Does anyone know anything about gypsies?

Posted By Message

2boys4me
He's coming soon!

Member since 4/10

4260 total posts

Name:

Does anyone know anything about gypsies?

I am watching that show My Big Fat Gypsy Wedding and am intrigued by what I am seeing but I don't know anything about them. The show is making it seem that they are hated in England. Is this true? If so, why? What do they do, believe, etc, like what binds them together as a group? Also, some are called gypsies and some are called Irish Travelers, what is the difference?

Posted 7/23/11 8:04 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MommaG
Yay Spring!

Member since 5/05

5133 total posts

Name:
Gloria

Re: Does anyone know anything about gypsies?

I believe the Irish Travelers are of Irish heritage (that seems like a given) and the gypsies are called Romani gypsies, so I would think they're from Romania.

I think people have an issue with them because many are transient (living in trailers and moving whenever) and do not hold down regular jobs (some would say they try to scam people to make money).

In general, it seems people don't like them because they lead a very different lifestyle than the typical English citizen. But this is all what I'm picking up from watching the show - I have no personal knowledge of this.

Posted 7/23/11 8:21 PM
 

Ayne11
Yep

Member since 1/09

18021 total posts

Name:

Re: Does anyone know anything about gypsies?

I've been watching this all day! Chat Icon

From what I gather, the men are hustlers & are always looking how to make a quick buck.

Posted 7/23/11 8:56 PM
 

DirtyBlonde
*****

Member since 11/07

7344 total posts

Name:

Re: Does anyone know anything about gypsies?

They are known as Romani or Rom if you want to look them up. They do not originate from Romania.

I don't think the general attitude toward their community is positive through most of Europe. They live in camps and live entirely separately from everyone around them, don't send their children to public schools and from what I've seen, the women and children are sent out to beg for food and money all day. They are often blamed for rising crime rates. They have their own customs, beliefs, culture and it's rare that they marry outside of their community.

My family and I have had several experiences with them in our travels. None of which have been positive, unfortunately.

Posted 7/23/11 8:57 PM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Does anyone know anything about gypsies?

Posted by DirtyBlonde

They are known as Romani or Rom if you want to look them up. They do not originate from Romania.

I don't think the general attitude toward their community is positive through most of Europe. They live in camps and live entirely separately from everyone around them, don't send their children to public schools and from what I've seen, the women and children are sent out to beg for food and money all day. They are often blamed for rising crime rates. They have their own customs, beliefs, culture and it's rare that they marry outside of their community.

My family and I have had several experiences with them in our travels. None of which have been positive, unfortunately.



The problem is (as I am sure you know) they beg and steal at the same time, as in a lady with a baby begs while her friend is behind you unzipping your grandfather's fanny pack to steal his wallet Chat Icon and then they yell at you when you curse at them.

We have had zero positive experiences with them in Europe (this is in both Italy and Germany, not the UK) and I don't care what anyone thinks, I do not agree with their lifestyle at all. I would be perfectly fine with a live and let live philosophy if they didn't negatively impact the lives of those they try to steal from or swindle.

Posted 7/23/11 9:35 PM
 

thisisme
LIF Adolescent

Member since 3/06

560 total posts

Name:
ME

Re: Does anyone know anything about gypsies?

From what I gather, to add to what everyone else has said, they also dodge paying taxes in many cases, and live on land they don't own or pay rent for.
However, I can only go on what I've heard, I have no first hand experience with them. I do have friends who live in the UK who say a lot of it is discriminatory and stereotypical and that many gypsies and travelers are not like that at all. So who knows?

Posted 7/23/11 9:43 PM
 

EsquireFish
LIF Adult

Member since 3/09

1259 total posts

Name:
G

Re: Does anyone know anything about gypsies?

Posted by headoverheels

Posted by DirtyBlonde

They are known as Romani or Rom if you want to look them up. They do not originate from Romania.

I don't think the general attitude toward their community is positive through most of Europe. They live in camps and live entirely separately from everyone around them, don't send their children to public schools and from what I've seen, the women and children are sent out to beg for food and money all day. They are often blamed for rising crime rates. They have their own customs, beliefs, culture and it's rare that they marry outside of their community.

My family and I have had several experiences with them in our travels. None of which have been positive, unfortunately.



The problem is (as I am sure you know) they beg and steal at the same time, as in a lady with a baby begs while her friend is behind you unzipping your grandfather's fanny pack to steal his wallet Chat Icon and then they yell at you when you curse at them.

We have had zero positive experiences with them in Europe (this is in both Italy and Germany, not the UK) and I don't care what anyone thinks, I do not agree with their lifestyle at all. I would be perfectly fine with a live and let live philosophy if they didn't negatively impact the lives of those they try to steal from or swindle.



Please don't stereotype a whole population -- gypsies are one of the most persecuted populations historically. Used as slaves centuries ago, thrown into concentration camps, denied land, education, etc... do a few Google searches, and some of the very well-researched articles by respected publications will have you shaking your fists at the obvious civil rights violations they face in other countries.

Posted 7/23/11 9:52 PM
 

Tah-wee-ZAH
Kisses

Member since 5/05

15952 total posts

Name:

Re: Does anyone know anything about gypsies?

My first experience with the Irish Tinkers was in 1984. MY father took my brother, myself and my granny back to her hometown in Co. Donegal, Ireland. One day we were at the farm where she grew up, visiting her brother and SIL when there was a knock on the door.

I could overhear her SIL getting a bit terse at whomever was at the door. My grandmother asked who it was, got up to check and then her teeth became clenched, her face red and I could tell she was MADChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

It was Paddy, a Tinker who she remembered from childhood. He looked like he bathed in dirt and was begging for two eggs. My great aunt shoved two in his hand and slammed the door on him. He lived in a 10' by 10' shack in a far corner of their land bordering another farm.

I later learned, during my grandmother's childhood, his family would squat on the far corners of their land, steal their crops, beg for work and food, run scams on people.

My MIL was raised in Brooklyn in the 40's and 50's and told me stories of the Eastern European gypsies she would see in her neighborhood. They often lived in the empty storefronts because the rent was cheaper... they would sit in the windows or cover them with newspaper.

BTW: The show says the grooms' faces (at least the Irish Travelers/Tinkers) are blurred because they are afraid they won't be able to find work... not true... most are wanted by the law.

Message edited 2011-07-23 22:16:12.267000.

Posted 7/23/11 10:13 PM
 

partyof6
b nice like u want ur kidz 2

Member since 7/06

7752 total posts

Name:
jeannine

Re: Does anyone know anything about gypsies?

I watched the show when it first came out I was mesmerized, the mannerisms, the strictness with themselves with certain things but then the very flamboyant communion n wedding dresses and verrrry sexy everyday clothing. I have to Watch some more, lol

Posted 7/23/11 10:18 PM
 

EsquireFish
LIF Adult

Member since 3/09

1259 total posts

Name:
G

Re: Does anyone know anything about gypsies?

Please, please read this article.

The New Republic article on gypsies...

Stereotyping such as what has been included in this thread is probably why my own family left Europe about 100 years ago.

Posted 7/23/11 10:27 PM
 

partyof6
b nice like u want ur kidz 2

Member since 7/06

7752 total posts

Name:
jeannine

Re: Does anyone know anything about gypsies?

Let me correct myself if I sounded like I thought they were Inappropriate. No. I do not know enough about them n that would b clumping them all together. I was mesmerized by the very elaborate dresses. I do think it's because the go all out because it is taken as a very serious honor, ex: communion.I guess I watched quite a few episodes in one day because I saw the girl that married out of her community, (the one that married a gypsy when she was not) I saw the grabbing episode n the episode where they were driven out and the poor little boy spoke. The grabbing one was messed up, I felt bad for the girls.
I saw how strict they were with the no sex n those beliefs n then I guess u expect them to b prudish looking because of their prudish beliefs so u r taken back when u see them dress club like or wear the costumes to dance. I found them very interestng to leaner about. Thanks for posting the article, I read it.
I wonder if the show will continue or if neon of them will want to go on anymore?
I have to say mimed after watching the first two episodes my sister n I were curios to see if we could find a dress on eBay or something. They r a lot of money n extremely elaborate. That's for sure.

Posted 7/23/11 10:48 PM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Does anyone know anything about gypsies?

Posted by EsquireFish

Please, please read this article.

The New Republic article on gypsies...

Stereotyping such as what has been included in this thread is probably why my own family left Europe about 100 years ago.



I read the article that you posted and have watched the show. The article seems to only bash TLCs decision to air the show and how they portray the traveler lifestyle. I wish that it would have offered insight into the traveler lifestyle, why they throw the weddings that they do, and defend the criticism/allegations of theft.

Having studied the Holocaust, many Gypsies were murdered during that time frame. I know that the travelers do face persecution to this day.

From only watching the show I really wonder why they wear the outfits they do but have such conservative moral standards - they seem to contradict one another.

Posted 7/23/11 11:27 PM
 

WhatNow
Say Cheese!

Member since 1/06

8033 total posts

Name:
A (formerly WhatNow?)

Re: Does anyone know anything about gypsies?

I have only seen that show you are referring to once for a few minutes but there was a huge gypsy settlement where my family owned a summer home in Eastern Europe. So, I grew up with them and knew many of them very well.

This is what I know and saw every day: they lived in very tight knit communities, with many generations living together in huge houses with very little personal space. Women generally earned their living by begging and trickery. Men - by stealing, mostly cars and horses (I am talking 25-30 years ago). A vast majority of males in the community were either wanted by the law or have been in prison.

The traditions and way of life within the Gypsy community was not much different from Middle Ages... Most didn't believe in modern medicine and technology and were extremely superstitious. For example, my grandfather, who was an excellent mechanic, was once asked to take a look at a car that wouldn't start up by a Gypsy family that lived in a house nearby. Upon opening the hood of the car he discovered a dead black cat on top of the motor -- it was suppose to help fix the car... Women wore long dresses, almost to the ankles; men-- pants, shirts and vests and always soft caps with a visor. I have no idea why those were so popular...

Generally, children were not forced to attend school but rather made to help out in the house and tend to younger infants of the family.

I believe the eastern European gypsies have their heritages based in India and/or Egypt and all look very much like modern inhabitants of those countries.

Most girls started off very beautiful with exotic features, long black hair and almond shaped eyes. Unfortunately, their beauty faded very quickly as they were married off VERY young and regularly beaten by their husbands.

There were some young people who broke off from their communities and went off to live completely normal lives in large cities, gotten education, jobs...

Generally, Gypsies had very bad rap among the rest of the population for obvious reasons and while unfortunately I must say that the majority of them were as I described above, there were many very nice families with completely normal way of life, no different from the rest of the population of the village.

Posted 7/24/11 3:26 AM
 

yankinmanc
Happy Days!

Member since 8/05

18208 total posts

Name:

Re: Does anyone know anything about gypsies?

These "Gypsies" aren't really the same kind of thing as what you guys have all posted about. What the big problem with them is is that they flaunt the laws of squatting and property rights, so for instance, if you are a farmer and have any plot of open land, they can make camp there and they do not have to leave, they are very canny in their knowledge of the law. They are not the kind that pickpocket, they make an honest living doing what they do...they just do different kinds of jobs, for instance, where I live, they drive around in vans looking for scrap metal, and they sell it on...making quite a good living, but their traditions make them lead a transient life, while being modern and up to date with technology etc. They send their children to mainstream schools until they are old enough to marry. Also, even though they live iin England, and may never have stepped foot in Ireland, the travellers all have Irish accents!

I live quite near to that guy Paddy with the silver blingy trailer, but you never see their communities, they are quite hidden away. He was involved in a lawsuit and a big street brawl that made the news here a month or so ago.

The thing is, these people have money, lots of it. They all drive fancy cars and spend £££££ on those wedding dresses. Also, they take over a small town in NorthYorkshire for their horse fair, there is a lot of drinking and fighting...and that also gives them a bad reputation. They make a heck of a lot of money with the scrap metal sales...but they are a society on the fringe in the UK and to be quite honest, people in rural areas are scared of them...they literally can and will set up camp in the parking lot of your local supermarket and the police have little power to make them move on.

In a little aside, since 2009 Irish Travellers have been considered their own Ethnic group, and on all job applicaitions there is now a tick box to put down that you are an Irish Traveller...I couldn't imagine a traveller to apply for a job with an application.

Message edited 2011-07-24 04:06:21.113000.

Posted 7/24/11 4:02 AM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Does anyone know anything about gypsies?

I follow a lot of English and Irish social workers through their blogs and on Twitter and have asked this same question.


They basically pointed out the same negatives that were already mentioned here, and also said that a lot of their kids end up in care due to neglect.


Posted 7/24/11 7:26 AM
 

chickiemom
LOVE my boys!!

Member since 10/09

1473 total posts

Name:
Leanne

Re: Does anyone know anything about gypsies?

The only question I keep asking myself when I watch this show is how do they get the money to afford these dresses, nevermind the rest of the wedding and the limos? I can understand the scamming part but they have that one dress designer that seems to do most of the dresses so she can't be getting scammed every time...

Posted 7/24/11 10:19 AM
 

shadows
LIF Adult

Member since 1/10

4694 total posts

Name:

Re: Does anyone know anything about gypsies?

OMG i saw this show for the first time yesterday, and I was intriegued! The most shocking thing to me was how scandalous they dressed their little girls (like 4 yrs old)... the tight, SHORT dresses... and all the make-up, fake lashes, etc. Their little girls looked like h00kers! Yet they are devout Roman Catholics?! I was disgusted at how the men (and boys) seem to have little respect for females. But it was very interesting to watch.

Posted 7/24/11 7:56 PM
 

babyface10
LIF Adolescent

Member since 3/11

804 total posts

Name:

Re: Does anyone know anything about gypsies?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irish_Traveller

Here is some info on them. But in Ireland they are renowned for fighting, stealing, drinking. If a town gets word they will be passing through most bars close down for the day or days instead of having to let them in. As there will be guaranteed fights and robberies.

Years ago though my grandfather did say that they were not all bad. They would come by every so often and offer to fix things and buy metal etc from the local farmers.

They marry in here own circle and the might also mean family. Mostly they travel in Caravans. But in the last 10 years the government are trying to get them to settle in cheap housing estates for them alone (as no one would live near them anyway). The reason for this is to try to get the kids medical attention and also an education. It has worked in some of the bigger towns in Ireland. But it is definitely not accepted by the locals. You can also tell the traveler community estates as there will still be caravans parked around in all states of decay. There will probably be horses. There will definitely be garbage everywhere and kids and people hanging all around.

The others still roam the country in caravans but it is certainly not seen as much now as it did when i was growing up. They would just park the caravan anywhere along the road they wanted and light a fire on the side of the road. We would often visit the site after they left and there would be empty tins of food and general rubbish left behind.

Posted 7/25/11 10:12 AM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: Does anyone know anything about gypsies?

As bad as the Irish Travelers can be they are still a lot better than the gypsies you deal with in Italy.

There was a lot of uproar a year or so ago when France started rounding them up and sending them back home.

We have some here in our southern states

Posted 7/25/11 10:20 AM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Does anyone know anything about gypsies?

Posted by headoverheels

Posted by DirtyBlonde

They are known as Romani or Rom if you want to look them up. They do not originate from Romania.

I don't think the general attitude toward their community is positive through most of Europe. They live in camps and live entirely separately from everyone around them, don't send their children to public schools and from what I've seen, the women and children are sent out to beg for food and money all day. They are often blamed for rising crime rates. They have their own customs, beliefs, culture and it's rare that they marry outside of their community.

My family and I have had several experiences with them in our travels. None of which have been positive, unfortunately.



The problem is (as I am sure you know) they beg and steal at the same time, as in a lady with a baby begs while her friend is behind you unzipping your grandfather's fanny pack to steal his wallet Chat Icon and then they yell at you when you curse at them.

We have had zero positive experiences with them in Europe (this is in both Italy and Germany, not the UK) and I don't care what anyone thinks, I do not agree with their lifestyle at all. I would be perfectly fine with a live and let live philosophy if they didn't negatively impact the lives of those they try to steal from or swindle.



I am very accustomed to them being from Europe.

They do not have a good reputation at all.

They live in RV type settings. Using vacant lands and just start using them without approval from the landlord.

They have the reputation to steal in stores (like putting meat between their thighs....Chat Icon since the women were long skirts). If you go by their camp they WILL take your wallet or ANYTHING they want from you (jewerly, leather jackets, etc..). They steal EVERYTHING at every chance they can. That how they get their goods.

They are always involved in shady deals. Will steal chickens from farms.

They don't work. The steal to eat and survive.

It is NOT a glamourous lifestyle at all and usually involves others losing their property to them.

Posted 7/25/11 10:46 AM
 

sfp0701
Liam's Mommy!

Member since 1/07

9764 total posts

Name:
Tricia

Re: Does anyone know anything about gypsies?

I too was intrigued by the dress. I can't understand how they are so devout and chaste but, dress soooooo sexy. It's such a contridiction!

Posted 7/25/11 1:09 PM
 

cateyemm
Twins!

Member since 7/10

8027 total posts

Name:

Re: Does anyone know anything about gypsies?

I dont know more about it than what many have already posted. I only had ever hear of Rom gypsys and beleive it or not, Ive seen a bunch here. The Irish travellers, I have never heard of and they dont seem to be the same as the romanians- they seem more settled and established (from what i've gathered on the show lol)

Posted 7/25/11 1:16 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Ya Know What Hurts REALLY REALLY BAD??? Mrs-Boop 5/13/05 10 Families Helping Families ™
does anyone know about family law? janet 5/12/05 0 Business Helping Families
Know what I miss already? Cocoa 5/11/05 11 Families Helping Families ™
Anyone Know a Kitchen Designer? aimerliny 5/11/05 5 Home
Any body know of any Streetfairs coming up? TAD 5/11/05 9 Families Helping Families ™
know what's exciting??? Cocoa 5/11/05 2 Families Helping Families ™