Excerpt from an interesting article

Posted By Message

MrsPorkChop
Twinning!!

Member since 5/05

9941 total posts

Name:
Missy

Excerpt from an interesting article

This discusses why modesty is seen as such a bad thing nowadays....

I found it when I was researching Orthodox Weddings. DH and I are attending one soon, and I wanted to learn about the culture. This article is talking about how orthodox women are so modest, and how its frowned upon by society.

If you have time its a very thought provoking read.

LINK TO FULL TEXT OF ARTICLE

EXCERPT
-----------
The October 2005 Marie Claire provides another window into postmodern extremism. Five “confident” women are showcased – a nurse, a musician, a dancer, a sales agent, and a testing-lab proctor – all of whom posed in the buff for the magazine. As we are told, “these women are actually more confident naked than clothed.” Then the editors pointedly demand, “Are you?” In case you missed the lesson, if you don’t want to show your naked tush to millions of strangers, then baby, you’ve got a confidence problem.

Actually, the contemporary woman seems to have a lot of problems. She is deemed to have “jealousy issues” if she cannot grasp why her boyfriend requires “lap dances” from strippers. In her new book Pornified, Pamela Paul interviews twenty-four-year-old Ashley, insecure because her boyfriend visits strip bars to get lap dances every month or so. Ashley tries “to explain why I thought it was offensive,” but to no avail. Kara, a thirty-year-old physician, has the same problem and got into a big fight with boyfriend Rob over whether getting a lap dance constitutes cheating: “I said it’s cheating because the woman is touching you?... but Rob didn’t think so.”

Paul also reports that increasing numbers of men are finding it impossible to perform with their girlfriends and wives because sex has become so “demystified.” Shockingly, when given a choice between a real woman and their Internet porn, many choose the porn.

It all begs the question: If doing away with modesty was supposed to be liberating, why is the sex now so bad? Why should men and women be further apart than ever?

To me, the essential confusion comes down to mistaking modesty for shame. If you think sexuality should be private, goes the prevailing view, then you must be ashamed of it. You must be a prude. Conversely, if you are “comfortable with your sexuality,” then you should be “cool” with lifting your shirt for strangers, or cheering on your man as he watches hard-core porn – even standing by supportively while he enjoys lap dances.

History has taught us a surprising lesson: Real intimacy flourishes only where there’s also restraint. Having sex for its own sake, without waiting to integrate our deepest emotions and hopes, at best becomes boring, fast. At worst, men and women end up competing over how cruelly they can use one another.

In truth, the real reason for sexual modesty is not shame, but an awareness of how precious we are. Smirk at that statement if you will, but the fact remains: It is a rare dog that desires a candlelit dinner before mating. On the other hand, it is a rare human who can have a one-night stand without feeling at least a twinge of guilt afterward. And, howls of protest from vested interests notwithstanding, most men know that their most intimate relationships should not be with their computer browsers.

Where does our modesty confusion come from?

No wonder, then, that public displays of affection are seen as cheapening. If you want to show everyone, how special can it be? This is perhaps the source of the public’s suspicion of “TomKat” – Tom Cruise and Katie Holmes’s overexposed romance. I don’t think people are cynical to suspect there is something a bit “off” about Tom’s repeated protestations of love, his couch-jumping on Oprah, or all those kisses staged for the cameras. Such a blatant disregard for modesty seems, rather, to betray a lack of profound feeling – at least on the part of one of them.


CRTHODOX CULTURE....
Even after the wedding, an ongoing concern for modesty preserves a married couple’s sensitivity and attraction to each other. Orthodox men make a concerted effort not to look at undressed women who aren’t their wives, whether it’s on a beach or at a newsstand. They avert their gaze. Another place for modesty in Jewish marriages is during the period each month when the couple abstains from physical intimacy. Traditional couples say they follow this commandment because it is God’s will, but there are also well-known side effects. Taking a break from physical intimacy tends to foster friendship and improved communication, and also makes the wife “as dear to her husband as when she entered the marriage canopy”


To some, Orthodox women will always be repressed and Orthodox men will always be sexist. To be sure, Orthodox men do not “objectify” women with the “male gaze,” but on the other hand, they don’t touch other women besides family and their own wives, and that really stretches the limits of tolerance. The “Ethicist” of the New York Times infamously counseled a woman not to do business with an Orthodox realtor who could not shake her hand, though he was “courteous and competent.” Decreed the Ethicist: “Sexism is sexism, even when motivated by religious convictions. I believe you should tear up your contract.”


Most of us recognize that being desensitized to the power of sexuality is sad, that if you’ve gotten to the point where stopping for a lap dance is like stopping at McDonald’s, then you’re missing out. Yet instituting concrete boundaries to preserve sensitivity – such as not hugging people of the opposite sex outside of one’s family – is still seen as absurd. Nonetheless, I maintain that examining our sexual values from the vantage point of Orthodox Jews can be refreshing. If you pull aside a religious woman from Jerusalem and try to explain our debate over whether your boyfriend’s receiving a “lap dance” from a stripper constitutes cheating, she will surely think it is our culture that’s gone completely crazy. Indeed, she might argue with good reason that we are the ones who are “repressed” about sexuality. Emotionally repressed, that is.

And could you really blame her? When it comes to modesty, I often wonder, who are the real extremists? Those who insist that only public and tawdry displays of sexuality are legitimate, or those who appreciate privacy and restraint as necessary components for attaining real intimacy?

Posted 8/4/06 8:52 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

LadyMaravilla
Fall Is Here

Member since 5/05

12023 total posts

Name:
Sonia

Re: Excerpt from an interesting article

Great article. I'm one that appreciates privacy. Many think I'm nuts because I don't like Public displays of affection. DH had a hard time in the begining with it, but he's come to appreciate it now. Chat Icon

Message edited 2006-08-04 09:00:17.593000.

Posted 8/4/06 9:00 AM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: Excerpt from an interesting article

there is something to be said about modesty. I understand when you're young and single and want to "flaunt what you got". but I get grossed out when I see older women wearing very revealing clothing. Chat Icon

Posted 8/4/06 9:03 AM
 

2PreciousBlessings
The Perfect Pair

Member since 5/06

19861 total posts

Name:
Best Wife & Mommy

Re: Excerpt from an interesting article

Wow!! Very interesting article.

Posted 8/4/06 9:06 AM
 

MrsRbk
<3 <3 <3 <3

Member since 1/06

19197 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: Excerpt from an interesting article

Prior to my wedding, my rabbi required that I take what I call "how to be a good jewish wife class" I went for three nights (not consecutively) to visit with his niece who instructed me on the pre-marital (what I need to do to prepare for the mikveh) and post-marital instruction. Part of what she explained to me is exactly what the first paragraph talks about, how that period of time during your period fosters a deeper relationship and bond with your spouse because you are not preoccupied with being intimate with eachother.

Posted 8/4/06 9:48 AM
 

Redhead
You Live, You Learn

Member since 5/05

31871 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Excerpt from an interesting article

interesting article but i have to say i really am not getting the definitions of public displays of affection...

i mean is that just considered holding hands and kissing...?

If so then i guess i am all for public ...

i think it is wonderful to see people in love like that...

And i think it does wonders for your love and sex life....to keep that kind of love in the forefront of your mind...

but i really think that this article then swings hard to the porno/stripper aspect of it...

can't say i can really compare them..

i do believe that the best is moderation..

ETA...and i think that almost all religions are sexist Chat Icon
and i think that all this looking away and covering up is DEF NOT for me...

people will lust no matter what the person is wearing or not wearing or where they are looking...if they are DTD or waiting 4-5 days...
IMO nothing really changes that...

Message edited 2006-08-04 10:09:09.247000.

Posted 8/4/06 10:06 AM
 

MrsPorkChop
Twinning!!

Member since 5/05

9941 total posts

Name:
Missy

Re: Excerpt from an interesting article

jen- im not saying i agree with everything...but i do happen to feel pressured to be cool about certain things - like porno and strip clubs...because society would think me as jealous or uncool if i was not OK with it

but the article is just saying that being cool with stuff like that, and with casual sex etc. is totally normal and expected
when it really does not help to foster things like good communication and the desire to go home to your wife and want to be with her..

and i think she made a few points that made me think about how our society is.

im all for PDA- dh and i are all about kissing and holding hands and showing our love for one another in public...

but i think the writer made some good arguments about Tomkat etc. , exaggerated, what have you, but good points.

Message edited 2006-08-04 10:18:32.440000.

Posted 8/4/06 10:16 AM
 

Snozberry
I might steal your diamonds

Member since 2/06

4680 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Excerpt from an interesting article

Thanks for posting this. I'm looking forward to reading the entire article when I have time.
I found this except to definitely be an interesting read.

Posted 8/4/06 10:17 AM
 

Redhead
You Live, You Learn

Member since 5/05

31871 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Excerpt from an interesting article

i was just giving my thoughts on the article...

i too agree and disagree with things in the article..

again...i found it interesting
ETA...althought i never felt pressured to be cool about the stripper thing

hey call me jealous ....i ain't havin it unless it is for the RARE bachelor partyChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Message edited 2006-08-04 10:20:06.110000.

Posted 8/4/06 10:18 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Excerpt from an interesting article

That was a very good article! I wholeheartedly agree with the modesty & the pda part (eta. mauling each other in public).

I'm not sure that I agree with the Orthodox way of thinking in terms of not looking at another woman, etc. A very good friend works in a predominately Orthodox business. The number of men going for "happy endings", having affairs or "using" the bathrooms on their lunch hour is sickening. I realize there will always be people like that in every culture - but I believe that the pervasiveness in this particular sect derives more from the need of an outlet for sexuality than anything else.

Message edited 2006-08-04 11:06:04.797000.

Posted 8/4/06 11:04 AM
 

Lanabean
Yoginis

Member since 11/05

9202 total posts

Name:
Lana

Re: Excerpt from an interesting article

I don't think a woman should be called "jealous" if she doesn't like her man going to strip clubs. Thankfully, this isn't something I deal with because my DH doesn't like it. But when he had his b party, he had a nice dinner with the guys, got drunk, went out. Our dads were there! I think DH felt pressure from some of the men who wanted him to have a classic stip party. And when I would say "He's not into it; and I also think it's really gross"...I'm sure it at times appeared as though I was jealous.

I think women are perceived as jealous when in fact, we all know that when women (90%) have a stripper at their parties (I did not; it was a freaking spa party) it's more of a joke; the guy is big guido and everyone is laughing. For men, these parties get very sexual and it's more about being turned on. Now, yes--you have to trust your man, and I would never stop him from attending someone else's party and never have....but the term "jealous" is thrown around so easily, making us feel so "uncool"...which is a societal stereotype that really BLOWS.

As for PDA, I believe there's a time and place for everything. And I never bend as to who I am to please anyone. DH knows who I am, how I am, and he married me this way.

Posted 8/4/06 11:21 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Interesting article in this month's Parenting magazine (April 2006) CathyB 3/18/06 4 Adoption
Interesting article in this week's People CathyB 3/18/06 1 Infertility
Interesting article regarding IVF casey31 3/16/06 5 Infertility
Interesting article LuckySV 3/15/06 0 Home
Interesting article in this month's Parents mag (april) re: cord blood banking debate CathyB 3/7/06 12 Pregnancy
Interesting NYTimes article Sassyz75 3/1/06 0 Home