God Parents... I need HELP

Posted By Message

jgl
Love my little boys!!!

Member since 8/07

7060 total posts

Name:
g

God Parents... I need HELP

I would love for my sister to be godmother to our DS. I would choose her over my brother (who is older than her) but because DH wants to have someone from his side and someone from my side, I have to choose my brother. DH has no guys on his side we would consider right now. He has one step brother who is not dependable. So we are going to have his Female Cousin be god mother. All 3 will be amazing GPs so that isnt the issue.

I have to tell my sister. I know she is hoping she will be it and is going to be devistated. Im devisted for her because she is going to be so hurt. No matter what I say she is going to be hurt. it does kill me that Im picking DHs cousin over her I feel like that is just wrong of me and makes me horrible


I want her to know that it was a hard decision, I want her to know that we arent picking both her and my bro together because I want my children (when we have another) to at least have one of them as a godparent because I know they will be there for them.

Its not going to matter what I say she is going to be sad... I even asked the priest if we could have 3. I wish we didnt have to even pick GPs

Thoughts anyone? anyone help me with this situation or to feel better?
Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-07-06 16:50:51.523000.

Posted 7/6/10 4:49 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

BAM 2009
I am who I am!!!

Member since 5/09

6081 total posts

Name:

Re: God Parents... I need HELP

I had the same problem, but our church allowed us to have 4 god parents. I was a basket case up until I found that out. We were going to go with no family members so we couldn't leave anyone out. We had picked 2 of our closest friends. I know this doesn't help you out too much, but you definitely aren't alone. maybe your sister can be a sponsor or witness at the christening?

Posted 7/6/10 4:54 PM
 

jgl
Love my little boys!!!

Member since 8/07

7060 total posts

Name:
g

Re: God Parents... I need HELP

Posted by BAM 2009

I had the same problem, but our church allowed us to have 4 god parents. I was a basket case up until I found that out. We were going to go with no family members so we couldn't leave anyone out. We had picked 2 of our closest friends. I know this doesn't help you out too much, but you definitely aren't alone. maybe your sister can be a sponsor or witness at the christening?



wow.. thanks. Im glad it worked out for you. I wish he would have said yes then i wouldnt be so upset right now. grrr.. and my dad is making me feel like i made te wrong decision too. but I know its just because he knows she is going to be upset.

Posted 7/6/10 4:56 PM
 

Bri
I Love You to Pieces!

Member since 5/05

9919 total posts

Name:
Brianne

Re: God Parents... I need HELP

Will the church allow 2 women? I know some do . . .

Posted 7/6/10 5:06 PM
 

jgl
Love my little boys!!!

Member since 8/07

7060 total posts

Name:
g

Re: God Parents... I need HELP

Posted by Bri

Will the church allow 2 women? I know some do . . .



IDK but DH actually just mentioned this. I think I may call tomorrow about that.

Do you think that is strange to do that?

Posted 7/6/10 5:09 PM
 

Bops
My 3 wishes

Member since 12/07

13625 total posts

Name:

Re: God Parents... I need HELP

Are you planning on having more children ? Maybe if you tell her your situation and you and DH come to an understanding that she will be God-Mother to thje next child it would soften the blow a bit ? That a tough one Chat Icon

Posted 7/6/10 5:45 PM
 

jgl
Love my little boys!!!

Member since 8/07

7060 total posts

Name:
g

Re: God Parents... I need HELP

Posted by Bops

Are you planning on having more children ? Maybe if you tell her your situation and you and DH come to an understanding that she will be God-Mother to thje next child it would soften the blow a bit ? That a tough one Chat Icon



yes we are and that is the plan. I want to have one of them to be for each child. But imk still sure she will be upset not to be GM of this child.

Im just going to have to talk to her and tell her that I want her to be and explain the situation. she will be upset but hopefully she will deal

Posted 7/6/10 6:09 PM
 

adeline27
LIF Adult

Member since 5/06

3121 total posts

Name:
Angela

Re: God Parents... I need HELP

Chat Icon I went through a similar situation. It all boiled down to making sure my DH was happy in the decision too. It sounds like your DH's cousin will be a great GM to your DC as your sister would be and that's the most important thing. I would talk to your sister about how you and your DH decided and let her know that she is just as important in your DC's life. You shouldn't feel like you are doing something bad/wrong. Your DH chose someone close from his side and you're choosing someone from your side. I hope your sister and other family members will understand. I hope your church will also allow two Godmothers but if they don't your sister should know she is on top of the list with the second.

Posted 7/6/10 6:17 PM
 

sunflowerjesss
Mommy to 3!

Member since 10/05

20369 total posts

Name:
Jesss, duh.

Re: God Parents... I need HELP

I don't know your personal situation or plans. But is telling your sister she will be godmother of your next child be an option?

Posted 7/6/10 6:23 PM
 

jgl
Love my little boys!!!

Member since 8/07

7060 total posts

Name:
g

Re: God Parents... I need HELP

Posted by adeline27

Chat Icon I went through a similar situation. It all boiled down to making sure my DH was happy in the decision too. It sounds like your DH's cousin will be a great GM to your DC as your sister would be and that's the most important thing. I would talk to your sister about how you and your DH decided and let her know that she is just as important in your DC's life. You shouldn't feel like you are doing something bad/wrong. Your DH chose someone close from his side and you're choosing someone from your side. I hope your sister and other family members will understand. I hope your church will also allow two Godmothers but if they don't your sister should know she is on top of the list with the second.



Chat Icon

thanks so much ! i know you are right and I think if I talk to her she might understand.

The priest happened to call me a few min ago for some missing info and I asked him and he said to women wouldnt be ok. Chat Icon

Posted 7/6/10 6:24 PM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: God Parents... I need HELP

our church told us that it is 100% OK to have more than 2 Chat Icon

however, only 2 will be on the baptism certificate but you dont have to tell the "2" who they are Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/6/10 7:22 PM
 

Mom-of-one
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/08

677 total posts

Name:

Re: God Parents... I need HELP

My DD has 2 Godmothers & no Godfathers.
The Pastor had no objections at all.

Posted 7/6/10 7:24 PM
 

CucumberGirl
You give the best smiles!

Member since 1/09

2398 total posts

Name:
M~

Re: God Parents... I need HELP

I am one of my nephew's 2 godmothers but I know this will depend on the parish itself. We had a similar issue too - DH and I disagreed but we had to compromise and explained as much to the others involved. I know your sister will be hurt, but I think she will understand too.

Posted 7/6/10 9:26 PM
 

LuvmyShihTzu
<3 I <3 my DD <3

Member since 8/08

3325 total posts

Name:
Happiest Mommy <3

Re: God Parents... I need HELP

I think that choosing Godparents is such a hard task! I know in my situation I have brothers and I KNOW that there are people in my family who are frowing on the fact that I did not choose any of them as my 1st DC's Godfather....it just worked out that way for our child and for our next one I know I'm in for it because I have 2 brothers and want to choose the younger one...that will cause an uproar I'm sure.

I guess I'm getting at do what you feel is right and hopefully everyone will respect your feelings. Good luck : )

Posted 7/6/10 10:32 PM
 

jgl
Love my little boys!!!

Member since 8/07

7060 total posts

Name:
g

Re: God Parents... I need HELP

thanks all. Nothing can just be easily resolved. My dad called me before to TELL me that eh needs to talk to me about this because my sister is going to be devistated and how we are doing what is convienent and easy for us. How we are going to ruin our relationship and not thinking of the long term consequences. UGH

Im so beyond ******. as if im not upset about this already. Forget the fact that my emotions are all screwed up from having a baby. I was just starting to feel okay with it, that I would be able to explain it to her and have her be okay with it. Now im at square one again. how dare they tell US what we need to do. Like we just pulled names out of a hat. I sent my father a nasty text and now may ignore their phone calls tomorrow.Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/6/10 10:53 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: God Parents... I need HELP

Honestly I would choose your sister and brother to be godparents than if your sister is going to be that devastated and if you are that upset about it. A sister trumps a cousin IMO.

Posted 7/6/10 10:53 PM
 

jgl
Love my little boys!!!

Member since 8/07

7060 total posts

Name:
g

Re: God Parents... I need HELP

Posted by jellybean1420

Honestly I would choose your sister and brother to be godparents than if your sister is going to be that devastated and if you are that upset about it. A sister trumps a cousin IMO.



i understand that but how do I tell DH that he cant have someone from his side of the family be a godparent? I would feel terrible about that. Dh offered to have my bro and sistelr be the GPs but i also want to be able to have our next child have one of them as a GP. sorry im rambling andprob making no sense

Posted 7/6/10 10:56 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: God Parents... I need HELP

Posted by jgl

Posted by jellybean1420

Honestly I would choose your sister and brother to be godparents than if your sister is going to be that devastated and if you are that upset about it. A sister trumps a cousin IMO.



i understand that but how do I tell DH that he cant have someone from his side of the family be a godparent? I would feel terrible about that. Dh offered to have my bro and sistelr be the GPs but i also want to be able to have our next child have one of them as a GP. sorry im rambling andprob making no sense




It's not about you choosing one person from your side and DH choosing one person from his side...it's about who you two choose together, two people who you feel will make the best godparents for your DC. And if it is your sister and brother, I think that is who you should pick.

I also dont think you need to "save" one sibling for your next child. I think it would be fine to ask DH's cousin to be a godparent with the next child. And your brother or sister can be godparents again for your next child if you want.

I dont have any siblings. DH only has one brother. My cousin is DS #1's godmother and DH's brother is his godfather. My twin cousins are DS #2's godparents.

Posted 7/6/10 11:03 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: God Parents... I need HELP

Can I be completely honest.............I would choose your sister. So what if DH doesn't have someone on his side. Then have 2 from your side. I know with me and my siblings we don't have one from each side so I don't think you have to make an effort to ensure you both have a family member chosen.

That being said, I too think your sister will be devastated.........especially if she is your only sister. My only sister screwed up ROYALLY last year and chose someone else as her MOH for her wedding (long story) and I ended up not being in her wedding at all, my family was literally torn up over the whole thing, I was devastated, and we've not really gotten along since.

The point is, I agree with your Dad, it's a decision that WILL have long term consequences. I know this from experience. I CANNOT get past what my sister has done to me. It hurts me EVERY day that she made the choices she did and it didn't hurt just me, it hurt my whole family. I would hate for you to go through a similar situation as mine and I know MOH and GM are a little different but it's still an honor and I am sure something your sister has probably been looking forward to for as long as she can remember. I know for me I NEVER would have imagined that my sister would have not chosen me as MOH being that I am her only sister and she was my MOH.

I think you should think long and hard about this before making any final decisions. If your sister is who you truly want, if your sister is someone who will play a big part in your child's life then go with your heart on this one and choose your sister. And promising her that she will be GM the next time around won't be any consolation and won't make it hurt any less.

Don't be mad at your Dad...........as someone on the outside and as someone who has been in a similar situation I see where he is coming from. My mom did the SAME EXACT thing time and time again with my sister..............she did and said everything she could to try and protect her kids and protect her family and do what was right. That's all your Dad is doing.

Lastly, you shouldn't make a decision about who will be GM or GF simply based on who has the right gender on each side and making it all balanced and fair. You should choose who based on who you feel in your heart would be the best GM (or GF) for your child and if that means it's two from your side and none from your DH's then so be it. If you truly in your heart want your DH's cousin then that's what you want and you should follow your heart but if the only reason you're not choosing your sister is because you "need" someone from DH's side I really think ou should reconsider. I hate to say it and I don't want to make you feel bad but she will be hurt. Very, very hurt. I know, I've been there, and it damaged my relationship with my sister. You don't want to go down that road.

Good luck with your decision. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/6/10 11:08 PM
 

LAMGAJ28
.

Member since 10/05

6039 total posts

Name:

Re: God Parents... I need HELP

Posted by jellybean1420

Honestly I would choose your sister and brother to be godparents than if your sister is going to be that devastated and if you are that upset about it. A sister trumps a cousin IMO.



I agree with this as well. Why not have both Godparents from your side for this child and then for your next child have your DH pick from his side of the family. This might be a solution and one that can prevent from getting your sister hurt. Good luck with your decision.

Posted 7/7/10 1:03 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: God Parents... I need HELP

Marriage trumps siblings.

Marriage us about compromise-both you and DH need to be comfortable with the decision and if the compromise is that your sister is out for this child, then I think that is how it has to be.

Especially since all 3 would make great god parents.

I would explain the situation as you just did and I would hope that your sister understands.

That said, what will you do with your next child? If your sister is the god mother for the next child, who will be the god father next time? It's a decision you are going to have to face eventually (if you plan to have more kids). Why not bump up that candidate and have him and your sister be god parents now, if that will make both you and DH happy? That's the only part I am not understanding.

Posted 7/7/10 9:11 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: God Parents... I need HELP

Posted by MrsFresca

Posted by jellybean1420

Honestly I would choose your sister and brother to be godparents than if your sister is going to be that devastated and if you are that upset about it. A sister trumps a cousin IMO.



I agree with this as well. Why not have both Godparents from your side for this child and then for your next child have your DH pick from his side of the family. This might be a solution and one that can prevent from getting your sister hurt. Good luck with your decision.



But it seems then that her DH will be unhappy. I don't think that's a better option unless she can get DH to feel good about it.

Posted 7/7/10 9:12 AM
 

jgl
Love my little boys!!!

Member since 8/07

7060 total posts

Name:
g

Re: God Parents... I need HELP

thank you!

I do not want to make is seem like we are JUST going by haivng one person from each side, we thought this through and the each one of them would be amazing GPs. His cousin is great with DS and would do anything for him, but so would my brother and sister. This is what makes it hard. Yes Im trying to compromise with DH because this is his son too and if he wants someone from his side to be a GP to our son I cant say no.

I appreciate your responses and I know that we could just have my bro and sister be GPs to our son. Dh did say it was okay with him, he brought it up, but again, i feel strongly about having one of them be the GP to each of my children. I know what it is like to not have involved GPs and I dont want that to happen to our children. I know that my siblings will always be there for them.

i need to think about this more before I speak with my sister.

Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/7/10 9:21 AM
 

1stimemom
Love my boys

Member since 2/08

8766 total posts

Name:
Mrs Dee

Re: God Parents... I need HELP

Here are a few questions that *may* make your choice a little bit easier....

*If heaven forbid something happened to you and your DH, who would you honestly want to raise your child?

*Who would definitely be there hands down with no question should your child ever really need anything at all?

*Who has the same religious/spiritual and moral values as you and DH that would help to instill those things into your child?

If you can think of the same person (whoever it is/ whatever "side") then you hands down have your Godparent(s).

Good luck with your decisionChat Icon

Posted 7/7/10 9:29 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Asking God Parents DanandNette 4/6/09 3 Pregnancy
?? about God Parents divamommy 10/28/08 19 Pregnancy
When choosing god-parents.... Bops 8/25/08 1 Parenting
god parents/guardians nferrandi 8/2/07 7 Parenting
God parents..... Diane 2/7/07 3 Parenting
God parents Dee 9/27/06 10 Parenting