Fallen tree
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
Fallen tree If your neighbors tree falls onto your property causing damage, who is responsible? Whose home owners do you go through? |
|
Posted 6/30/19 7:59 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: Fallen tree If it's their tree your insurance will go after theirs. Just like if you get in a car accident that is 100% the fault of the other driver...your insurance pays you but they go after the other driver's insurance to get reimbursed |
Posted 6/30/19 8:22 PM
|
|
|
Fallen tree Your insurance pays. Unless. There was neglect on the neighbors part. |
|
Posted 6/30/19 8:39 PM
|
|
|
Re: Fallen tree Posted by alli3131 Your insurance pays. Unless. There was neglect on the neighbors part. this |
|
Posted 6/30/19 9:30 PM
|
|
|
Fallen tree Your insurance pays unless you can prove neglect on your neighbors part. |
|
Posted 6/30/19 9:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: Fallen tree Regardless of whose tree it is. It depends on whose property is damaged. Whoevers fence, house, etc is damages is whose policy will pay. |
|
Posted 6/30/19 9:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: Fallen tree Prior to contacting your insurance company, I would speak to your neighbor. They may offer to pay or split the cost. |
|
Posted 7/1/19 8:47 AM
|
|
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: Fallen tree My Father in Law had a neighbors tree fall on his fence during a storm. His insurance paid but they did tell him they went after the neighbors insurance to recoup some costs- but I believe the tree was in bad shape for a long time and the neighbors failed to get it taken care of. |
Posted 7/1/19 8:50 AM
|
|
|
Re: Fallen tree Posted by skew Prior to contacting your insurance company, I would speak to your neighbor. They may offer to pay or split the cost. One of our trees fell into the neighbor's yard last week. I went to neighbor's house and said we would remove the tree and fix the fence. Neighbor said not to worry. Asked us to remove the tree and they will repair the fence. Mutual and inexpensive resolution. Were actually out of town right now-we originally thought it was just the tree and the fence, and were hoping to do something like you said. However, we’re pretty sure we lost our shed, which was a fully built structure-not just one of th ones you get from Home Depot, and there’s a good chance the tree damaged our sprinkler system as well-it gauged 12-14 inches deep in some spots. The part of the tree that fell is probably 5-6 feet in diameter and about 40 feet long. |
|
Posted 7/1/19 9:20 AM
|
|
|
ave1024
Member since 12/07 6153 total posts Name: |
Re: Fallen tree Posted by mommywantsababy Posted by skew Prior to contacting your insurance company, I would speak to your neighbor. They may offer to pay or split the cost. One of our trees fell into the neighbor's yard last week. I went to neighbor's house and said we would remove the tree and fix the fence. Neighbor said not to worry. Asked us to remove the tree and they will repair the fence. Mutual and inexpensive resolution. Were actually out of town right now-we originally thought it was just the tree and the fence, and were hoping to do something like you said. However, we’re pretty sure we lost our shed, which was a fully built structure-not just one of th ones you get from Home Depot, and there’s a good chance the tree damaged our sprinkler system as well-it gauged 12-14 inches deep in some spots. The part of the tree that fell is probably 5-6 feet in diameter and about 40 feet long. I am not sure why a neighbor would offer to pay anything in this situation. Fallen trees are covered by homeowners insurance and the property that gets damaged is the property who has to provide the insurance. If a neighbor approached me with this I would tell them that I am not paying anything out of pocket for this as that is what insurance is for. I would tell the person that they should go through their insurance and if their insurance wants to pursue mine (as the neighbor) they are welcome to make an inquiry. |
Posted 7/1/19 10:08 AM
|
|
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: Fallen tree Posted by ave1024 Posted by mommywantsababy Posted by skew Prior to contacting your insurance company, I would speak to your neighbor. They may offer to pay or split the cost. One of our trees fell into the neighbor's yard last week. I went to neighbor's house and said we would remove the tree and fix the fence. Neighbor said not to worry. Asked us to remove the tree and they will repair the fence. Mutual and inexpensive resolution. Were actually out of town right now-we originally thought it was just the tree and the fence, and were hoping to do something like you said. However, we’re pretty sure we lost our shed, which was a fully built structure-not just one of th ones you get from Home Depot, and there’s a good chance the tree damaged our sprinkler system as well-it gauged 12-14 inches deep in some spots. The part of the tree that fell is probably 5-6 feet in diameter and about 40 feet long. I am not sure why a neighbor would offer to pay anything in this situation. Fallen trees are covered by homeowners insurance and the property that gets damaged is the property who has to provide the insurance. If a neighbor approached me with this I would tell them that I am not paying anything out of pocket for this as that is what insurance is for. I would tell the person that they should go through their insurance and if their insurance wants to pursue mine (as the neighbor) they are welcome to make an inquiry. True. Nobody should be paying out of pocket for an act of nature. |
Posted 7/1/19 10:14 AM
|
|
|
Re: Fallen tree Your homeowner's policy will cover it. |
|
Posted 7/1/19 10:14 AM
|
|
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: Fallen tree Posted by NYCGirl80 Your homeowner's policy will cover it. The only way your neighbors will cover is if you can PROVE that the tree was 1) unhealthy and 2) you notified the neighbor that the tree was at risk of falling due to (1). We have this exact situation right now. Our neighbors tree is actually dead. Like DEAD. And it's about to fall on our fence and shed. He does NOTHING about it. I need to take some pictures before it falls because I will definitely have a case. |
Posted 7/1/19 10:21 AM
|
|
|
Re: Fallen tree Posted by NervousNell Posted by NYCGirl80 Your homeowner's policy will cover it. The only way your neighbors will cover is if you can PROVE that the tree was 1) unhealthy and 2) you notified the neighbor that the tree was at risk of falling due to (1). We have this exact situation right now. Our neighbors tree is actually dead. Like DEAD. And it's about to fall on our fence and shed. He does NOTHING about it. I need to take some pictures before it falls because I will definitely have a case. You need to send a certified letter to the neighbor. |
|
Posted 7/1/19 10:25 AM
|
|
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: Fallen tree Posted by LSP2005 Posted by NervousNell Posted by NYCGirl80 Your homeowner's policy will cover it. The only way your neighbors will cover is if you can PROVE that the tree was 1) unhealthy and 2) you notified the neighbor that the tree was at risk of falling due to (1). We have this exact situation right now. Our neighbors tree is actually dead. Like DEAD. And it's about to fall on our fence and shed. He does NOTHING about it. I need to take some pictures before it falls because I will definitely have a case. You need to send a certified letter to the neighbor. I'm glad I read this thread. I had no idea. Thank you! |
Posted 7/1/19 10:39 AM
|
|
|
Re: Fallen tree Posted by ave1024 Posted by mommywantsababy Posted by skew Prior to contacting your insurance company, I would speak to your neighbor. They may offer to pay or split the cost. One of our trees fell into the neighbor's yard last week. I went to neighbor's house and said we would remove the tree and fix the fence. Neighbor said not to worry. Asked us to remove the tree and they will repair the fence. Mutual and inexpensive resolution. Were actually out of town right now-we originally thought it was just the tree and the fence, and were hoping to do something like you said. However, we’re pretty sure we lost our shed, which was a fully built structure-not just one of th ones you get from Home Depot, and there’s a good chance the tree damaged our sprinkler system as well-it gauged 12-14 inches deep in some spots. The part of the tree that fell is probably 5-6 feet in diameter and about 40 feet long. I am not sure why a neighbor would offer to pay anything in this situation. Fallen trees are covered by homeowners insurance and the property that gets damaged is the property who has to provide the insurance. If a neighbor approached me with this I would tell them that I am not paying anything out of pocket for this as that is what insurance is for. I would tell the person that they should go through their insurance and if their insurance wants to pursue mine (as the neighbor) they are welcome to make an inquiry. I think splitting the cost was a thought bc we get along incredibly well with our neighbors. I know she feels awful this happened-it involved three different property lots. But it will all work out-I care more about the relationship than I do the damage. |
|
Posted 7/1/19 11:22 AM
|
|
|
Re: Fallen tree Posted by NervousNell Posted by LSP2005 Posted by NervousNell Posted by NYCGirl80 Your homeowner's policy will cover it. The only way your neighbors will cover is if you can PROVE that the tree was 1) unhealthy and 2) you notified the neighbor that the tree was at risk of falling due to (1). We have this exact situation right now. Our neighbors tree is actually dead. Like DEAD. And it's about to fall on our fence and shed. He does NOTHING about it. I need to take some pictures before it falls because I will definitely have a case. You need to send a certified letter to the neighbor. I'm glad I read this thread. I had no idea. Thank you! Yes, certified letter, return receipt requested. You need proof they got the letter. |
|
Posted 7/1/19 2:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: Fallen tree Posted by mommywantsababy Posted by skew Prior to contacting your insurance company, I would speak to your neighbor. They may offer to pay or split the cost. One of our trees fell into the neighbor's yard last week. I went to neighbor's house and said we would remove the tree and fix the fence. Neighbor said not to worry. Asked us to remove the tree and they will repair the fence. Mutual and inexpensive resolution. Were actually out of town right now-we originally thought it was just the tree and the fence, and were hoping to do something like you said. However, we’re pretty sure we lost our shed, which was a fully built structure-not just one of th ones you get from Home Depot, and there’s a good chance the tree damaged our sprinkler system as well-it gauged 12-14 inches deep in some spots. The part of the tree that fell is probably 5-6 feet in diameter and about 40 feet long. You obviously have significant damage. The damage caused to my neighbor's yard from our fallen tree was minimal. My landscapers removed the tree from their yard and repaired the fence. Less than an hour of work and they didn't charge me. Several years ago, a different neighbor's tree fell into our yard, damaged the fence and pool cover. We were out of town at the time. The neighbor contacted us, asked if we wanted them to send pics and for us to get quotes for the repairs and send them the bill. Repairs were less than their deductible so they paid us out of pocket. From reading the replies on the thread, I guess this is not common practice with many. Whether common or not, I feel the moral and neighborly route is for the owner of the tree to incur some of the damage repair costs. I cannot imagine telling a neighbor or being told by a neighbor, "sorry, your property, your problem." Message edited 2019-07-03 07:21:45.620000. |
|
Posted 7/2/19 5:33 PM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Is there a way to honor a fallen firefighter at your home? IE: a ribbon around a tree... | LIMOMx2 | 7/31/06 | 1 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Fallen tree question | renee92405 | 11/5/12 | 4 | Home |
| Who Is Responsible For a Fallen Tree and Fence | mom2b | 11/2/12 | 13 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Whose tree is it???? | Dani00518 | 8/29/05 | 13 | Home |
| Tree guy? | jms100303 | 5/31/05 | 0 | Home |
| Dollar Tree | dm24angel | 5/26/05 | 27 | Families Helping Families ™ |









