Financial whizzes -- I ask you.....

Posted By Message

leighdvm
My golden boys!

Member since 3/06

4419 total posts

Name:
Michele

Financial whizzes -- I ask you.....

If you were to take out a loan for a large purchase, say a car or home remodel, would you choose a second mortgage or a home equity loan?

Posted 2/17/10 8:46 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MommaG
Yay Spring!

Member since 5/05

5133 total posts

Name:
Gloria

Re: Financial whizzes -- I ask you.....

When we did the addition on our home, we refinanced our mortgage because we could write a lot of things off on our taxes, and always pay it off early if we want with no penalty. I don't know much about home equity loans, but I don't think you can write it off which is why we didn't go that route. I didn't like the idea of a second mortgage because I like the one consolidated payment.

Posted 2/17/10 10:53 AM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Financial whizzes -- I ask you.....

Posted by leighdvm

If you were to take out a loan for a large purchase, say a car or home remodel, would you choose a second mortgage or a home equity loan?




I would NEVER take out any sort of home loan (HELOC, HEL, etc) on a car... or anything not realted to a house.

You don't borrow secured debt (house), to pay down a depreciating asset (car). That should be financial rule number 1.

If you want a car, get a car loan.

If it's for a home remodel, I might do it. But i'd try to play a credit card game instead and look for a low APR credit card.

Unsecured debt is ALWAYS better than secured debt.

Posted 2/17/10 11:15 AM
 

leighdvm
My golden boys!

Member since 3/06

4419 total posts

Name:
Michele

Re: Financial whizzes -- I ask you.....

Posted by ave1024

Posted by leighdvm

If you were to take out a loan for a large purchase, say a car or home remodel, would you choose a second mortgage or a home equity loan?




I would NEVER take out any sort of home loan (HELOC, HEL, etc) on a car... or anything not realted to a house.

You don't borrow secured debt (house), to pay down a depreciating asset (car). That should be financial rule number 1.

If you want a car, get a car loan.

If it's for a home remodel, I might do it. But i'd try to play a credit card game instead and look for a low APR credit card.

Unsecured debt is ALWAYS better than secured debt.



From what people are telling me, it's better for 2nd mortgage or HELOC because you can write off the interest.....I'm no expert, believe me, and I appreciate any and all feedback Chat Icon

Posted 2/17/10 12:07 PM
 

KLSbear
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

1908 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: Financial whizzes -- I ask you.....

Posted by ave1024

I would NEVER take out any sort of home loan (HELOC, HEL, etc) on a car... or anything not realted to a house.

You don't borrow secured debt (house), to pay down a depreciating asset (car). That should be financial rule number 1.

If you want a car, get a car loan.

If it's for a home remodel, I might do it. But i'd try to play a credit card game instead and look for a low APR credit card.

Unsecured debt is ALWAYS better than secured debt.



I think it depends on the details of your specific situation and particularly your income and ability to pay down any loan. Our HELOC has a 3% interest rate - much better than the 9% being offered as a loan on the model car we purchased. The dealership would only allow a limited amount to be put on a CC. We put the max we could on the CC knowing we would be paying it off in full when it came in (just wanted to get the points on the card), we paid a significant amount in cash and the remaining 1/3 of the total cost went on the HELOC. At 3% it was the best deal and we knew we would be able to pay it down in the next few months.

The key thing is, IF you are using your equity in your home you'd better be very certain you can pay that loan down and regain the equity fairly quickly. You don't want to risk the equity for long term debt, but by the same token, if you can't pay it down quickly you don't really want to have it on a CC either. Look for cars that offer zero percent financing, or good deals on financing as the better option if it's long term debt.

Message edited 2010-02-17 12:49:31.900000.

Posted 2/17/10 12:48 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Financial whizzes -- I ask you.....

Posted by leighdvm

From what people are telling me, it's better for 2nd mortgage or HELOC because you can write off the interest.....I'm no expert, believe me, and I appreciate any and all feedback Chat Icon




Frankly, it's not good advice.

That's like saying "I am buying a house because I need tax breaks".

In order to get tax breaks, you need to be paying more tax in the first place. The same advice pretty much applies... you should never borrow against secure debt to pay off unsecured debt.

Car loans are unsecured (by anything outside of the car). You should never, never, never take out a HELOC to buy a car. Read any financial blog or financial forum online and you will hear the same thing.

Car loans typically carry lower interest rates than HELOCs anyways. My credit union offers 4.25% car loans. Many car manufacturers give you 0% financing too.

Posted 2/17/10 1:06 PM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Financial whizzes -- I ask you.....

if you miss a few car payments....they take the car back

(I can't believe a new car rate would be 9%...I am paying 3% on a car I bought it may)

if you missing a few HELOC payments..foreclosure

I would never use the equity in my house for anything other then increasing the value of my home...b/c people have been using their homes as ATMs is part of the reason we are in the housing mess now

Posted 2/17/10 1:08 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Financial whizzes -- I ask you.....

Posted by KLSbear

I think it depends on the details of your specific situation and particularly your income and ability to pay down any loan. Our HELOC has a 3% interest rate - much better than the 9% being offered as a loan on the model car we purchased.





I would never pay 9% in car financing in the first place. Like I said in the PP, there are credit unions out there offering around 4%.

And your HELOC offers 3% now, what if interest rates spike up?

What if times get tough and you have to dump the car payment? At least with a car loan, you can default on that and just lose the car. With a HELOC... you default on that and you lose your house!

Posted 2/17/10 1:09 PM
 

melbalalala
Little Lady

Member since 5/07

5015 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Financial whizzes -- I ask you.....

I wouldn't.. I'd just start saving the money until I had enough to make the large purchase. Chat Icon Debt creeps me out....

Message edited 2010-02-17 13:27:45.413000.

Posted 2/17/10 1:27 PM
 

leighdvm
My golden boys!

Member since 3/06

4419 total posts

Name:
Michele

Re: Financial whizzes -- I ask you.....

I just want to add that I wasn't only asking about a car -- also for a home remodel. Thanks for everyone's replies!!

Posted 2/17/10 1:35 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
this may be a stupid question but I have to ask luvsbob4603 6/22/05 12 Families Helping Families ™
I don't usually ask for prayers... SoinLove 6/19/05 17 Prayers
please dont laugh...but i have to ask Boobobunny 6/3/05 12 Families Helping Families ™
List of questions to ask current Homeowners? groovypeg 5/28/05 16 Home
what to ask when you call a realtor? bella 5/12/05 2 Home
Can I ask HarleyGirlFLA 5/12/05 20 TTC