EI Eval Rant/Question

Posted By Message

keepinmyman
LIF Infant

Member since 9/07

212 total posts

Name:

EI Eval Rant/Question

So Zoey had her eval. The speech part was last Saturday. He said she has both receptive and expressive delay but I don't know the percentage yet. The CORE eval was today. My concern is this: she asked me questions about Zoey's temperament, specifically about tantrums. Zoey doesn't have tantrums (at least not yet!) and this woman basically induced a tantrum through her testing by continually giving her things that she had never seen before and then after she got whatever response she was looking for (or didn't get it)-took it away. So after a few different things Zoey started to get really angry and frustrated and of course began crying. So now she does some test with a trial size dish soap bottle (clean and empty) and some Cheerios. She was trying to get her to either dump them out or put some in but she was so angry already that she just wanted to HAVE it in her hands and play with it. During the rest of her tests she was basically aggravated. Anyway, summing up she then decides that A) she has some diffculty with Fine Motor b/c she couldn't (or wouldn't) empty the bottle and B) checked off that she sometimes has tantrums. I told her that that was pretty much the first time she ever acted like that and my oldes DD who is almost 17 and cares for her often during the week also agreed that she doesn't have tantrums.
I'm pretty annoyed that this woman basically created a situation that caused Zoey to become mad and frustrated and then is holding that against her. I'm not sure how you can "test" an 18 month old for 15 seconds on any one "test" and then draw a conclusion. Before the Cheerios she had a ziploc of small wooden blocks, about an inch square. Our blocks are bigger more like 3 inches square and they are squishey rubber. So she had never seen the little ones and wanted to play with them. She kept taking them away from her without waiting to see what she would do. The woman stacked 2 and then gave her about 2 seconds to stack them and of course she didn't and then marked that while she stacked our blocks she didn't stack the little ones! Seriously? Whatis that about? This is pretty much when Zoey started to go nuts. She is def behind in her language but give the kid a chance to do something! So am I out of line if I want to have her evaluated again? I just don't think she got a fair shot.

Oh and also this woman was consistently scattered in her attempts to reach me to set up an appointment. She had my number and my schedule. She called me when she knew I was at work on a Friday. I left her a message on the following Monday, no response. Tuesday I called her again and told her "I will be at work after 3:30 pm today" So I get a call from her at 5:30 and then again at 8. At 8 left left a v.m. that she was leaving messages on the wrong number. ???????? And she was supposed to be here at 10 this morning and at 10:15 she calls to tell me she is running late (Duh!) and that she was lost. She didn't know that she was running late until it was 15 minutes after the appt and she was 10 minutes from my house? So I gotta say I'm not too confident in her abilities. Any suggestions?

Message edited 2010-03-14 19:37:41.107000.

Posted 3/14/10 7:24 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

keepinmyman
LIF Infant

Member since 9/07

212 total posts

Name:

Re: EI Eval Rant/Question

Does anyone have a suggestion?

Posted 3/14/10 7:56 PM
 

Jacksmommy
My love muffin!

Member since 1/07

5819 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: EI Eval Rant/Question

FM

Posted 3/14/10 8:03 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: EI Eval Rant/Question

I posted a rant about DS's EI evaluation last year. He had just turned 2 in April.

The evaluator did something similar. She handed him a ball and had him identify it and throw it. Than took it away and tried to show him pictures in a book and identify the pictures. Obviously he didnt want to look at pictures of a kid eating and sleeping he wanted the bowl. So she said he didnt know how to follow directions Chat Icon and in turn had receptive issues. Meanwhile, with me he was pretty good at following ALL directions.

It's hard. I was not happy at all after his evaluation and even questioned getting it done. He did not requalify for speech or spec. ed in December but still received OT for silly reasons IMO (I've ranted on here about it in the past).

It's hard because these evaluators come into your house for an hour and try to get an idea who your child is, what they can and cannot do and in some cases, like my DS's, he just didnt "perform" for them. In turn he received services for things I didnt think were needed but in the long run they helped him and pushed him ahead. Take the services, there free. It will only help

ETA: If you were not happy with the evaluator I would express your cocerns to your service coordinator. I dont know if they will do a re-evaluation but at least you let her know your not happy.

The funny thing was we had two evaluators come (which you may as well, not sure). We had a spec. ed instructor and speech therapist. What he did for one evaluator he wouldnt do for the other. Sometimes it is just personality and my DS took well to one evaluator and not the other.

Message edited 2010-03-14 20:51:26.527000.

Posted 3/14/10 8:48 PM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: EI Eval Rant/Question

I had DS evaluated about a month ago and I was in tears at the end of the evaluation.

I had 3 women plus the service coordinator come into the house and bombard him with tasks. Everything seemed to happen in a flurry, they kept asking me if I noticed DS doing certain things and I couldn't answer because the energy level in the room was so out of wack, I felt confused. They were moving so fast that I felt stressed, I can only imagine how DS felt.

I decided to let go of the experience, because I do know DS best, I called for the evaluation because I was concerned about his mobility and after the evaluation I do agree that he isn't very verbal and could use help. As the parent you choose what goes in the report and you choose what services to receive. I did have our service coordinator remove things from the report that I didn't agree with and I only scheduled the things I felt DS needed.

After the evaluation they told me that DS was below average for cognitive, my PED, and the two therapists that have come to work with DS all say he is very bright and they are shocked that he was scored low, they also said they were surprised at how he was scored for communication (they put him at the level of a 5 month old and his speech therapist says that he is communicating fully for his age, he is just not verbal). The evaluator are looking for very specific things to check off a list and if DC does not perform, it doesn't get checked.

I guess the moral of my long post is don't stress about the evaluation, it is a means to the services, if you want services in certain areas accept them and have your service coordinator modify the report to only include the info you want in there.



Chat Icon

Posted 3/14/10 9:06 PM
 

keepinmyman
LIF Infant

Member since 9/07

212 total posts

Name:

Re: EI Eval Rant/Question

I called my Service Coordinator today regarding where to fax Zoey's health forma nd expressed my issues with the eval. She said that there are time limits to the testing, which i understand. I will wait and see what the eval says and take it from there. She asked me if the evaluator recommended an OT eval, which she did not. I guess i may be making too much of her comments. I know she is trying to help. It just got me aggravated. I have the meeting on 3/31 to see what services she qualifies for. I'm pretty sure she is going to qualify for speech therapy since she pretty much has no words and has trouble with instructions.

Posted 3/15/10 10:52 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Questions for you all Smileyd17 5/20/05 2 Pregnancy
Teacher Interview questions that you have been asked Missy 5/18/05 0 Career
Questions about Fortunoff returns/exchange Bri 5/16/05 2 Families Helping Families ™
Questions about Block Island peabody 5/12/05 2 Travel & Vacations
Questions to ask a daycare Redhead 5/11/05 9 Parenting
Silly questions asked to you at work HarleyGirlFLA 5/11/05 8 Families Helping Families ™