Does Anyone know how this works?

Posted By Message

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Does Anyone know how this works?

I'm trading in my car -
Say they are giving me $10k and I still owe $7k .

Is there any benefit at all to me paying off my car first, and then trading it in? It just seems like so much more time and energy and paperwork -

It's easeier to just let them handle it and put that $3k difference toward my down payment ........but is thre any benefit to me paying out that $7k to pay it off first?
Sales tax wise, or anything?

TIA !!

Posted 7/18/13 2:28 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

RubyWoo
Complete.

Member since 1/11

1357 total posts

Name:

Re: Does Anyone know how this works?

I think that the amount of the trade in is subtracted from the cost of the car, thereby saving you sales tax. For example, if the purchase price is 30k and they give you 10k for your trade in, you only pay tax on the 20k. However, if you were to put 10k cash down you would pay tax on the 30k. At least that was the situation I encountered when I recently purchased a car and why I decided to trade in instead of sell privately.

Based on that, I don't think you would benefit from paying off your car first.

Posted 7/18/13 3:07 PM
 

Bridex100
Two Under Two Mommy

Member since 3/08

10420 total posts

Name:
Momx100

Re: Does Anyone know how this works?

Posted by RubyWoo

I think that the amount of the trade in is subtracted from the cost of the car, thereby saving you sales tax. For example, if the purchase price is 30k and they give you 10k for your trade in, you only pay tax on the 20k. However, if you were to put 10k cash down you would pay tax on the 30k. At least that was the situation I encountered when I recently purchased a car and why I decided to trade in instead of sell privately.

Based on that, I don't think you would benefit from paying off your car first.



I am pretty sure you pay sales tax on the price of the car regardless of whether you have a trade in or not.

We just leased our first car 2 months ago. We went in planning to buy a car cash. We had my old car that we could have traded in. We were told it would not make a difference on the sales tax. I ended up gifting my old car to a family member.

ETA: I would just let the dealership handle it and not pay off the car first.

Message edited 2013-07-18 15:12:58.853000.

Posted 7/18/13 3:11 PM
 

chilltocam
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

9141 total posts

Name:

Does Anyone know how this works?

You only pay tax on the price of the car minus the amount of the trade in. So, you would be better off having a bigger trade in amount. I'm not sure if you would get the benefit of a $10K trade in if the dealer has to then pay off the loan, or if you would only get the benefit of a $3K trade in. If you can pay off the loan and then trade it in for 10K instead of $3K you'd definitely save the difference in the tax on $10K v. $3K

Posted 7/18/13 3:20 PM
 

RubyWoo
Complete.

Member since 1/11

1357 total posts

Name:

Re: Does Anyone know how this works?

Posted by Bridex100

Posted by RubyWoo

I think that the amount of the trade in is subtracted from the cost of the car, thereby saving you sales tax. For example, if the purchase price is 30k and they give you 10k for your trade in, you only pay tax on the 20k. However, if you were to put 10k cash down you would pay tax on the 30k. At least that was the situation I encountered when I recently purchased a car and why I decided to trade in instead of sell privately.

Based on that, I don't think you would benefit from paying off your car first.



I am pretty sure you pay sales tax on the price of the car regardless of whether you have a trade in or not.

We just leased our first car 2 months ago. We went in planning to buy a car cash. We had my old car that we could have traded in. We were told it would not make a difference on the sales tax. I ended up gifting my old car to a family member.

ETA: I would just let the dealership handle it and not pay off the car first.



I wonder if it depends on the dealer then. I actually just looked at my paperwork (I'm home cleaning up all my paperwork and happened to have it handy) and the amount we paid tax on was the amount of the car minus their promo deal and the amount they gave me for my trade in.

Regardless, I agree in letting the dealer handle and not paying off your car first.

Posted 7/18/13 3:20 PM
 

Bridex100
Two Under Two Mommy

Member since 3/08

10420 total posts

Name:
Momx100

Re: Does Anyone know how this works?

Posted by RubyWoo

Posted by Bridex100

Posted by RubyWoo

I think that the amount of the trade in is subtracted from the cost of the car, thereby saving you sales tax. For example, if the purchase price is 30k and they give you 10k for your trade in, you only pay tax on the 20k. However, if you were to put 10k cash down you would pay tax on the 30k. At least that was the situation I encountered when I recently purchased a car and why I decided to trade in instead of sell privately.

Based on that, I don't think you would benefit from paying off your car first.



I am pretty sure you pay sales tax on the price of the car regardless of whether you have a trade in or not.

We just leased our first car 2 months ago. We went in planning to buy a car cash. We had my old car that we could have traded in. We were told it would not make a difference on the sales tax. I ended up gifting my old car to a family member.

ETA: I would just let the dealership handle it and not pay off the car first.



I wonder if it depends on the dealer then. I actually just looked at my paperwork (I'm home cleaning up all my paperwork and happened to have it handy) and the amount we paid tax on was the amount of the car minus their promo deal and the amount they gave me for my trade in.

Regardless, I agree in letting the dealer handle and not paying off your car first.



Our dealership was really pushing the lease. Maybe the salesman meant on just the lease portion then. I may have misunderstood or he gave us misinformation?

We only had to pay sales tax on the depreciation amount for the duration of our lease.

I also live in VA and not NY.

Message edited 2013-07-18 15:26:58.197000.

Posted 7/18/13 3:26 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Does anyone know of a Nutritionist that works with kids? avamamma 3/29/08 1 Parenting
So....I held off posting this but I know the power of prayer works.... Gertyrae 9/12/07 125 Prayers
Does anyone know anyone that works at the ANG base? -Laurie- 2/22/07 1 Families Helping Families ™
Anyone work for or know anyone who works for Polar Electro? curliegirl 8/28/06 0 Families Helping Families ™
Anyone know anyone who works or has worked for Newsday?? Cookiegobbler 1/24/06 1 Families Helping Families ™
Does anybody know somebody who works at Hyundai Sales and can answer some questions. mishy626 8/19/05 0 Families Helping Families ™