Financial Advice Needed

Posted By Message

TTCin2010
LIF Infant

Member since 1/10

118 total posts

Name:
TTC Girl

Financial Advice Needed

Situation: You bought a house for $420,000 back in 2005 and took a 20/80 mortgage out on it. The interest rates that you took out on the house were extremely high. You want to refinance because today's interest rates will potentially save you $1,000 a month (excellent credit/no cc debt). Unfortunately, your house will not appraise for enough for you to refinance. Mortgage is with a well known bank.

Would you...
withdraw money from your 403bto pay off enough of your loan to refinance?

You and husband are teachers and have pensions. Money saved from mortgage can be put back into 403b easily over next few years.

Mathematically, what would be worse? Continue to pay an insane amount of interest on mortgage over next 25 years or take a hit on your 403b now?

This is just a thought and I am looking for honest opinions as I know that taking money out of retirement is considered to be taboo.

Message edited 2010-08-23 18:27:51.940000.

Posted 8/23/10 6:26 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: Financial Advice Needed

It's hard to say. I would not withdraw money from my retirement to put into a house to increase the equity just to refi a house. What I would do, is aggressively pay down the Home Equity loan on the house to increase your equity in the home then revisit refinancing. Also, if you made one extra mortgage payment each year, you can potentially knock 10 years off a 30 year mortgage.

Also, for the past several years, mortgage rates have been low. Right now they are lower then they were but they were never really very high. What is your current interest rate as opposed to your potential rate? Are you rolling closing costs and if you are, where is your break even point?

Posted 8/23/10 7:08 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Financial Advice Needed

How much do you need to pump into the mortgage to refinance (and borrow from 403b)?


Posted 8/23/10 7:13 PM
 

TTCin2010
LIF Infant

Member since 1/10

118 total posts

Name:
TTC Girl

Re: Financial Advice Needed

Thank you for your reply.

Our rates are:
20% loan - 9% range
80% loan - 7% range

Potential interest rate - 3.1%

We would roll the closing costs into the loan.


Posted 8/23/10 7:15 PM
 

TTCin2010
LIF Infant

Member since 1/10

118 total posts

Name:
TTC Girl

Re: Financial Advice Needed

Posted by ave1024

How much do you need to pump into the mortgage to refinance (and borrow from 403b)?





About $25,000.

Posted 8/23/10 7:15 PM
 

FranM
And so it goes....

Member since 9/05

2217 total posts

Name:

Re: Financial Advice Needed

I would look into taking a Loan from your 401(b) rather than a withdrawal. You will be paying interest on the loan but you will pay the interest back to yourself. There is not tax penalty on a loan unless you default. You should be able to use your mortgate savings to pay back the loan over a 24 - 28 month period and then start reaping the benefits of your refi.

Posted 8/23/10 7:41 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Financial Advice Needed

Posted by TTCin2010

Posted by ave1024

How much do you need to pump into the mortgage to refinance (and borrow from 403b)?





About $25,000.




25k is not a lot. I would do it. But I would try to take a loan out before a withdrawal.

Posted 8/23/10 8:04 PM
 

LuvHelloKitty
LIF Infant

Member since 1/10

112 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: Financial Advice Needed

I just had this dilemma a few months ago. I bought my condo in 2006 with only 5% downpayment, 30 year fixed mortgage at 5.9%. I would love to refinance to get it down to a 4.5% rate.

However the condo's value has dropped 30% in value. I contacted the bank that holds my mortgage and they told me I could still refinance under a 105% Loan to Value ratio program put in place by the Obama administration to allow homeowners who are underwater on their mortgage to refinance, but I would have to kick in at least 30K to do so.

I talked to a financial advisor and realized it wasn't worth it. 30K is better to leave it in my 401K/savings and let it accrue interest. If I refinance, I'd have to really kick in around 40K to account for Closing costs (min 8-12K), appraisal ($500), application fees, and other costs associated with refinancing (paying points to get APR down to 4.5, 4 or even 3.875%).

So no - I decided against it because the costs weren't worth it for me....

Posted 8/23/10 8:43 PM
 

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: Financial Advice Needed

Posted by TTCin2010

Thank you for your reply.

Our rates are:
20% loan - 9% range
80% loan - 7% range

Potential interest rate - 3.1%

We would roll the closing costs into the loan.





I think you will have a hard time getting a 3.1 rate and if you are rolling the closing costs back into the loan, you are really just increasing debt. You end up paying the closing costs over the life of your mortgage.

Posted 8/23/10 9:25 PM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Financial Advice Needed

who quoted you a 3.1% rate?

rates are on average 4.5% right now

Posted 8/24/10 9:52 AM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Financial Advice Needed

I would definitely take the $$ out. $1000 a month is HUGE.

Posted 8/24/10 10:14 AM
 

LeShellem
A new beginning

Member since 2/07

3600 total posts

Name:
LeShelle

Re: Financial Advice Needed

Could you try the making homes affordable program. They did not do a physical appraisal and the closing costs were paid by the government. Contact your bank to see if you are eligible.

Posted 8/24/10 1:29 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Financial Advice Needed

Posted by LeShellem

Could you try the making homes affordable program. They did not do a physical appraisal and the closing costs were paid by the government. Contact your bank to see if you are eligible.




This is NOT true!!!! We did the Home Affordable program because we did not need a new appraisal and it was the only way to refi being our value dropped. We paid $8k in closing costs out of our own pocket PLUS $4k for taxes that were coming due.

ETA: There is a misconception about the Home Affordable program. It is not for people who are in forclosure or close to forclosure either. In order to be eligible you CANNOT be behind in payments at all. The program was created to help people refi who's home values have dropped who would not be able to refi the traditional way due to appraisals, etc. Our rate went from 6.25% (we bought in 2006 and that was a good rate than) to 4.85%.

Message edited 2010-08-24 22:04:13.500000.

Posted 8/24/10 9:59 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Financial advice needed...... KittyCat 7/29/09 3 Families Helping Families ™
Financial advice needed! hayleyandsteveold 3/5/08 4 Families Helping Families ™
Job advice needed...I went on an interview CaseyGirl 8/24/05 9 Families Helping Families ™
Santorini Advice Needed Leeners 5/19/05 11 Travel & Vacations
Florence Advice Needed Leeners 5/19/05 4 Travel & Vacations
Opinions (advice needed) PLEASE..job related dm24angel 5/17/05 32 Families Helping Families ™