For once and for all, how does this bottle crap work!?!?

Posted By Message

missus-hbradio
Twin mommy

Member since 5/05

15857 total posts

Name:

For once and for all, how does this bottle crap work!?!?

My twins are 18 months old. They have an 8oz bottle when they wake up and one before bed. They drink a straw sippy all day with water no problem.

I KNOW the bottle is bad news and I am trying to switch to a sippy. We are trying to switch the morning bottle out first. Not in a straw sippy bc DD likes to lay down with it. I have an Elmo sippy (they love Elmo) with a nozzle type spout. I have tried for them to drink water from it several times and they think its a game. I tried to give them their morning milk with it and they barely tried it. I surrendered and switched it to a bottle to stop the meltdown.

Question is...how do I work a transition if they are so hesitant? I feel like the answer is cold turkey. My friend said something to me today that stuck in my head - she said - they don't want or need that milk - they need the comfort of the bottle.

The ped said to be completely transitioned with morning and night bottles to sippies by 2 years old. Well 6 months goes pretty fast and I know I am already behind compared to most Chat Icon

Posted 6/19/12 8:51 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

AMLMT1
LIF Adult

Member since 10/09

933 total posts

Name:

Re: For once and for all, how does this bottle crap work!?!?

I cut out the bottle at 12 months cold turkey. My DS wouldn't drink and still wont drink milk from the sippy cup. I was told as long as they get 3 servings of dairy a day it is fine. DS too liked to lay down with the bottle, but he can't with the straw sippy cup. He fussed the first few days, but he had no choice. I definitely think it's about the comfort of the bottle than "milk" itself.

Posted 6/19/12 9:01 PM
 

missus-hbradio
Twin mommy

Member since 5/05

15857 total posts

Name:

Re: For once and for all, how does this bottle crap work!?!?

Posted by AMLMT1

I cut out the bottle at 12 months cold turkey. My DS wouldn't drink and still wont drink milk from the sippy cup. I was told as long as they get 3 servings of dairy a day it is fine. DS too liked to lay down with the bottle, but he can't with the straw sippy cup. He fussed the first few days, but he had no choice. I definitely think it's about the comfort of the bottle than "milk" itself.



What did he do after he fussed and what does he do now? Just have nothing?

Posted 6/19/12 9:05 PM
 

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: For once and for all, how does this bottle crap work!?!?

My DS is 27 months and still gets a bottle at night.Chat Icon up until a month ago he still got one at nap time too. We ad to drop it cold turkey. He screamed for days, but eventually he got the point. Now he gets nothing at nap time or a sippy of milk or juice if he asks for it.

Message edited 2012-06-19 21:15:10.900000.

Posted 6/19/12 9:14 PM
 

missus-hbradio
Twin mommy

Member since 5/05

15857 total posts

Name:

Re: For once and for all, how does this bottle crap work!?!?

Posted by nferrandi

My DS is 27 months and still gets a bottle at night.Chat Icon up until a month ago he still got one at nap time too. We ad to drop it cold turkey. He screamed for days, but eventually he got the point. Now he gets nothing at nap time or a sippy of milk or juice if he asks for it.



They GUZZLE the milk down so right now I'm not ready to cut the milk out yet but I want it in a sippy not a bottle Chat Icon

Posted 6/19/12 9:27 PM
 

Eireann
Two ladies and a gentleman!

Member since 5/05

12165 total posts

Name:

Re: For once and for all, how does this bottle crap work!?!?

My DS is 19 mos and was drinking three 8oz bottles a day up until last week. I had tried at 15 months and 18 months to transition with no success. Anyway, the weekend before last we were at parties both days and I didn't bring the bottle with me, not necessarily on purpose though. I brought his sippy cups and I filled them with water or with milk if he shouted for "baba." When we got home both nights, it was already bedtime so in bed he went.

On Monday, it was like he forgot to ask for his morning bottle and I was about to just give it to him when I thought, 'Hey, wait a minute...' I hid the bottles because he knows where they are and when he shouted for "baba" I opened up that cabinet and took out a sippy and gave him milk in that.

It's been 8 full days now and we haven't looked back. He drinks WAY less milk now--as did my girls at the time--but I know he'll pick up the pace soon enough.

So with us a combination of cold turkey and staying out of the house did the trick!

Good luck!

Posted 6/19/12 9:38 PM
 

jewels
Stop and smell the flowers

Member since 7/06

1538 total posts

Name:

Re: For once and for all, how does this bottle crap work!?!?

I went through a similar thing with DS. I always thought he looked at me like I was crazy when I tried to give him milk in a sippy. So I kept pouring the milk back in the bottle so he would drink it. Eventually I figured he was big enough that if he missed a few servings of milk it wasn't a big deal and I went cold turkey to the cup - but in the mornings only at first and then eventually i did it that way at night too. We didn't get him off bottle until after 18 months too. I don't think it's a big deal to take your time with it as long as they can use a cup too and you brush teeth after using the bottle at night. We used the nozzle type sippies before straw sippies but I'd say that if they are already using the straws during the day for water then I would give them the milk in the straw sippy too. Otherwise it's like you are introducing 2 new things -milk in a cup & a new cup.

Posted 6/19/12 9:49 PM
 

missus-hbradio
Twin mommy

Member since 5/05

15857 total posts

Name:

Re: For once and for all, how does this bottle crap work!?!?

Posted by Eireann

My DS is 19 mos and was drinking three 8oz bottles a day up until last week. I had tried at 15 months and 18 months to transition with no success. Anyway, the weekend before last we were at parties both days and I didn't bring the bottle with me, not necessarily on purpose though. I brought his sippy cups and I filled them with water or with milk if he shouted for "baba." When we got home both nights, it was already bedtime so in bed he went.

On Monday, it was like he forgot to ask for his morning bottle and I was about to just give it to him when I thought, 'Hey, wait a minute...' I hid the bottles because he knows where they are and when he shouted for "baba" I opened up that cabinet and took out a sippy and gave him milk in that.

It's been 8 full days now and we haven't looked back. He drinks WAY less milk now--as did my girls at the time--but I know he'll pick up the pace soon enough.

So with us a combination of cold turkey and staying out of the house did the trick!

Good luck!



Thanks Eir! Sounds like that was pretty easy?!?!

Too bad my DS wakes up and IMMEDIATELY points to the dresser where his bottle is usually. I mean, he's half asleep and still pointing!
And DD likes to lounge on her boppy with her milk and be fanned while eating grapes.

Posted 6/19/12 9:57 PM
 

cds58019
The loves of my life :)

Member since 6/08

4276 total posts

Name:
Candice

Re: For once and for all, how does this bottle crap work!?!?

Im in the exact same boat as you. My twins are 21 months and they still have a milk bottle at nap time and bed time. And like you said, it's more of a comfort and soothing thing then them actually needing milk. As soon as they lay down in their cribs they are reaching their hands up for their bottle. I dont have the heart to take it away from them, it makes them too happy. I also dont think they will understand if I tried to explain why they cant have them anymore.

Sooooooo Im clearly no help but at least you know you're not alone! Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 6/19/12 10:41 PM
 

nycgirl
Angels!

Member since 3/09

7721 total posts

Name:

Re: For once and for all, how does this bottle crap work!?!?

IMO... The longer you wait... The harder it will be.
Ds didn't get the sippy cup.
He would wake and scream for the bottle.
We just took it away one day. We gave him a regular cup and that was that.
I didn't want him using food as comfort so drinking and eating are only done in the kitchen.

Posted 6/20/12 6:09 AM
 

sasha96
lovin' my 2 little ladies!

Member since 5/05

7401 total posts

Name:
Julianne

Re: For once and for all, how does this bottle crap work!?!?

yeah, that bottle is for comfort! the sippy top is just like a bottle. they use the same suckle pattern on it as they do on a bottle nipple. Just keep going with the straw if you have it. I've found cold turkey is the only way and delaying it only makes it worse. It will be a rough week! If they don't drink the milk, give them a yogurt or something to make up the difference.

Posted 6/20/12 6:54 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Do Bottle huggers really work? KittyCat 2/20/07 4 Parenting
Work related - OH CRAP! NovMom 3/26/09 2 Pregnancy
Holy crap, it DOES work KPtoys 1/16/08 2 Diet & Fitness
Crap - I'm going back to work on monday.... lipglossjunky73 6/1/07 13 Parenting
So we tried something yesterday and it seemed to work!!! So I have a bottle size question for you guys kerrycec03 2/19/09 6 Parenting
4 days before I return to work - now DS won't take a bottle! bpmom 6/5/08 18 Parenting