Ortiz beat out Giambi as the starting 1B all star. Now I respect Ortiz and his hitting ability. But how could someone who doesn't even play in the field be considered a starting 1B all star? I am so mad about this. This is another reason why I don't like the fans picking the team. It's stupid. There should at least be a minimum number of games played at a position in order for someone to make the all star team. Here are their numbers. Tell me what you think...

Player TEAM POS G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI TB BB SO SB CS OBP SLG AVG
1. D Ortiz BOS DH 82 307 60 84 15 0 27 76 180 53 64 0 0 .381 .586 .274
2. J Giambi NYY 1B 74 250 53 66 12 0 25 65 153 61 63 1 0 .424 .612 .264

ETA:

I wanted to add an other as a choice for the poll but I hit enter by accident. So if you think someone else should have won please feel free to add them.