Dr. Browns bottles - disappointed

Posted By Message

clwp
Love my girls!

Member since 10/06

2114 total posts

Name:
mommy

Dr. Browns bottles - disappointed

I was using the Playtex air vented bottles for the longest time, but I was afraid the pieces would get lost at daycare. So I tried the Dr. Brown's bottles... first DD was WEARING her formula b/c the nipple must flow too fast (it's the nipple it came with). Then if that wasn't bad enough... she spit up all over me. I know they sell different nipples - could that be the issue? I switched also b/c I had heard that the Playtex air vent bottles are not BPA free and the one's I have only hold up to 6 oz (when I make powdered formula they overflow a bit). The Dr. Brown's one's I bought were BPA free. DD hasn't spit up in many weeks, I don't want to start that up again.

Are there bottles that others feel are better than Dr. Brown's? I'm thinking of going back to the playtex for now. She's already "contaminated" if it's true that the Playtex are not BPA free.

Posted 7/17/08 7:07 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

FrankiesGirl107
My Girls

Member since 12/06

3642 total posts

Name:
Amee

Re: Dr. Browns bottles - disappointed

We use Dr. Browns, but what about the playtex drop-ins, with the disposable liners?

Posted 7/17/08 7:11 PM
 

RO1976
LIF Infant

Member since 4/08

309 total posts

Name:
ROBIN

Re: Dr. Browns bottles - disappointed

I use the playtex air vented bottles. I used the with all 3 of my babies. I swear by them.
They never leaked with me and they never spit up. but all babies are different and like different things.
Just as long as you dont heat the bottle itself you dont need to worry about the BPA.

Good Luck

Posted 7/17/08 7:12 PM
 

clwp
Love my girls!

Member since 10/06

2114 total posts

Name:
mommy

Re: Dr. Browns bottles - disappointed

Posted by FrankiesGirl107

We use Dr. Browns, but what about the playtex drop-ins, with the disposable liners?




She had gas from the liner bottles... we use the air vent. Prior to today's incident she hadn't spit up in about 3 weeks.

What nipple do you use? I'm wondering if that's the problem b/c while she was feeding it would drip out of her mouth as if too much was going in at once.

Posted 7/17/08 7:15 PM
 

FrankiesGirl107
My Girls

Member since 12/06

3642 total posts

Name:
Amee

Re: Dr. Browns bottles - disappointed

Posted by clwp

Posted by FrankiesGirl107

We use Dr. Browns, but what about the playtex drop-ins, with the disposable liners?




She had gas from the liner bottles... we use the air vent. Prior to today's incident she hadn't spit up in about 3 weeks.

What nipple do you use? I'm wondering if that's the problem b/c while she was feeding it would drip out of her mouth as if too much was going in at once.



Now, DD is using stage 2 during the day and stage 3 at night (I put cereal in her bottle at night)...but in the beginning we used the stage 1...is that what you have?

Have you tried the Avent bottles? We used them first, but the flow was too fast for DD, but I know a lot of people swear by them....and they're a heck of lot easier to clean!

Posted 7/17/08 7:51 PM
 

SweetT
LIF Adult

Member since 4/06

1305 total posts

Name:
Ali

Re: Dr. Browns bottles - disappointed

I am surprised to hear someone is disappointed with the Dr. Browns. Are you sure the nipple is in right and not cut somehow?

Posted 7/17/08 7:55 PM
 

ds319
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/07

659 total posts

Name:
Dena

Re: Dr. Browns bottles - disappointed

I use the Avent bottles and I love them. I switched for a little bit to the Dr. Brown's and didn't like them. DS didn't like them either. But every baby is different.

Posted 7/17/08 8:33 PM
 

clwp
Love my girls!

Member since 10/06

2114 total posts

Name:
mommy

Re: Dr. Browns bottles - disappointed

I'm using the nipples that came with the bottles.

I'll go to BRU tomorrow and see about getting some stage 1's (the lady at BRU told me to use Stage 2's, but I'm not going to even open them until she's over 3 months. If not, I'm not sure what to do...

I was reading that the daycare center does insist I prepare the bottles and that they warm the formula in the bottle, obviously this cannot be done with the Playtex.

Are Avent bottles BPA free? I cannot imagine why all bottles are not BPA free... unless it's just a lot of hype. But I'm not willing to take a chance. Usually at home I put the formula in a medela bottle with a cap and warm it in hot tap water that we put in a mug - we let the bottle sit in the hot water. Then once warm, we transfer the formula to a Playtex air vent bottle. Sounds like Day Care won't do this though.

Not sure what to do about this...Chat Icon I can't have her spitting up all the time, she's been so happy lately - I hate to see such a set back.

Posted 7/17/08 10:33 PM
 

EmmaNick
*

Member since 12/06

16001 total posts

Name:
*

Re: Dr. Browns bottles - disappointed

Why can't you prepare bottles ahead of time with Playtex? Chat Icon Oh I see, the BPA worries.

Were you pushing the air out of the drop-ins when you were using them? When DD was gassy, I made sure to push the air out and she was fine.


I'm confused why you currently transfer the formula from one type of bottle to another? If the formula is warm in the Vent Air (that is not BPA free), then it's no different than just heating the mlk in that bottle to begin with.

Message edited 2008-07-17 23:20:41.130000.

Posted 7/17/08 10:45 PM
 

clwp
Love my girls!

Member since 10/06

2114 total posts

Name:
mommy

Re: Dr. Browns bottles - disappointed

I heat up the formula in a Medela bottle, not the Playtex air vent. I transfer it b/c the Medela bottles came with instructions that said they can be heated... even microwaved (I don't microwave them, but the point is that they can be heated). I got the Medela bottles b/c they came with my Medela Breast Pump. However, DD had horrible gas issues from the medela bottles (so bad she cried for 8 hours and I took her to Winthrop b/c the Pediatrician couldn't even understand her sudden cholic onset, but the said it was from gas), so we tried the air vented Playtex and her gas issues were resolved. They're great bottles, I just don't understand why they can't just make them BPA free and make my life so much easier.

Message edited 2008-07-17 22:54:06.000000.

Posted 7/17/08 10:53 PM
 

EmmaNick
*

Member since 12/06

16001 total posts

Name:
*

Re: Dr. Browns bottles - disappointed

Posted by clwp

I heat up the formula in a Medela bottle, not the Playtex air vent. I transfer it b/c the Medela bottles came with instructions that said they can be heated... even microwaved (I don't microwave them, but the point is that they can be heated). I got the Medela bottles b/c they came with my Medela Breast Pump. However, DD had horrible gas issues from the medela bottles (so bad she cried for 8 hours and I took her to Winthrop b/c the Pediatrician couldn't even understand her sudden cholic onset, but the said it was from gas), so we tried the air vented Playtex and her gas issues were resolved. They're great bottles, I just don't understand why they can't just make them BPA free and make my life so much easier.




I realize that but transferring the warm liquid into the Vent Air is no different than warming the formula in the Vent Air to begin with. There is still warm liquid in the bottle. It sounds like you are creating a lot more work for yourself then necessary Chat Icon I hope you find a solution to your bottle troubles soon!! Chat Icon

Posted 7/17/08 10:56 PM
 

clwp
Love my girls!

Member since 10/06

2114 total posts

Name:
mommy

Re: Dr. Browns bottles - disappointed

Posted by Summerrluvv

Posted by clwp

I heat up the formula in a Medela bottle, not the Playtex air vent. I transfer it b/c the Medela bottles came with instructions that said they can be heated... even microwaved (I don't microwave them, but the point is that they can be heated). I got the Medela bottles b/c they came with my Medela Breast Pump. However, DD had horrible gas issues from the medela bottles (so bad she cried for 8 hours and I took her to Winthrop b/c the Pediatrician couldn't even understand her sudden cholic onset, but the said it was from gas), so we tried the air vented Playtex and her gas issues were resolved. They're great bottles, I just don't understand why they can't just make them BPA free and make my life so much easier.




I realize that but transferring the warm liquid into the Vent Air is no different than warming the formula in the Vent Air to begin with. There is still warm liquid in the bottle. It sounds like you are creating a lot more work for yourself then necessary Chat Icon I hope you find a solution to your bottle troubles soon!! Chat Icon



I don't heat it in the air vent b/c they are not BPA free and I think the instructions say never heat their bottles - I think it can interfer with the vent or something as well. The liquid is cold when I first pour it in since it's in the fridge (RTF formula). I don't do this when I use powdered formula since I use room temp distilled water. I think it's a lot of unnecessary work too, but someone needs to tell this to Playtex so they make a BPA free bottle with a cover so you can heat it directly in the bottle.

Posted 7/17/08 11:01 PM
 

JChia
Mom of 2 Princesses

Member since 9/07

2540 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Dr. Browns bottles - disappointed

Posted by SweetT

I am surprised to hear someone is disappointed with the Dr. Browns. Are you sure the nipple is in right and not cut somehow?



I agree - do you have all the pieces in with Dr. Browns? We use them and never had an issue - except the one time DH forgot to put the pieces in with the bottle...

Posted 7/17/08 11:05 PM
 

EmmaNick
*

Member since 12/06

16001 total posts

Name:
*

Re: Dr. Browns bottles - disappointed

Posted by clwp

Posted by Summerrluvv

Posted by clwp

I heat up the formula in a Medela bottle, not the Playtex air vent. I transfer it b/c the Medela bottles came with instructions that said they can be heated... even microwaved (I don't microwave them, but the point is that they can be heated). I got the Medela bottles b/c they came with my Medela Breast Pump. However, DD had horrible gas issues from the medela bottles (so bad she cried for 8 hours and I took her to Winthrop b/c the Pediatrician couldn't even understand her sudden cholic onset, but the said it was from gas), so we tried the air vented Playtex and her gas issues were resolved. They're great bottles, I just don't understand why they can't just make them BPA free and make my life so much easier.




I realize that but transferring the warm liquid into the Vent Air is no different than warming the formula in the Vent Air to begin with. There is still warm liquid in the bottle. It sounds like you are creating a lot more work for yourself then necessary Chat Icon I hope you find a solution to your bottle troubles soon!! Chat Icon



I don't heat it in the air vent b/c they are not BPA free and I think the instructions say never heat their bottles - I think it can interfer with the vent or something as well. The liquid is cold when I first pour it in since it's in the fridge (RTF formula). I don't do this when I use powdered formula since I use room temp distilled water. I think it's a lot of unnecessary work too, but someone needs to tell this to Playtex so they make a BPA free bottle with a cover so you can heat it directly in the bottle.



I don't think you are understanding what I'm saying. You are heating liquid into another bottle and pouring that warm liquid into the Playtex bottle. IF BPA is your concern, that warm liquid you just poured into the Playtex bottle can make the BPA leach from that Playtex bottle into the formula. Putting the Playtex bottle in a glass of warm water to heat the formula and doing what you are currently doing is the same exact thing as far as the BPA aspect of it is concerned. So, I would save yourself a step and put the Vent Air in a cup of warm water to heat it and instruct daycare to do the same
Chat Icon

Posted 7/17/08 11:07 PM
 

clwp
Love my girls!

Member since 10/06

2114 total posts

Name:
mommy

Re: Dr. Browns bottles - disappointed

Posted by Summerrluvv

Posted by clwp

Posted by Summerrluvv

Posted by clwp

I heat up the formula in a Medela bottle, not the Playtex air vent. I transfer it b/c the Medela bottles came with instructions that said they can be heated... even microwaved (I don't microwave them, but the point is that they can be heated). I got the Medela bottles b/c they came with my Medela Breast Pump. However, DD had horrible gas issues from the medela bottles (so bad she cried for 8 hours and I took her to Winthrop b/c the Pediatrician couldn't even understand her sudden cholic onset, but the said it was from gas), so we tried the air vented Playtex and her gas issues were resolved. They're great bottles, I just don't understand why they can't just make them BPA free and make my life so much easier.




I realize that but transferring the warm liquid into the Vent Air is no different than warming the formula in the Vent Air to begin with. There is still warm liquid in the bottle. It sounds like you are creating a lot more work for yourself then necessary Chat Icon I hope you find a solution to your bottle troubles soon!! Chat Icon



I don't heat it in the air vent b/c they are not BPA free and I think the instructions say never heat their bottles - I think it can interfer with the vent or something as well. The liquid is cold when I first pour it in since it's in the fridge (RTF formula). I don't do this when I use powdered formula since I use room temp distilled water. I think it's a lot of unnecessary work too, but someone needs to tell this to Playtex so they make a BPA free bottle with a cover so you can heat it directly in the bottle.



I don't think you are understanding what I'm saying. You are heating liquid into another bottle and pouring that warm liquid into the Playtex bottle. IF BPA is your concern, that warm liquid you just poured into the Playtex bottle can make the BPA leach from that Playtex bottle into the formula. Putting the Playtex bottle in a glass of warm water to heat the formula and doing what you are currently doing is the same exact thing as far as the BPA aspect of it is concerned. So, I would save yourself a step and put the Vent Air in a cup of warm water to heat it and instruct daycare to do the same
Chat Icon



Well, actually I think I'd like to change bottles if possible anyway b/c I really didn't want her "contaminated", I just really wanted to resolve her gas issues. I mean, the formula isn't hot when we pour it in... it's about room temp since the water it sits in is from the tap, not boiled, but maybe there's still some leakage like you mention which honest s*cks. Oh well, guess I'm still on a hunt for a new bottle that's BPA free and doesn't give this poor baby gas. If it's not one thing - it's another, although my 2 good friends both used the Playtex bottles (that's how I started with them - they gave me unused one's from their kids) and their kids are fine. I should call Playtex and ask them why they don't make their bottles BPA free. Kind of doesn't make sense if there's such a health concern.

Posted 7/17/08 11:12 PM
 

EmmaNick
*

Member since 12/06

16001 total posts

Name:
*

Re: Dr. Browns bottles - disappointed

Posted by clwp

Posted by Summerrluvv

Posted by clwp

Posted by Summerrluvv

Posted by clwp

I heat up the formula in a Medela bottle, not the Playtex air vent. I transfer it b/c the Medela bottles came with instructions that said they can be heated... even microwaved (I don't microwave them, but the point is that they can be heated). I got the Medela bottles b/c they came with my Medela Breast Pump. However, DD had horrible gas issues from the medela bottles (so bad she cried for 8 hours and I took her to Winthrop b/c the Pediatrician couldn't even understand her sudden cholic onset, but the said it was from gas), so we tried the air vented Playtex and her gas issues were resolved. They're great bottles, I just don't understand why they can't just make them BPA free and make my life so much easier.




I realize that but transferring the warm liquid into the Vent Air is no different than warming the formula in the Vent Air to begin with. There is still warm liquid in the bottle. It sounds like you are creating a lot more work for yourself then necessary Chat Icon I hope you find a solution to your bottle troubles soon!! Chat Icon



I don't heat it in the air vent b/c they are not BPA free and I think the instructions say never heat their bottles - I think it can interfer with the vent or something as well. The liquid is cold when I first pour it in since it's in the fridge (RTF formula). I don't do this when I use powdered formula since I use room temp distilled water. I think it's a lot of unnecessary work too, but someone needs to tell this to Playtex so they make a BPA free bottle with a cover so you can heat it directly in the bottle.



I don't think you are understanding what I'm saying. You are heating liquid into another bottle and pouring that warm liquid into the Playtex bottle. IF BPA is your concern, that warm liquid you just poured into the Playtex bottle can make the BPA leach from that Playtex bottle into the formula. Putting the Playtex bottle in a glass of warm water to heat the formula and doing what you are currently doing is the same exact thing as far as the BPA aspect of it is concerned. So, I would save yourself a step and put the Vent Air in a cup of warm water to heat it and instruct daycare to do the same
Chat Icon



Well, actually I think I'd like to change bottles if possible anyway b/c I really didn't want her "contaminated", I just really wanted to resolve her gas issues. I mean, the formula isn't hot when we pour it in... it's about room temp since the water it sits in is from the tap, not boiled, but maybe there's still some leakage like you mention which honest s*cks. Oh well, guess I'm still on a hunt for a new bottle that's BPA free and doesn't give this poor baby gas. If it's not one thing - it's another, although my 2 good friends both used the Playtex bottles (that's how I started with them - they gave me unused one's from their kids) and their kids are fine. I should call Playtex and ask them why they don't make their bottles BPA free. Kind of doesn't make sense if there's such a health concern.



They do make BPA free ones, the drop in's. I would try them again, make sure you push the air out of the liner though! I think the Vent Aires are not BPA free because of the shape of the bottle and the type of plastic needed to shape it that way (I think anyway!)

Posted 7/17/08 11:14 PM
 

clwp
Love my girls!

Member since 10/06

2114 total posts

Name:
mommy

Re: Dr. Browns bottles - disappointed

Posted by Summerrluvv

Posted by clwp

Posted by Summerrluvv

Posted by clwp

Posted by Summerrluvv

Posted by clwp

I heat up the formula in a Medela bottle, not the Playtex air vent. I transfer it b/c the Medela bottles came with instructions that said they can be heated... even microwaved (I don't microwave them, but the point is that they can be heated). I got the Medela bottles b/c they came with my Medela Breast Pump. However, DD had horrible gas issues from the medela bottles (so bad she cried for 8 hours and I took her to Winthrop b/c the Pediatrician couldn't even understand her sudden cholic onset, but the said it was from gas), so we tried the air vented Playtex and her gas issues were resolved. They're great bottles, I just don't understand why they can't just make them BPA free and make my life so much easier.




I realize that but transferring the warm liquid into the Vent Air is no different than warming the formula in the Vent Air to begin with. There is still warm liquid in the bottle. It sounds like you are creating a lot more work for yourself then necessary Chat Icon I hope you find a solution to your bottle troubles soon!! Chat Icon



I don't heat it in the air vent b/c they are not BPA free and I think the instructions say never heat their bottles - I think it can interfer with the vent or something as well. The liquid is cold when I first pour it in since it's in the fridge (RTF formula). I don't do this when I use powdered formula since I use room temp distilled water. I think it's a lot of unnecessary work too, but someone needs to tell this to Playtex so they make a BPA free bottle with a cover so you can heat it directly in the bottle.



I don't think you are understanding what I'm saying. You are heating liquid into another bottle and pouring that warm liquid into the Playtex bottle. IF BPA is your concern, that warm liquid you just poured into the Playtex bottle can make the BPA leach from that Playtex bottle into the formula. Putting the Playtex bottle in a glass of warm water to heat the formula and doing what you are currently doing is the same exact thing as far as the BPA aspect of it is concerned. So, I would save yourself a step and put the Vent Air in a cup of warm water to heat it and instruct daycare to do the same
Chat Icon



Well, actually I think I'd like to change bottles if possible anyway b/c I really didn't want her "contaminated", I just really wanted to resolve her gas issues. I mean, the formula isn't hot when we pour it in... it's about room temp since the water it sits in is from the tap, not boiled, but maybe there's still some leakage like you mention which honest s*cks. Oh well, guess I'm still on a hunt for a new bottle that's BPA free and doesn't give this poor baby gas. If it's not one thing - it's another, although my 2 good friends both used the Playtex bottles (that's how I started with them - they gave me unused one's from their kids) and their kids are fine. I should call Playtex and ask them why they don't make their bottles BPA free. Kind of doesn't make sense if there's such a health concern.



They do make BPA free ones, the drop in's. I would try them again, make sure you push the air out of the liner though! I think the Vent Aires are not BPA free because of the shape of the bottle and the type of plastic needed to shape it that way (I think anyway!)



Good to know... I will try that... I actually have so many unused liners that I hated to see go to waste. I'll give it a shot since I have them anyway. Thank you!!

Posted 7/17/08 11:16 PM
 

KristinasMama
How did she turn 2 so quickly?

Member since 10/07

8257 total posts

Name:
Blessed Mama of Kristina Elena

Re: Dr. Browns bottles - disappointed

I have glass Dr. Brown's, and I like them, but I must say that I love my Born Free's for the gas resolving issue. Kristina has ZERO problems getting rid of her gas with them. I almost feel as if she gets less gas with them than the Dr. Brown's.

Posted 7/17/08 11:24 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
HELP!!! On The Hunt for Dr.Browns Glass Bottles ... Ladybug63 4/23/08 7 Parenting
Does anyone know how to contact Dr. Browns? (the bottles are all leaking!) maybebaby 5/4/07 11 Parenting
bottles.. playtex, dr. Browns or Avent?> 04bride 7/12/06 12 Parenting
dr browns bottles nancygrace 3/6/07 9 Parenting
Dr. Browns bottles jessbaby 12/14/06 7 Parenting
Dr. Browns bottles jessbaby 11/30/06 8 Parenting