Dilemma regarding baptizing DD..

Posted By Message

mitabtrfly

Member since 12/06

2770 total posts

Name:

Dilemma regarding baptizing DD..

DH is not of any religion. He was forced to go to Kingdom Hall (Jehovah's Witness) when he was younger with his mom, but chose not to go anymore once he became of age.

I myself am Catholic and was baptized Catholic. While I don't go to church religiously, I have been having the urge to return and would like to baptize my daughter, the same way I did my son. When DH and I were married, I decided to get married in the hall so that his mom would not feel "uncomfortable" coming to a church, and I regret doing so because I always dreamt of having my wedding in a church...

Anywho..I have spoken with DH about baptizing her and he said he would feel weird. I told him I'm not asking him to convert, and if he doesn't want to be a part of it he doesn't have to be, but I feel like I compromised for our wedding, so maybe he should for this.

Would it be wrong of me to go ahead and do this w/out him if he does not want to participate?

ETA: I am not doing this behind his back. I am asking if it would be wrong of me to do it w/out him if he doesn't want any part of it.

Message edited 2007-09-22 10:11:45.703000.

Posted 9/21/07 7:31 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

InShock
life is good

Member since 10/06

9258 total posts

Name:

Re: Dilemma regarding baptizing DD..

Do you mean going ahead w/o him knowing or just going ahead and doing it but he will know? I certainly wouldn't do it with him knowing -- perhaps give him some more time and maybe he'll change his mind.

Posted 9/21/07 8:14 PM
 

justthe4ofus
I hate hypocrites!!!!!

Member since 5/05

6905 total posts

Name:

Re: Dilemma regarding baptizing DD..

Well I am Jewish and my DH is RC. We are raising our daughter in the Episcopal church. They like to consider themselves the Catholic church on lite and the Catholic church will recognize an Episcopal baptism (I already check that out with the diocese) but I sit in church every week and the congregation has made me feel very welcome. Would he be willing to try another church.

Also it was important to me that my daughter be given a Hebrew name and be named in a temple and we found a temple to do that in a lovely ceremony for us and my DH was not there (he had to work) and it was fine.

Posted 9/21/07 8:22 PM
 

my3boys
I love these boys

Member since 7/07

2711 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Dilemma regarding baptizing DD..

Not sure if this is true or not but I was told that a child is what ever the mother is. But my oldest sons dad is jewish (we never married) and when he was born I got him baptized. He came along with his mom and sister however the great grandparents did not come to the church. They did come to the dinner but did not give a gift instead on Valentine's (1st holiday after the baptisum) they gave him a big gift. It was their way of giving him a baptisum gift but couldn't give it to him on that day because it would of been like they were celebrating it. I guess I trying to say if you feel strongly about doing so then I would, like you said you didn't get married in a church and your 1st dc is baptised. It is a tough decision and I hope everything works out.

Posted 9/21/07 8:36 PM
 

mitabtrfly

Member since 12/06

2770 total posts

Name:

Re: Dilemma regarding baptizing DD..

I wouldn't do it w/out him knowing..but if he chooses not to come then I will go ahead w/out him. I did ask him if he wanted to be a part and he said he would, but wasn't sure what it entailed. I guess we'll have to play it by ear. I know for myself, I would like her to be baptized.

Posted 9/21/07 10:37 PM
 

pmpkn087
Life is good...

Member since 9/05

18504 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Dilemma regarding baptizing DD..

Posted by mitabtrfly

I wouldn't do it w/out him knowing..but if he chooses not to come then I will go ahead w/out him. I did ask him if he wanted to be a part and he said he would, but wasn't sure what it entailed. I guess we'll have to play it by ear. I know for myself, I would like her to be baptized.



Then I would definately go ahead with it. I'm sure DH would go to the church and stand up and participate.

My DH is of no religion, but he fully participated in my son's baptism.

Good luckChat Icon

Posted 9/21/07 10:46 PM
 

waytogo
Balancing act on a highwire

Member since 5/05

1292 total posts

Name:
a

Re: Dilemma regarding baptizing DD..

Posted by my3boys

Not sure if this is true or not but I was told that a child is what ever the mother is.



Not in all religions. A lot have the child as the dad's religion. But in American culture it usually ends up being the mom...

My DH and I had a huge dilema (my family is Muslim and his RC). We decided to let our DS decide what he wants with him being exposed to everything. My dad didn't want me to be with DH at first b/c he was RC so that was our compromise. MIL isn't happy about no baptism but she understands. I'm sure DS will be going to church with her in the future and we're happy about that.

Posted 9/22/07 12:33 AM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: Dilemma regarding baptizing DD..

I would try to come to a compromise. Relgion is huge for me and Im not even a practicing Catholic or anything, but Iw ould never ever do something like that if my husband didnt agree with it.

I would compromise..SOMEHOW.

Find that compromise Chat Icon

Posted 9/22/07 12:45 AM
 

2BEANS
wow time is going fast.

Member since 9/07

16106 total posts

Name:
Tina

Re: Dilemma regarding baptizing DD..

My DH is muslim and im catholic. He does not practice the religion or know much about it, his mother does. Im dont attend church but i did receive all the sacraments and do pray on my own at night. We decided to get married in the church, but b/c my mother is no longer with us and it made me feel closer to her since she was there for all the religious aspects of my life. Now its im about to have DD and we decided (even though DH is not too happy with it) to baptize her. He made it clear that he will not attend church on sundays, but will attend anything that has to deal with our DD. I felt that since i knew about my faith and have a bond with what i believe that this what i wanted my dd to have.

I think you should sit down with your DH and discuss your feelings, dont go behind his back it will just cause more problems in the future.

Posted 9/22/07 5:13 AM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: Dilemma regarding baptizing DD..

DH is not religious at all. I am a church attending catholic. He was supportive though, went to the class with me, we were also married in the church.

I did not wait around though, once I go the okay to baptize, I scheduled it immediately. Josh was baptized at 3 weeks...I did not want the issue to linger.

I use to work with a lady who married a Muslim man. Great marriage, but he was not into baptizing the baby Catholic at all. So while he was at work one Friday, she had a christening! Party and all at a restaurant. Her family paid for it. He did not know for months, till he found a pic of it at his inlaws house. It hurt their marriage pretty badly.

Posted 9/22/07 6:38 AM
 

JerseyMamaOf3
Boo!

Member since 6/05

15144 total posts

Name:

Re: Dilemma regarding baptizing DD..

If it is important to you then I think you try understand that. To me him feeling weird isn't a really good enough reason. What makes him feel weird? I do like the idea that Jamie had about going to an episcopal church. DH and I got married in one (FM me if you want their info) and we loved the priest and the church is small but beautiful with alot of history. We are both RC but DH was married before and never had it annuled. We had no problems baptizing either children. Another thing you can do is call around various churchs if you go the RC route and ask if they do private ceromonies. Some do and in that case you could just ask your immediate family to come.
I don't think what you are asking him is unreasonable especialy since he isn't practicing any religion now. Another way you could try and explain it to him is that you would like for her to receive all her scaraments and then let her decide what she chooses after her confirmation. That way she has them when she is an adult.

Posted 9/22/07 6:49 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Dilemma, need your opinions. bee 3/21/06 8 Pregnancy
Ava's 1st birthday party - DILEMMA Please help! Denisemang 3/20/06 3 Parenting
Christening Dilemma... AndreaLMT 3/16/06 19 Parenting
Thought I was going to have a "dilemma" tonight.. lvdolphins 3/7/06 1 Families Helping Families ™
wedding dilemma -- what would you do? w/poll jersee3380 3/6/06 19 Pregnancy
Childcare vs SAHM P/T dilemma...would like input BabyAvocado 2/10/06 14 Families Helping Families ™