Doctors and False Hope

Posted By Message

jessnbrian
Only God knows His plan for us

Member since 4/13

7238 total posts

Name:
Jessica

Doctors and False Hope

I have a staff member who's partner has been seriously ill for the last year. He's needed a liver transplant but they keep "finding" new things to prevent them from putting him on the list. I feel like they are giving this woman false hope letting her think they're going to eventually do this transplant. She thinks that once he has it, he's going to be fine. He's had so much more going wrong than just the liver issues, there's no way he'd even survive the transplant. This poor woman keeps thinking the next thing they do is going to be the final procedure before they put him on the list - she's been thinking this for over 6 months. The man's son, who has been MIA during almost all of this, is supposedly the one who is willing to donate part of his liver - they haven't even checked to see if he's a match because the man isn't on the transplant list yet. I just feel like these doctors keep pumping her up with this false hope that all will be well after the transplant, but they have NO intention of ever doing it. It just breaks my heart.

Posted 5/30/14 12:22 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MsSissy
xoxoxo

Member since 3/07

39159 total posts

Name:

Re: Doctors and False Hope

Maybe they are being honest with her about how ill he is. But maybe she's just holding on to any hope? Only hearing that side of it.

Posted 5/30/14 12:28 PM
 

jessnbrian
Only God knows His plan for us

Member since 4/13

7238 total posts

Name:
Jessica

Re: Doctors and False Hope

Posted by MsSissy

Maybe they are being honest with her about how ill he is. But maybe she's just holding on to any hope? Only hearing that side of it.




I'm not sure, she just got off the phone with another doctor who said that they can do a "high risk biopsy" on the new mass they just found in his stomach yesterday. The doctor said there is a good possibility he won't make it through the biopsy but that "this is the last procedure before we can put him on the list". (Perhaps she added that last part herself.)

Posted 5/30/14 12:35 PM
 

MsSissy
xoxoxo

Member since 3/07

39159 total posts

Name:

Re: Doctors and False Hope

Posted by jessnbrian

Posted by MsSissy

Maybe they are being honest with her about how ill he is. But maybe she's just holding on to any hope? Only hearing that side of it.




I'm not sure, she just got off the phone with another doctor who said that they can do a "high risk biopsy" on the new mass they just found in his stomach yesterday. The doctor said there is a good possibility he won't make it through the biopsy but that "this is the last procedure before we can put him on the list". (Perhaps she added that last part herself.)



Possibly.
Especially after the " possibility he won't make it through the biopsy".
That speaks volumes for how sick he is.
I can understand hanging on to hope though. Chat Icon

Posted 5/30/14 12:38 PM
 

jessnbrian
Only God knows His plan for us

Member since 4/13

7238 total posts

Name:
Jessica

Re: Doctors and False Hope

Posted by MsSissy

Posted by jessnbrian

Posted by MsSissy

Maybe they are being honest with her about how ill he is. But maybe she's just holding on to any hope? Only hearing that side of it.




I'm not sure, she just got off the phone with another doctor who said that they can do a "high risk biopsy" on the new mass they just found in his stomach yesterday. The doctor said there is a good possibility he won't make it through the biopsy but that "this is the last procedure before we can put him on the list". (Perhaps she added that last part herself.)



Possibly.
Especially after the " possibility he won't make it through the biopsy".
That speaks volumes for how sick he is.
I can understand hanging on to hope though. Chat Icon



One doctor told it like it is FINALLY and said she recommended stopping all treatment. But then added he would likely go in a few days, and that just set her off. It's so hard, it's never easy, but I've seen so many family members who were this sick, and it was so much better on them and family once we set them up in hospice care.

Posted 5/30/14 12:40 PM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Doctors and False Hope

I think for some people holding out hope for a miracle is their only way of coping with the situation. Based upon what you wrote, it sounds like the doctors are treating him to the best of their ability. But she may be basing the hope of getting him on the transplant list from old information.

Posted 5/30/14 12:47 PM
 

ISpoilHim
I think I got this

Member since 11/10

1523 total posts

Name:
K

Doctors and False Hope

I'll admit that I am not the best one to speak to about this issue, but I absolutely feel dr's tend to give patients and family false hopes. It happened with my mom. Dr's exact words - "Take these meds and you will be fine." My mother was gone 6 months later. We were never told exactly how sick she was, until I put 2 & 2 together and started asking questions. When I asked one of her dr's why they just weren't honest from the beginning, he told me, "well we always want the patient to have hope"
It sucks. Big time. And we would have done things so much differently if we had known the facts from the beginning,.

Posted 5/30/14 12:58 PM
 

BaseballWidow
*****

Member since 8/08

6657 total posts

Name:

Re: Doctors and False Hope

I think it is probably a combination of the two here, some false hope and some denial. I do think doctor's do give false hope and I also think at some point they need to be the ones to recommend stopping treatments if they know it is only prolonging misery and pain when the outcome will be the same, just separated by a few months.

Posted 5/30/14 1:09 PM
 

Pray4Baby2010
<3 Cutest Giants Fan

Member since 10/09

5796 total posts

Name:
MB

Re: Doctors and False Hope

I didnt think you had to be on the list if you had a ready match/donor? My gf just had a lung transplant and if it had got to a dangerous point for her, they would have just used part of her brother's lung.

Posted 5/30/14 2:01 PM
 

OnlyU12
LIF Toddler

Member since 8/13

431 total posts

Name:

Re: Doctors and False Hope

I have first hand experience in this. Any transplant requires SO much testing in a specific time period. If something needs to be addressed, it delays being put on the list. So you mentioned that the patient was ill, so if something is causing him to be ill, or if it's the liver, there might be something that the drs need to address first.

Now if he is a donor that is willing to give part of his liver, that donor has to go for testing and then see if he/she is a match. Again if there are any issues this has to be addressed first, it could be weight, blood pressure, etc. Usually the transplant testing is good for one year. It anything delays it, then there is retesting. It's a very lengthy process.

If the donor is a match, the patient doesn't need to be put on a transplant list. There are so many factors involved with transplants and sometimes it's not always the doctor's fault nor the patient's.

Also if the doctor's test and find things that can't be fixed and he can't make surgery, he will denied to have the surgery and not be put on the list. It will then fall into palliative care. If it gets to that point, the dr's will inform him and his SO that they can't do the transplant.

Message edited 2014-05-30 14:13:00.080000.

Posted 5/30/14 2:09 PM
 

jessnbrian
Only God knows His plan for us

Member since 4/13

7238 total posts

Name:
Jessica

Re: Doctors and False Hope

Posted by Pray4Baby2010

I didnt think you had to be on the list if you had a ready match/donor? My gf just had a lung transplant and if it had got to a dangerous point for her, they would have just used part of her brother's lung.




That's what I thought, I feel like there's a lot of misunderstanding going on here. I just feel bad because they aren't married, she didn't want to marry because of a situation like this, and none of his family is helping.

Posted 5/30/14 2:11 PM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: Doctors and False Hope

Posted by Pray4Baby2010

I didnt think you had to be on the list if you had a ready match/donor? My gf just had a lung transplant and if it had got to a dangerous point for her, they would have just used part of her brother's lung.




Yes I was going to say, I thought the "list" was to receive an organ from a random donor.
If you have someone who is willing to donate and is a match, why would you need to go on the list?
Maybe she is misunderstanding.

Posted 5/30/14 2:14 PM
 

jessnbrian
Only God knows His plan for us

Member since 4/13

7238 total posts

Name:
Jessica

Re: Doctors and False Hope

Posted by NervousNell

Posted by Pray4Baby2010

I didnt think you had to be on the list if you had a ready match/donor? My gf just had a lung transplant and if it had got to a dangerous point for her, they would have just used part of her brother's lung.




Yes I was going to say, I thought the "list" was to receive an organ from a random donor.
If you have someone who is willing to donate and is a match, why would you need to go on the list?
Maybe she is misunderstanding.



That's what I've been wondering, they haven't even done anything to see if he is a match yet. I've asked her on a few occasions why they haven't and she said that they told her that in order to check the match, he needs to be on the transplant list.

Posted 5/30/14 2:20 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Doctors and False Hope

From what I do for a living, I often feel that people see what they want to see. It's a coping mechanism.

I had to have a conversation with a mother today about her extremely disabled family member that they could not continue in my program because they were too low functioning and their behaviors were inappropriate and setting off the other patients.

Of course I/the program got blamed for not doing our jobs to help their family member.

As an aside too, I always confirm with doctors myself about their opinions because 90% of the time the family interprets things differently or tells me what THEY told the doctor as what the DOCTOR said.

It's sad but in some cases it's not a good outcome.

Not every patient is a miracle.

Posted 5/30/14 6:37 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
false hope Mags1227 7/18/13 4 TTC
uh oh...we are supposed to close wednesday..i hope we get the closing cost figures raken40 8/15/05 8 Home
Hope everyone had a great weekend! KaRiSsA 8/1/05 15 Families Helping Families ™
Hope I an stay motivated!! Wendy 7/16/05 9 Diet & Fitness
Hope I get a temp spike soon dm24angel 6/2/05 21 TTC
hope this isnt too personal, but raken40 5/23/05 19 Home