Formula q - Why powedered vs. RTF?

Posted By Message

itsbabytime
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

9644 total posts

Name:
Me

Formula q - Why powedered vs. RTF?

I'm just starting to give DD some formula - with DS he didn't get much formula until 10 mos so it wasn't an issue for that long. I'm wondering though - is there a reason so many use powdered formula - it seems like SO much more work to me!

ETA: What about the fact that the RTF is in plastic bottles?

Message edited 2010-08-17 19:14:00.620000.

Posted 8/17/10 6:58 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Reese32
LIF Adult

Member since 7/07

3631 total posts

Name:

Re: Formula q - Why powedered vs. RTF?

Biggest reason for me: it's a LOT cheaper. Every once in a while, I'd "splurge" on a case of rtf, but mostly we went with powdered.

Posted 8/17/10 7:09 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Formula q - Why powedered vs. RTF?

people use it bc it's much cheaper.

Posted 8/17/10 7:10 PM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: Formula q - Why powedered vs. RTF?

seems like too much work to me too ... I guess people like it because you don't have to warm it, if you're using room temp water.

Where as the RTF, you probably will make the bottles ahead and store in fridge.

Well, I was using individual serving cans for some time. That was heaven.

eta: duh! its cheaper (bonking myself on the head)

Message edited 2010-08-17 19:11:59.797000.

Posted 8/17/10 7:11 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Formula q - Why powedered vs. RTF?

Cost. Powder is much cheaper.

But I also think that RTF is MUCH thicker.

Posted 8/17/10 7:11 PM
 

LemonHead
Sour Girl

Member since 3/08

5271 total posts

Name:

Re: Formula q - Why powedered vs. RTF?

So much cheaper!

I don't really think it's a lot of work.

Posted 8/17/10 7:27 PM
 

Ian&EmmesMommy23
My family is complete!

Member since 11/08

12970 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Formula q - Why powedered vs. RTF?

cheaper and more convenient for me. if we're going out, i bring lukewarm water in a bottle and the powder in a separate container. then i mix it whenever im ready. not worrying if its going to spoil or have to warm it up.

Posted 8/17/10 7:28 PM
 

sunnygirl
loving life

Member since 1/07

5413 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Formula q - Why powedered vs. RTF?

cheaper - i have twins
more convenient, i never warm a bottle
my new formula didn't come in rtf, im just recently seeing it as rtf, (gerber good start)
one dd started nutrimigen today and dr recommended to use the powder

Posted 8/17/10 7:31 PM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Formula q - Why powedered vs. RTF?

at first i thought it was a pain in the ***..but it is cheaper and then our daycare gives us a can of goodstart per week so i started using it.

I make a big batch in our blender...measure the water, count the scoops, mix and pour. it does save a lot of $$ so I've pretty much switched over to powder. I keep a few cans of ready made on hand for emergencies.

Posted 8/17/10 7:40 PM
 

beautyq115
New Year!

Member since 5/05

13729 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Formula q - Why powedered vs. RTF?

Posted by smdl

Cost. Powder is much cheaper.

But I also think that RTF is MUCH thicker.



Yeah it seems thicker. I personally don't like the smell or consistency of RTF.

Posted 8/17/10 7:48 PM
 

AMF1115
Loves being Joey & Vinny's mom

Member since 1/09

3771 total posts

Name:
Athina

Re: Formula q - Why powedered vs. RTF?

i use it b/c its cheaper and i didnt have to worry about heating it up.

Posted 8/17/10 7:51 PM
 

A3CM
Avatar Title

Member since 9/08

3762 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Formula q - Why powedered vs. RTF?

i guess i feel like the odd one out... i couldnt stand powder... it was a PITA to make and both my kids drank formula straight from the fridge, and when i was on the go i used the single RTF bottles where all i did was screw on a nipple.

with the powder, you have to measure the water, measure the powder, make sure there are no clumps, where as the RTF you just shake pour and feed.

powder is also thinner than the RTF and both kids has slight reflux so the RTF was better.

Posted 8/17/10 8:02 PM
 

mlny
blessed <3

Member since 10/09

2113 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Formula q - Why powedered vs. RTF?

it's cheaper, i don't have to worry about it spoiling because i make it when he needs it, and i don't have to worry about warming it up. i just keep room temperature water in his bottles and pour in the powder when i need it.

it works out great!

Posted 8/17/10 8:31 PM
 

CucumberGirl
You give the best smiles!

Member since 1/09

2398 total posts

Name:
M~

Re: Formula q - Why powedered vs. RTF?

I actually think powdered is easier and wish I could use it, but DD's on Alimentum and would only tolerate the RTF. In the beginning, I'd warm them a little bit, but now she takes it just fine from the fridge so it's not so bad.

Posted 8/17/10 8:40 PM
 

iamme
LIF Toddler

Member since 6/10

495 total posts

Name:

Re: Formula q - Why powedered vs. RTF?

yes it is much cheaper. but, if you are like me, both of my ds were on formulas that were not available in powder!

Posted 8/17/10 8:41 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Formula q - Why powedered vs. RTF?

Its about convenience vs. cost savings, mostly.

Posted 8/17/10 8:45 PM
 

NYchic
Girl & boy

Member since 6/09

2357 total posts

Name:

Re: Formula q - Why powedered vs. RTF?

Posted by QTDimps23

cheaper and more convenient for me. if we're going out, i bring lukewarm water in a bottle and the powder in a separate container. then i mix it whenever im ready. not worrying if its going to spoil or have to warm it up.



ITA.
I don't even think of it being cheaper...I use powdered purely for convenience sake. I cannot imagine having to warm a bottle...I know I'd be lazy and use the microwave which I know is not recommended. I just use room temp water - toss in the powder and shake. Honestly I do not get why anyone who uses powder makes a large batch in a pitcher ahead of time...defeats the purpose of the convenience of not having to heat a bottle.

Posted 8/17/10 8:49 PM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Formula q - Why powedered vs. RTF?

My kids didn't like the RTF, they'd throw it up. I think it was too thick for them. They both were fine on powdered.

Posted 8/17/10 9:00 PM
 

oneday
<3

Member since 5/05

4319 total posts

Name:
Pam

Re: Formula q - Why powedered vs. RTF?

Posted by QTDimps23

cheaper and more convenient for me. if we're going out, i bring lukewarm water in a bottle and the powder in a separate container. then i mix it whenever im ready. not worrying if its going to spoil or have to warm it up.

Exactly my reasons too.

Posted 8/17/10 9:12 PM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: Formula q - Why powedered vs. RTF?

It's so much cheaper -and for me, my DD spits up any formula that isn't thick enough and the RTF are thinner than the powdered too

Posted 8/17/10 9:21 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
RTF formula vs. Powdered Formula - I finally did the math... MrsJ 8/2/06 7 Parenting
Has anyone shipped RTF bottles of formula overseas? Is it possible? Stephybaby 3/11/09 1 Parenting
Is there somewhere to buy diapers and RTF formula around Disney? Cookiegobbler 11/14/07 7 Travel & Vacations
is it ok to switch between powder formula and rtf? raken40 11/2/07 4 Parenting
About RTF formula where you have to add water... preciouslove 9/24/06 5 Parenting
Does anyone see a difference in baby with powder and the RTF formula?? bean 6/10/06 4 Parenting