Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

Posted By Message

KGools
Happy

Member since 9/06

9532 total posts

Name:
Kim

Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

Just out of curiousity, because there's been some back-and-forth on the topic among some people I know, do you think she should have resigned as a White House correspondent after the remarks she made about the Israeli-Palestinian confilct?


Here's a link to an article about what happened.... LINK

Posted 6/8/10 5:56 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

SummerMom
Now a mom of 2!

Member since 6/07

4970 total posts

Name:

Re: Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

This is a tough one. What she said was awful, hurtful, and ignorant of history. As a Jewish woman I found the comment disgusting.

BUT. The article slips in at the very end that she said the comment in private to a rabbi and it happened to be caught on videotape. People who are prejudiced against Hispanics are given their own talkshows and a pulpit from which to preach their bigotry. But this woman who thought she was having a private conversation was fired for her insensitive remark. I've read a couple of articles on this, and she does have a very colorful (and pro-Arab) history, but this is the remark that she was fired for. I'm truly ambivalent about this one. I hate what she said, but I don't know if she should have been fired for having said it privately.

Posted 6/8/10 6:25 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

Yes, not necessarily because of her remarks. Every reporter has an opinion.

She should retire because she's had a long successful career.

I don't know much about Helen Thomas's normal stance on Israel. I know she asks extremely pointed & opinionated questions - (ie asking Bush why he always wanted a war with Iraq from the moment he stepped into the White House).

When my grandmother (2 years younger than Helen Thomas) lost her normal filter & would say things out of character, it was an early sign of Alzheimer's. I'm not saying Helen Thomas has Alzheimers but if it's out of character, she should at least get a medical exam.

Posted 6/8/10 6:27 AM
 

MrsYank
She's here :)

Member since 4/07

3238 total posts

Name:
Mrs. Yank

Re: Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

If her opinion is that Israel should leave what is left of Palestine, I don't think that is anti-semitic because many Jewish People feel the same. However, using the terms "Jews" makes it sound anti-semitic, which I think why she is getting in such hot water over it. Also that the article states "Home to Germany and Poland" and then the ARTICLE added in a holocaust reference- maybe she meant it is as leaving Israel which was formally known as Palestine? Either way her choice of words were poor.

Posted 6/8/10 7:10 AM
 

BunnyWife
Insert Witty Comment Here

Member since 5/07

8274 total posts

Name:
BunnyWife

Re: Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

Posted by MrsYank

If her opinion is that Israel should leave what is left of Palestine, I don't think that is anti-semitic because many Jewish People feel the same. However, using the terms "Jews" makes it sound anti-semitic, which I think why she is getting in such hot water over it. Also that the article states "Home to Germany and Poland" and then the ARTICLE added in a holocaust reference- maybe she meant it is as leaving Israel which was formally known as Palestine? Either way her choice of words were poor.



Very well said. I completely agree. I don't think she should have resigned mostly because I'm sure her statements were coming from a place of frustration considering the Flotilla debacle that was last week.

Posted 6/8/10 8:56 AM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

Posted by nrthshgrl

When my grandmother (2 years younger than Helen Thomas) lost her normal filter & would say things out of character, it was an early sign of Alzheimer's. I'm not saying Helen Thomas has Alzheimers but if it's out of character, she should at least get a medical exam.



I recall my grandmother saying things that made me Chat Icon as she got older- so I had that thought as well (though in both their cases it wasn't Alzheimers- just senility). I do think it's sad that she's had this amazing career but this is what most people will remember. And I suspect that most people had no idea who she was till a few days ago.

Message edited 2010-06-08 09:13:06.673000.

Posted 6/8/10 9:12 AM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

Resigned due to her comments - no, but because of her age yes. I am really thinking she had no concept of what she was doing and how it would affect her. She didn't get this would be posted for all to see. I do think that is her real opinion, just like most reporters they all have their own opinions. The good ones typically put that aside and give you the facts with out tainting it with their point of view unless that is what the story is about.

I think how she said it was god awful but I think the base of it is valid.

Posted 6/8/10 9:31 AM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

As a Jewish woman, I find her statements very offensive. Her opinions that Jews don't belong in Israel- fine. That's her political opinion.

But saying that the Jews should go back to Poland and Russia- is dispicable. The Jews, like my grandparents, left those countries to go to the concentration camps- and 6 million of them were murdered. Those who escaped were lucky. Those who didn't- not so lucky.

Even after the war, the Jews came back to progrums and more murder. So they left- and thankfully because Israel was made a Jewish state- they had a place to go. You have to remember that the US turned down Jews trying to escape the Nazis and sent a boat full of Jews back to germany- where most of them were murdered.

Telling people to go"home"- back to a country that essentially expelled anyone who survived being tortured and murdered over 50 years ago-That is what is dispicable. And for that comment, I think she should resign.

Message edited 2010-06-08 14:49:14.283000.

Posted 6/8/10 2:07 PM
 

Songwriter76
LIF Adult

Member since 4/08

902 total posts

Name:
David

Re: Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

Nope

Posted 6/8/10 6:49 PM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

Posted by nrthshgrl

When my grandmother (2 years younger than Helen Thomas) lost her normal filter & would say things out of character, it was an early sign of Alzheimer's. I'm not saying Helen Thomas has Alzheimers but if it's out of character, she should at least get a medical exam.



Same with my Mom. She died on Aricept. When she started to spew words out of character, we said she had a case of DOM (Diarrhea of the Mouth)

To address the OP's question, sure she is entitled to her opinion, and the remarks may have been poor choices of words but to pass them off as an "OOPSIE" because of her age or any other reason is not acceptable. It perpetuates ideologies and negativity - something Jewish people have fought so long to overcome.

I'd also be curious to see the division of opinions between Jews and non-Jews. I'm a Jew - I'm offended.

Posted 6/8/10 7:06 PM
 

MrsYank
She's here :)

Member since 4/07

3238 total posts

Name:
Mrs. Yank

Re: Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

Posted by Goldi0218

Posted by nrthshgrl

When my grandmother (2 years younger than Helen Thomas) lost her normal filter & would say things out of character, it was an early sign of Alzheimer's. I'm not saying Helen Thomas has Alzheimers but if it's out of character, she should at least get a medical exam.



Same with my Mom. She died on Aricept. When she started to spew words out of character, we said she had a case of DOM (Diarrhea of the Mouth)

To address the OP's question, sure she is entitled to her opinion, and the remarks may have been poor choices of words but to pass them off as an "OOPSIE" because of her age or any other reason is not acceptable. It perpetuates ideologies and negativity - something Jewish people have fought so long to overcome.

I'd also be curious to see the division of opinions between Jews and non-Jews. I'm a Jew - I'm offended.




See I'm not sure how she meant it- if she meant it for Jewish people to literally go to Poland and Germany and be annihilated then absolutely that is anti-semitic. However, if she meant to leave what remains of Palestine than that is her opinion (however poorly stated).

Posted 6/8/10 7:20 PM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

i am not Jewish (was not raised) but my father's side is Jewish. None of them ever went to Israel. After they were kicked out of Italy then went to Germany then they either came here or they went to Spain, Turkey or back to Italy. Oddly enough I have catholic relatives living in Israel they plan on leaving.

Posted 6/9/10 9:44 AM
 

CallaLily
Thank you, Saint Gerard!

Member since 10/07

4937 total posts

Name:

Re: Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

Do I agree with what she said? No, but I don't think she meant it in an anti-semitic way. She is entitled to her opinion.

Message edited 2010-06-09 10:47:36.510000.

Posted 6/9/10 10:47 AM
 

2boys4me
He's coming soon!

Member since 4/10

4260 total posts

Name:

Re: Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

I think that she should have resigned if she said those comments due to the fact that she was getting older and just saying dumb things because she's old (my grandfather said a lot of stupid things starting around 6 months before he passed away and we all knew something was going on, 3 months later they found a brain tumor)

As horrible as I think her comments were, I don't think that she should have resigned if her mental health is completely intact and she just said those things because that is how she felt. This is America, and being able to say how we feel is one of the best things about this country and if we start to make people resign because we don't personally believe or agree with what they say, then think of the ramifications... where do we draw the line with what we allow people to say and what we don't.
I think in order to maintain our freedoms, sometimes we have to listen to ignorant people speak their thoughts and it's up to us what we take from them.
I don't agree with everything I hear on the news, from celebs, or even from my parents. It's our job to take in what we want from what we hear and leave what we don't

Posted 6/9/10 10:48 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

Posted by Goldi0218
I'd also be curious to see the division of opinions between Jews and non-Jews. I'm a Jew - I'm offended.



I was raised Catholic (my mom is Jewish, so maybe I'm considered a Jew on a technicality?). I'm offended by her comments as well. Even give that, I don't know that she couldn't be a White House correspondent, presenting news with a bias.

I also believe that she was asked to step down either by her new organization or by the White House.

Posted 6/9/10 11:06 AM
 

Pray4Baby2010
<3 Cutest Giants Fan

Member since 10/09

5796 total posts

Name:
MB

Re: Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

I'm Catholic so I didnt really read the comments as anti-semetic until it was pointed out to me- I just thought they were her opinion and should have been kept to herself- but I can see exactly why people are offended.

because of her position she should have thought before she spoke- and age is no excuse, my grandmother uses that all the time to excuse the things she says and sorry- its no excuse for insenstivity

I think stepping down was appropriate

Posted 6/9/10 11:25 AM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

Posted by 2boys4me

As horrible as I think her comments were, I don't think that she should have resigned if her mental health is completely intact and she just said those things because that is how she felt. This is America, and being able to say how we feel is one of the best things about this country and if we start to make people resign because we don't personally believe or agree with what they say, then think of the ramifications... where do we draw the line with what we allow people to say and what we don't.
I think in order to maintain our freedoms, sometimes we have to listen to ignorant people speak their thoughts and it's up to us what we take from them.
I don't agree with everything I hear on the news, from celebs, or even from my parents. It's our job to take in what we want from what we hear and leave what we don't



I agree in theory- but in this case- the problem is that the "ignorant person" is our NEWS REPORTER!! If she was standing on a soapbox in times square- let her say what she wants. But she is supposed to be reporting the news.

Also, asking her to resign was a businsess decision. If they kept her on, you bet a lot of people would stop buying her articles- and then the news source would lose money. So its the same freedom that allows a private business entity to ask a reporter to resign with dignity rather than get fired.

Posted 6/9/10 11:26 AM
 

BunnyWife
Insert Witty Comment Here

Member since 5/07

8274 total posts

Name:
BunnyWife

Re: Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

Posted by Shelly

Posted by 2boys4me

As horrible as I think her comments were, I don't think that she should have resigned if her mental health is completely intact and she just said those things because that is how she felt. This is America, and being able to say how we feel is one of the best things about this country and if we start to make people resign because we don't personally believe or agree with what they say, then think of the ramifications... where do we draw the line with what we allow people to say and what we don't.
I think in order to maintain our freedoms, sometimes we have to listen to ignorant people speak their thoughts and it's up to us what we take from them.
I don't agree with everything I hear on the news, from celebs, or even from my parents. It's our job to take in what we want from what we hear and leave what we don't



I agree in theory- but in this case- the problem is that the "ignorant person" is our NEWS REPORTER!! If she was standing on a soapbox in times square- let her say what she wants. But she is supposed to be reporting the news.




I understand what you're saying but lots of reporters (Glenn Beck anyone?) say stupid things and aren't forced to resign.

Posted 6/9/10 12:00 PM
 

MrsYank
She's here :)

Member since 4/07

3238 total posts

Name:
Mrs. Yank

Re: Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

Whoops Chat Icon Chat Icon I stand corrected- was going off of what a PP said. here is the video

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rN4FN12fTgA

Message edited 2010-06-09 18:36:15.060000.

Posted 6/9/10 1:01 PM
 

BunnyWife
Insert Witty Comment Here

Member since 5/07

8274 total posts

Name:
BunnyWife

Re: Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

Posted by MrsYank

She didnt post the comment as news- she said it in a private convo with a rabbi that was overheard.




OK! Now I really think she shouldn't have resigned. This was a private conversation. Why did this become news anyway?

Posted 6/9/10 2:42 PM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

Posted by MrsYank

She didnt post the comment as news- she said it in a private convo with a rabbi that was overheard.




according to what i saw.. someone (i assumed it was a reporter) had a microphone and a camera and asked her the questions, and she responded looking straight into the camera.
if it was a 'private' conversation then why was it being filmed/recorded?
She wasn't talking with anyone else and over heard from far away.. she was being interviewed (or stopped on the street by a reporter)


Posted 6/9/10 2:51 PM
 

Sassyz75
Turning a new page

Member since 5/05

9731 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

I wonder if she would've said something equally negative toward the Palestinians (like, they're all a bunch of terrorists, etc) if there would be as much outrage re: her comment... I lean towards not..

Honestly- no, I don't think she should've been forced to resign- I think everyone has a bad day and says things in a way that comes off "gruff"

Posted 6/9/10 3:11 PM
 

timanda
Puppy Love

Member since 6/08

1627 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

Posted by Otherme

Posted by MrsYank

She didnt post the comment as news- she said it in a private convo with a rabbi that was overheard.




according to what i saw.. someone (i assumed it was a reporter) had a microphone and a camera and asked her the questions, and she responded looking straight into the camera.
if it was a 'private' conversation then why was it being filmed/recorded?
She wasn't talking with anyone else and over heard from far away.. she was being interviewed (or stopped on the street by a reporter)





Right, it wasn't a private convo. She was asked by the rabbi, he was clearly interviewing her, and he said he was asking everyone their thoughts considering it was a Jewish Heritage Celebration.

The video is on YouTube. She didnt look directly into the camera, but it seems like it would have been difficult NOT to see the camera right in front of her face.

Edited because I wasn't paying attention to what I was quoting and I read it wrong.

Message edited 2010-06-09 16:15:52.897000.

Posted 6/9/10 4:13 PM
 

MrsYank
She's here :)

Member since 4/07

3238 total posts

Name:
Mrs. Yank

Re: Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

Posted by timanda

Posted by Otherme

Posted by MrsYank

She didnt post the comment as news- she said it in a private convo with a rabbi that was overheard.




according to what i saw.. someone (i assumed it was a reporter) had a microphone and a camera and asked her the questions, and she responded looking straight into the camera.
if it was a 'private' conversation then why was it being filmed/recorded?
She wasn't talking with anyone else and over heard from far away.. she was being interviewed (or stopped on the street by a reporter)





Right, it wasn't a private convo. She was asked by the rabbi, he was clearly interviewing her, and he said he was asking everyone their thoughts considering it was a Jewish Heritage Celebration.

The video is on YouTube. She didnt look directly into the camera, but it seems like it would have been difficult NOT to see the camera right in front of her face.

Edited because I wasn't paying attention to what I was quoting and I read it wrong.



I stand corrected Chat Icon I was just going off of what a PP posted. I just watched the video and..

She does not say "jews" the question is obviously asking her about Israel's Occupation of Palestine- and in addition to saying Germany and Poland she also says America......

my comp won't let me link

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rN4FN12fTgA

After viewing the video I really don't feel that she is being anti-semitic.

Message edited 2010-06-09 18:38:31.840000.

Posted 6/9/10 6:30 PM
 

BunnyWife
Insert Witty Comment Here

Member since 5/07

8274 total posts

Name:
BunnyWife

Re: Do you think Helen Thomas should have resigned?

Posted by MrsYank

Posted by timanda

Posted by Otherme

Posted by MrsYank

She didnt post the comment as news- she said it in a private convo with a rabbi that was overheard.




according to what i saw.. someone (i assumed it was a reporter) had a microphone and a camera and asked her the questions, and she responded looking straight into the camera.
if it was a 'private' conversation then why was it being filmed/recorded?
She wasn't talking with anyone else and over heard from far away.. she was being interviewed (or stopped on the street by a reporter)





Right, it wasn't a private convo. She was asked by the rabbi, he was clearly interviewing her, and he said he was asking everyone their thoughts considering it was a Jewish Heritage Celebration.

The video is on YouTube. She didnt look directly into the camera, but it seems like it would have been difficult NOT to see the camera right in front of her face.

Edited because I wasn't paying attention to what I was quoting and I read it wrong.



I stand corrected Chat Icon I was just going off of what a PP posted. I just watched the video and..

She does not say "jews" the question is obviously asking her about Israel's Occupation of Palestine- and in addition to saying Germany and Poland she also says America......

my comp won't let me link

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rN4FN12fTgA

After viewing the video I really don't feel that she is being anti-semitic.



OK. I just watched this. It almost looks like this was a hidden camera or something. Like she had no idea she was being filmed.

Posted 6/10/10 8:11 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Patricia Arquette, Thomas Jane Get Married nylisa 6/27/06 1 Families Helping Families ™
Knicks fire Brown, name Thomas new coach nylisa 6/22/06 0 Sports
Introducing Matthew Thomas preciouslove 6/7/06 59 Pregnancy
Jon Thomas Inn dm24angel 4/10/06 4 Families Helping Families ™
Thomas and friends.... CAJ 1/24/06 3 Families Helping Families ™
St. Thomas DML 8/2/05 5 Travel & Vacations