FB Status - Immigration Laws

Posted By Message

LoriH
There's no place like home

Member since 8/07

4110 total posts

Name:
Lori

FB Status - Immigration Laws

This is a family member's FB status today.

"Interesting: - If you pass the North Korean border illegally you get 12 yrs. hard labor, you pass the Afghan border illegally you get shot, you pass the American border illegally you get a job, driver?s license, allowance for a place to live, health care, education, billions of dollars spent so you can read a document....... We carry passports in other countries or face jail time. Repost this if you agree"

I do not see this family member often, we are not close, we have very different political and religious views. However I couldn't leave this status alone, I had to say something. Instead of addressing the subject mater, I commented on the comparison made in the statement. "I am sorry but comparing the US to a communist country and a terrorist country is absolutely ridiculous. Freedom and a constitution are what make this country great."

He obviously did not like my comment and turned in into an issue of paying taxes ect. Anyone else take issue with this statement? Not the subject matter at hand, just the comparison in the statement.

Please do not turn this into a discussion on immigration, the law in AZ or racial profiling.

Posted 5/5/10 1:11 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: FB Status - Immigration Laws

I have seen that status and I agree with you. Would you want to live in either of those countries? I wouldn't. But I am sure that there are people who would be happy to see people trying to come here illegally be shot on sight or sentenced to hard labor.

Posted 5/5/10 1:15 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: FB Status - Immigration Laws

I'd say the person has no idea what illegal immigrants go through in this country. No one is handing them a job, education & healthcare as they cross the border.

If we want to stop illegal immigrantion, we need to come down on the employers. They are the ones hiring them, skirting irregularities on their I-9 forms because they want to pay less for a workforce.

It's utterly ridiculous to hold Afghanistan & North Korean immigration policies up as an "ideal"

Posted 5/5/10 1:27 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: FB Status - Immigration Laws

Posted by nrthshgrl

I'd say the person has no idea what illegal immigrants go through in this country. No one is handing them a job, education & healthcare as they cross the border.

If we want to stop illegal immigrantion, we need to come down on the employers. They are the ones hiring them, skirting irregularities on their I-9 forms because they want to pay less for a workforce.

It's utterly ridiculous to hold Afghanistan & North Korean immigration policies up as an "ideal"



I just want to engrave in stone EVERYTHING you just wrote.

I also want to add that this person obviously didn't even read the BULLET points of the new healthcare bill, which SPECIFICALLY addresses and EXCLUDES illegals.

the comparisons are totally ridiculous.

when it suits them, socialism/communism is the devil OR it's the way to deal with those kind...depending on the topic.

I WISH someone would have posted that in my facebook world

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-05-05 13:39:38.173000.

Posted 5/5/10 1:37 PM
 

Sassyz75
Turning a new page

Member since 5/05

9731 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: FB Status - Immigration Laws

As far as I know- the only thing immigrants are entitled to is ER visits if necessary and their children to use the school system...
now I'm not sure what would make people happy? To allow people to drop dead in the street? Is that the kind of country we want to be? Or, are we the kind of country that doesn't want to educate children and "punish" them because of their parents?

I just don't get it.

As far as drivers license- the last time I checked you needed to show proof of citizenship.

Posted 5/5/10 1:58 PM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: FB Status - Immigration Laws

Posted by Sassyz75

As far as I know- the only thing immigrants are entitled to is ER visits if necessary and their children to use the school system...
now I'm not sure what would make people happy? To allow people to drop dead in the street? Is that the kind of country we want to be? Or, are we the kind of country that doesn't want to educate children and "punish" them because of their parents?




Honestly- I think that what you've described is what a lot of people want. Do I agree with illegal immigration? No- but I think it's sad the way we've demonized people who come here for a better life for themselves and their kids. Not all of them are drug dealers and murderers (and we do a good job of creating those here from our own citizens). As Barb has already pointed out, as long as people are willing to employ illegals, they will continue to come.

Message edited 2010-05-05 14:16:14.643000.

Posted 5/5/10 2:15 PM
 

MissRadiant
Happily Ever After

Member since 9/08

2534 total posts

Name:
N

Re: FB Status - Immigration Laws

That status is disturbing on so many levels. Thank you for commenting and sharing your opinion.

I agree with what most of the PP's mentioned.... so now we are looking to get guidance from a terrorist country and a communist one? Give me a break.

It's sad bc the humane value does seem to be lost. Let the illegal immigrants die in the street and their children be uneducated. That should show them to come here! Chat Icon

I mean after all, when Columbus discovered America they all came with their American passports. Chat Icon

Posted 5/5/10 2:34 PM
 

MrsA714
Baby #2 is here!

Member since 8/07

8806 total posts

Name:

Re: FB Status - Immigration Laws

Posted by Sassyz75


As far as drivers license- the last time I checked you needed to show proof of citizenship.




This is neither here nor there...but I thought you didn't need to show proof of citizenship to apply for a drivers license. Not unless you wanted to apply for the new 'enhanced' license. Am I wrong? Just curious.

Posted 5/5/10 2:35 PM
 

Cpt2007
A new love!

Member since 1/08

5946 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: FB Status - Immigration Laws

Posted by MrsA714

Posted by Sassyz75


As far as drivers license- the last time I checked you needed to show proof of citizenship.




This is neither here nor there...but I thought you didn't need to show proof of citizenship to apply for a drivers license. Not unless you wanted to apply for the new 'enhanced' license. Am I wrong? Just curious.



most states require you to provide proof of "legal presence" meaning documents that at some level do require you to prove citizenship or being a legal alien.

Posted 5/5/10 4:15 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: FB Status - Immigration Laws

Posted by nrthshgrl

I'd say the person has no idea what illegal immigrants go through in this country. No one is handing them a job, education & healthcare as they cross the border.

If we want to stop illegal immigrantion, we need to come down on the employers. They are the ones hiring them, skirting irregularities on their I-9 forms because they want to pay less for a workforce.

It's utterly ridiculous to hold Afghanistan & North Korean immigration policies up as an "ideal"



Exactly!


UGH! I can't even!

Posted 5/5/10 4:22 PM
 

gporka23
:)

Member since 11/08

3783 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: FB Status - Immigration Laws

This is something my dad would say.. or post as his status if he had FB.. and it really bothers me.

Yes I agree there is NO comparison at all..

I could go on but this type of thing stresses me out.. too many screaming arguments with my dad over this I have learned to keep my opinions to myself... as should most of the people that make this their FB status. JMO.

Posted 5/5/10 4:24 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: FB Status - Immigration Laws

Posted by gporka23

This is something my dad would say.. or post as his status if he had FB.. and it really bothers me.

Yes I agree there is NO comparison at all..

I could go on but this type of thing stresses me out.. too many screaming arguments with my dad over this I have learned to keep my opinions to myself... as should most of the people that make this their FB status. JMO.



Haha...so true. When I see FB statuses that pizz me off, I just have to tell myself to back away and don't even try to fight it out on FB Chat Icon

Posted 5/5/10 4:29 PM
 

LoriH
There's no place like home

Member since 8/07

4110 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: FB Status - Immigration Laws

Posted by brownie

Posted by gporka23

This is something my dad would say.. or post as his status if he had FB.. and it really bothers me.

Yes I agree there is NO comparison at all..

I could go on but this type of thing stresses me out.. too many screaming arguments with my dad over this I have learned to keep my opinions to myself... as should most of the people that make this their FB status. JMO.



Haha...so true. When I see FB statuses that pizz me off, I just have to tell myself to back away and don't even try to fight it out on FB Chat Icon



I try to do the same and trust me this guy and a few others have posted some really bad ones. The ignorance of this one just got to me. I'll blame the pregnancy hormones, the fact that I am very opinionated and have a very thin filter. Chat Icon

Posted 5/5/10 6:30 PM
 

Alexandra17
Keep It Positive

Member since 4/09

6262 total posts

Name:
Alexandra (ali)

Re: FB Status - Immigration Laws

People need to get out more and really stop hopping on this band wagon of anti immigrant crap. I am sick of it. It makes me so upset that instead of saying how we could HELP people, we want to have them all out. HOW did YOUR family get here, remember those days..wait you DON'T..you have the fortune of being 3rd generation. You have no idea of what they must have struggled through.

Posted 5/5/10 6:37 PM
 

klingklang77
kraftwerk!

Member since 7/06

11489 total posts

Name:
Völlig losgelöst

Re: FB Status - Immigration Laws

Yeah it would annoy me. I would just hide them from my news feed from now on. Chat Icon

Posted 5/5/10 7:48 PM
 

kabr13
LIF Toddler

Member since 2/09

470 total posts

Name:

Re: FB Status - Immigration Laws

Posted by Sassyz75

As far as I know- the only thing immigrants are entitled to is ER visits if necessary and their children to use the school system...
now I'm not sure what would make people happy? To allow people to drop dead in the street? Is that the kind of country we want to be? Or, are we the kind of country that doesn't want to educate children and "punish" them because of their parents?

I just don't get it.

As far as drivers license- the last time I checked you needed to show proof of citizenship.




I used to work with a high risk pregnancy population in queens. More often than not women would come over from their countries late pregnancy, sometimes at week 39 just to have their child be an american citizen. Their child would then qualify for medicaid till the age of 18 at the expense of all tax payers in the US. Also, a hospital cannot turn down a service so technically if you are in the hospital at length and have no payment source and or insurance there is really nothing they can do, so yes illegal immigrants are entitiled to more then an ER visit. Just something to think about.

Posted 5/5/10 7:51 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: FB Status - Immigration Laws

Posted by LoriH

Posted by brownie

Posted by gporka23

This is something my dad would say.. or post as his status if he had FB.. and it really bothers me.

Yes I agree there is NO comparison at all..

I could go on but this type of thing stresses me out.. too many screaming arguments with my dad over this I have learned to keep my opinions to myself... as should most of the people that make this their FB status. JMO.



Haha...so true. When I see FB statuses that pizz me off, I just have to tell myself to back away and don't even try to fight it out on FB Chat Icon



I try to do the same and trust me this guy and a few others have posted some really bad ones. The ignorance of this one just got to me. I'll blame the pregnancy hormones, the fact that I am very opinionated and have a very thin filter. Chat Icon



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 5/5/10 8:01 PM
 

Sassyz75
Turning a new page

Member since 5/05

9731 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: FB Status - Immigration Laws

Posted by kabr13

Posted by Sassyz75

As far as I know- the only thing immigrants are entitled to is ER visits if necessary and their children to use the school system...
now I'm not sure what would make people happy? To allow people to drop dead in the street? Is that the kind of country we want to be? Or, are we the kind of country that doesn't want to educate children and "punish" them because of their parents?

I just don't get it.

As far as drivers license- the last time I checked you needed to show proof of citizenship.




I used to work with a high risk pregnancy population in queens. More often than not women would come over from their countries late pregnancy, sometimes at week 39 just to have their child be an american citizen. Their child would then qualify for medicaid till the age of 18 at the expense of all tax payers in the US. Also, a hospital cannot turn down a service so technically if you are in the hospital at length and have no payment source and or insurance there is really nothing they can do, so yes illegal immigrants are entitiled to more then an ER visit. Just something to think about.



if I were a pregnant woman from a second or third world country I'd come here too so my child would be given a chance at something better.. dont' we all want the same things for our children?

Again- not sure what we should do if someone goes to the hospital and needs extended care and doesn't have any insurance, illegal or not- let them die? let them suffer? is that what would make us happy... just to save money?

and how would we feel if we were traveling overseas and our insurance wasn't "good" or we didn't have any and we fell sick and we were turned away? There would be international outrage.

Posted 5/5/10 10:59 PM
 

butterfly20
Party of 5 - 2015

Member since 4/06

7390 total posts

Name:

Re: FB Status - Immigration Laws

Posted by kabr13

Posted by Sassyz75

As far as I know- the only thing immigrants are entitled to is ER visits if necessary and their children to use the school system...
now I'm not sure what would make people happy? To allow people to drop dead in the street? Is that the kind of country we want to be? Or, are we the kind of country that doesn't want to educate children and "punish" them because of their parents?

I just don't get it.

As far as drivers license- the last time I checked you needed to show proof of citizenship.




I used to work with a high risk pregnancy population in queens. More often than not women would come over from their countries late pregnancy, sometimes at week 39 just to have their child be an american citizen. Their child would then qualify for medicaid till the age of 18 at the expense of all tax payers in the US. Also, a hospital cannot turn down a service so technically if you are in the hospital at length and have no payment source and or insurance there is really nothing they can do, so yes illegal immigrants are entitiled to more then an ER visit. Just something to think about.



Yes, this is happening in our backyard- over at Winthrop Hospital, probably the others too.

Posted 5/6/10 12:36 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: FB Status - Immigration Laws

Posted by kabr13

Posted by Sassyz75

As far as I know- the only thing immigrants are entitled to is ER visits if necessary and their children to use the school system...
now I'm not sure what would make people happy? To allow people to drop dead in the street? Is that the kind of country we want to be? Or, are we the kind of country that doesn't want to educate children and "punish" them because of their parents?

I just don't get it.

As far as drivers license- the last time I checked you needed to show proof of citizenship.




I used to work with a high risk pregnancy population in queens. More often than not women would come over from their countries late pregnancy, sometimes at week 39 just to have their child be an american citizen. Their child would then qualify for medicaid till the age of 18 at the expense of all tax payers in the US.



There child is an American citizen, so why wouldn't they have all the benefits a citizen has?Chat Icon

Being a American means that you were born here. Outside of a Native American, I'm assuming at one point every single American had an ancestor that was a chld of an immigrant - and they were afforded (or eventually afforded) the same rights as everyone else.

Posted 5/6/10 6:31 AM
 

CallaLily
Thank you, Saint Gerard!

Member since 10/07

4937 total posts

Name:

Re: FB Status - Immigration Laws

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by kabr13

Posted by Sassyz75

As far as I know- the only thing immigrants are entitled to is ER visits if necessary and their children to use the school system...
now I'm not sure what would make people happy? To allow people to drop dead in the street? Is that the kind of country we want to be? Or, are we the kind of country that doesn't want to educate children and "punish" them because of their parents?

I just don't get it.

As far as drivers license- the last time I checked you needed to show proof of citizenship.




I used to work with a high risk pregnancy population in queens. More often than not women would come over from their countries late pregnancy, sometimes at week 39 just to have their child be an american citizen. Their child would then qualify for medicaid till the age of 18 at the expense of all tax payers in the US.



There child is an American citizen, so why wouldn't they have all the benefits a citizen has?Chat Icon

Being a American means that you were born here. Outside of a Native American, I'm assuming at one point every single American had an ancestor that was a chld of an immigrant - and they were afforded (or eventually afforded) the same rights as everyone else.



I think she meant the mother was an illegal. Sorry, but if parents come here illegally, I don't think a child should be an American citizen.

Posted 5/6/10 8:02 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
I have the Best In-Laws!!!! JodiBabe 9/22/05 19 Families Helping Families ™
Wish me Luck...the In Laws fly in today btrflygrl 9/21/05 7 Families Helping Families ™
work hour....laws? butterfly22 9/2/05 8 Families Helping Families ™
Labor Laws - any HR person out there Irishlass 8/25/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
Does anyone know anything about NYS lemon laws? MrsR 8/15/05 3 Families Helping Families ™
Would you vacation with your in-laws? jms100303 5/26/05 64 Families Helping Families ™