Fat Cat Tax Question

Posted By Message

mommy2Alex
3 babies for me :)

Member since 5/05

6683 total posts

Name:

Fat Cat Tax Question

For those that want the fat cats to pay their fair share of taxes, I have a question (This excludes corporations) I am talking about individuals, not corporations.

If the top 10% of earners in this country pay 73% of all tax revenue collected in this country and 40% of earners pay $0 or have a negative tax liability, how is this an unfair system?

I know there are more complicated issues underlying it, but these fat cats are funding 3/4 of the US governments tax income. Do we ever think that maybe it is a spending problem on the governments part?

How much more do we want them to pay?

Posted 10/4/11 2:20 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Re: Fat Cat Tax Question

I think it's not the amount of tax paid in total, but the rate they pay taxes on and on what they pay tax on.

Mr. WILLIAMS: Well, if we take a look at people with incomes, say, over $500,000. That's about one percent of all Americans. And the total share of taxes that they pay is about 24 percent. They have about 16 percent, 17 percent of income. They pay about half again that much share of taxes.



http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=125997180


"Last year my federal tax bill ... was $6,938,744. That sounds like a lot of money. But what I paid was only 17.4 percent of my taxable income -- and that's actually a lower percentage than was paid by any of the other 20 people in our office. Their tax burdens ranged from 33 percent to 41 percent and averaged 36 percent."

-Warren Buffet
http://money.cnn.com/2011/08/15/news/economy/buffett_taxes/index.htm

Many of the billionaires, like Buffet, pay only on actual income and end up paying zero on their investment income. Some CEO's set their income at a ridiculously low rate, like $1/yr salary and end up paying even LESS tax because of that.

They should have to pay tax on the investment income as well.

Why are you opposed to taxing millionaires and billionaires so they are paying their fair share of taxes?

Why should working people like us here, whether we make 50K a year or 250K/yr have to pay 35+ % and a billionaire only pay 16%?

Of course Gov't spending is out of control. Too much is being spent on the programs lobbyists (aka corporate paid bribers) steer politicians towards.

Our schools, roads, bridges, tunnels, rail systems, power grids etc are all paying the price and falling apart while we spend wastefully.

Taxing the disadvantaged isn't going to do much. Blood from a turnip and all that. If some schlep is clearing 20K/yr on social security or disability or in a minimum wage job, what is the $100/year in taxes going to do? And if they're working, they're paying FICA, SS and Medicare. I believe SS income is taxed as is some disability income? So even some poor may still be paying taxes.

Making 35k/yr on Long Island is borderline poverty, but elsewhere it's a decent, livable salary. Sometimes I think we forget that the numbers here on LI, metro NY, Washington DC, parts of Cali are different than the rest of the country. 200k/year on LI or in Westchester county is firmly middle class. In Iowa? You're living quite well. So to hear the rest of the nation and politicians refer to those making over 100k/yr as "well off" can be infuriating, because we're far from "well off" at 100k on Long Island. So I think our views on dollar amounts tend to be a little skewed.

ETA: I'm not an accountant or an expert, I go by what I've read and heard. I'm open to learning more though, so educate me if you think I am off base Chat Icon

Message edited 2011-10-04 14:58:56.757000.

Posted 10/4/11 2:55 PM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Fat Cat Tax Question

This site has a lot of good charts: http://rationalrevolution.net/articles/american_income_taxation.htm

Especially towards the bottom, when they explain how it's basically the same tax burden overall, vs income.

This next graph, perhaps, sums everything up best. Though so much is heard about how the wealthy pay a hugely disproportionate share of taxes, this simply is not the case. Virtually every time someone makes the claim that the wealthy pay a disproportionate amount of the taxes they are discussing only federal income taxes, because the federal income tax is the most progressive major tax in America. However, when all taxes are taken into consideration every group is currently paying a roughly equal share of taxes to their share of national income, and in fact the ratios of shares of income to shares of total taxes is much more equal now than it has been any time since reasonably reliable income and taxation data has been recorded, which covers about the past 60 years. Traditionally in America, throughout virtually all of American history, taxes have been levied most heavily on the wealthy, and this was especially true during the first 80 years of the 20th century. Prior to World War II income taxes were levied exclusively on the wealthy.
External Image



The assumption from people in the upper middle class is that if taxes are getting worse for them, then they must be getting even worse for those above them, but this is not the case. The burden is really increasing on those people making between about $60,000 and $150,000 or $200,000 a year, but once you get above that into the $500,000+ a year incomes the tax burden has been greatly reduced over the past 20 years.



Over the past 20 years the salaries of corporate executives have grown by a factor of more than 10. In 1982 the average corporate executive was paid about 42 times the salary of the average employee. In 2002 that figure had increased to 500 times the compensation of the average employee.

Posted 10/4/11 3:08 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Fat Cat Tax Question

I hpe that satisfies you, b/c the answer is there in technicolor.

and again, beyond that, I don't care about the people making 500k or even 1 million dollars a year...they are at least paying SOMETHING.

the corporations are what is really killing us so they can no longer be put to the side.

Posted 10/4/11 3:11 PM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Fat Cat Tax Question

Posted by Ophelia

I hpe that satisfies you, b/c the answer is there in technicolor.

and again, beyond that, I don't care about the people making 500k or even 1 million dollars a year...they are at least paying SOMETHING.

the corporations are what is really killing us so they can no longer be put to the side.



http://www.businessinsider.com/companies-pay-lowest-tax-loopholes-2011-2
America's corporate tax rate is 35 percent.

But 115 companies on the S&P500 pay less than 20 percent in taxes, according to a study the Capital IQ and The New York Times. That's not even counting 37 companies like Citigroup and AIG that received more in tax credits than they paid.

All this thanks to loopholes in the immensely complicated tax code.

We tracked down the data from Capital IQ to identify the large corporations that pay less than 5 percent in taxes.



http://www.politifact.com/ohio/statements/2011/mar/15/marcia-fudge/rep-marcia-fudge-says-some-largest-corporations-pa/
Between 1998 to 2005, GAO found that about 72 percent of large foreign controlled companies and 55 percent of large U.S. controlled companies reported zero tax liability for at least one year. About 57 percent of foreign controlled large companies and 42 percent of U.S. large companies paid no taxes in two or more years, and a third of the foreign companies and one quarter of their U.S. counterparts paid no taxes for at least four of those years. Just 45 percent of large U.S. companies and 28 percent of foreign companies reported a tax liability for each of the eight years. The report defined large companies as those with at least $250 million in assets, or at least $50 million in receipts

When GAO factored smaller companies into the mix, it found a higher overall proportion who didn’t pay taxes. Throughout the eight years the study examined, the overall percentage of non-tax-paying foreign and U.S. controlled companies never fell beneath 60 percent annually.
The report said that corporations may not pay U.S. income taxes for a variety of reasons, including current-year operating losses, tax credits, and multinational corporations shifting income to lower tax jurisdictions.



http://www.freerangelongmont.com/2011/03/14/corporate-tax-cheats/
BANK OF AMERICA: In 2009, Bank of America didn’t pay a single penny in federal income taxes, exploiting the tax code so as to avoid paying its fair share. “Oh, yeah, this happens all the time,” said Robert Willens, a tax accounting expert interviewed by McClatchy. “If you go out and try to make money and you don’t do it, why should the government pay you for your losses?” asked Bob McIntyre of Citizens for Tax Justice. The same year, the mega-bank’s top executives received pay “ranging from $6 million to nearly $30 million.”

BOEING: Despite receiving billions of dollars from the federal government every single year in taxpayer subsidies from the U.S. government, Boeing didn’t “pay a dime of U.S. federal corporate income taxes” between 2008 and 2010.

CITIGROUP: Citigroup’s deferred income taxes for the third quarter of 2010 amounted to a grand total of $0.00. At the same time, Citigroup has continued to pay its staff lavishly. “John Havens, the head of Citigroup’s investment bank, is expected to be the bank’s highest paid executive for the second year in a row, with a compensation package worth $9.5 million.

EXXON-MOBIL: The oil giant uses offshore subsidiaries in the Caribbean to avoid paying taxes in the United States. Although Exxon-Mobil paid $15 billion in taxes in 2009, not a penny of those taxes went to the American Treasury. This was the same year that the company overtook Wal-Mart in the Fortune 500. Meanwhile the total compensation of Exxon-Mobil’s CEO the same year was over $29,000,000.

GENERAL ELECTRIC: In 2009, General Electric — the world’s largest corporation — filed more than 7,000 tax returns and still paid nothing to U.S. government. They managed to do this by a tax code that essentially subsidizes companies for losing profits and allows them to set up tax havens overseas. That same year GE CEO Jeffery Immelt — who recently scored a spot on a White House economic advisory board — “earned total compensation of $9.89 million.” In 2002, Immelt displayed his lack of economic patriotism, saying, “When I am talking to GE managers, I talk China, China, China, China, China….I am a nut on China. Outsourcing from China is going to grow to 5 billion.”

WELLS FARGO: Despite being the fourth largest bank in the country, Wells Fargo was able to escape paying federal taxes by writing all of its losses off after its acquisition of Wachovia. Yet in 2009 the chief executive of Wells Fargo also saw his compensation “more than double” as he earned “a salary of $5.6 million paid in cash and stock and stock awards of more than $13 million.”

Message edited 2011-10-04 15:45:10.593000.

Posted 10/4/11 3:41 PM
 

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Re: Fat Cat Tax Question

Posted by GoldenRod

http://www.businessinsider.com/companies-pay-lowest-tax-loopholes-2011-2
America's corporate tax rate is 35 percent.

But 115 companies on the S&P500 pay less than 20 percent in taxes, according to a study the Capital IQ and The New York Times. That's not even counting 37 companies like Citigroup and AIG that received more in tax credits than they paid.

All this thanks to loopholes in the immensely complicated tax code.

We tracked down the data from Capital IQ to identify the large corporations that pay less than 5 percent in taxes.



http://www.politifact.com/ohio/statements/2011/mar/15/marcia-fudge/rep-marcia-fudge-says-some-largest-corporations-pa/
Between 1998 to 2005, GAO found that about 72 percent of large foreign controlled companies and 55 percent of large U.S. controlled companies reported zero tax liability for at least one year. About 57 percent of foreign controlled large companies and 42 percent of U.S. large companies paid no taxes in two or more years, and a third of the foreign companies and one quarter of their U.S. counterparts paid no taxes for at least four of those years. Just 45 percent of large U.S. companies and 28 percent of foreign companies reported a tax liability for each of the eight years. The report defined large companies as those with at least $250 million in assets, or at least $50 million in receipts

When GAO factored smaller companies into the mix, it found a higher overall proportion who didn’t pay taxes. Throughout the eight years the study examined, the overall percentage of non-tax-paying foreign and U.S. controlled companies never fell beneath 60 percent annually.
The report said that corporations may not pay U.S. income taxes for a variety of reasons, including current-year operating losses, tax credits, and multinational corporations shifting income to lower tax jurisdictions.



http://www.freerangelongmont.com/2011/03/14/corporate-tax-cheats/
BANK OF AMERICA: In 2009, Bank of America didn’t pay a single penny in federal income taxes, exploiting the tax code so as to avoid paying its fair share. “Oh, yeah, this happens all the time,” said Robert Willens, a tax accounting expert interviewed by McClatchy. “If you go out and try to make money and you don’t do it, why should the government pay you for your losses?” asked Bob McIntyre of Citizens for Tax Justice. The same year, the mega-bank’s top executives received pay “ranging from $6 million to nearly $30 million.”

BOEING: Despite receiving billions of dollars from the federal government every single year in taxpayer subsidies from the U.S. government, Boeing didn’t “pay a dime of U.S. federal corporate income taxes” between 2008 and 2010.

CITIGROUP: Citigroup’s deferred income taxes for the third quarter of 2010 amounted to a grand total of $0.00. At the same time, Citigroup has continued to pay its staff lavishly. “John Havens, the head of Citigroup’s investment bank, is expected to be the bank’s highest paid executive for the second year in a row, with a compensation package worth $9.5 million.

EXXON-MOBIL: The oil giant uses offshore subsidiaries in the Caribbean to avoid paying taxes in the United States. Although Exxon-Mobil paid $15 billion in taxes in 2009, not a penny of those taxes went to the American Treasury. This was the same year that the company overtook Wal-Mart in the Fortune 500. Meanwhile the total compensation of Exxon-Mobil’s CEO the same year was over $29,000,000.

GENERAL ELECTRIC: In 2009, General Electric — the world’s largest corporation — filed more than 7,000 tax returns and still paid nothing to U.S. government. They managed to do this by a tax code that essentially subsidizes companies for losing profits and allows them to set up tax havens overseas. That same year GE CEO Jeffery Immelt — who recently scored a spot on a White House economic advisory board — “earned total compensation of $9.89 million.” In 2002, Immelt displayed his lack of economic patriotism, saying, “When I am talking to GE managers, I talk China, China, China, China, China….I am a nut on China. Outsourcing from China is going to grow to 5 billion.”

WELLS FARGO: Despite being the fourth largest bank in the country, Wells Fargo was able to escape paying federal taxes by writing all of its losses off after its acquisition of Wachovia. Yet in 2009 the chief executive of Wells Fargo also saw his compensation “more than double” as he earned “a salary of $5.6 million paid in cash and stock and stock awards of more than $13 million.”




This all makes my blood boil.

Imagine if they paid taxes.

Chat Icon

Posted 10/4/11 3:56 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
FSA question and Tax question hbugal 2/4/11 3 Families Helping Families ™
just wanted to share some pics of our fatty fat cat MeeshMosh 2/14/09 10 Pets
Did anyone see this fat cat? LiPo 1/13/07 5 Pets
Question for all Homeowners about the new tax law if it passes MommyofG 10/25/05 20 Home
Tax question checka 8/26/05 3 Home
Cat Question Aliking 7/30/05 9 Pets