was born. They came to visit the day we came home from the hospital and we asked them if they would like to hold their godson. It was a great moment.

Message edited 2009-12-17 15:10:44.020000.

Posted 12/17/09 3:09 PM
 

Salason
♥

Member since 6/05

9878 total posts

Name:

Re: Godparents

I had to get letters from both godparents that they were catholics "in good standing" but i've been a godmother 3 times in the last year and only needed a letter from my church once so it obviously varies widely!

ETA: in case it helps, I needed the letters in NYC and PA but both times I did not need them were on LI (Rocky Point and North Massapequa).

Message edited 2009-12-17 16:20:36.750000.

Posted 12/17/09 3:27 PM
 

JoJo2010
Happy Family

Member since 8/09

6266 total posts

Name:
JO

Re: Godparents

Thanks all for your responses! I guess we will have to see what the church says.

Posted 12/17/09 4:14 PM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Godparents

Posted by JoJo2010

I am just wondering the Catholic rules with godparents. I am not catholic I am Lutheran, I got married catholic and we are raising our children catholic. Now I want my sister to be the godmother and she is not catholic. Is that allowed? i mean I know all churches are different, but wanted to see what everyone else experienced.

Also did you ask the godparents before the baby was born or after?




this is us 100%, i am lutheran (or was baptized, took communion and confirmed lutheran) but was married in DH's Catholic church.

We were told that as long as 1 godparent is catholic, its fine Chat Icon

ETS - can I also add my frustration here? Dont flame me, please, JMHO. I dislike how I was accepted by the catholic church to marry there without conversion from Lutheran but they want to dictate (to a degree) who I will choose to be my children's godparents? I understand that the point of a godparent is to see that the child is brought up with religion and in the catholic church (when baptized in a catholic church) BUT I see it as more of a caretaker, parental figure in general should anything happen to me and DH. Just frustrating that they will let me marry in the church but I cannot decide who will be the godparents if I want my children welcomed into the congregation (the ones I swore I would accept as God's children when I took my vows in the catholic church)...

SORRY for the vent Chat Icon hormonal day Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-12-17 16:56:45.643000.

Posted 12/17/09 4:51 PM
 

Alex110879
craziness

Member since 8/06

3762 total posts

Name:
Alexandria

Re: Godparents

my church requires that both god parents be CONFIRMED catholics... they actually do check with the diocease....

Posted 12/17/09 7:36 PM
 

kms717
St Philomena Protect My Son

Member since 2/06

2747 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Godparents

You only need one Godparent and they have to have made all their sacraments (Christening, First Holy Communion, and Confirmation). The other person if they are not Catholic can stand on the alter, but will not "officially" be a Godparent unless they are Catholic as well.

Posted 12/17/09 7:39 PM
 

kms717
St Philomena Protect My Son

Member since 2/06

2747 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Godparents

Posted by mrskparetta

Posted by JoJo2010

I am just wondering the Catholic rules with godparents. I am not catholic I am Lutheran, I got married catholic and we are raising our children catholic. Now I want my sister to be the godmother and she is not catholic. Is that allowed? i mean I know all churches are different, but wanted to see what everyone else experienced.

Also did you ask the godparents before the baby was born or after?




this is us 100%, i am lutheran (or was baptized, took communion and confirmed lutheran) but was married in DH's Catholic church.

We were told that as long as 1 godparent is catholic, its fine Chat Icon

ETS - can I also add my frustration here? Dont flame me, please, JMHO. I dislike how I was accepted by the catholic church to marry there without conversion from Lutheran but they want to dictate (to a degree) who I will choose to be my children's godparents? I understand that the point of a godparent is to see that the child is brought up with religion and in the catholic church (when baptized in a catholic church) BUT I see it as more of a caretaker, parental figure in general should anything happen to me and DH. Just frustrating that they will let me marry in the church but I cannot decide who will be the godparents if I want my children welcomed into the congregation (the ones I swore I would accept as God's children when I took my vows in the catholic church)...

SORRY for the vent Chat Icon hormonal day Chat Icon



I understand your frustration and this is not a flame, but the whole point of being a Godparent is to be able to educate the child on their religion, they can't truly fulfill that duty if they are not a member of the church. You can designate someone else to be the caretaker, it doesn't have to be the Godparents.

Posted 12/17/09 7:43 PM
 

donegal419
St. Gerard, pray for us.

Member since 7/07

7650 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Godparents

Posted by kms717

You only need one Godparent and they have to have made all their sacraments (Christening, First Holy Communion, and Confirmation). The other person if they are not Catholic can stand on the alter, but will not "officially" be a Godparent unless they are Catholic as well.



this is true....they will be considered a witness, but not the godparent. to be the godparentS, BOTH must be Catholic. Most Churches take your word for it (I mean, if you lie about that to a priest or deacon, not cool! Chat Icon some churches though will ask to see the baptismal certificates of the godparents.

Message edited 2009-12-17 20:34:17.213000.

Posted 12/17/09 8:33 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
what did you get your dc's godparents as a christening gift??? wowcoulditbe 4/18/07 15 Parenting
Dont know where to post Gifts for Godparents Again I know Sorry !!! CHRISTINEL 10/18/06 4 Parenting
DH and I were asked to be godparents...parents already have a dress & cross..What should be do for a present? BigB 7/28/06 7 Families Helping Families ™
I need help with what to put on my the picture frame that I am giving to my DS godparents bean 6/26/06 1 Parenting
dh and I are going to be godparents sunday....help!!! TwoGirls4Me 5/5/06 5 Families Helping Families ™
Godparents - is there a min. age? pinky 5/3/06 5 Pregnancy