ethics question - am i crazy?

Posted By Message

bikramaddict
mommy-to-be

Member since 8/06

4376 total posts

Name:

ethics question - am i crazy?

One of my colleagues hosted an event that I planned last week. One of our co-hosts provided gift certificates for spa services to the guests. My colleague was not a guest. I come in today and find two gift certificates waiting for me - 'extra goodies for me to use' to quote my colleague. I handed them back and said it isn't right to keep these, that they were intended for guests, not us. He looked at me like I was crazy and said they are extra and I should keep them. I said it isn't right and they should be given back to the co-host who provided them. He thinks they should be kept. So I told him that if he wants to keep them, go for it but I will not do so.

So...am I nuts or is he unethical? Just looking for an outsider's perspective.

Posted 9/26/11 9:58 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: ethics question - am i crazy?

You're right. I'd give them back to the co-host, and if he/she requested that you use them, then you could do so.

Posted 9/26/11 10:12 AM
 

AngnShaun
Sisters

Member since 1/10

21015 total posts

Name:
Ang

Re: ethics question - am i crazy?

i would be annoyed that he wanted to keep them rather than offer them to the hosts... but i have no idea if its unethical... eta: like barb said it depends on contract if there was one... i would need more information to make that call

Message edited 2011-09-26 10:20:23.670000.

Posted 9/26/11 10:14 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: ethics question - am i crazy?

I think it borders on unethical (and maybe illegal) depending on the terms the vendor gave the charitable donation.

Speaking solely in ethical term, I think:

If they specified for an auction/raffle, then their wishes should be respected.

If they didn't spell out the terms, then it's up to the charity to distribute as they see fit - even if it's for a perk for an employee who worked overtime for an event.

Speaking from experience of working non-profit events,most companies donate to support the cause, for the tax deduction & the publicity.

Posted 9/26/11 10:17 AM
 

bikramaddict
mommy-to-be

Member since 8/06

4376 total posts

Name:

Re: ethics question - am i crazy?

Posted by nrthshgrl

I think it borders on unethical (and maybe illegal) depending on the terms the vendor gave the charitable donation.

Speaking solely in ethical term, I think:

If they specified for an auction/raffle, then their wishes should be respected.

If they didn't spell out the terms, then it's up to the charity to distribute as they see fit - even if it's for a perk for an employee who worked overtime for an event.

Speaking from experience of working non-profit events,most companies donate to support the cause, for the tax deduction & the publicity.



It wasn't a charity and there was no contract.

Gift certificates for spa services were given out by the co-host (a hotel). They were included in gift bags for guests and since two guests didn't show up, there were two extra gift bags.

I could understand if it was some small swag that would just go in the garbage anyway but not something that has a cost involved for the giver.

Posted 9/26/11 10:31 AM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: ethics question - am i crazy?

I’d ask the host.

It happens all the time. We expect 100 guests and get 125 GC. The group rate is cheaper and really gets to be next to nothing for the difference. A few are left over as extras, its not worth returning (even if we COULD) so we tell them to keep them. Do what you want with them.

But mostly no one would call and TELL us that they had extras.

Now, in our office, if an event is held and we receive gift cards automatically, then we are in a pickle. We are not allowed gifts in our profession. Or at least nothing over $5 unless it’s a random draw. So if you appreciate all my hard work I’ve done for you, you can’t give me a gift to a spa. You have to give the OFFICE the gift card and it must be randomly drawn for the winner of the gift. Talk about mad bad mojo in the office! If however, I drop my card in a fish bowl and win a gift card, I can keep it.

I think you may be surprised to find it’s not that big of a deal. But as always, ask first.

Personally, I would have said nothing. Taken them and then made the call on my own. Less drama and I’d feel right about it. Especially since some of my co-workers may not have bothered to call.

Posted 9/26/11 10:40 AM
 

Little-J-Mommy
I'm a Big Brother

Member since 5/06

8041 total posts

Name:
D

Re: ethics question - am i crazy?

I can see why he thought it was ok to keep them. I can't imagine that the hotel wants them back. Can they really return 2 of them?? It seems fair to me that the extras went to the 2 people that worked really hard on the project. But I can see why you'd feel funny. maybe just call the host and ask them what they want you to do with them. My guess is they'll say keep them.

Posted 9/26/11 10:49 AM
 

bikramaddict
mommy-to-be

Member since 8/06

4376 total posts

Name:

Re: ethics question - am i crazy?

Posted by Little-J-Mommy

I can see why he thought it was ok to keep them. I can't imagine that the hotel wants them back. Can they really return 2 of them?? It seems fair to me that the extras went to the 2 people that worked really hard on the project. But I can see why you'd feel funny. maybe just call the host and ask them what they want you to do with them. My guess is they'll say keep them.



He didn't do cr@p for the event, just attended in my place (which I am very bitter about for reasons that I won't get into!)

I did all of the work. He just got to reap the benefits.

Posted 9/26/11 10:54 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: ethics question - am i crazy?

Posted by bikramaddict

Posted by Little-J-Mommy

I can see why he thought it was ok to keep them. I can't imagine that the hotel wants them back. Can they really return 2 of them?? It seems fair to me that the extras went to the 2 people that worked really hard on the project. But I can see why you'd feel funny. maybe just call the host and ask them what they want you to do with them. My guess is they'll say keep them.



He didn't do cr@p for the event, just attended in my place (which I am very bitter about for reasons that I won't get into!)

I did all of the work. He just got to reap the benefits.



Maybe I'm misreading your post but it sounds to me like he tried to make it up to you by making sure you got the gift certificates.

Posted 9/26/11 10:55 AM
 

bikramaddict
mommy-to-be

Member since 8/06

4376 total posts

Name:

Re: ethics question - am i crazy?

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by bikramaddict

Posted by Little-J-Mommy

I can see why he thought it was ok to keep them. I can't imagine that the hotel wants them back. Can they really return 2 of them?? It seems fair to me that the extras went to the 2 people that worked really hard on the project. But I can see why you'd feel funny. maybe just call the host and ask them what they want you to do with them. My guess is they'll say keep them.



He didn't do cr@p for the event, just attended in my place (which I am very bitter about for reasons that I won't get into!)

I did all of the work. He just got to reap the benefits.



Maybe I'm misreading your post but it sounds to me like he tried to make it up to you by making sure you got the gift certificates.



He gave it to me because he said he won't be in the area to use them.

Posted 9/26/11 12:17 PM
 

AngnShaun
Sisters

Member since 1/10

21015 total posts

Name:
Ang

Re: ethics question - am i crazy?

I'd just take them and give them to the co-hosts

Posted 9/26/11 12:18 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
CRAZY QUESTION RE: Kiddie Ride Machine rentals... adeline27 10/3/08 1 Families Helping Families ™
Crazy question but I'm bored tonight 4ForMe 9/21/08 28 Families Helping Families ™
One more crazy question... reggie 6/3/08 5 Parenting
Maternity leave - crazy question clwp 4/4/08 5 Pregnancy
CRAZY TMI question regarding sex and the big O Janice 10/3/06 10 Pregnancy
crazy twin question sunflowergirl 1/24/06 6 Pregnancy